Representative forward Lindsay Collins could miss the Sydney Roosters’ NRL finals campaign after pleading guilty to the dangerous contact charge incurred for his hip drop tackle on Tom Eisenhuth.
Collins was handed a grade three charge, the worst category possible, for his hit late in the Roosters’ defeat of fellow premiership heavyweights Melbourne on Friday night.
The match was Collins’ first back from a concussion lay-off but he will now miss four more games, meaning the Queensland State of Origin forward will only feature again this season if the Roosters make the grand final.
Collins’ history of prior offences meant his ban was longer than otherwise.
The 26-year-old had been considered a chance to fight his charge in a bid to play again sooner, but would have risked sitting five games out if found guilty at the judiciary.
Collins will miss the last game of the regular season, the Roosters’ elimination final and their two games after that, which could be a semi and a preliminary final.
“You don’t want to take that risk of trying to fight it and miss a grand final,” Roosters captain James Tedesco said.
“It hurts to miss four games but there’s confidence and belief that we can win our next four games and have him back for the grand final.”
Lindsay Collins. (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)
Tedesco said Collins had been left “shattered” by his ban, which was extended due to his prior record.
“It’s disappointing for ‘Linds’,” Tedesco said.
“Since Origin, he’s only played a couple of games with the head knocks and now suspension.
“He’s such a good player for us. He’s a big part of our forward pack going forward.”
If the Roosters are eliminated early, Collins’ suspension will stretch into next season.
The NRL has begun coming down hard on instances of the hip drop tackle, an illegal move where a defender grips onto the ball-carrier and, using their hips, applies dangerous pressure to the rival’s legs.
The tackle can cause serious damage and the Storm have already confirmed Eisenhuth has been left with a season-ending ankle injury.
Collins’ Roosters teammates Victor Radley and Jared Waerea-Hargreaves have entered guilty pleas for their respective dangerous contact and contrary conduct charges but will escape suspension with fines.
Renouf rips into ‘soft’ Broncos
Broncos legend Steve Renouf has taken aim at any Brisbane players who were put out by coach Kevin Walters’ post-game spray by calling them “soft, privileged knobs”.
In the wake of reports that some members of the team were upset about getting a bake from the coach after their 53-6 capitulation at the hands of Parramatta, the former international took to social media to tell them to not be so sensitive.
“Precious soft privileged knobs! Toughen up boys!” he wrote on Twitter.
Brisbane dropped to ninth on percentages after the loss and need to thrash the Dragons or hope Canberra lose to the Wests Tigers in the final round to qualify for the playoffs about being in the top four a month ago.
“The Pearl” was an integral member of Brisbane’s four premierships in the 1990s and he was not the only former player disgusted with the team’s reaction to Walters giving them a well-deserved serve.
Former Broncos captain Gorden Tallis said the coach had a right to unload on the players after such an inspid performance.
“It’s a high-pressure situation where at the moment what do you want them to say?” he said on Triple M.
“Whoever those two who whinged and whoever they whinged to, that boke (Walters) should just write a line through them because if I found out and I’m in that organisation, I don’t want to play with that guy.
“If I got called soft, my response is I’m going to prove him wrong.”
His Triple M stablemate Mark Geyer slammed the “entitlement of young players these days”.
“I agree 100% with what Gordie says. If you get called soft you go and atone, I want to prove you wrong coach. It’s something that mirrors society.”
Geyer said it was “unbelievable” that the Broncos had plummeted to ninth on the back of four losses from their past five outings.
Kelly faces lengthy ban
Gold Coast centre Brian Kelly is set to miss the last NRL game of the year and the first three of next season for up-ending Newcastle’s Dominic Young on Sunday.
Kelly was sent from the field early in the second half but the Titans managed to secure a 36-26 victory, despite playing the final 29 minutes of the game with only 12 men.
Young was not injured but the NRL has nevertheless been tough on one-man dangerous throws this season. Penrith co-captain Nathan Cleary is in the midst of a five-game suspension for a similar tackle while Brent Naden and Karl Lawton each missed four matches earlier in the year.
Kelly has been hit with a grade-three dangerous throw charge, the worst category available, and will miss four games if he takes an early guilty plea.
He risks sitting out for five by taking his case to the judiciary but, given the Titans are out of finals contention, the club appears unlikely to contest the charge.
Gold Coast veteran Isaac Liu can accept a $1000 fine for his crusher tackle on the Knights’ Krystian Mapapalangi and will not miss any game time.
A week after James Tamou was slapped with a grade three contrary conduct charge for referee dissent, St George Illawarra utility Jack Bird has escaped scrutiny for arguing with referee Liam Kennedy against Wests Tigers.
Bird conceded a penalty for tackling fullback Daine Laurie mid-air and then gave the Tigers a ten-metre advantage for talking back to Kennedy.
After he continued to bicker, Bird found himself sin-binned just three minutes after his teammate Cody Ramsey returned from a 10-minute spell of his own. Bird faces no penalty for his outburst.
Tigers centre Asu Kepaoa is likely to miss the last game of his side’s season for a hit on Zac Lomax, which gave the Dragons the chance to kick a penalty goal and win the game on Sunday.
Kepaoa was binned for making contact with Lomax’s head and has been hit with a grade two careless high tackle charge.
He can accept a one-match ban but will miss two games if he unsuccessfully pleads his case.
In the NRLW, Gold Coast second-rower Zara Canfield is poised to miss this weekend’s Queensland derby after receiving a grade two careless high tackle charge.
Late in Sunday’s game, Canfield was sin-binned for her tackle on superstar Newcastle fullback Tamika Upton and risks missing two games by taking her case to the judiciary.
The Titans have dropped their first two games and given the short length of the season, cannot afford to go down to Brisbane this weekend.
Canfield’s Titans teammate Laikha Clarke and Parramatta’s Kennedy Cherrington were both charged with dangerous contact but have escaped with warnings.
Albo’s inside knowledge to benefit Bunnies
The NRL is no guarantee of cutting its COVID-19 isolation period to five days even if the federal government makes changes to home quarantine guidelines this week.
As it stands, those who test positive to COVID-19 in any state or territory must isolate for at least seven days.
But changes to isolation rules are expected to be on the agenda when the prime minister, premiers and chief ministers meet at national cabinet on Wednesday.
In July, NSW premier Dominic Perrottet told 2GB he was keen to review the length of the mandatory isolation period, pointing to the likelihood of future outbreaks in the years to come.
(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)
Changes this week would prove timely for the NRL, given no formal biosecurity bubbles have been announced for the finals series, which begins next weekend.
The Sydney Morning Herald has reported Prime Minister Anthony Albabese has tipped off the Rabbitohs about a potential change.
National cabinet will meet on Wednesday with the isolation period set to be reduced to five days, which could mean Cook suits up against the Roosters.
Both teams are locked on 28 competition points and guaranteed a playoff berth but the winner will finish fifth or sixth and earn hosting rights for the playoff opener.
Canterbury forward Luke Thompson is the only other player currently in COVID-19 isolation but had already been on track to play this weekend.
While the NRL has to date followed government guidelines in developing its own COVID-19 policies, any amendments would need to be approved by league officials ahead of the first round 25 game on Thursday night.
The NRL is set to begin reviewing its COVID-19 guidelines if any changes are announced by the PM following Wednesday’s meeting.
Tim J
Roar Rookie
I totally agree with every point Steve.. :thumbup: Nelson has now been find $12,000 this season with not one suspension! The judiciary system is a joke and needs a review taken place. HIA injuries are simply not being taken seriously, shoulder to head with no contact but with intent should be a YC! Shoulder making contact to the head with intent, needs to be a RC with a significant suspension.
steveng
Roar Rookie
All I was looking at last Friday night was JWH's eyes, he was like mass murder possessed :unhappy: but and at least JWH either gets sin binned or gets suspended for a few weeks as that Nelson gets nothing (especially with that pile driving elbow) and never ever gets nothing, just a fine, he's had 25 offences in his career and never got suspended only a grade 1 fine? Which is very ordinary as Nelson has already done some damage in that Knights game when he knocked a few teeth lose with a dangerous elbow and no sin bin. All this rubbish has to be stamped out of the game as the judiciary are a big joke and irrelevant as they do nothing.
Where are the Clowns
Guest
The native Aussies ? I agree , they wouldn't even know where their kids are most of em.
Big Daddy
Roar Rookie
David, a man of many hats is our PM , he is also devout Hawthorn fan or so he says and wants the AFL to put a team into tassie and he is also going to fix the problem with Mackay Cutters not wanting to play in PNG . I'm sure he'll be the next board member of the NRL commission.
Big Mig
Roar Rookie
Luckily Souths v Roosters is not a do-or-die clash, and it could well be viewed as a dead rubber (with fire). While I am ok with Souths resting for the finals ahead (i hear Cook will be rested), but if the Storm beat the Eels, then Souths and Easts will be playing for 5th spot = a home final v 8th Raiders (most likely). In the first knock out final I'd rather Souths play Raiders at Accor, however the chooks win then we'll play the Eels at CommBank. If Storm win, then we play roosters regardless of our game with them (6 v 7), the only difference is Accor V allianz as a venue. Still prefer Accor for this one.
Big Mig
Roar Rookie
:laughing:
Yawn
Guest
No bronco player complained about the spray. It’s a deflection made up by a media mate. ‘Kevvie’ is untouchable.
Where are the Clowns
Guest
And the sheep will just nod in agreement and go Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa gimme another potentially unsafe and ineffective jab Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
Glory Bound
Roar Rookie
You have to give the Roosters credit for showing some backbone and consistency in resting Victor Radley and prioritising player welfare over 2 competition points. That said the chooks probably realise the game will be a dead rubber if the Storm beat the Eels. Also, if Cook gets to play our little covid-19 superspreader could decimate the whole Roosters team ahead of their sudden death game in week 1 of the finals.
Kay Merda
Roar Rookie
Exactly. Solomona, Kafusi and Munster are WORSE than grubs, they're cowards. Anyone else notice whenever they elbow faces, headslam tackled players or smash people's teeth it's always much smaller/younger men like Sam Walker or Joseph Suaali they single out?They're nothing but cheap-shotting bullies. At least when Jared WH goes after blokes, they're big units, not tiny halves or 18 year old debutants.
Big Mig
Roar Rookie
Friday night expect a lot of cackling from those toothless, small brained, flightless birds of the east. JWH & co will be running around like chooks without a head as souths put 20+ on them. Pity the midget Radley wont be playing, you can be assured he'll implode. :shocked: Souths v Chooks (last 4 encounters) ; Souths 60- Chooks 8 :laughing: Souths 26- Chooks 16; Souths 54- Chooks 12 ; Souths 28- Chooks 16.; Total Souths 168 v Chooks 54.
Tim J
Roar Rookie
Exactly Geoff, too many times players go for the head with no consequence. Where is the supposed protection for the players? More head injuries will continue plus worse if the NRL do not take the situation seriously. Head injuries should be the priority as this can lead to a life long condition.
Nick Maguire
Roar Rookie
GP, Collins should have been suspended for the clash of heads he instigated on his previous return from concussion. Dale Finucane got 3 weeks, but because Collins was the one concussed not a peep. That was just pure luck for Boyle. This bloke clearly has a big problem and the soft talk from Easts about him isn't doing him any favours. Concussion in 2021, concussion in SOO, knocked unconscious and concussed in his return game from his own actions. I have to query the HIA protocols.
Tim J
Roar Rookie
G’day Huddo, coming from a Kiwi you are totally correct. He has a history for both club and Country, he is a great player but his actions let him down.
steveng
Roar Rookie
NO Tony
steveng
Roar Rookie
He's a lose canon anyway, it won't take long for him to get suspended. Never mind, the Bunnies will beat the Roosters irrespective
Big Daddy
Roar Rookie
Or playing basketball with Mr O' Neal .
Hudddo
Roar Rookie
JWH seem to be protected. 3 reports and a yellow in one game, history, and not even a week.
Geoff Parkes
Expert
Not condoning what Collins did, the NRL is right to rub those tackles out of the game, but when you get 4 weeks for potentially injuring an opponents leg, in an isolated incident, and nothing for consistent headhunting with your elbow and forearms, week after week... something is definitely not right.
Andrew01
Roar Rookie
From staying in the competition when they didn't meet the criteria, to managing their cap through medically forced retirements.. that weren't medically forced, to not even being remotely close to being located in South Sydney. There is no loop hole Souths can't navigate...