Eight talking points from NRL Round 18

By Scott Pryde / Expert

Sunday night. You know the drill. Here are my talking points from a fascinating Round 18 in the NRL.

Jack Wighton’s ball running is critical for Canberra
When you think of the best ball-running halves, names like Cody Walker, Cameron Munster and Shaun Johnson are the ones who immediately come to mind.

One who often goes unacknowledged is Jack Wighton.

The Canberra half has a knack for making a critical break from inside his own half or taking on the line to create time and space for others.

Even when he doesn’t break through, his runs always seem to require extra attention, and it can then open up space on the following plays.

While the kicking game is generally noted as the most important attribute in a halves combination, Wighton has taken it on his own accord to make the Raiders a better side with his running.

He had two tries, five tackle busts, a line break and 122 metres on Saturday, causing the Dragons headaches from start to finish, but averaging more than 100 metres per game as a half, it’s not just a one-off.

His ball running is of utmost importance if the Raiders are to make a fist of the finals.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Reserve a sky blue jersey for Daniel Tupou
Towering Roosters winger Daniel Tupou last represented New South Wales in 2015.

When he was dropped in Game 1 of that year’s series, it was probably the right decision for a winger who was still learning how to get the best out of himself.

There is no doubt he had to continue doing that over the following years, with Tupou often frustratingly failing to utilise his height, pace and jumping ability.

Last year, Tupou turned a corner. He was the first to put his hand up to do the hard yards out of his own end, he became more secure both under the high ball and in general defence, and improved his attacking game out of sight.

That has only continued into 2020 as the beanstalk continues to prove himself as one of the best wide men in the competition.

With the worrying lack of form from incumbent Blake Ferguson, the wing spots seem to be a three-way race for the Blues between Tupou, Nick Cotric and Josh Addo-Carr.

While none would look out of place, Tupou’s work rate and the mammoth advantage he provides with attacking players no longer able to be tackled in the air mean he should be first picked.

How eager will the Roosters be for the World Club Challenge? (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Ryan Papanhuyzen just proved his worth to the Storm
Yeah, yeah, I know. It’s not a typo. I know he didn’t play.

But Ryan Papenhuyzen didn’t need to be on the field to prove how important he is to Melbourne.

While the Storm still put 36 points on the Cowboys, they didn’t look themselves in the first half. North Queensland dropped a lot of ball and defended abysmally, making it easy for the men in purple to get the scoreboard ticking.

You have to wonder if things might have been uglier at both ends of the park for the Cowboys if Papenhuyzen was there.

The young fullback has played a vital role for Craig Bellamy’s side this year, and while Nicho Hynes wasn’t poor by any stretch, Papenhuyzen has seven tries, ten assists, 65 tackle busts, 11 line breaks, an average of 191 metres per game in his 16 appearances and pace to burn.

He has made himself virtually irreplaceable in the Melbourne system, and his form puts him close to the best fullback in the competition this season.

(Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

Jamal Fogarty has made all the difference for Ashley Taylor
If there is one particularly pleasing point about the Titans’ good form, it has been Ashley Taylor finally hitting something near his potential.

Gold Coast’s win over Brisbane was the second time they have beaten their closest rivals this season, and the improvement to their style of footy has been a joy to watch.

At the centre of that has been nearly-rookie Jamal Fogarty, whose consistency has taken all the pressure off Taylor.

As it stands, Taylor has 11 try assists and 12 line break assists in his 17 games, to go with ten offloads, eight forced drop-outs and a much higher kicking efficiency than in previous seasons.

He has been in a much more relaxed role on-field because he’s no longer the only one running the team.

While he (and the rest of the Titans) still have a way to go, the additions they are making to their forward pack will give them an even stronger platform to work off next season.

And it’s that platform, combined with Justin Holbrook’s coaching and the nurturing of other young talent including gun centre Treymain Spry, fullback AJ Brimson and Beau Fermor which make the Titans look like they have finally turned the corner.

Ash Taylor. (Photo by Jason O’Brien/Getty Images)

How much time does Brad Arthur have?
Earlier in the season, it looked as if nothing could stop the Parramatta Eels.

That’s gone flying out the back window though, hasn’t it?

While Friday’s 18-point loss wasn’t their worst performance, it was yet another in a run of very average games. It looks like, at most, the end of their season is four weeks away. And that’s if they survive in the top four.

It seems ridiculous to be talking about job security for a coach who has turned a club around in the preceding years like this, but the Eels have the roster to be challenging for a premiership now.

When it was all downhill running, Arthur looked like a world-beater. Now, he can’t right his sinking ship right, and is persevering with a stagnant attacking plan.

From Mitchell Moses seemingly refusing to play both sides of the field, a team dropping the ball on the regular and a forward pack struggling to match it with not only Penrith, but other teams for some weeks, it’s a major concern.

Arthur has also failed to make changes to his team. It’s a major concern, and while I won’t call for Arthur to be sacked, surely Parramatta fans are starting to turn up the pressure on their coach.

(Photo by Daniel Pockett/Getty Images)

Campbell Graham deserves credit for South Sydney’s rise
When it comes to picking the most improved player of 2020, Campbell Graham’s name should be top of the list.

The South Sydney outside back has put together a stellar year. From not being able to hold a first-grade place down 12 months ago, he has played every fixture this year and has 11 tries. Not only that, but his versatility and club-first approach has meant he has spent a stack of time in the centres.

Graham’s ability to find the tryline has always been undoubted, and now his defence, ball-handling and passing have all improved out of sight.

Add that to a more consistent style of footy from Graham, and it’s clear why he is now an important, permanent fixture of Wayne Bennett’s 17 each week.

Another two tries against the Tigers on Thursday means he now has eight in his last five matches, while playing against some of the NRL’s better opposition.

The former Australian Schoolboys captain will only continue to improve as the weeks and months tick by, and with his height and pace, he should become a very dangerous, long-term outside back.

Manly’s injury woes have provided a glimpse of the future
Manly are struggling with an injury crisis and their finals charge might be over, but it has allowed fans a glimpse of generation-next on the northern beaches.

In fact, the biggest problem Des Hasler and his recruitment staff face is who to keep and who to let go.

They have a superb batch of players coming through. Josh Schuster and Albert Hopoate, who we have seen in the last fortnight, Sean Keppi and Haumole Olokau’atu, who have played throughout the season, and Ben Trbojevic, who is yet to debut, are all earmarked for big things.

That’s not even to mention the younger Fainu brother, Sione, who is yet to appear in a 21, but could be one of the best junior props in the game.

It’s little wonder Manly have been so dominant in the junior age groups recently, and throwing players of that quality into a team already featuring the other two Trbojevic brothers, as well as Daly Cherry-Evans, Addin-Fonua Blake and Martin Taupau will do wonders for their confidence and abilities.

If those players can stay in Manly and away from injury, a golden generation may not be all that far away for the Sea Eagles.

(Photo by Mark Evans/Getty Images)

The Sharks need Shaun Johnson, rocks, diamonds and all
Before injury, Shaun Johnson was arguably in the form of his career.

The New Zealand international, who has long been touted one of the most talented players in the game, has struggled for consistency over the years, but the run he put together in turning the Sharks into an attacking powerhouse didn’t go unnoticed.

He wasn’t at his absolute best against the Warriors in Sunday night’s tight victory that confirmed the final make-up of the top eight, but he will need to be if Cronulla want to go anywhere in the finals.

The Sharks have made their game plan all about scoring this year. They sit fifth for points scored, but have the worst defensive record of all top eight (and two in the bottom eight) teams.

For that to work, Johnson, with his pace, footwork and creative abilities, is their most important player. He needs the forwards to give him some territory to work in, but even then, creating something from nothing runs in Johnson’s blood.

It won’t beat teams like the Roosters, Storm and Panthers unless they play out of their skin, but it will cause a scare or two in September.

Johnson simply must be at his best.

The Crowd Says:

2020-09-15T12:31:07+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


I thought Jakes defence was very good against the Storm. I have always been willing to give the kid a go . I'm happy to start with him next year and tell him you run the show. Show some confidence in him. Drinkwater though leaves me cold. I have no idea how you teach a guy who continually refuses to put his body in front to change his ways. Sets up a try , let's two in. I pray I am wrong.

2020-09-15T09:42:41+00:00

Rob

Guest


Fair call. Buck stops with the bloke who picks the team and accepts the players input. I thought Clifford was good and he certainly out shone his opposite Hughes for most of the game. Jake’s defence on Frizzell, Kafusi and Hughes on the edge has been good. I think he should be given a long sustained crack at the 7 going forward. If Drinkwater can create he can read a defensive line. Now the Cowboys have to get him using that knowledge to defend smart and tough when needed. Lot of doom and gloom but they have young bodies and I still believe the talent is worth working with. McGuire is 30 and only going backwards IMO. I thought he could bring some experience and aggression to the middle in defence but I didn’t realise he had ambitions of being the Queensland version of Gallen.

2020-09-15T05:29:38+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


Rob , you will get no argument from me about the negstive aspects of Mooses game. I agree with you. If Moose is 'running the team' what does that does that say about the p poor coaching that allows that to happen. I mean if he was demanding the ball on last tackle and kicking it , the coaches would have heart palpitations and hook him quick. He needs to be put in his place. You blame him . I blame the coaching that allows this to happen. You reckon , Bennett or Bellemey or Robinson let this go on. ? You have the right problem but are blaming the wrong person.

2020-09-15T04:52:15+00:00

Rob

Guest


Jimmmy if by chance did you notice Clifford take control of the game with 15min to go? You will notice McGuire is off the field? In that time 3 tries, 1 disallowed (Fido’s ball on the post) and another 1 Holmes murdering a try passing behind Fido. 3 out of the 5 was on a 4th tackle shift. Usually McGuire is in looking for his favourite hit up on the 4th so Clifford doesn’t see the football? Clifford can play but he certainly doesn’t like Mouth (prawn) McGuire running the team IMO.

2020-09-15T01:39:26+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


OK ! But the Storm were doomed once the Raiders beat them at AAMI park in the first qualifying final sending them to the Roosters side of the playoffs draw. And it is shaping up again as a Storm v Roosters showdown early this playoff series.

2020-09-15T00:40:47+00:00

Willie La'ulu

Roar Guru


The Roosters knocked the Storm out of contention last year mate lol. The eventual champs, Roosters.. I don't think the Raiders are anyones worry to be honest mate, the top 3 sides will comfortably beat them. The Storm spine has a whole season to play together and I dont think any of those Hughes cracks from last season against the Raiders, would show this year.

2020-09-14T23:46:10+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Time will tell, Willie ! No one forgets how good the Storm have been , but they have some obvious defensive issues that have not been addressed all season. And you of all supporters should not be downplaying the ability of the Raiders, who with a lesser team knocked the Storm out of contention just 12 months ago.

2020-09-14T21:35:59+00:00

Willie La'ulu

Roar Guru


Fearing the Raiders more than the Storm is the most ludicrous thing I have read on this site lol. One bad game and people tend to forget the dominance and brilliance of the Storm smh

2020-09-14T21:32:14+00:00

Kramer

Guest


Sorry but silly comment. “The sport exists for the benefit of the fans” and without the referees you have no Rugby League. Do you think the referees want to be abused by players week in and week out. Can I come to your job and abuse you week in and week out without any repocussions?The referees are there to referee and the fans are there to watch, cheer and boo etc. Blame the player not the refs mate for letting the fans down. Such a weird comment.

2020-09-14T13:15:08+00:00

Big Mig

Roar Rookie


Good comment on Campbell Graham, he's a good pair of safe hands, solid in defence, god runner and has scored tries from many different plays. Whether he plays as wing or centre he is comfortable.

2020-09-14T12:12:07+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


History has shown that there is often more to the story than what we read in the papers but I still hear people regarding what a witness says as being close to being gospel. It's ridiculous.

2020-09-14T09:27:12+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


What really annoyed about the weekend was the Collins no try decisions n and Annesely coming out with his usual analysis . Yet once again we will have the same referees and bunker officials next weekend. He has previously said there is no-one to replace the them yet week after week the same mistakes by the same officials and nothing happens. I saw his pathetic interview from last week and honestly I don't know how the guy holds this job down.

2020-09-14T09:11:55+00:00

thomas c

Guest


The sport exists for the benefit of the fans and "dissent" is vague. Asking fans to potentially swallow a loss because a player said something compromises the experience. The experience of the fans is in the moment, not when the explanation eventually filters out. Weren't the punches over the weekend only 10 minutes in the bin? Preventing serious injury and hurt feelings seem like they should warrant different degrees of response.

2020-09-14T08:55:42+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Yeah that’s what I was angling at. Whah doctor cleared him?

2020-09-14T08:10:48+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


I agree with a lot of what you say on Moose, but Moose doesnt run the team. Surely the coach can say , no ball to Moose after tackle 2 . Surely the 9 , 6, 7 and whoever is Captain can say get the f out of the way dumbass. It’s a long , long , long time since my playing days but if a forward ever got in the way when the backs called the ball, there would be hell to pay from the captain, the coach and everyone else. My take is he probably does it cause he is told to or at best because he is not told to p off. That’s why we need a new coach.

2020-09-14T07:35:00+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


A good wrap Scott, though I think you might be a bit harsh on Brad Arthur, I would think he's safe until at least 2022 when Parra won't figure in the 8. Then the heat will be back on. My highlight for the round was Ramsey's mum... Give it to him luv.. Ref was so spooked he pulled a hammie in the tunnel and I hear he snuck out 12 minutes before full-time so he didn't run into her in the car park.

2020-09-14T07:23:05+00:00

Nambawan

Roar Rookie


Not sure that Manly has had more injury problems than most of the other clubs but their backline depth has certainly been tested and found wanting. Over recent reasons Manly has been easy pickings for any side moving the ball wide to the outside backs and so there is a pressing need to find some wingers with pace. Whilst young Hopoate has not yet done anything spectacular, his achievement , at age 19, to survive three 1st grade games after virtually three seasons out of the game and two ACL reconstructions, is astonishing. Agree that Schuster looks the goods, as does the hulking forward Olakau'atu, and Hasler's continued failure to give him a game, is mystifying.

2020-09-14T07:09:44+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


There has been a deafening silence from everywhere after the Curtis Scott case was thrown out of court. Hardly any discussion on Fox or Ch 9. Poor bugger was treated like dirt by the police with the capsicum spray and tasering when all he was doing was sleeping it off after a big night. The magistrate couldn't even bear to watch all the footage. The cops have a lot to answer for after that episode. And for having the gall of taking it to court. As Scott himself said it was lucky they had the body cam pictures otherwise he could have been on the shovel for the rest of his life given how the whole episode was blown out of proportion. Hope he can now get his life back together and play some good footy.

2020-09-14T07:00:53+00:00

Kramer

Guest


I have an idea. Josh McGuire can keep his mouth closed and then we don’t need to guess what he said. This was a closed case and easy 10 minutes. Correct all the way from the ref.

2020-09-14T07:00:33+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


The Storm have plenty of defensive issues at present, particularly on their right edge, and through the middle without Finucane & B Smith there. I'm sure Bellamy can't be happy with things there ? They even made the Cows left side attack look good at times. I would back decent defensive sides the Panthers, Roosters & Raiders to have beaten them yesterday. Whether that holds up when full squads are back remains to be seen, but I as a Panthers fan, right now I fear the Chooks & Raiders more than I do the Storm ( and our record against them has been atrocious till this season).

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar