Wise old heads prevail as the Force awakens

By Nicholas Bishop / Expert

I hate to say I told you so, but this is how I summarised the Western Force’s Super Rugby 2021 prospects last December:

“The Force should certainly be strong enough to win at least 50 per cent of their games in 2021, and that may be enough to slingshot them into local play-off contention.”

That comment formed part of an article which suggested the addition of ex-Reds second row Izack Rodda as part of the Force’s ongoing trawl for new talent.

“From this point of view, the best Christmas gift [Tim] Sampson could receive would be the news that Izack Rodda wants to return to Australia – more precisely, to Western Australia.”

Rodda duly signed with the Force in March.

There is no doubt whatsoever that the quality of the recruitment drive in Western Australia has surpassed all of its peers in the country, despite the loss of ace Argentine hooker Julián Montoya to the Leicester Tigers on the eve of the tournament.

The Force badly needed to find some speed and finishing ability in the back three, and they got it in a part-exchange loan signing from Tigers, ex-England age group wing Jordan Olowofela. The Welford Road academy graduate bagged a hat-trick of tries in the weekend nail-biter against the Queensland Reds.

Jordan Olawofela was pivotal in the Force’s win over the Reds. (Photo by Will Russell/Getty Images)

Tim Sampson and his coaches unearthed Feleti Kaitu’u to replace Montoya, and he was selected in Dave Rennie’s first Wallaby squad of 2021. They found Tim Anstee in Australian sevens and he made it to Rennie’s camp, too.

All of the signings for the 2021 season (bar Tomás Lezana) – Tom Robertson, Santiago Medrano, Sitaleki Timani and Anstee up front; Tomas Cubelli, Domingo Miotti, Tevita Kuridrani, Rob Kearney, Toni Pulu and Olowofela behind – have been fully integrated as starters as the team have continued the steady upward curve of their development.

If the Force beat the Reds anywhere (other than the scoreboard) on the field on Friday evening, it was in the maturity of their leadership. James O’Connor has been touted as a Wallaby captain in 2021, but the relationship between O’Connor and club captain Liam Wright did not work out particularly well on the night.

The Reds started by taking two close-range attacking scrums against the Force when they were down to 14 men, and they scored tries from both. So far, so good.

The clarity of the decision making started to unravel in the second period, with Queensland opting for scrums in the 65th and 79th minutes against a full, 15-man defence. The last failed attacking scrum decided the fate of the game in the Force’s favour.

When the hosts awoke to the fact that they could win the match in the third quarter, there were plenty of veteran Yodas willing and able to steer the ship home. Jeremy Thrush and Tevia Kuridrani may be far more limited in the range of their movements than they were at their athletic peak, but both still know how to influence the course of important games at critical moments.

Kuridrani – now ruled out of the preliminary final against the Brumbies – dredged his muscle memory to relive the day when he was the most powerful, dominant back on the paddock. It all started with a huge hit on his opposite number Hunter Paisami, which immediately ended the Queensland man’s interest in proceedings:

Tevita spots his opposite number coming hard onto the angled ball off Tate McDermott, and the first lesson is crystal clear: never give Tevita Kuridrani a definite target!

Kuridrani’s influence was also felt via his communications skills – first, on defence:

He throws up an arm to keep Olowofela away from the ball which Domingo Miotti has hacked ahead – pick it up, and he will be pinged for offside:

With the English wing backing off, Kuridrani is able to make another offensive tackle on Bryce Hegarty and set up a successful jackal by Miotti behind him. The penalty goes the other way.

The big man’s communication on attack was just as good.

Take a look at the three-minute mark on the above highlights reel. As the ball is spun out to the left, Kuridrani knows he is marked by Hegarty and signals for the ball to go over the top to Olowofela directly:

Kyle Godwin duly obliges, and Olowofela is able to score his second try of the game.

When Kuridrani finally departed in the 74th minute, it was a case of replacing one 30-year-old with a 35-year-old guru in the shape of Richard Kahui. Kahui still had the time to make two decisive interventions, the first of which was putting through a perfectly weighted left-foot kick for Olowofela to score the final try (which can be seen at five minutes on the highlights reel).

In the final act, Kahui held up Josh Flook over the goal-line to force a maul turnover:

The two men assisting him are Godwin and Jeremy Thrush. The Force second row was also highly instrumental in spotlighting some Reds’ weaknesses which had previously been masked by their wins.

At 36 years of age, Thrush is the most venerable of all the Yodas at the Force, and has accumulated a lifetime of lineout wisdom. The Reds struggled on their own throw, losing four lineouts out of 13 to first touch, with three of those converted to full turnovers.

With Angus Scott-Young in his debut season as a lineout caller, the Queensland set-piece is quite straightforward. The majority of throws are pre-called before the forwards enter. Thrush knew exactly where to position himself to mount a contest:

He knows the ball is going to Lukhan Salakaia-Loto in the middle, and the Force forwards close the gap on the Reds big man before the throw is ever made – less than half a metre separates the two lines as Brandon Paenga-Amosa delivers the ball, and that gives Thrush a realistic shot in defence:

The signs that Thrush had read and understood the Queensland lineout before a ball was ever thrown were plain at one second-half set-piece:

Thrush is so certain of the target area that he is able to make the steal look for all the world like a blue throw, not a maroon one.

He was just as effective when he chose to compete on the ground.

Thrush is able to swim past the receiver, Liam Wright, and onto Alex Mafi, who is the ball-carrier at the back. That is the lineout drive stuffed.

The other area of weakness highlighted by Thrush’s activity was the vulnerability of scrumhalf Tate McDermott at the base. In a recent Coach’s Corner column, I outlined how McDermott’s tendency to stand tall and lift the ball off the ground before passing could create a problem for the attack.

The Force obviously had a plan to pressure McDermott from his kicking (right) side, and it was put into action from the start:

Thrush is positioned to block the box-kick and he nearly gets into Bryce Hegarty’s exit, just for good measure. It was a repeated issue, and not only in obvious kicking situations:

The final counter-ruck by Thrush is especially instructive. The Force have McDermott just where they want him – standing tall in the saddle and out of sync with the support outside him – and it takes an outstanding, high-risk offload by Taniela Tupou to rescue the play:

Summary
Both Tevita Kuridrani and Jeremy Thrush may have spent ten minutes in the sin bin after receiving yellow cards, but their positive contributions still comfortably outweighed the negatives against the Reds. It was a game where the leadership of the old souls in the Force made most of the difference.

In the process, some of the Queensland fault lines, previously masked by their long winning run, have become more evident. There is a question about who is really captaining the side after Liam Wright’s long-awaited return from injury. The choice to take scrums from close range in the second half, against 15 men, ultimately cost them the match.

The Reds have also backed themselves into a corner by delegating the lineout calling to Angus Scott-Young. Scott-Young has made a decent fist of the job, with an 86 per cent success record across the regular season. At this stage of proceedings, it is too late to change to someone else.

But it also means he has to start the game ahead of players who could add more potential value to the Reds’ cause in the grand final – Wright in the back row, or Seru Uru (the Reds’ best lineout player) in the second row.

Whoever reaches that final, whether it is the Force or the Brumbies, will have noticed the fragility of the Reds’ lineout under pressure. Queensland were confined to winning ball from the front or middle of the line, and that is not ideal.

They will also have observed Tate McDermott’s vulnerability at the base when kicking or passing. The last game of the season is very far from a foregone conclusion, regardless of the contestants.

In the meantime, the advances the Force have made from a near-death experience have to be admired. They have not only re-awakened, they have come back from the dead, and are one tantalising step away from a domestic final.

They can no longer be counted as the fifth team in Australia – even if the idea of maintaining five genuinely competitive professional franchises still seems as improbable as ever.

The Crowd Says:

2021-05-03T05:59:59+00:00

TJ-Go Force!

Roar Rookie


I see hope in the Tahs. Get Hooper and Big Ned back. That slick back rower from Japan.

2021-05-03T05:58:18+00:00

TJ-Go Force!

Roar Rookie


Nailed it.

2021-05-03T05:56:00+00:00

TJ-Go Force!

Roar Rookie


We are losing a few sadly: Cubelli to Leicester, Miotti to Glasgow. I hope we can hang onto Medrano and Thomas L. Kearney most likely won’t be around either.

2021-05-03T05:53:52+00:00

TJ-Go Force!

Roar Rookie


As a loyal Bear over here that was a gutting one to lose. I know we rested plenty but to be so close against them at full strength, it shows Lam knows what he’s doing.

2021-05-02T08:06:46+00:00

Choppies

Roar Rookie


1. Rennie said it in his interview discussing wallaby selection in camp (albeit that he needs some evidence of Petaias kicking game) 2. Thorn has mentioned it a few times, most notably in the press conference after the reds second win against the brumbies

2021-05-02T01:46:53+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Cheers mate, I don't mean to come at you. It's an interesting idea you raise and worth discussion. Maybe the reason that I'm unconvinced is that I'm not a SS fan but rather a Southern Districts one. If none of the players from my club are in the SS team then I have no connection to it. Whereas under the Sydney/NSW Country model I'm connected to a side by geography. The other key question I have that remains is who pays for and runs the SS team? Finally it feels like this further creates a shopfront for Sydney talent to be picked up by any team, rather than working to help strengthen the Tahs. And my word, don't we need some strengthening!

2021-05-01T11:02:47+00:00

Joe King

Roar Rookie


I love the idea but not sure how practical it is. Anyone that goes well would play a single season for the SS team and then be picked up by a Super team and play for their NRC team subsequently. How do you maintain that connection for fans when every good player moves on each season? That’s a good question. I hadn’t considered that. While I don’t think every player would be picked up by a SR team each year, so there would be some continuity, I don’t think the fans need that kind of continuity to stay connected to the SS team simply because they are following the players through the SS for that year, and then want to see how they go against the best. It would actually get SS fans onboard with the NRC better than other models, I think. And they might even be cheering to see their beloved and ‘deserving’ SS players get picked up by a SR team. As I say, it’s not ideal, but it still does the trick of providing a stepping stone between club and super pretty ok. I just think the other model will always feel like it’s in competition with the SS and not get them on board. Where as this model says, ‘we recognize the importance of the SS and want to give you a chance to prove yourself’. I think the derby with the Tahs (minus their wallabies) would prove especially interesting to fans of the SS. Feel free to come back at me. Appreciate your thoughts.

2021-04-30T22:09:47+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Thanks for the clarification Joe, I had misunderstood. I love the idea but not sure how practical it is. Anyone that goes well would play a single season for the SS team and then be picked up by a Super team and play for their NRC team subsequently. How do you maintain that connection for fans when every good player moves on each season? Also who is paying these guys? Are the funds coming from NSWRU? In which case why not go to what we had for the last two years of NRC which was the same as the Qld model of a City and Country team under the Tahs?

2021-04-30T21:54:09+00:00

Joe King

Roar Rookie


The SS team would be run by the SS organisation as well. Maybe the winning coach in SS gets to coach them for that year. But playing under the banner of NSW Country and Sydney, with Tahs politics and interests involved, doesn't seem to motivate the SS crowd. But having a proper Sydney SS rep team, just might.

2021-04-30T21:43:50+00:00

Joe King

Roar Rookie


Well if they're not good enough for test rugby, then they're only at NRC level like everybody else I guess.

2021-04-30T21:42:43+00:00

Joe King

Roar Rookie


Sorry jeznez, I don't think I made myself clear. I don't mean a stand alone club team. I mean a combined SS rep team, under that banner. It provides a clear pathway for players in SS. Make the rep team, and you're on show against the best. Older players in SS will no longer be overlooked. The SS team will want them and need them! The SS team players have something to play for. They get to prove themselves against everybody else. And it brings the whole SS fan club on board with the NRC. It would be a good derby against the Tahs too. That's what we need right now. It may not be ideal, but it will still do the trick of step between club and SR pretty ok. But most importantly, it gets people onboard.

AUTHOR

2021-04-30T14:48:22+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Where have Rennie and Thorn said that?

2021-04-30T14:23:42+00:00

Choppies

Roar Rookie


Do you think the reds havn't moved him there yet because BT feels bad for Hagerty and Jock?? I just don't understand why they refuse to play him at 15 when both DR and BT say he'd florish there

2021-04-30T14:20:36+00:00

Choppies

Roar Rookie


Perese has a more limited skill set, that is for sure. His defence/kicking is definitely worse than JPs... but JP is a FB at heart so no point comparing oranges with apples.

2021-04-30T11:42:48+00:00

GusTee

Roar Pro


I did not get your comment until I had a look in the mirror and checked out the white haired and aged grimace looking back at me despite the fact that I was feeling elated after the Force's win - now I know understand what you mean! But Note young NB, as sure as the outcome of a modern day tip-tackle, you too will succumb to age one day - Lol.

2021-04-30T03:56:29+00:00

AndyS

Guest


Only a minor point, but I'd note that equal funding from broadcast revenue is different from equal funding. The broadcast revenues for SR don't come close to covering the funding to teams, with the rest coming from the wider revenue stream. Or, in the case of the Force, from Forrest. That is why they make the 'broadcast' distinction, rather than just saying equal funding without the modifier. My understanding is that it becomes equal funding once they sort out the license situation though.

2021-04-30T03:07:19+00:00

Greysy

Roar Rookie


I never said they were treated on an equitable basis. I acknowledged that they weren't in the first line of my original comment. I agree they should be fully restored to the same position as all 4 other teams, although I think you should probably acknowledge that the lack of progress on this is largely due to the more immediate priorities RA has been dealing with in the last year which pretty obviously account for the sluggishness on reform. My comments are not at all about denying the continuing unjust aspects of the Force's situation. It's about taking issue with the fact that you ignore the things that have changed for the better (the return of equal funding from broadcast revenue, the offer of the same five year licence to play in the comp that all of the other four have received etc.) and that every time an article on the Force appears the same rehash of grievances always appears. This article was about rugby - why can't we just discuss rugby? Anyway, I seem to be repeating things I've already said so I'll leave it there. Good luck to your boys on Saturday EFF. As a Brumbies fan, I don't want the Force to win, but will be happy for them if they do manage it.

2021-04-30T01:10:17+00:00

terrykidd

Roar Pro


Yes, but an aspect I really like is he kn0ws when t0 pass and when t0 run. I think Petaia is still learning that

AUTHOR

2021-04-29T19:08:42+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Yes it has disturbed the back five balance. Angus Blyth is a better tight forward than Ryan Smith, and Izack Rodda is better than Blyth - so Queensland has been missing that element in the second row.

2021-04-29T12:44:45+00:00

Fin

Guest


Nick, Do you think the loss of Rodda continues to effect the Reds, even one and a half seasons after his departure?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar