Calm down, you've played one game

By AJ Mithen / Expert

It was faster than ever. It was breathless. It was brutal. It was gloriously chaotic. Not the NRL Round 1 on-field product, but the massive overreactions from fans of winners and losers.

The early few rounds of a season are generally a less-than-beautiful experience as players find their feet and fitness, new combinations and game plans are tested in real time under real pressure, and teams who have designs on high achievement pace their seasons to peak at the right time, which is several months down the road.

Penrith coach Ivan Cleary summed it up best after his side’s win over North Queensland: “We were never going to play our best footy tonight”.

For their part, the game’s new rules were decried and praised in pretty much equal measure after their first proper public outing. There was some frustration after tries were taken away while a conversion was being lined up, but you’d be hard-pressed to say the calls were wrong barring one knock-on decision against Jack Bird at a critical time for the Dragons.

I’m not a fan of changing up the rules so much. What matters most to me is that the health and wellbeing of the players is taken into consideration, not set aside as an afterthought for gimmicks that sop to broadcasters who continue to disrespect the game at every turn. But I’m realistic enough to give it some time to see how things pan out.

Having said that, it was off-putting to often see defensive lines (and attacking teams for that matter) as coordinated as a bunch of drunk relatives trying to dance the nutbush at a wedding, but hopefully as match endurance returns that’ll sort itself out.

The general consensus seems to be a month or so will give us a clearer picture about whether more fatigue will equal points and excitement, but right now more tired players equals more sloppy play and errors.

Keep in mind the game’s best players are coming off the shortest preseason of their careers, with the late finish to the 2020 season and State of Origin wrapping up in November. Now they’re being tipped into a new style of game that is testing their condition like never before.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

To the overreactions, which are always the best part of a rugby league weekend. Just 25 minutes into the first game of the season Storm fans were making wall space for a new premiers poster and Bunnies fans wanted Wayne Bennett out and Adam Reynolds cut adrift. By the end of the game both clubs had good and bad things to take home.

Raiders fans at halftime were going each other about the team’s lack of penetration against a stubborn Wests side, whose own fans spent Sunday night tearing themselves apart over an apparently insipid effort against a premiership contender. The Tigers performance wasn’t that bad, especially when compared to teams of a similar calibre. But there’s no telling some people.

Parramatta fans spent halftime on Saturday night sharpening pitchforks and fashioning effigies of Brad Arthur before nonchalantly carrying on like nothing had happened once the Eels put on 24 to zip in the second half to beat the Broncos.

Eels fans are already angst-riddled after a straight-sets exit in 2020. There’s no need to be so worked up right now. Parramatta are a good team with more important things to worry about than a Round 1 match-up against the reigning wooden spooners.

For the Broncos, they put up a spirited fight, and if not for injuries to key players, they might have been able to close out the game. Hopefully someone gets to Xavier Coates to remind him that not every try out wide needs a remarkable spectacular dive.

St George Illawarra fans were already on the downside before a ball was kicked, but boy oh boy did they let it rip when their side went down to the Sharks. Never mind a try being taken away by a slightly sniffy ruling cost them a second-half lead and essentially ended the contest when they copped a try not long after.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

My own massive overreaction to Round 1 is that there’s only likely to be one or maybe two changes to this current top eight at the end of the season. The good teams remain good, the bad teams are really bad. It’s going to be hard to fairly judge formlines when there are some teams who won’t hold a candle to at least ten others.

Again though, it has been only one round of games. Definitive statements at this point are as useful as trying to serve a cup of tea to a cow. There are 24 rounds left, COVID-19 willing. We’ll need a few more games in the bank before we can go writing off our teams and demanding everyone gets sacked.

Don’t put too much pressure on your team. They’re still working things out – except for the Storm and Roosters, who are always like this.

Instead of firing up too early, do what relaxes you. Take a breath, light a candle, run a nice warm bath and leave the vegan jojoba bath bomb you got for Christmas to do its work.

Alternatively, have a thousand beers. Whatever works.

The Crowd Says:

2021-03-15T07:10:46+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru


I really liked his presser. His approach is exactly was NQ needs. And of course hat $1m white elephant sitting on the wing.

2021-03-15T07:07:56+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru


I hate to defend Manly’s management but I think they’re right to only extend him two years with a bunch of performance clauses for a sacking. After Seibold and a bunch of others, every club must be able to sack under performing coaches without having to pay out multi-year contracts in full. That of course comes with the caveat that the coach is largely getting the side that he wants. Can’t have a Dragons scenario where the coach isn’t the sole responsibility for the game day squad then have him fall on his sword.

2021-03-15T06:44:34+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


The Dragons haven't won a spoon yet.

2021-03-15T06:22:54+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Yes as a St.George boy I’m living in the past and they haven’t been too good in the limited tackle game. Glebe suffered from the same unfortunate problem as Newtown and Balmain by taking the name of a suburb rather than a district or shire. It was especially tough when you had to play for the team of the area you lived in. Souths had a big advantage over the little suburban teams and that’s why they won so many premierships. The SRL president was S.G.Ball a Souths man.

2021-03-15T06:09:06+00:00

kk

Roar Pro


AJ, always a pleasure to read your works. Jack Rayner was one of the very best coaches and disciplinarians in my time. Todd Payten has that similar aura about him. I know he will be successful.

2021-03-15T05:49:44+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


So Jack has as many premierships as the Sharks and his wasn't tainted by rorting of the Salary Cap. Some Shark fans have a 2nd team like Melbourne to make them feel successful.

2021-03-15T05:42:31+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


I went to Uni in Canberra a decade before the Raiders came into being. It was full of Victorians who had moved from Melbourne, the previous capital, and students from the Aussie Rules states. We had great code war arguments. They can't tackle, partly because its against the rules to tackle around the legs, and they can't run more than 10/15 metres but need to be good long distance runners. I was walking past a group of kids booting a rugby league/union ball around and the ball was picked up by my South Australian friend who handballed the ball back to them. The kids laughed and made fun of him.

2021-03-15T04:39:40+00:00

farkurnell

Roar Rookie


Yeah and Glebe shouldn’t have been dumped in 1929 and women shouldn’t been given the vote - but hey let’s move on

2021-03-15T04:26:54+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Yes they fell apart after two dubious decisions. The rest of the game was like having dental surgery.

AUTHOR

2021-03-15T04:26:37+00:00

AJ Mithen

Expert


Thanks kk - Good to see you this early in the week. The reaction to Payten was interesting, as if people just want a coach to go in and maintain status quo. Like he said, that'll get him punted pretty damn quick!

2021-03-15T04:05:30+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


The Sharks had trouble with the Dragons who couldn't even ground the ball in their own in goal. It was only the first round as the author points out. Maybe the Dragons will come good and prove me wrong, they always have trouble with little brother. Cronulla didn't deserve to be promoted as the reason they were promoted was to cut St.George down to size.

2021-03-15T03:38:46+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


It's clear after the clearance of a school kid we don't care about anyone pulling on a jersey outside of their contribution on the field and ability to "hurt the brand".

AUTHOR

2021-03-15T03:32:35+00:00

AJ Mithen

Expert


I'm really worried about that Mushi. But moreso that HQ won't give a hoot

2021-03-15T03:21:29+00:00

farkurnell

Roar Rookie


Hiroti will probably come in.Impressed with Nikora,Uele,Kennedy an Moylan(improved defence).Up Up

2021-03-15T02:42:06+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


At ‘home’ is nice and Jessie needs to play. Defence online was pretty good, Briton didn’t miss anyone, Williams did. I like Tolman in there talking, Woodsy picking up the sly metres. Bomber will probably fancy our chances more going around them rather than getting smashed in the middle.

2021-03-15T02:38:24+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Yep, the only season long takeaway is half the teams no longer have a shot at undefeated. Injuries keep worrying me. If they stay at last year's level we've got to look at human cost of the new rules

2021-03-15T02:23:06+00:00

farkurnell

Roar Rookie


Gees Souv - gone off a bit early mate.Your forgetting the Mighty Shark Pack .I’m anticipating Bomber will challenge his charges to put it to the Viking boys up front this Sunday.I’m more concerned with the Sharks handling the Two W’s in the halves.

2021-03-15T02:11:49+00:00

JVGO

Guest


I wonder how much these dills at the Dragons are paying him? I guess it's more than they offered Cameron Macinnes though.

2021-03-15T02:02:06+00:00

farkurnell

Roar Rookie


Don’t worry Nick they’ll come back to earth when the Sharks test them this week.Don’t forget who they beat, Joey and his mates- who’ll be fighting over the Spoon

2021-03-15T01:26:20+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Wait until he comes to Brisbane. Injuries happen and that's not his fault but to rag out on the club when he leaves... Why, because 'they treated me like a number'. You were a number Jack, a large one that spent a majority time on the bench. You and 14 other blokes last year but you want a cuddle. Wipe your tears on the $100 notes you sook.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar