What on earth does a visit from Barcelona FC do for football in Australia?

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

With an apparent rebirth of the A-League All-Stars concept taking place as we speak, news broke late last week of the likelihood of a visit from Spanish giant Barcelona FC in either late May or early June.

Advanced discussions reportedly have the deal close to being done and with the newly branded Accor Stadium in Sydney a certain venue, more than 80,000 people would be expected to attend.

The quality of the squad brought to Australia would of course have a huge impact on any potential crowd figure, yet as has been the case with other major European club tours in the years prior to the pandemic, there seems little point in making the trip without bringing the bulk of the club’s best talent.

Australian fans will be champing at the bit to see players like Frenkie de Jong, Pedri, the other Adama Traore, Jordi Alba and Ferran Torres in the flesh, with a combined A-League team likely to be their opponent.

Should scheduling see any A-League Men finals’ play fall after the proposed Barcelona visit, the All-Stars would be then made up of players not involved in those fixtures, thus providing a brilliant opportunity for some who otherwise may not have received such a call up.

As a member of Accor Stadium my ticket is secured, yet my attendance questionable with doubts around the purpose, motivation and benefit of such visits by famous football clubs.

Emotionally it is a no brainer for some, thousands of people with Spanish and/or Barcelona blood in their veins would walk many a mile to see one of world football’s most famous clubs on our shores.

Thousands more youngsters would be inspired beyond belief and experience a potentially life changing event were they to attend; seeing the stars they watch on television right before their very eyes.

However, many with such passion for Barcelona FC will be unable to access or afford tickets, with the majority sold to middle class ‘Event-goers’ who will be able to add yet another notch to their belts.

Putting football support and emotion of Barcelona fans to one side, what does such an event actually do for the Australian game?

Aside from a passionate group of Euro-snobs waxing lyrical about a brand valued at just less than $5 billion and the pockets of the corporates getting well lined as a result of the visit, what possible benefit could a one-off match between Barcelona FC and an A-League All-Stars team actually produce?

(Photo by Jose Breton/Pics Action/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Plenty of merchandise, advertising space, tickets, buckets of chips and an array of beverages will be sold, with the broadcaster, stadium and contracted caterers all standing to have a big night with a tidy profit appearing on the balance sheet come the end of it.

No doubt plenty of flesh will be pressed in the private suites and boxes and let’s hope all those corporate entities do manage to secure those deals that could well be sealed on the back of an invite to such an ‘event’.

Heaven knows, those struggling corporates certainly do need it, as the average fan forks out a tidy sum to watch Barcelona do its business.

In the past, the price of additional tickets available to members of the stadium has been excessive. If memory serves me correctly, the price of a single adult seat for my guest during the last talked up visit of a major European team was $219.

In my view, that is far from value for money; potentially proven with hard evidence gathered during similar cheesy matches of the past, with many fans seemingly more interested in the challenge of folding and then successfully launching a paper plane that soars through the air and finds its way onto the playing surface.

On more than one occasion during similar matches in Sydney’s biggest stadium, second halves offering little interest to the football fly-by-nights have seen paper plane activities occupy their minds far more successfully.

The sight of young kids and more alarmingly, adults, completely engrossed in a solid half-hour of aeronautical entertainment asks the question as to why they were there in the first place and how much money they actually have to waste.

The thought of a young kid watching on television in a less than salubrious suburb of Sydney always comes to mind, knowing that he or she would have engaged with the contest wholly and never, ever take the opportunity for granted.

Yet, should the plans all come to fruition and the mighty Barcelona FC visit our shores in a few months’ time, an ‘event’ it will be.

Some folks will make a bucket of money, the majority of attendees will be thoroughly ripped off to the tune of anywhere between $100 and $300 and the chasm between the domestic game and the overseas elite will only become clearer in the minds of many.

I’m not sure Australia really needs these football exercises that do little more than line pockets and fuel snobbery. Perhaps the game could be promoted and supported in a manner that actually benefits the domestic scene.

The Crowd Says:

2022-03-19T00:35:18+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


The A-league teams have been subsiding the visiting teams along with various state governments not the other way around. Charity going to these entities is a big joke, same with the AFL teams being paid over the odds to go to Tasmania and Canberra. Melbourne its sporting capital status based on paying big dollars for the biggest events to come over, its like boasting that one pays for the biggest hookers. Sage, Tinkler, Palmer , Serepisos have all dished out big money to visiting teams and taken huge losses over these matches. Tinkler and Serepisos got to rub shoulders with Beckham before bankruptcy though in the case of Tinker the half a billion he put into race horses did him in, Even in the cases where the A-league teams haven't directly paid for them, they have subsidised them through low appearance fees. Some teams have played for nothing , Sydney FC played three matches for 100k, at the so called festival of football and 70% of the crowd were wearing Sydney FC gear. Why are the state governments giving money to foreign clubs to come over. They dont give money to foreign music acts to come over. If it weren't for these subsidies then they wouldn't come over. The structure of European football is all about the big clubs subsiding the rest that doesn't extend to other confederations.

2022-03-16T02:26:26+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


I disagree with your analogy. Pure entertainment (by way of singers, artists, films, etc) differs from big football brands/clubs cannibalising local football leagues and hence support. And I'm giving Fuss a call to get the whole gang back on the Roar :laughing: :happy: :stoked: :laughing: :silly:

2022-03-15T21:14:00+00:00

AR

Guest


Most of the comments here seem to be based around the popular - yet utterly bizarre - concept that the entire world owes the ALeague something, or owes Australian football something. If Barca want to come to Australian shores, then great. If the Yankees want to come, perfect. If the Lakers want to come, even better. Big entertainment events are fun. It’s like saying: “They shouldn’t release the new Star Wars movie in Australia because it might make the Australian film scene look poor by comparison.”

2022-03-15T20:33:03+00:00

Football is Life

Roar Rookie


Exactly. What about the promotion of Asian football. It's bloody good. Get San Frecce, Urawa, Ilsan and F Marino's out here to play the local lads.

2022-03-15T20:30:12+00:00

Football is Life

Roar Rookie


When you have a problem You've got to attack it one day at a time and eat it one mouthful at a time.

2022-03-15T18:32:19+00:00

Stevo

Roar Rookie


"Secondly, I’d prefer that young woman be frequenting A-League games. That would be a benefit to the domestic scene." Perfect.

2022-03-15T14:17:40+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Kewell and Cahill came to the A-league when they were too old, the top Socceroos that came back to the A-league have been failures. Usually its the next level down that come back earlier that have ben success stories.

2022-03-15T11:13:05+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


And Stu goes bang! Not to say I don't disagree with you

2022-03-15T10:11:24+00:00

stu

Guest


I get the distinct feeling that the author is not in favour of individuals or companies from taking an opportunity and making a buck from this article. I would also suggest that the author believes that the individual is not capable of accessing value to them from buying a ticket to attend the game. It also strikes me that on a forum that regularly berates some football codes for being insular in regards to their primary support base being in Australia, yet the global game sends teams out here and apparently there is no value in doing so. The logic works in mysterious ways.

2022-03-15T07:07:39+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


Josh - took me a long while to pull on red and black - most of the first season in fact - wearing red just didn’t seem right!

2022-03-15T07:06:11+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


In europe (and on Fifa) there are always mini round robin tournaments between neighbouring countries p at club level as a part of pre season. I’d be much happier to see a couple of Japanese and Korean teams here in a pre season tournament - trouble is, our pre season is their regular season as we are not aligned at all.

2022-03-15T05:32:04+00:00

Remote

Guest


You read the tea leaves wrong Brainstrust. I’m indicating the type of player required to compete, rather than Kewell, Cahill in the flesh ie Australian players who return(ed) home to play in the A-League of high quality. I doubt there is any in the present Socceroos squad who fit that bill. Same with Ninkovic, I agree would have been more useful a couple of years ago in this type of match.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:30:43+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


A much better idea and focussing on our region will have a much more long term and tangible impact on the domestic game. But Australia will play its part in the silly tour and wipe some of the debt Barca have accumulated over the last two years.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:28:49+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Ahhhh, because the Barca tour will not leave a legacy for the local game. That's kind of the point. I'm not silly enough to blindly hope for something that won't happen, as a team heads abroad to service their debt. Secondly, I'd prefer that young woman be frequenting A-League games. That would be a benefit to the domestic scene.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:25:19+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Pretty good for the debt too. We are merely being used and benefitting in no way shape or form.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:22:03+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Or when one of the stars of Hamilton has a night off and you get the understudy! Very disappointing King George.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:21:06+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I'm certain the calls for marquee players is for athletes to actually play in the A-League and not those who pop in for a three day visit to finance their club's debts.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:18:37+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Same people who were at the Bruce Springsteen concert in the Hunter Valley with me a few years back.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:17:25+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I'm fairly sure football as a global game is not really struggling with participation or interest. It is the biggest game in the world for goodness sakes! Aligning such a trip with promoting the game is the same as the nonsense that came from FIFA and legends like Tim Cahill when a biennial World Cup was announced.

AUTHOR

2022-03-15T04:14:53+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Your first sentence makes no sense. Do you mean, " who think they cant afford tickets because of corporate conspiracies?"

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar