BRETT GEEVES: Marnus, Smith schtick is infuriating and must be countered by impactful verbals

By Brett Geeves / Expert

There were two moments in this Test where I had to turn the TV off and seek comfort food.

The first was watching Marnus Labuschagne and Steve Smith bat together. The extravagant leaves.
The self-commentary. The third person congratulatory self-talk.

The continual shouting of “NO-RUN”, at a decibel level deafening for Xmas shoppers in Hindley Street.

As an aside, in case you don’t know Adelaide, night-time shoppers of Hindley St are hunting very different things than day-time shoppers.

But the clincher for this angry bogan were the overt displays of body language whenever an English bowler got some seam movement, or bowled a leg cutter, off-cutter or any other type of ball set to do something off the wicket.

It was of the utmost importance to the two aspiring street mimes that every spectator, player in the game, members of both coaching staff and cameras, broadcasting to the world, knew that they had just survived the greatest individual ball ever delivered.

If they were teenagers, each delivery would have received its own diary entry.

The entire partnership was like watching an under 9 free form jazz recital, with over laid commentary from a character Rob Sitch would play in an ABC satire, such was the level of outrageousness in communication.

I’m old school. From a different generation of cricketers. And honestly, I hated it.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Even Ricky Ponting, the most passionate supporter of all things Australian cricket, put his hand up to say he would hate playing against it too.

But I get it. This act works. And I respect (and, yes, am jealous of) the level of ability, and decision making, to be able to operate at that level on the international stage. It is staggering how in control they both were in the first innings.

Ultimately, all that matters is that it impacts England. And that is clear. The Poms hated it most.

It would be incredibly confronting, and demoralising, as a bowler to be constantly mocked by two guys who are making your efforts look pathetic. I’m surprised no code of conduct was breached by the English players. That is where embarrassment takes you in sport.

Sadly, I’ve been there. Whenever Phil Hughes shouted, “WAIT ON”, it was like a dagger to my ego, and soul, and hurt me more than his 22nd boundary of the day, second hundred of the game, and so on with the records for Phil against Tasmania. Phil was special. And his dominance of Tasmanians from that era allows us a little empathy for the Poms bowling to Smith and Marnus, who I must add, are on their own level of ego crushing behaviour.

So, how can England impact the momentum and confidence of Smith and Labuschagne?

Verbal. Hard verbal. Impactful verbal. Relationship changing verbal. 100% of your match fee level verbal. It is the only way I can see England winning back any momentum when either Smith or Marnus are doing their thing.

The other act of disrespect that had me hunting another chocolate covered pretzel was Michael Neser scratching at the bowling crease after every delivery.

After a decade of playing with Benny Hilfenhaus, who did the same thing, it brought back a flood of memories and the reason my poor left ankle barks at me on cold Hobart mornings.

When it comes to landing areas, I don’t know a fast bowler who is comfortable with their front foot landing in a pothole, or a trench, or any surface that isn’t dead flat. The human ankle isn’t built for that level of instability.

If you’ve seen Shawshank Redemption, you’ll know you only need to remove a little dirt in every sitting to create a big enough hole to fit a fully sized human through a wall. Applying The Dufresne theory, by day five that crease line from the every-ball-digging-bowler is a moon crater.

Bizarrely, the hole being dug by the scratcher doesn’t ruin the landing area for them, but trust me, for everyone else it is a long-term injury waiting to happen and means everyone other bowler in the game is having to deliver the ball exclusively wide of the crease.

One day at the SCG, Hilf carved a hole so big that the curator had to dig out a fresh crease from the practice wickets and cut it into the centre wicket, so the game wasn’t played exclusively from around the wicket at that end.

A Queensland insider tells me that Neser has been causing the same headaches for his state based fast bowling brethren. And that during one shield game v Tasmania, Jackson Bird was openly cussing him out every time he bowled a poor ball because he was wobbling on the edge of Neser’s attempt at escaping Shawshank.

Queensland insider also shared with me a long-standing Bulls tradition, of which Neser is the current champion. He is the Bulls Goanna Pulling Champion, having defeated Nathan Reardon in 2015 and has been undefeated since. (Yes, of course it’s real.)

Cricket takes all types. Hole diggers, leather round the back of the neck strong men, nerds, julios. bogans, merchant bankers, narcissists, and escape goats.

Moving forward to Boxing Day, the Poms need more of the above and less of the 128kph trundlers. They need a spinner. Even if it is Jack Leach. They need Mark Wood back in the team to provide air speed and grunt.

They also need batters with techniques that can withstand the pace and bounce of Australian surfaces. More Root, less Burns, whose bat path goes from high, to wide, to over to under… his arm as he trudges off the ground. And that ain’t it.

They’ve played nice. Smiled lots. And this needs to change.

But perhaps their biggest chance at saving this series comes in the form of COVID and the potential of a shutdown, through the ever-growing case numbers of the Omicron variant, which say’s plenty about England’s cricket so far in this series.

The Crowd Says:

2021-12-24T11:08:32+00:00

Gee

Roar Rookie


Another good read, keep up the good work. Neser should never play again, we don’t want those beautiful ankles of Patty getting injured. (And Starc bowls on the wrong side so unfortunely he can’t go down from ‘friendly fire’)

2021-12-23T21:55:43+00:00

.kraM

Roar Rookie


Precisely

2021-12-23T09:53:03+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


I've seen jokes about not being able to catch Covid either...

2021-12-23T00:48:46+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


The only way this particular contest approaches 50/50 is if selection is sound, toss decisions are favourable, there are zero genuine chance errors in the field, practically everything hits optimum for this particular England group at the same time and conversely there are some major failures within the Australian bowling and batting. An unlikely scenario at commencement and looks even less likely now. In a La Nina season England can’t even catch a shower when needed.

2021-12-22T23:16:27+00:00

Benjamin

Guest


What an inconsequential thing to be upset about. Everything that's going on in the world today, all the evil and sickness and everything else, and you get to sit in your house and watch sport, and you don't like the way two of the 22 players do their job? I think you need to reassess your priorities, mate.

2021-12-22T21:57:51+00:00

Andrew

Roar Rookie


I think I like the Lyon jokes more than the true story. But thanks for the answer.

AUTHOR

2021-12-22T21:53:16+00:00

Brett Geeves

Expert


Warner’s brother took to Twitter when Mickey Arthur was sacked and called him the escapegoat.. pretty obscure, sorry!!

2021-12-22T21:29:19+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


That’s probably the most interminable example of whataboutism I’ve seen on this site Mike. It’s also one of the weakest forms of argument, no matter how earnest.

2021-12-22T20:59:15+00:00

Just here to say you’re wrong

Guest


Ben Franks Tawera Kerr-Barlow Steve Devine Tyrel Lomax Benson Stanley I can keep going if you like?

2021-12-22T20:55:15+00:00

Ado Potato

Roar Rookie


This article is truly funny. Acerbicly, insightfully funny. And Brett Geeves, the 'angry bogan', can write. My favourite line: "It was of the utmost importance to the two aspiring street mimes..."

2021-12-22T09:24:22+00:00

robertbrob13226

Roar Rookie


Name them Einstein

2021-12-22T08:55:00+00:00

Loads

Guest


Totally nailed it Mike. 100%.

2021-12-22T07:11:07+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Ah, fair enough. I did scratch my head at comments suggesting it was 50/50. If England is to win in Australia, their team needs to be significantly better - and vice versa as well. You cannot underestimate home court advantage.

2021-12-22T06:50:19+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


That would imply a level of expectation I could never have mustered James.

2021-12-22T06:44:46+00:00

Phillip Abbott

Guest


Tony Greig, Allan Lamb, Andrew Strauss, Jonathan Trott, Basil D'Oliviera, Robin Smith, Matt Prior.

2021-12-22T06:37:36+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


Whoohoo, a pile on! Love it.

2021-12-22T03:24:07+00:00

josh

Roar Rookie


They all seem to get excited that bowling short actually does something that doesn't result in a long hop. So they all get bit carried away with it.

2021-12-22T02:08:57+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


No one's got on Boonie's case, because he drank it.

2021-12-22T02:08:21+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Wasn't it Bowie's Sound and Vision? It's still stuck in my head.

2021-12-21T23:27:54+00:00

Mike

Guest


Wow! Some real Smith hatred seeping through there. I'm struggling to understand why Vaughan and Atherton (who was the captain AND did the deed - filmed with a pocketful of dirt and confessed) are so easily excused and probably loved by you Neil. Also, I can't see why it's acceptable to have Stokes in a leadership role as VC following his disabled child mockery incident and his filmed thuggery assaulting a member of the public, yet Smith is to be treated as a criminal for the rest of his life. I think your assessment of the situation is affected by your dislike of Smith as a player, your frustrations at the poor performance of your own team, and your longing to have a go at Australia and it's fans. I think you'll find that most Australians accept that the English cricket board assessed Atherton and Stokes (Vaughan was never "sprung" but Trescothick's memoir and confession ahve made it all clear) and dished out the punishment they thought apt. Many of us raised eyebrows at how lenient the punishments were and, as I recall, they just went with the ICC recommendation. In Australia we were much harder on Smith and co. They could have been back playing much, much earlier if we had followed the same path as England and stuck with the ICC punishment. However, it was Australia who punished them so harshly. I suggest if Atherton had been Australian he'd have been out of all forms of cricket for at least a year. It was our own harsh punishment of Smith that seemed to escalate the venom dished out to him from the English. It placed, in your minds, a totally disproportionate assessment of him vs your own "good old Athers" actions. Australia was willing to have a weakened test team for quite a while (probably cost us a home series vs India) in order to make a statement of what it expects from it's captain and senior players. It seems to me that England doesn't have those same standards. Athers is lauded and his distatseful cheating seems to be forgotten. Stokes is a needed "hero" and his behaviour just accepted - "bit of a lad our Ben." Still, that's England's choice and our crowds have never reacted towards them in the same continuous "booing" way yours did towards Smith on the last Ashes tour - and probably will again. Clearly the "booing" was counter productive as he smacked your backsides. Perhaps your own current batsmen should start showing some similar grit.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar