Why CA needs the BBL Draft to be a success

By The Peoples Dude / Roar Rookie

Cricket fans, sit back and strap yourselves in.Tthe 12th edition of the Big Bash League will soon be hitting our screens and this year Cricket Australia has taken the step of introducing a BBL Player Draft aimed at bringing excitement back to Australia’s domestic Twenty20 competition.

This Sunday the first-ever Player Draft will take place. It was a ploy to attract bigger name players to the domestic competition that had seen viewership wain.

Attract players it did with almost 300 players representing 20 different countries putting their hands up to live the dream and be selected in the draft.

While there is no doubt that the draft will bring interest in to the upcoming 12th season, it remains to be seen whether a player draft will result in more attendees at the game or viewers watching on screens around the country.

The global pandemic we have all been through no doubt played a role in the last few lacklustre seasons, however, it remains no secret that the competition was struggling well and truly before the pandemic. The product had grown stale, the seasons had become too long, and it had become no different.

Compared to the Indian Premier League, where expansion teams have been added as it continued to grow and develop into the premier T20 competition on the globe, new domestic competitions in South Africa and the UAE have all seen the importance of the Australian T20 competition dwindle to stagnant levels.

Some of the country’s biggest players such as David Warner and Chris Lynn sent shockwaves through the Australian sporting landscape when they originally looked at travelling overseas skipping the Big Bash League season for more lucrative contracts elsewhere.

Cricket Australia was implored to step in – which they eventually did – however it is a problem that was completely Cricket Australia’s doing, falling into the same trap many sporting organisations across the country do.

Simply too scared to make changes, to try new things.

David Warner. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

In 2011 Cricket Australia announced that an exciting new competition was being introduced to replace the then stagnant Twenty20 Big Bash – which had featured the six state teams play in a short T20 competition over the past six seasons – with the eight-team Big Bash League.

It was hailed as the dawn of a new era for Twenty20 cricket in Australia, a format while still in its infancy was taking the cricketing world by storm almost more importantly it brought with it a new audience.

Lights, fireworks and music built the atmosphere, ticket prices were affordable and all of a sudden you had families attending games of cricket, soaking up the atmosphere and enjoying the on-field action as some of the biggest names in world cricket travelled down under to see what all the fuss was about, while at the same time giving fans the ability to see some of these players without the international ticket fee costs usually associated with such an experience.

The issue is that was 12 years ago. Nothing has changed. It’s the same tournament, the same teams, just with an additional 30 games to the seasons to seemingly ‘milk’ the product for everything it is worth.

For so long Cricket Australia have shared their reluctance to the idea of the draft despite many sports journalists, cricket insiders and even players themselves calling for something to be added to the game at a local level.

There have been many ideas floated to try and help the game. What about expansion sides so there isn’t the constant talent sitting on the sidelines all season because they are surplus to the clubs’ actual needs? Cricket Australia says no.

Player Draft to try and get some of these international players floating around to other clubs? Cricket Australia says no.

Shorter seasons to bring the actual excitement back to the competition? Cricket Australia says no.

Lower ticket fees that have risen drastically over the past 12 years so that families can go back to affording to go and enjoy the game of cricket? Cricket Australia says no.

Open discussions with New Zealand Cricket and see if there is a way to merge the two domestic competitions into some sort of combined T20 comp, possibly with promotion/relegation, to try and fight the constant growth of the IPL and other international domestic competitions? Cricket Australia says no.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

As the 12th edition of the Big Bash League begins to enter the countdown to the first ball being bowled, with star players originally looking to skip the tournament to follow lucrative options in other competitions across the world, and the reluctancy of Cricket Australia to listen to those they should – the fans – it is no stretch of the imagination to sit back and think that now they have introduced the Player Draft does the future success of the Big Bash League rest on the shoulders of the 300 players, representing 20 countries all vying for just a handful of list spots?

While cricket is a results-driven sport, and the Big Bash League is no different, surely the best result for Cricket Australia is for one of the current clubs to take a ‘gamble’ on one of these more obscure players on the list and them getting a real shot.

Does anyone have all the answers? No. But surely there are discussions to be had, which need to include all options on the table for the Big Bash League moving forward… otherwise it could be a case of ‘unlucky’ 13 for the BBL next year where fans, players and stockholders could finally turn their back on the games shortest format – at a domestic level at least.

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-03T12:57:48+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Well, by definition...no. It's a domestic competition. Playing international opposition could presumably done through some sort of champion's league format.

2022-09-02T11:37:20+00:00

Reddy

Roar Rookie


Isn't it better for Australian bbl sides to take on international opposition rather than obscure grassroots club players. As that is what you would get if you add Geelong, Newcastle, Gold Coast, possibly Canberra etc. The Australian teams would be spread too thin. Personally I would like to see those places added though as well as the NZ teams.

2022-08-31T01:04:20+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


NZ's domestic T20 comp doesn't get the interest of locals, so hard to see CA funding 6 NZ franchises that don't seem popular anyway.

2022-08-30T13:19:33+00:00

Reddy

Roar Rookie


Scrap NZ's t20 domestic comp and add all 6 NZ teams with some overseas players available to join NZ sides. Northern Districts my home team has Seifert, Williamson, Santner, Sodhi, Southee and used to have De Grandhomme and Boult. Wagner plays for Northern Districts as well. If you combine with Auckland then added is Guptill, Phillips, Chapman, Ferguson and Jamieson. Imagine how great a combined side would be in bbl.

2022-08-29T01:29:36+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


That aspect of it doesn’t need to change. That’s the best part of the comp. I want to follow my boys. The only thing that needs to change is staffing at CA. Too many staff so they keep trying to change things so they can add an achievement to their CVs.

AUTHOR

2022-08-29T00:57:34+00:00

The Peoples Dude

Roar Rookie


This… this exactly. At least it’s something different. At least it’s something put on the table. Taking on your lightning round idea (great idea btw) what if they were set up like the NRL Magic Round. All the teams descend and in action over one weekend before moving to the next state/region type of thing. TBH anything different lol!

AUTHOR

2022-08-29T00:54:13+00:00

The Peoples Dude

Roar Rookie


Appreciate your points Don Freo. The retention of the 5 players were if BBL looked at adding additional teams and to bring some interest to the game. Last night (IMO) the Draft was a failure. I, personally don’t see the point with BBL squads being so big with so much decent talent just sitting on the sidelines during the season, teams have their preferred 11/12 that they want to have on the field to win - it’s understandable - but when you have 46 players on the rosters who featured in 2 games or less last season, the fact they have a chance to open up more picks in the draft and hence more talent on the field, and teams will be forced to use draft picks rather than PASSING. Do I think it’s the perfect answer? No! But to just drive the point home of how nothing has changed - WA Warriors in the Big Bash became the Perth Scorchers filled with WA players (and people like yourself wanting those types of players) further proves the point that in both in its previous incarnation and 12 years ago as the new and exciting product… nothing really changed!

2022-08-28T22:56:04+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


I don't like this idea of only retaining 5 of their current squad. What would that add? Supporters want the same squad, not different people. We are parochial. I don't want Cam Green, Mitch Marsh or Ash Agar playing for someone else.

2022-08-28T20:56:24+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


And so a number of the highest profile players, including Faf du Plessis, who was used in this year’s promotional materials, and Andre Russell, were left on the shelf by the BBL franchises. They obviously didn’t see the value for money of them turning up for two weeks. Two left field options, apart from shortening the season which is a no brainer. 1. Allow private ownership. The othe leagues will get the players because there are clubs owned by IPL owners who are directing their star players to go there. The IPL teams are heading towards year round traveling squads 2. Or do a deal with touring international sides, that while they are here for the summer, their players, including squad and A Team, play for BBL franchises. So India tour and everyone from the Indian and Australian squads who is not playing in a clashing international goes to a BBL squad.

2022-08-28T09:18:29+00:00

Anth

Roar Rookie


Yeah the sad fact of the matter is I sat down today and watched a pretty mediocre ODI between Australia and Zimbabwe: Ironically despite being a fairly Ho hum affair, it was still more entertaining than anything the best of anything the BBL has ever served up. (Sigh) another January coming up sans international cricket.

2022-08-28T06:07:27+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


The BBL worked as a short 2-3 lightning tournament. Greed got in the way, and (ironically) the longer it goes the more boring it is. Instead of expanding the season length, they needed to maintain the same season length, and have a 2-3 week lightning tournament, but with new franchises added in places like Canberra, Newcastle, Gold Coast, Geelong etc.

2022-08-28T06:03:30+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


:laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :thumbup:

2022-08-28T05:11:16+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Yeah, I'm ambivalent (uncertain) at this point re the draft. I think "it" works where players are desperate to get into a premier comp and the process is seen as recognising players value - which team is prepared to really put their money down to secure players? ie IPL auction. Not sure BBL is valued as much by o/s players. And BBL's approach is a draft v auction. We'll see how it plays out, but I'm a sceptic ahead of time as to whether tonight's draft will really garner much public interest or whether it really makes much structural/performance difference to the comp. I agree there should be more double headers - and I mean double headers between the same teams on the same day. Retain the content, reduce the length of time of the comp and give fans a second chance to see their team play, especially if they lose the first match. And I'd play those double headers later into the night; school holidays after all. Good bang for buck re attendance.

2022-08-28T05:00:56+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


I agree, nothing changed materially. Hence the bat flip observation; CA - in the face of the juggernaut that is the increasing professionalism of the IPL - went with gimmickry as their best foot forward..

AUTHOR

2022-08-28T04:57:18+00:00

The Peoples Dude

Roar Rookie


Picture - annual BBL Draft - two new teams (for now) added and teams are only able to retain 5 of the BBL12 squad ALL other players go into the draft (new clubs a couple additional draft picks added into the mix to catch up on the five players they are behind). You add to that double headers, family friendly ticket prices again, and a review of the amount of matches played - something to bring the interest back in the competition.

AUTHOR

2022-08-28T04:52:55+00:00

The Peoples Dude

Roar Rookie


You are right - It was more the entire product is the same. Admittingly, it is the same product as the KFC Big Bash just instead of state based teams we have clubs. Bat Flip/ Boost Point/ XFactor Subs - did they add anything to the game. I actually originally liked the idea of the Boost Point as we have seen (in many sports) you can have an off day and be completely blown away on the field - that boost point gave teams at least something to chase. A proper draft, a couple new teams added allowing current teams the ability to only retain 5 of their current squad each season. There are international players etc and even players no one would've thought of before hand who are at least interested in coming to play Domestic T20 in Australia!

2022-08-28T03:40:39+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Agree. This draft is really more akin to a season-by-season o/s player auction, without the bidding. Which makes one wonder what it's purpose is other than to try and secure o/s players from going elsewhere; problem is CA's draft is after the UAE draft. Admittedly CSA is yet to hold an auction or similar, but likely the IPL franchises will simply make their players be available for selection anyway. CA remains on the backfoot here.

2022-08-28T03:32:22+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


"The issue is that was 12 years ago. Nothing has changed." Um, hello? Bat flip?

2022-08-28T03:27:52+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Off topic: Nice tribute to Roy in the ODI innings break. Heartbreaking watching his son wipe away tears. His kids are the spitting image too.

2022-08-28T00:55:41+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


A draft like this means nothing. It's like two captains picking sides in a playground. Drafts work in footy because that player is being selected as part of the framework of the club for the next decade or so, remaining as part of its history. Selecting for guest appearance for a BBL series is not a draft. It's speed-dating. Aussie sport is about clubs, states and long term camaraderie. It's why soccer and basketball remain minor sports. Too many no names popping in to take the places of Aussie names.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar