And then there were six: Who wins the flag from here?

By 13th Man / Roar Rookie

So, then there were six.

After a dramatic first weekend of finals we now have seen the back of Richmond and the Bulldogs and have a clearer view of just where everyone sits. Here’s the sides most likely to least likely to raise the premiership cup after the first week of finals.

1. Sydney

Clearly the most impressive team out of this weekend. Put in a commanding performance against the Dees and booked themselves a home preliminary final against either Freo or Collingwood. It’s very hard to see them getting beaten at the SCG and a grand final spot is probably theirs to lose.

From there they have the wood over both Geelong and Melbourne in recent times and that makes them the clear favourites to win the premiership. Look well balanced across the board and John Longmire has them flying at the business end of the season.

2. Geelong

Secured a home preliminary final by winning in week one of finals, which has often been where the Cats have come unstuck in recent years, but I still have doubts over their credentials in big finals. It could’ve very easily come unstuck for them against a spirited Collingwood side, and for a team that were so commanding in the home-and-away season, the same big-game frailties showed.

They had enough skill and character to get across the line, but will face the winner of Melbourne and Brisbane in two weeks’ time, and Melbourne in particular could cause them serious problems. A potential grand final against Sydney would also likely see them start outsiders, as the Swans have a brilliant record against the Cats.

Still, they are on track, and have the talent to win it all, it just remains to be seen whether they can conquer the mental demons of prelim final weekend.

Gary Rohan of the Cats celebrates a goal. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

3. Melbourne

A major dent to their chances of going back to back was dealt by the Swans on Friday night, but I’m not completely off the Demons bandwagon just yet. They were well beaten by the Swans, but face a Lions side that they have absolutely dominated in recent times. You’d expect them to bounce back strongly, and will certainly not give Lachie Neale the freedom that the Tigers gave him.

If they get past the Lions, as expected, they’ll fancy their chances against a Geelong side that they absolutely belted in the corresponding fixture last year. It’s a different path from last season, but they won’t need to leave Melbourne at all during the finals and it’s all very doable.

A potential rematch with Sydney in the grand final looms large, and they would back themselves to turn it around. Concerns over Christian Petracca’s leg injury, though, is a major worry.

4. Collingwood

Lost no admirers in their spirited loss to Geelong, and could’ve quite easily found themselves in a home preliminary final had things gone their way in the final moments, like they have done so many times before this year. They were always due to lose a close one at some point, and it just so happened to be in a final.

They do, however, thanks to Carlton, have the double chance and find themselves in a crunch semi-final against Freo. This is a genuine 50-50 game between two sides that were split by very little in the regular season.

The Pies got the better of Freo in a wet and soggy game earlier on in the year, and with the long range forecast suggesting rain next weekend, the Pies will certainly welcome it. If they get past Freo, however, it’s really difficult to see them beating Sydney, who comfortably accounted for them a couple of weeks ago up at the SCG.

The loss of Taylor Adams, however, looms large as a potential fork in the road for the Pies’ progression.

5. Fremantle

Flagmantle is still alive! It was on life support early on in the second quarter against the Bulldogs but the Dockers showed serious spirit to turn a 41-point deficit into a 13-point win in front of a delirious home crowd at Optus Stadium.

They go into a semi-final against Collingwood with a very real chance of progressing, considering their form on the road, particularly in Melbourne, has been nothing short of outstanding and they’ll take huge confidence out of that.

What they cannot afford to do is give the Pies a head start like they did against the Bulldogs and GWS a couple of weeks prior, they won’t be given the same generosity from a hardened Pies side. I can, however, see them winning this one, particularly if the wet weather stays away.

What’s harder to see is them getting past the next hurdle, Sydney at the SCG, a ground that they barely ever win at.

6. Brisbane

Won a dramatic shootout against the Tigers, and Chris Fagan finally got that win in a final that involved elimination.

Joe Daniher of the Lions celebrates the winning goal against Richmond. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

They now turn their attention towards a team that has absolutely dominated them in recent times. Just two weeks ago they got belted by 58 points at the hands of the Dees, and earlier on this season it was 64 points. That form line gives them very little hope this weekend against Melbourne.

If they can turn the tables on the Demons they then would face Geelong in a prelim, a team that they have had some tight battles with over the last few seasons, but would also start as heavy underdogs in that game.

It’s fair to say that the Lions are far and away the biggest outsider for the flag from here, but perhaps less expectation of success may be healthy in propelling the Lions further into the finals than anyone expects. Most people didn’t even give them much of a chance of beating Richmond, and yet here they are!

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-14T05:53:33+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Geez, you reckon you can be the 2022 version of the 2016 WB? Long way to go yet!

AUTHOR

2022-09-14T05:50:36+00:00

13th Man

Roar Rookie


Hahaha no it absolutely did not :laughing: :laughing: In fact my entire Brisbane segment aged very poorly... Oh well that's what you get for putting an opinion out there.

2022-09-14T03:35:22+00:00

Jorge of Brisvegas

Roar Rookie


This did NOT age well

2022-09-14T03:30:26+00:00

Jorge of Brisvegas

Roar Rookie


This ‘prediction piece’ got old real quick ! Wouldn’t it be a hoot with the Lions being chosen as least likely 4 weeks in a row and having a Craic at “the big dance”? I was one of the many members and fans that based on results and performance had lost faith. But I now have faith. Not that we will win but that we CAN win. And it may be more unlikely but as they say in poker ‘ a chip and a chair” . Brisbane’s catch cry is ALL IN - some nice symbiosis there. CARN LIONS

2022-09-08T17:28:51+00:00

Glenn

Guest


Good grief, insular NSW-based Swans supporters that clearly don't pay attention. I don't know where you get your info, but the Melbourne media gives the Swans exactly what they should get. Did you not see Gary Lyon gushing about the Swans after they had made a mess of his beloved Dees last week? Maybe you turned off as soon as the song had been sung to actually avoid listening to the Melbourne media? Vic-based Swans fans don't complain about the media coverage of the Swans by Melbourne media because it is adequate. Is it maybe because the Swans get very little coverage in Sydney that you expect the Melbourne media to pick up the slack? I am genuinely curious. There are a lot of us down here and we don't feel hard done by.

2022-09-06T18:40:13+00:00

M. Rockatansky

Guest


And then comes the serenity

2022-09-06T09:54:31+00:00

berrlins

Roar Pro


Nice write up dude and congrats again on the Dockers win. Hard to go past Melbourne against the Lions, they just know how to belt them and then it's a 50/50 against Geelong. Freo could give the Pies a run for their money as long as they don't get stunned like they did against the Dogs, but I don't think it'll matter. Sydney are far too strong for both and will be quality grand finalists.

AUTHOR

2022-09-06T04:33:24+00:00

13th Man

Roar Rookie


West Coast and North are in a different category altogether which is 'basket case'. I can't speak for Port Adelaide fans but I don't think they were great this year.

2022-09-06T02:57:19+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


The mighty Pav has called it for Freo this weekend. Surely he couldn't be wrong :)

2022-09-06T02:55:48+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Well truthfully, most Victorian teams rarely travel interstate.

2022-09-06T02:55:12+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Lost the first 5 games, after that the ledger was more palatable. Did ok in my book but not the total train wreck of North and West Coast.

2022-09-06T02:52:00+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


It's the "Vibe" of the thing When we get the trophy, it will go straight to the poolroom

2022-09-06T01:17:28+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Especially that Subway ad that pops up over the comments section while we are typing a comment. ( It has popped up 3 4 times as I made this comment).

2022-09-06T00:58:52+00:00

Charlie

Roar Rookie


Yep, it's getting ridiculous.

2022-09-06T00:36:09+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Dam that would make you wonder wouldn't it, imagine your forward line with Cameron running around, thats a scary thought for opposition teams.lol.

2022-09-06T00:29:34+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Only eastern states commentators. That's because Brayshaw and Serong are the only Freo players they know. You only have to listen to Freo players speak about Fyfey's influence to know they will re-elect him as captain next year. This idea that he needs to be relieved of captaincy duties to heal from a hamstring strain is ridiculous.

2022-09-05T23:59:17+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Are you guys all getting an advertisement between each post? This is getting unreadable.

2022-09-05T23:59:07+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


My point stands undented. West Coast, North and Adelaide may resemble your description.

2022-09-05T23:57:19+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Chapman or Young kicking in would be under the same instructions as Ryan. When you have Darcy or Lobb, Cox and Pearce up there bringing the ball to ground, Serong, Brodie and Brayshaw get it out to Young, Chapman, Clark or Walker running past. We want their kicking to send it forward. That spill happens more often than not. Even if it becomes a neutral ball up, as it usually does, we get the advantage of Darcy's ruckwork. It looks ugly but it works heavily in Freo's favour

AUTHOR

2022-09-05T23:54:02+00:00

13th Man

Roar Rookie


I don't think there is anything wrong with Pearce's captaincy, he has been great. Think a lot of people see Brayshaw and Serong as the long term successors. No issues if Pearce continues next season at all.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar