REACTION: 'It's a high-speed game' - Brumbies coach slams Wallabies star's red card after thrilling Force battle

By The Roar / Editor

If we see a better game this season, it will have been a classic.

The Brumbies’ edge-of-your-seat 39-38 win over the Force had everything you want from a rugby match – points aplenty, incredible skill in spite of difficult, greasy conditions in Perth, and fierce determination from every single player involved.

Central to it all was a moment that exemplified the latter quality: Tom Banks red-carded after a brutal head clash with Toni Pulu that left the Brumbies star with a suspected facial fracture.

An onrushing Banks was caught by surprise mid-tackle as Pulu stepped inward, the pair’s heads clashing as the Force winger dropped the ball.

It was enough for a penalty try, the Force’s first of the night – and while being treated for a HIA, Banks was given his marching orders in slightly farcical scenes.

“World Rugby now is all about the welfare of players and head collisions, and you’ve got to make an effort to go low. But five metres out, there’s got to be some sort of mitigating factor,” rugby legend Tim Horan said on Stan Sport.

“When you’re the last defender as a fullback and the player is running down, you’re not expecting him to step inside so your whole focus is there.

“All of a sudden, you’re off-put by the way he steps off his right foot back in.

“It surprises you and he’s going to hit you a bit closer than what you’d normally expect. It’s hard, when you’re a player, and the referees need to understand how that works in a game.

“It’s a tough call.”

The Force, trailing 3-20 at the time, sensed their moment. Remarkably, and to the delight of a parochial home crowd, they would deal the 14-man Brumbies a blitzkrieg, piling on 28 points including four tries in the 20-minute period to take a remarkable lead.

It fell to player of the match Andy Muirhead to steady the ship for the Brumbies, completing his hat-trick shortly after half time as the points rapidly dried up.

They would then hold their nerve at the death to escape with a thrilling one-point victory, in an instant frontrunner for the game of the year.

Speaking after the game, though, Brumbies coach Dan McKellar was typically blunt in his assessment of the Banks red card.

“No I don’t. Honestly, I don’t think it was [a red card],” he told Stan Sport.

“I talk about this all the time: it’s a high-speed, high collision game. Banksy’s coming across at full speed, TP changes direction and there’s a head clash.

“If Tom Banks has got a nasty bone in his body, or goes out there to deliberately hurt someone, then I don’t know the bloke.

“As a game, we’ve got to look at these sorts of things… I’d have an orange card – 20 minute orange card, and then a red card stays for deliberate foul play, punching, gouging, whatever it might be.”

Having lost in similarly heartbreaking fashion to the Brumbies back in Round 1, Force captain Feleti Kaitu’u was a bitterly disappointed man speaking with Stan Sport after the final whistle.

“Against all odds there, with the red card, they managed to sneak away with it again,” he said of the Brumbies’ second-half fightback.

Chief among the skipper’s concerns was another sluggish start by the Force before the Banks red card, who could easily have emerged victorious if not for a dire first 20 minutes that saw the Brumbies score three tries.

“Against a quality opposition like the Brumbies, you can’t afford to give up that much of a lead that early,” Kaitu’u said.

“We’ve got a pretty awesome attacking structure, we haven’t been quite able to execute in recent weeks, but we know that if we get it right, we’re able to put points on the scoreboard and it showed tonight.

“It was great to be able to come back, but against the Brumbies, or any side for that matter, you just can’t afford to give up that many points.”

Kaitu’u’s frustration was clear, but former great Justin Harrison argued the loss was still a giant leap forward for the rising Force.

Toni Pulu of the Force runs the ball against Andy Muirhead of the Brumbies. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

“It’s not often that you’re in a losing team that outscored a team by 28 points for a period of the game,” he said on Stan Sport.

“It shows the closeness of these two teams – Round 1 when they first played, close, down to the last play of the game, again tonight down to the last play of the game.

“Western Force have got a lot to walk tall off from that game. They have put in a performance that is deserving to garner some support in Perth.”

Horan agreed, praising coach Tim Sampson for the Force’s rapid improvement over the last 12 months.

“Tim Sampson’s done a great job in those last 15 to 18 months with this side, bringing them through off the field first, and now they’re starting to deliver on the field,” he said.

“That’s a very good performance.”

For the Brumbies, Muirhead’s performance was singled out for particular praise, with the winger scoring three of the game’s whopping 11 tries.

In Horan’s eyes, the 28-year old deserved all the acclaim after years of playing second fiddle to his more high-profile teammates.

“He often gets overshadowed by players around him – Len Ikitau, Noah Lolesio when he’s playing, Tom Wright,” he said.

“He’s a small player, but I tell you what – he comes off his wing really well, but he also knows when to stay on his wing and look for the ball. A very good player amongst a very talented Brumbies backline.”

In Horan’s eyes, the Brumbies’ gutsy win comes down to their improvement from the side that came within a whisker of Super Rugby AU glory last year.

“I think they’re a much better side this year than they were last year,” he said.

“Last year, they made a few mistakes: this year, everyone knows where to stand, they know exactly their roles and their responsibilities, and that comes down to the coaching staff.”

They needed to be every bit of that to take down the Force. Up next awaits the Reds in a top-of-the-table showdown: we can’t wait.

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-02T09:51:00+00:00

BrumbiesFan

Roar Rookie


Ill informed? The tribunal cleared Banks of a Red! They cited three - THREE - mitigating factors when Gardiner found none. Well, he actually did find mitigation but, stupidly and inexplicably, allowed a touchie to talk him out of it. Just asking, but where do you get your "information"?

2022-04-02T09:45:39+00:00

BrumbiesFan

Roar Rookie


Banks got his Red Card rescinded by the SANZAAR tribunal! It should NOT have been given, simple as that. They gave him a Warning (i.e. a Yellow, which is precisely what I suggested). I am a Brumbies Fan, sure, but I feel well vindicated! Regardless of which team we support, we all play under the same Laws. And, having spent my life around this great game, can we just accept that some know Rugby Laws better than others?

2022-03-28T07:55:05+00:00

Colvin Brown

Roar Guru


I think we're talking about the same thing here. A ball carrier has the responsibility to play in a safe way. The Chiefs 8 who hurdled Aaron Smith to score a couple of weeks ago was belatedly determined to have acted in a dangerous manner. The try should have been disallowed. So yes, these occasions can occur.

2022-03-28T07:31:54+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


I am talking about the future , about doing more to ensure no head injuries. A ball carrier will have a clear responsibility to ensure care and safety in this regard.

2022-03-28T07:14:09+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Thanks mate, agree with you there. We don't have the natural stoppages American football does to accommodate the endless pontificating

2022-03-28T06:51:22+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


Sorry I didn't explain it well. I mean with so many stoppages and even more Hal;ts as they discuss what went wrong. It seems that everyone is expecting a perfect play from the referee and yet are allowing the players to make mistakes and I think that's wrong

2022-03-28T05:51:36+00:00

Jack

Guest


As long as you don’t head butt the bloke attempting the tackle you’ll be fine

2022-03-28T04:40:58+00:00

Colvin Brown

Roar Guru


Peter, the driver changing lanes has a clear responsibility to ensure care and safety. It's hard to see that same responsibility sitting on a winger trying to step his way to the try-line. unless in doing so he did something crazy like say treading all over a player lying on the ground to spring himself over the line. That would fall into dangerous play.

2022-03-28T04:36:35+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


It’s not that the referees are sacrosanct, or that they don’t make mistakes but the game needs them with all their faults or we’ll go down the American Football path and that would be bad. Curious what you mean by this JC - refs in the NFL, whilst often attacked by disgruntled fans, are rarely if ever second guessed by the surrounding media.

2022-03-28T04:18:05+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


His change of direction altered the dynamics of the collision in his favour. Well, that's rugby in a nutshell isn't it?

2022-03-28T04:07:11+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


"I have times when" That's the qualifying pretext that you left out so you could get upset on behalf of someone who doesn't need you to take a hike

2022-03-28T03:01:35+00:00

JP

Guest


'I don’t believe Horan has even played rugby' That snide comment was not warranted.

2022-03-28T02:15:43+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Agree. The ends justifies any means apparently... And it worked for Rassie too. I think play a 10Mtr or 6 phase adv and then move on or reduce penalty adv not taken to a free kick and it MUST be Tap and go. There has to be ways to change the current coaches attitudes.

2022-03-28T02:00:45+00:00

Thenipper

Roar Rookie


Banks was coming across at full-speed, upright - you're telling me that (to use the legal parlance), "but for" Pulu stepping in, Banks was going to tackle him lower and legally? I don't buy it for a second.

2022-03-28T01:37:13+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


So what’s the solution? I guess you tackle low and allow them to score out wide. Same as it is anywhere on the field, if you can't make a legal tackle, you have to let them go. This has always been the rule, we've always penalised players for reflexively throwing an arm out at the last minute after a change in direction and collecting them high.

2022-03-28T01:34:49+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


It's the Rassie effect, Jacko - the Springboks won a world cup playing like this so can hardly blame teams for copying it. I'd like to see penalties for cynical play when they're clearly playing for a penalty rather than playing the game. - not sure if it would be enforceable though tbh, would mean penalising intent which I hate.

2022-03-28T01:26:57+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Even when he's clearly wrong? More fool you I suppose

2022-03-28T00:28:21+00:00

JP

Guest


I`d believe a guy who has played 80 tests and won a world cup over a Piru from Perf. How many tests you played keyboard warrior?

2022-03-27T13:42:08+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


So no changing directions then?

2022-03-27T13:39:39+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


I think our first year back playing the rebels must have been close

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar