The best Test XII of the last 30 years, with 12 Test nations represented

By mike101 / Roar Rookie

Until recently, we really only had eight Test cricketing teams, with Test cricket increasingly becoming a niche format for the genuine purists.

With the conferring of Test status to Ireland and Afghanistan, we now have 12 nations with Test status and elegantly this opens up the opportunity to deliberately create controversy and select the best Test XI by selecting the best possible player from each team from the last three decades.

The challenge with this one is that we are trying to pick the best player from each team, but we also have to fully assemble a balanced side – two openers, three genuine middle order batters, a wicketkeeper, an all-rounder, two spinners, one right-arm pacer and one left-arm pacer.

Openers

Alastair Cook (England) and Kumar Sangakkara (Sri Lanka)
I have selected the fifth and sixth highest scorers in Test cricket as my openers – with Sangakkara slightly out of place here as opener.

Neither of these players are arguably the best from their nation, with Muttiah Muralitharan probably taking that mantle for Sri Lanka (although, we’ll come to spinners later) and Cook potentially behind Joe Root, Andrew Flintoff, and maybe James Anderson (the English bowling equivalent of Cook).

Cook isn’t out of place here, he’s a genuine opener with a huge appetite for runs and a great record against both spin and pace. He deserves to be opening here with Sangakkara, a man who astonishingly amassed 38 tons at an average of 57.40, with his 195 in Hobart sticking out as one of his best knocks.

Middle order

Sachin Tendulkar (India)
Not a lot to say here, as the most prolific batter in history – most Test runs, most hundreds, most matches and god-like status in his home nation. His longevity, stroke play and runs all over the world make him India’s greatest and the No.3 in this side.

Brian Lara (West Indies)
Started his career in a powerful West Indies side, he barely tasted team success after 1995 but captured everyone’s imagination across a 16-year Test career and as West Indies’ highest ever run scorer.

A popular and swashbuckling strokemaker, he’s most famous for his booming cover drive and his ability to turn a start into huge knocks, holding the record twice for highest Test score (375, 400 not out), and the highest first class score (501 not out).

Jacques Kallis (South Africa)
Such is the class of Kallis, he is being picked in this side in the middle order and not in the all-rounders slot. Arguably the greatest cricketer who ever lived, Kallis amassed 13,289 Test runs at 55.37, to go with 292 wickets at 32.65 with his fas- mediums, and has therefore etched himself as easily the greatest produced by South Africa, let alone this generation.

Kallis will also be the third pacer in this side.

Wicketkeeper
Andy Flower (Zimbabwe)
A close call with Adam Gilchrist, but no doubt here that Flower is the greatest cricket ever produced by Zimbabwe. Flower played the majority of his career for the weakest team in the Test arena until the introduction of Bangladesh in 2000, however, this didn’t stop him from being one of Zimbabwe’s only world-class cricketers throughout his career.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

He holds all the big records for Zimbabwe – most Test runs, highest Test average, most stumpings and most catches. He is the first and only keeper-bbatsman to average 50 in Test cricket (although, Gilchrist did this for a long time), and has the highest individual score by a keeper/ batter (232 not out).

All-rounder

Shakib al-Hasan
Like Flower, Shakib is head and shoulders the best cricketer produced by his nation. A mercurial left-arm spinner with an efficient action, and an aggresive left-handed batter, his batting average of 39.50 (5 x 100s) and bowling average of 31.30 (18 x 5 wickets) across 59 Tests puts him ahead of contemporaries like Flintoff, Stokes, Jason Holder, Ravindra Jadeja and Shane Watson as one of the great all-rounders of his generation.

Left-arm pace

Wasim Akram (Pakistan)
For the sake of balance, it’s an even better looking XI if we include a left-arm pacer. Wasim Akram terrorised batters in the ’90s and early ’00s with his fearsome left-arm swing off a short run, bowling in tandem with his pace bowling contemporary Waqar Younis.

A prolific record, which would have been even better if his team could hang on to all their catches, Wasim alongside the likes of Inzamam, Waqar, Yousuf and Younis Khan is one of Pakistan’s greatest cricketers of the last 30 years.

Spinners

Shane Keith Warne (Australia)
As one of the great cricketing nations, Australia has produced a long line of great cricketers in the last 30 years. Named as one of the five greatest cricketers of the 20th century by Wisden, Warne is probably Australia’s second greatest after Bradman. Not much else to say here, he’s the king of spin.

(Photo by Daniel Pockett/Getty Images)

Rashid Khan (Afghanistan)
From the newest cricketing nation, the mature looking 23-year old leggie from Afghanistan has been making huge waves in the global T20 circuit for years now, with his unique style of at the stumps quick leg spin and an outstanding googly bamboozling batters worldwide.

He already has an astonishing two 10-wicket match hauls to his name in his short five-Test career.

Right-arm pacer

Shane Bond (New Zealand)
A career curtailed by injury, his emergence on the cricket scene in ’01-’02 versus Australia caught everybody’s attention with his leaping action and express pace.

Bond owns the second highest strike rate ever in Test cricket and always left his best for the better sides around the world. Pound for pound on talent, he’s one of New Zealand’s greatest ever, with only contemporaries Cairns, Williamson, Daniel Vettori and perhaps Taylor matching him on ability.

12th man

Kevin O’Brien (Ireland)
O’Brien unlocked his dream of representing his nation in Test cricket when they were conferred Test status in 2018 and he didn’t disappoint, scoring the first Test century for his nation.

A dynamic all-rounder, O’Brien couples his aggressive batting (he scored a century in 50 balls at the 2011 World Cup against in England) with accurate stump to stump medium-pace.

Curiously, of all the players I have picked, a few have been Test captain, but none have truly impressed or finished the game with a strong captaincy record.

Who would you pick as captain?

The Crowd Says:

2022-01-16T07:46:15+00:00

Martyn

Guest


Can't understand all the problems with kallis selection the stats don't lie! He could of got in any test team as a batsman n most as a bowler specialist. I would have had same team but had hayden open with cook n swapped murali for Warne as again stats don't lie

2022-01-16T03:43:00+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


Don't forget the wicketkeepsmen.

2022-01-15T20:56:53+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Micko, As I suggested, next time it might be different!

2022-01-15T20:56:21+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Micko, That's correct. If you remove Miller, then the structure changes from 5-1-1-2-2 to 6-0-1-3-1. That is, batsmen, all-rounder, keeper-batsman, pacemen, spinners. Miller allows you much more flexibility in other choices. We should also remember I think he was bette the his stats, as brilliant as they are.

2022-01-15T20:53:08+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Ado Potato, I'm not as strong either as I used to be on Miller. But he is integral to the balance of the team, allowing me to select 2 front-line pacemen & 2 frontline spinners. It's a fantasy best one-time XI that can play in any conditions in any country. If you start picking a best XI for Sydney, or Perth, or Mumbai, or Delhi, or Cape Town, or JoBurg, or Lords, or Headingly, or Kingston, or Port-of-Spain, then you might have slight changes for each XI, which then defeats the whole concept of picking one ultimate XI.

2022-01-15T14:37:45+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


It's actually good fun. Then you have to struggle to choose between a standout bowler and a batsman from one country. I had this dilemma myself between Lara or Ambrose from WI, or De Villiers or Steyn from SA. Went with Ambrose & De Villiers because Ambrose was marginally better than Steyn in my opinion, but I consider De Villiers to be Lara's equal.

2022-01-15T14:25:18+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


#3 Who should be an all-rounder in the first XI then? (assuming you want one in the first XI, and not 6+4+1?)

2022-01-15T14:22:04+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


I don't think you can justify leaving out Tendulkar though. Easily the best Indian test player I've witnessed in this era, and probably the best batsman I've seen, so for mine a walk up starter alongside Cook, Williamson, Sangakkara, R. Khan, Akram, A. Flower, & Al Hasan For mine, McGrath is Australia's selection as someone who excelled everywhere (only Lara in the WI got the best of him once or twice) over Warne, and the host of batsmen. SA & WI are tricky as you could go with Kallis (which I won't since I believe he's highly overrated), Donald, Steyn, or AB De Villiers. I pick De Villiers as I rate Ambrose elite, and slightly better than Steyn, but De Villiers to be Lara's equal...so: 1. Cook 2. Williamson (can be an opener, no issues!) 3. Sachin (can be a #3, no issues!) 4. Sanga 5. De Villiers 6. A. Flower (w/k) 7. Shakib 8. Wasim 9. Ambrose 10. McGrath 11. Rashid 12. (ditto regarding Irish fielder)

2022-01-15T13:47:45+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Probably would’ve picked McGrath as the Australian since he had success in India as well. Warne never achieved much success in India. edit: don’t know who’d get the spinners gig since Murali was a failure in Australia, and maybe another country as well?

2022-01-15T13:45:48+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Would’ve picked Kallis ONLY because it’s hard to choose between Steyn, Donald, or AB De Villiers in this side. Arguably NOT the greatest cricketer though, surely that’s Sobers! edit: for NZ you’d probably have to go with Williamson, despite how good Bond was in his limited career.

2022-01-15T13:05:55+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Surprised you picked Ponting as captain over Steve Waugh sheek! :shocked:

2022-01-15T12:49:51+00:00

Ado Potato

Roar Rookie


Batter and bowler sounds better than batsman and bowlsman.

2022-01-15T12:46:25+00:00

Ado Potato

Roar Rookie


Three quick thoughts. 1. I love the idea of Victor Trumper opening. 2. Great to see the demon bowler Spofforth made your second 11. 3. I am not convinced that Keith Miller, brilliant larger-than-life figure that he is, should be the all-rounder in the first 11. Great lists. (edit, didn’t read closely the first time)

2022-01-15T09:18:21+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


Right. Very interesting.

2022-01-15T09:16:50+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


I kinda expressed that poorly. It's common for adjectives to be used for first names there. Current male and female players include Blessing Muzarabani, Prince Masvaure, Nomatter Mutasa, Innocent Kaia, and Precious Marange.

2022-01-15T09:01:58+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


Don 't know about any of those ... can you tell me?

2022-01-15T09:01:16+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


And I thought the Zimbabweans had epic names!

2022-01-15T08:52:20+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


Shakib al Hasan literally means 'Bright Star the Handsome'.

2022-01-14T03:53:06+00:00

Brian Westlake

Roar Rookie


I'm sure Sir Garfield might have something to say about that. Not that he would have, with greatness comes humility

2022-01-14T02:40:46+00:00

ojp44

Guest


Which however, leads me into a joke. Statistics reveal that women make better archeologists because they are better at digging up old history. Very good Sheek :laughing: Hope you recovery goes well.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar