Rugby News: 'I held the World Cup and don't remember it' - hooker's harrowing battle, Edmed has 'all the tools', Campbell vows to step up

By Tony Harper / Editor

Anyone who thinks rugby’s escalating crackdown on head contact is going too far should spend a little time with the story of World Cup winner Steve Thompson.

The 2003 England hooker, who is suffering early onset dementia and suspected CTE chronic traumatic encephalopathy, gave a harrowing interview in The Times last week ahead of next week’s release of his book on his struggles with brain injuries he believes are due to his rugby career.

The Times also ran an extract from the book, ‘Unforgettable: Rugby, Dementia and the Fight of My Life’ in which Thompson, 43, reveals he has no memory at all of the triumphant 2003 tournament which culminated in Jonny Wilkinson’s match winning drop goal against the Wallabies.

He recalls rewatching the games from that tournament with a work colleague, and being unable to remember what he was watching unfold on the television.

As for the final celebrations, he writes: “On the podium I spot myself stood between my fellow front-row forwards, Phil Vickery and Trevor Woodman. I see myself jumping about as the trophy is passed around. Normally, when you look back on a big occasion in your life, your heart rate increases, you feel excitement, the hairs on the back of your neck stand up. None of that happens. I don’t expect it to. By now it’s all become very obvious — that part of me, that version of me, is dead. I held the World Cup and I don’t remember it.”

Watching the game, “All I see is a fat lad, round head, big arse… Knowing what I do know now, I 100 per cent wish it had never happened.”

Thompson doesn’t remember meeting the Queen to accept his MBE, nor the victory parade though London’s West End.

Thompson’s diagnosis was made public last year and he is part of an action by a number of former players seeking compensation and action from rugby’s governing bodies, alleging authorities failed to act on clear evidence of the risks of head injury.

The Times says lawyers for the players believe as many as 50 per cent of professional players from Thompson’s era will end up with neurological problems. Thompson says 300 former rugby players have already come forward with suspected symptoms.

Since being diagnosed, Thompson, who details in gut-wrenching detail his struggles with his family, has become a powerful advocate for change in the sport.

Steve Thompson, England (Photo by Mike Egerton – PA Images via Getty Images)

“I didn’t know rugby could be lethal,” he told The Times. In the book he argues the professional era has made the game too reliant on power and strength.

“I went from someone with real agility to a solid block with a 24-inch neck. I was basically half man, half bull,” he said.

“Time and again, I’d be knocked out training and the level of concern from those around me would be nothing more than a shrug of shoulders. After all, it was just Thommo, and Thommo was always OK, wasn’t he? Now I believe I did my job but the people around me didn’t. They were dishonest and they hid stuff.”

He argues that even now, “there are people in rugby, from top to bottom, who remain oblivious to the risks.” 

Thompson and other affected players are arguing for players to be given annual brain scans, concussion holidays of three weeks, better medically trained pitch-side personnel and limits on contact in training.

And he’s called for laws around replacements to be changed.

“A situation has arisen where teams can throw on eight fresh subs and use them to smash a vulnerable opposition,” he told The Times. “They should only ever be used in the case of injuries.”

Time for Reds backs to step up in JOC absence

Returning Queensland Reds fullback Jock Campbell says he and his teammates will need to take a step up after the loss of James O’Connor for the next month.

O’Connor suffered a knee injury in a collision with Wallabies teammate Andrew Kellaway in the Reds’ win over the Rebels last week and could be missing for up to six weeks, according to the Reds.

Campbell is just coming back into the team after a broken hand, and will slot into the No.15 jersey – a position he played impressively in the opening few rounds before he was shifted out to the wing for Jordan Petaia.

Stan Sport’s Sean Maloney joins The Roar experts Brett McKay and Harry Jones for this week’s edition of The Roar Rugby Podcast. Stream it here or like and subscribe in your podcast app of choice.

Petaia will also miss Saturday’s match against the Hurricanes with a minor hamstring injury while Lawson Creighton will start his first Super Rugby game in place of O’Connor.

“He’s a big loss and has been steering the ship for us for a while,” said Campbell of Wallabies veteran JOC. “But Lawsy’s been training here all pre-season and everyone gets injuries. We’re confident he’ll do the job for us.”

Creighton has had a lot of time in the No.10 role at training. “The first time he played on the wing was in a game,” said Campbell. “He’s been preparing as a ten and because he’s a great footy player and very versatile he can play multiple positions.”

Campbell acknowledged that he might need to take on more responsibility as a play maker in JOC’s absence.

“A few of us need to step up,” he said. “Lately James has even told us to step up a bit more to let him roam a bit instead of always being the dominant caller, so we’ll l;ook to cotinue that whether it be Hamish, Hunter or myself. We’re confident we’re pretty fluent and can step into that first receiver role.”

The Reds are eager not to let a good start to the season slip, as they did last season after winning Super Rugby AU.

“The results are fresh in the memory and we’re not afraid of saying that – we got played a little bit by the Kiwis. They were a lot better than us last year,” said Campbell.

“You’ve got dynamic players like Ardie and Julian Savea, Jordie Barrett – dynamic balls players who like open play so we’ll try to limit that as much as we can and give the ball to them on our terms.”

Edmed’s got ‘all the tools’

The Waratahs’ experienced Welsh centre Jamie Roberts has given a ringing endorsement of 21-year-old flyhalf Tane Edmed, after the youngster retained his spot for Friday’s game against the Chiefs.

Edmed will play in the No.10 with Ben Donaldson brought back into the squad via the bench, while Roberts starts with Lalakai Foketi missing for personal reasons.

“I just love his confidence,” Roberts said of Edmed. “His kick, run, pass decisions are every good. He’s very mature for his age as a ten.

Tane Edmed (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

“He wants to play but I think he has discipline in his approach as well. He’s a tough cookie, puts his body on the line and he’s got all the tools to to play at the top level and he’s in a great environment to do that.

“There’s competition for the 10 jersey here – I know he’s a very ambitious player. “

Edmed has been rewarded for his strong form, and Roberts said competition for places was healthy for the unit.

“Tane has come in and taken his opportunity with both hands, he’s been awesome so he keeps the jersey,” said Roberts.

“For any team that wants to achieve you have to have those battles in positions and lads desperate for the jersey. We have that.”

Roberts, who followed his partner Down Under to Sydney and was snapped up by Tahs coach Darren Coleman, says he’s relishing being part of a young team that’s on a high after an upswing in results.

“For me that energy and exuberance of youth is awesome because I’m a bit further down my career now,” Roberts said.

“I get a huge amount of pleasure out of seeing my co-players improving and putting in great performances.”

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-23T00:49:27+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


I think he's having you on there Paulo.

2022-04-22T22:08:28+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


To me the governing body needs to focus more on what happens to a player after a head contact. They already have laws in place in game for head contact and making more extreme card colours is not going to stop head contacts. More focus needs to be what happens next with starring with HIA actually happening and the beyond process. I think the yearly brain scan idea is a good idea to make sure that signs can be caught early and appropriate action is taken. IMO this is where the real gains for player welfare will happen.

2022-04-22T21:59:50+00:00

Dumbo

Roar Rookie


Tony Harper; it's a shame you chose to conflate three different stories - Steve Thompson, Tane Edmed and Jock Campbell - into one piece. The Thompson story is worth a piece on its own, to focus comments on the key issue of brain damage in Rugby players, and its impact on the future of the game. As it is, we get a mixture of comments on all three, plus weird ones that seemingly relate to none at all. "Perhaps that puts some perspective on those who thought Banks should not have been red carded. To approach the tackle zone in the manner he did was highly reckless". Banks? Never mentioned in any of the three articles. See what I mean about keeping commenters focused?

2022-04-22T21:58:58+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


I would be interested to know if this was focused on the tackling action or the lack of assessment, treatment, management and ongoing support of a player who have taken a head impact?

2022-04-22T21:55:47+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


And the guideline is killing the game. Should be a yellow card with mitigating and compounding factors. Currently the mass of refs are not willing to downgrade and need more options given to them.

2022-04-22T21:53:18+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


I have seen many and I mean many players knocked out from ball carriers initiating contact with defenders with good low body heights. I even remember states showing tacklers get injuries more from hips and elbow to head contacts so who is responsible here? Does player welfare not extend to protect the Defender? Many wrapper tackles happen every game without issues as well....this idea that contact with the head is not going to happen in a game is fantasy talk and this idea that the ball carrier has nothing to do with this is outright fantasy.... penalties and yellow cards are a suitable penalty a d deterrent.

2022-04-22T18:33:15+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


As I said, scrum, the safety of tacklers is a harder nut to crack.

2022-04-22T16:58:13+00:00

scrum

Roar Rookie


Or the poor technique of the tackler. It’s the duty of the tackler to tackle safely. Your suggestions virtually change the fabric of the game, high tackles have always been illegal, it’s not new.

2022-04-22T16:55:03+00:00

scrum

Roar Rookie


That’s called poor technique- many low tackles are made every match safely. Do you realise how ridiculous your comments are considering what happens in every match. Can you imagine the difficulty for match officials to make decisions. You think there is outrage now, it would increase dramatically. Most of the outrage now comes from the bias of team supporters rather than the actual event. Oddly every time an AB is YC for a high shot there is a plethora of complaints blaming the ball carrier, it’s so predictable

2022-04-22T16:35:51+00:00

Daffyd

Roar Rookie


I agree that the tackler is more at risk, whether going high or low. However if the tackler goes high, then that risk is then being shared with the carrier. Ultimately it comes down to technique.

2022-04-22T16:33:15+00:00

Daffyd

Roar Rookie


Outlaw ducking into a tackle by bending forward. It's not the same as bracing

2022-04-22T15:32:54+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


I find this thinking interesting since sports such as professional cycling which has way more money than Rugby and pours massive money into R&D are putting special paddings and mesh designed inlays inside of helmets purely to stop brain damage from the brain bouncing around....even to the point of dealing with rotational force through the brain and here we are in rugby with next to no R&D spend on this saying the opposite base on ill funded research...

2022-04-22T15:19:16+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


And I think from reading above the more important factor is he was being knocked out repeatedly at training and none cared and they just sent him out to still play on the weekend...I think that this is fairly obvious to us all that this is not a good thing and is something that is completely avoidable.

2022-04-22T15:11:09+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


How much is it down to poor technique of the ball carrier putting themselves into harm's way..... "What are you going to outlaw" I would start with the ball carrier leading with their head into contact...ball carrier's body high would need to be looked at.... the late jumping of ball carriers....Point of contact if initiated by the ball carrier and Force of contact....This may sound ridiculous to you but this is what is already being demanded of by the tackler...

2022-04-22T14:59:25+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


This is very interesting...Lower the tackle height...putting the tackler's head into danger of hip and knee contact...

2022-04-22T14:56:44+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


The Banks red card was overturned and I am amazed that this is the part you are taking out of this... I think the more important part to take out of this is that he was getting knocked out in training sessions and none cared....This is a clear failure to the player. If a player takes a big headshot, clearly they need to be medically checked and rested as per what is happening in the modern game. Hearing a player say they constantly got knocked out at training is madness and clearly where the problem has come from.

2022-04-22T08:26:12+00:00

Tooly

Roar Rookie


Perhaps the Tahs might lend Harrison to QLD they don’t use him. I’m not too excited about any of the young 10 s . They all do the job they are supposed to do without being brilliant. Lolisio has had the blow torch applied and has managed to do the same at Test level. He’s a long way behind Smith. Best to watch them against NZ sides. We won’t go anywhere if we keep going for JOC , Quadie or god forbid Toomua . The same applies to Hodge and Hooper.

2022-04-22T04:30:37+00:00

Sgt Pepperoni

Roar Rookie


Just because it's unsafe doesnt mean that there won't be people who still want to play it Look at boxing or MMA - who doesnt understand that there are risks to taking up sports where your head couldn't be more directly targeted. They still have plenty of participants coming into the sport With the attraction of the individual game plus the potential earnings, I would argue that there will continue to be young players who want to play contact sports

2022-04-22T03:08:06+00:00

Paulo

Roar Rookie


I think there can’t be an argument about it being reckless and dangerous. And stupid. I don’t it was intentional, if only for the fact he closed his eyes and looked away. If he was aiming directly at something he would have looked. This was more of “I’m just going to hit you hard, where ever”. It was pretty stupid. I’ll respectfully disagree about his one other RC being near identical. His other one was a foot off the ground as Hooper ducked around a ruck with the ball. Very little in common to this - Hooper had the ball, he wasn’t already wrapped up, Barrett wasn’t too upright. Now, Barrett was reckless and no argument from me now about it being a RC. But quite different situations for mine. https://youtu.be/4utRNkzcSPo

2022-04-22T01:01:23+00:00

scrum

Roar Rookie


Yes I accept there appears to be a contradiction. I hold with my view that in the main it is difficult to judge intent, there may be intent or may not be intent , only the perpetrator really knows and that is the reason it should not be a factor in determining what sanctions are applied. And if I am honest with myself I have contradicted myself over Barrett. My only defence is that it was late , totally unnecessary and what other outcome was there to be. I just thought “ why do that” which made me think it had to be intentional. It was certainly extremely reckless and dangerous. He has had a RC for an almost identical offence as well.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar