Ashes burning questions: Hazlewood's replacement, openers in doubt, should England make mass changes?

By Paul Suttor / Expert

Despite thumping England by nine wickets in a commanding victory to open the Ashes series, Australia have a few issues to sort out before Thursday’s second clash at Adelaide.

For the tourists, they have problems left, right and centre after their insipid performance at the Gabba which will be a lot harder to rectify before play gets underway at the Adelaide Oval in the pink-ball day-nighter.

Although England have a wider squad of players with their Lions team also in the country, there’s an element of shuffling the Titanic deckchairs with their team – can they rely on James Anderson and Stuart Broad in the twilight of their career or Ben Stokes to find form after a long layoff to turn their fortunes dramatically around?

The burning questions for Australia

Hoff’s hassles: Josh Hazlewood was restricted by a side strain, particularly on day three in Brisbane, when the dreaded fast bowler’s “grunter” muscle injury meant he bowled only eight overs.

He returned on day four to take Jos Buttler’s wicket but after flying home to Sydney on Sunday, he has been ruled out of the second game of the five-match series.

West Australian young gun Jhye Richardson should be called up for his third Test, although uncapped Queensland seamer Michael Neser has also been on the fringe of selection for a couple of years, and offers a similar bowling style to Hazlewood’s line-and-length mantra.

With Hazlewood out of the Adelaide game, that could mean Mitchell Starc gets a rest in Melbourne or Sydney as new skipper Pat Cummins looks to manage the workload of his fellow quicks over the course of the six-week schedule.

Warner’s sticky rib situation: Veteran opener David Warner said he could have batted on day four at the Gabba if needed but after copping a couple of nasty blows to the ribcage, he was not sighted for the third and fourth innings of the Test.

He was fortunate to ride his luck to 94 and with fellow opener Marcus Harris struggling for runs, Australia will play Warner if he can battle through the pain barrier.

However, they have an experienced replacement at the ready in Queensland captain Usman Khawaja who averages 96.8 from the seven times he’s opened for Australia, including two tons.

Harris on last chance: Whether he’s partnering Warner or Khawaja in the Second Test, there is unlikely to be a place for Harris on Boxing Day at the MCG if he again fails against England.

After registering scores of three and nine not out in Brisbane, his career average is a mediocre 23.15 after 11 Tests and just 10 from four clashes with England.

The Victorian left-hander has looked tentative outside the off stump and with the pink ball expected to swing in Adelaide, it will be an extremely tough proposition for him to find the runs needed to salvage his Test career.

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

The burning questions for England

Recall Broad and Anderson?: The England camp received widespread condemnation for the surprising decision to omit their record-breaking veteran pace duo from the Gabba Test but captain Joe Root was defiant after the game that their absence was not a factor in the loss.

They have 1156 Test wickets between them and using the pink ball in a day-nighter should suit the swing exponents but Root offered no guarantee that both or even either seamer would be included at Adelaide.

Anderson was underdone before Brisbane but if Broad was available, they should have at least played him in Brisbane rather than going into a series opener with four front-line bowlers with a combined experience of four Tests in Australia coming from Chris Woakes being part of the 4-0 drubbing in 2017-18.

Jack Leach and Joe Root. (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Leach bloodbath: Australia is the toughest country in the world for opposing spinners, particularly those who don’t particularly turn the ball a great deal.

The Aussie batters went on a seek and destroy mission with Leach and even though Marnus Labuschagne threw his wicket away as they flayed the left-arm tweaker to all parts of the ground, they didn’t let up. His 13 overs went for 112, which meant Joe Root had to cycle through his pacemen more than he wanted and also had to bowl himself to chew up some overs.

Off-spinner Dom Bess is part of the travelling party but is also untested in conditions Down Under, has never played Australia and has a modest record of 36 wickets at 33.97 from 14 Tests. Still, he can’t fare much worse than the Leach bloodbath at the Gabba.

Cupboard’s bare to fix the batting: Root and Dawid Malan, who each made it into the 80s in the second dig, can hold their head high after the Brisbane belting but the rest of the English batters looked out of their depth.

Star all-rounder Ben Stokes is clearly underdone, openers Rory Burns and Haseeb Hameed have a reputation for not giving away their wicket lightly and Ollie Pope has promise but none of them looked comfortable against Australia, particularly with the bounce of the wicket.

England have Jonny Bairstow and Zak Crawley on tour but rotating them into the team is hardly going to cause Cummins and his cohorts any concerns – the Poms are probably best off giving their Gabba line-up another crack and hope they can benefit from getting some proper match play under their belt.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2021-12-13T19:23:55+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Wow, did you keep track and make notes whilst it was happening Jeff? :shocked: If so then I'm impressed! :thumbup:

2021-12-13T08:49:58+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Hi Jeff. Yeah that 20/21 season for us was pretty uncharacteristic of Aust in catching department.

2021-12-13T03:33:27+00:00

Tempo

Roar Rookie


England often have a mentality that they need a strong tail and bowlers should be selected taking into account their batting. It's the reason why Ashley Giles played over 50 tests despite a bowling average of 40 and not once being accused of moving the ball off the straight. I guess this comes down to conditions in England where batting can be a bit of a lottery if it's swinging around a lot, and lower order runs can be very important once the pitch flattens out a little later in the innings. You can't play like that in Australia though. Wickets are far more important and valuable than runs here and you have to pick your best 4 bowlers, even if they are all rabbits. That said, if England do take that approach, it will put a lot of pressure on their Top 7 to perform, as I can't recall the last time we played an England team with a weaker tail than Robinson/Wood/Broad/Anderson. Maybe the end of the 2006/07 Ashes series when they'd replaced Giles with Monty Panesar?

2021-12-13T03:16:07+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Two years of planning for the series then mass changes after one Test would not reflect well on Silverwood. Neither will a big series loss.

2021-12-13T02:56:20+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


I think that's what will happen. They will need all 5 quicks because Wood and Anderson are made of glass, Stokes is still not fully fit, Robinson apparently can't bowl much more than 18 overs in a day and Broad hasn't played in while.

2021-12-13T02:12:06+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Dropped catches tally; 2021-22: - Australia: 0 - England: 5 2020-21 -Australia: 17 - India 17 ---- I have: Aus 1st Innings: -Head dropped by Hameed off Wood (105th) -Lyon dropped by Buttler off Wood (103rd) -Lyon dropped by Woakes off Woakes (98th) -Starc dropped by Buttler off Wood (84th) -Warner dropped by Burns off Robinson (32nd)

2021-12-13T00:34:58+00:00

TJ

Guest


The only changes I think England should make is Leech and Wokes for Anderson and Broad (provided they are both fit). Leech is an obvious one and Woakes just isn't effective in Australia. I like him as a player although he's now played 5 test's in Australia and taken just 12 wickets @ 47. He strenghtens their batting but if you're relying on your number 8 to score runs you aren't going to be winning many games.

2021-12-13T00:05:40+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


You're right about not making mass changes, Bob. That only signal panic to the opposition

2021-12-12T23:57:04+00:00

dungerBob

Roar Rookie


Yeah, those are good returns against India for Burns and Hameed. I'd say you're right about England sticking to the same batsmen for Adelaide. Surely they will be better for the run in Brissy. .. As far as their bowling goes I wouldn't make wholesale changes there either. They may not even play a spinner this time so either Anderson or Broad might get the nod. I thought the rest of them bowled Ok, particularly Robinson. Woakes wasn't quite at his best but he's a pretty good player imo. I just reckon mass changes would do them more harm than good.

2021-12-12T22:15:13+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


The decision on Hazlewood has to be based on whether playing him in Adelaide risks losing him for the rest of the series. I've no idea how severe his injury is, but this has to be a good time to rest him, given Jhye Richardson's ability to swing the ball. It could also mean Richardson stays for the BD Test while Starc has a spell. Prior to Brisbane, Burns & Hameed had shared in opening partnerships of 135, 5 & 100 against a very good Indian attack, so they've got something. Malan batted well in the second innings as did Root, while Pope and Buttler looked fair to middling in the first innings. I've no idea how anyone can say Stokes was underdone with the bat, especially when he got that delivery that got him out, second time round. This is their best batting lineup so stick with it. Bring in Broad & Anderson, give Leach some time in dayglo and see what happens And if Davey's out, I really hope they give Usman a run.

Read more at The Roar