'Tomorrow I'll get an apology': Stuart angered by controversial call as Dragons edge out Raiders

By Mike Meehall Wood / Editor

Raiders coach Ricky Stuart was steaming in the big Wollongong wet after St George Illawarra grabbed two crucial points in their quest for the finals, defeating Canberra 12-10 in a controversial match marred by torrential rain.

The game ended controversially with the Raiders screaming for a penalty under the posts that would have allowed an easy two points to send the game to extra time.

Ben Hunt was clearly not square at marker when making a tackle as Canberra looked to shift the ball on the final play of the 80, but ref Peter Gough blew full-time rather than in the Raiders’ favour.

Gough had signalled for a six again – it was difficult to see if it was for the Hunt tackle, or the tackle before – when, obviously, Canberra would have much preferred a regular penalty and a shot at goal.

“I’ve only seen it once,” said Stuart. “I only needed to see it once. Tomorrow I’ll get an apology or justification of maybe it not being a penalty.

“We set ourselves up to win that game. It was a tough grind in the first half, but we let ourselves down in the second half.

“When you’re in the high-performance business, there’s always going to be pressure. And when there’s pressure, you need to have courage. And there needed to be courage on the last play of the day.”

In a game defined by horrendous conditions, this was always likely to be a game of attrition and defence, and it was the Dragons to seemed to cope better in the match marking the Illawarra Steelers’ 40th anniversary.

They banked their points when the breeze blew in their favour and then backed their defence to keep the Raiders at bay. Chasing the game, it was always going to be a tough ask.

Xavier Savage. (Photo by Mark Nolan/Getty Images)

The wind blew from north to south at 65km/h, giving St George Illawarra the chance to build their lead in the first half, and while 12-4 didn’t look like it would be enough, it proved to be sufficient.

“It was a big game, they were right up for it,” said Anthony Griffin. “Even though we had the wind, they had the better of it in the first half. We had to get two points today and got those, so we move on.

“In the first half, at times, we got a few penalties and field position from their errors, but we didn’t respect the conditions as much.

“We were a little bit lateral and didn’t have enough physicality. But, to our credit, in the second half against the wind we played the type of football we need to play.”

“We killed ourselves with errors but through our kicking game and defence we kept them down their end of the field for long periods, which is how we won the game. If they’d have had more good ball they might have got us today.”

The Raiders struggled particularly badly in kicking: they made two crucial errors from short drop-outs when playing into the wind, while in the second, they kicked dead and missed touch from a penalty as the breeze took the ball long away from the sideline.

Cody Ramsey, the St George Illawarra fullback, fared little better was ultimately reprieved by his defence and, with time expiring, the referee.

The Dragons are rarely scintillating in attack, and given the conditions, there were never likely to chance their arm too much early on. Both sides made it to half time with completion rates above 80%, but at the premium of attacking footy.

The three tries that did arrive were the result of errors and bargeovers. The first was farcical: Canberra attempted to take a drop-out short, but it barely broke the plane of the 10m line.

Jack Wighton batted backwards, but directly into the hands of Junior Amone who couldn’t believe his luck.

Lomax missed the conversion, though was given another chance to add two points soon after. The Raiders hasn’t learned their lesson of the previous short drop-out and tried another, with this one not making it the 10-metre line.

It presented an easy chance from the tee: though in keeping with the gale, the ball fell off and the tee blew away as Lomax lined it up. After Andrew McCullough got down on his hand and knees to assist, the ball flew through the posts.

The Raiders had been more than charitable, and it was time for the Dragons to repay the favour. Aaron Woods dropped one in contact and allowed a good ball set, which Canberra did not waste.

Wighton, stung by his gift of a try to Amone earlier, was able to make amends by laying one on for his fullback Xavier Savage, who split winger and centre and slid low to get over the line.

On the brink of the break, Nick Cotric struggled to catch a bomb in the breeze and offered St George Illawarra another chance at the line, which saw Moses Suli crash through a poor attempt from Savage for a 12-4 lead at half-time.

With the switch of ends, so came a switch of momentum. After spending a few sets in the Dragons end, Joseph Tapine broke the line, only to be felled by a high tackle from Ramsey.

The Raiders complained it should have been 10 minutes and were denied, but found themselves celebrating just two tackles later as Hudson Young rattled through a poor defensive effort to get back within two points.

There were errors aplenty: Jordan Rapana offered the Dragons a chance, but they coughed the ball back, before Ramsey spilled a kick himself and gave the Raiders good ball, which Wighton dropped on the first play.

The scoring chances were few and far between and with the clock ticking down, that suited St George Illawarra fine. Both sides were completing south of 70%, but only one side needed to score.

Another Ramsey error presented one final shot, from which the Raiders could not capitalise: though, they would say, they were never given the chance by either the Dragons’ offside defence or the referee.

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-04T15:07:38+00:00

NSWelshman

Roar Rookie


Grow up mate…..my continual anti-Rooster sentiment is childish & boring? How often have I mentioned your team in here? Rarely to be exact! I’m purely stating fact, as many others also do! Mommy & daddy lolol? I think you’re the one with mommy & daddy issues by the sounds of it….oh BTW it’s don’t not doesn’t! Perhaps you should go back to school?

2022-07-04T09:24:43+00:00

Justin

Guest


Very true! Canberra players were complaining about the ball not going 10 metres when Wighton tapped the ball back to Amone, who scored. So they’re saying that they should have been penalised. If I was a referee, I’d have also given Saints the biggest advantage of the ball not going 10 metres, if that was so? That advantage was to allow Amone to score. One thing Amone should have done better there. Bring the ball closer to the posts, which he could have done.

2022-07-04T09:01:48+00:00

blahblah

Guest


In the first half Jack Wighton tapped the ball straight into the arms of Talatau Amone off a drop out. A bit later Wighton dropped the ball on the first tackle off a scrum 15 metres out from the Raiders line. Neither of those actions had anything to do with the referee yet they had a massive impact on the outcome. Give the ref a break. Give me a break. Please.

2022-07-04T06:52:31+00:00

KenW

Roar Rookie


Not particularly, that's strictly for entertainment purposes. :silly:

2022-07-04T06:21:43+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


@Ken W You’re going to be even grumpier if you watch Annesley weekly address.

2022-07-04T06:15:14+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Yes there is. If it is a deliberate act in front of the goal line, it is a professional foul, and then the ref can blow a penalty for a professional foul. Hunt deliberately interfered with the play 5m in front of goal. That is professional foul territory. I think the correct ruling should have been: penalty, and the sinbin.

2022-07-04T05:34:30+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


Sticky would have conveniently forgotten about that. :laughing:

2022-07-04T04:33:25+00:00

Justin

Guest


Yes. That’s the Storm & they’re Special! :laughing:

2022-07-04T04:13:27+00:00

Saints

Guest


Don’t think I would have believed it, if it had been suggested to me at the start of the season. That Saints would be in the 8 & 4 points in front of the Roosters! At around mid season. :laughing:

2022-07-04T03:52:29+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


You are correct. Roosters were certainly the beneficiaries of refereeing decisions last Friday!!! In fact the Bondi boys are probably the most penalised team in the NRL however that “fact” is either lost or ignored by those who imply that the Roosters are continually favoured by match officials & the judiciary. I suppose jealousy can sometimes prevent a process of rational thinking. Any well run, successful sporting team seems to attract a “Tall Poppy” mindset amongst fans who can only wish their team was able to duplicate that success. PS. Is my comment “childish & boring”? What about the repeated references to Salary Cap sombrero, brown paper bag & Uncle Nick? You seem to be very choosy with your criticism. At least you are consistent.

2022-07-04T01:50:43+00:00

KenW

Roar Rookie


Was worried coming into this game as a Dragons fan as the Canberra pack just looks made for this type of football, and the Dragons have been guilty of going to sleep in the middle on and off throughout the year. The Dragons forwards held the balance of power for the majority of the game though - helped a bit by better field position. Tapine is right up there as one of the best props in the game though - just checked and he led both the tackle and run metres for Canberra. Thought Horsburgh was a handful at times too.

2022-07-04T01:31:53+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


He is a perfectly serviceable halfback if you are a rebuilding club and have no genuine aspirations of playing in the Grand Final. But other than that...

2022-07-04T00:20:32+00:00

Paul

Guest


I know Papali’i is a good player. However, couldn’t help wondering about his fitness & conditioning when watching that game yesterday. He looks way overweight . Bob O’Reilly comes to mind. ( That’s being a bit unfair, but anyone go & look him up that doesn’t know who he is .) :stoked:

2022-07-04T00:03:19+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Yep, that's one for the suggestion box. :thumbup:

2022-07-04T00:00:10+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


JA, your responses to people's understandable resentment to preferential treatment is what is childish and boring. You continually imply that they are children and you are the only adult in the room. If you are so mature, take a step back and review the past few years to see what extraordinary bias and benefit your club gets in the game above many others. If you have difficulty with this, I (and many others) can provide you with a sample list to start with.

2022-07-03T23:48:47+00:00

TJ

Guest


I'm glad that ridiculous narrative about Fogarty being such a good player has died down now. No team is ever going to be successful in the NRL when he is your halfback.

2022-07-03T23:48:36+00:00

kk

Roar Pro


Enjoy your reviews, Albo.

2022-07-03T23:38:19+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Yep they just need to give the offending team the option.

2022-07-03T23:36:17+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


But then isn't that a professional foul? It's a pretty obvious loop hole that's been used a few times now. Teams have to get the option to take the points

2022-07-03T23:21:20+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


If you don't want the game to be decided by a 50-50 call by an official in the 80th minute, then play better. I'm old enough to remember when the signing of Jamal Foggarty was seen as a huge deal. I'm also old enough to remember when Elliott Whitehead was a decent footballer and not just whinging to referee's for 80 minutes every week. That is a man frustrated in his own diminishing ability.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar