The AFL has done it again, with furore erupting over rules, interpretation and application.
It’s quite amazing that almost everything the AFL do has the opposite effect to what is intended. Perhaps it’s because most of the things they introduce are done on the fly, sometimes only days or weeks before the season starts, and/or after minimal/zero testing at lower levels.
Australia being the nanny state that it is, perhaps it is no surprise that our true national code must be among the most over-officiated of sports in the world. The amount of rules the AFL has in place is disgustingly over-the-top, and only makes it harder for the face of those rules – the umpires.
Of course, the big issue of the week is umpire respect, and the ‘hands out’ ruling.
It started with Harris Andrews on Thursday night, which was embarrassing enough, but only became worse over the course of the weekend as many similar or more aggressive actions were ignored. What makes fans even angrier is when the umpires do randomly pluck one out again, such as in Hawthorn’s defeat against Geelong.
You won’t find anyone that disagrees with the idea of respecting officialdom on an AFL field. What we see in tennis is terrible. Some of what they get away with in soccer is not much better.
Could the amount of dissent towards umpires on an AFL field be reined in? Perhaps. Was putting some more rigour around these interactions, or at least calling it out, appropriate? Maybe.
But, as ever, it has gone too far too quickly. Fans have a keen sense of what is just and what isn’t, and the uproar has been justified.
Then we get the ‘think of the children’ brigade.
I’m a parent of a junior footballer. And I can tell you right now that if he does anything untoward an umpire in a game of football, that is on me. Certainly more so than it is on Harris Andrews, George Hewett or Tom Mitchell. And that will be true whether my child is 10, 12, 14 or 16. Then, in the transition to adulthood, we see the move toward personal responsibility.
The biggest problem with so many rules in the AFL is that they never all get called. If they were, there’d be 150 free kicks a game, which is untenable.
It is when some free kicks get paid and others don’t for the same or similar actions, that drive players, fans and commentators crazy.
It should be blindingly obvious to everyone that the fewer rules there are, the fewer interpretations of said rules, and therefore the less room for error. Right now, the umpires have no hope. It’s impossible for them to be consistent, and some rules get loosened over time, which leads to the even more embarrassing ‘rule of the week’ situation when a series of free kicks for a particular infringement gets paid in the first game of the week out of nowhere.
Almost all fans prefer a minimalist interpretation of the rules. If plenty of them get missed, that’s okay, because the game keeps moving, and no-one has time to worry about free kicks that weren’t paid. But when too many get paid, some of which are marginally there or not at all, the frustration of everyone rises, and anger follows.
So by trying to create a situation of respecting umpires more, they have now become the target of more serious heat than at any time in recent memory.
Of course, the funniest reaction to all of this was from Chris Scott, backing up the AFL as he always does. It was particularly humorous given Tom Hawkins has been the subject of multiple controversial decisions this year, that have all gone the Cats’ way.
Scott also happens to be the twin brother of the bloke at AFL House that brought in the dissent rule. Oh yes, and the head of football before Brad Scott was Steve Hocking – former Geelong player and administrator and current CEO, who took a gig at the AFL in between his lifelong devotion to the Cats.
Perhaps one day the AFL will pass a conflict-of-interest rule? We won’t hold our breath.
Ben
Guest
Such a great sport that they need to change rules every season.
Curmudgeon1961
Roar Rookie
Those boofy NRL blokes and the Union chaps seem to manage respect OK. Just saying
Curmudgeon1961
Roar Rookie
Chris you have a player in your team of Hooped Cats who seems to just loose his legs when he is tackled. Can you check is he is fit enough to play, no leg injuries etc? If he isn't fit please replace him. If he is fit just let him we wont be paying that free. Said no umpire ever.....
Curmudgeon1961
Roar Rookie
The games are actually better to watch (when you are there) too Prez
Cameron Rose
Expert
A thousand likes to this Brendon. Infuriating.
Cameron Rose
Expert
I did that last week!
Cameron Rose
Expert
This was very good Rowdy, had a good chuckle at this one. :laughing:
Cameron Rose
Expert
Don't get me started on the roadworks in Vic.
Mr Right
Roar Rookie
They were prepared to take the high ground & back their nonsense arms out rule that fans really can't relate too but took a blind eye to high diving Hawkins staging which fans are really sick of seeing. We don't need new rules, we need new management.
Cugel
Roar Rookie
If they change as many rules, introduce as many new ones, and poorly implement them more than the NRL does, I pity da fools. Exhibit A: someone dreamt up you can't tackle a player in the air. Result? Attackers just stand idly by, too afraid to do anything, because the referees are completely incapable of differentiating a tackle and merely contesting the kick.
Daveo
Guest
Another Essendon supporter having a crack at Joe. To be fair, he got bigger shoves than Ton got.
Vanessa August
Guest
Could not agree more with this article! The league is heavily supported by various gambling businesses and is littered with nepotism and clear conflicts of interest in its appointments. The potential for corruption is blindingly obvious and it is so easy to have an umpire change the result of a game with the “interpretation “ of a rule.
john singleton
Roar Rookie
Can remember the days with one Umpire they had my respect, you could talk to them,have a joke, and then have a drink with after the game.Not now with the Holy than thou chardonnay drinking snobs, no respect ????????????????
john singleton
Roar Rookie
I could be wrong I think it was a lot longer for the cats than the Tiges
Prez
Roar Rookie
SANFL do a lot of things right with their umpiring. The last touch rule is a good one.
Prez
Roar Rookie
Its such a simple rule to change and would take some of heat/pressure off the umpires.
dab
Roar Rookie
AFL says it won't be relaxing the 'umpire abuse' rules despite admitting inconsistencies Nothing wrong with HMAS AFL, Icebergs can't damage us! Faster! Full speed ahead.
What a Joke!
Guest
Who is with me on this? The umps get about 10 grand a game. Not bad for a 3 hour gig on a weekend and they can't take a bit of stick for doing a lousy job. It costs about two bucks for a set of ear plugs. Use a fraction of that 10k a week they get to buy ear plugs to block out the critics!
1dawg
Roar Rookie
It's a very slight possibility that he's wrong for the first time ever .
Yattuzzi
Roar Rookie
But didn’t Don say you were a Richmond trolll afterbirth.