REACTION: 'Disgraceful!': Wallabies stunned as ref 'cracks under pressure,' hands Bledisloe Cup to All Blacks

By Tony Harper / Editor

What on earth was that? The Bledisloe is blown for a 20th season and a French referee is set to become the most hated man in Australia after presenting the All Blacks an 81st minute win over a brave Wallabies at a heaving Marvel Stadium.

The Wallabies were leading 37-34 with 90 seconds left and on a penalty when Mathieu Raynal pulled up Bernard Foley for time wasting in front of his own sticks.

The All Blacks were awarded a scrum and after the siren Jordie Barrett ploughed over out wide on the final play .

The Aussies had come from 31-13 down after 56 minutes to edge ahead when Nic White pounded over a 48 metre penalty. The Australians were distraught at the finish as Raynal was booed from the field by many in the crowd of 53,245.

What the actual… The Roar Rugby experts Brett McKay, Harry Jones and Jim Tucker try to make sense of a chaotic match in the Instant Reaction podcast

Australia had heroes everywhere and it was harsh on them to have to watch the All Blacks hoist the trophy yet again. Foley nailed six from six including a couple from out wide, and he didn’t deserve the nature of the finish.

Pete Samu put in a momentous effort as a starter, and Andrew Kellaway was supreme at fullback, scoring two tries and being denied a third by millimetres.

“Absolutely gutted. I don’t know what to say,” said Wallabies captain James Slipper. “We wanted to put in performance tonight and we just fell short there. Probably the most gutting way to finish a game.

“When you play the All Blacks you have to make everything count and take your opportunities. Everything in the last 20 minutes was in our hands. We blew it.

“We have got to back it up next week and go to Auckland and we will go through the review process but it will take a while to get over this.”

Foley attempted to explain the decision that left commentators and fans scratching their heads and then struggling to cope with its magnitude.

“We were just understanding the line out call,” said Foley. “The ref said time off and he sped it up. It’s disappointing how good a game it was and yet we’re talking about the referee.

“I’ve been hurt a couple of times at the death by these blokes. They’re a good side and play the 80 minutes. It’s just disappointing we’re talking about a referee call after a great 80 minutes.”

Coach Dave Rennie said: “What we knew is time was out and he told the boys to play but the clock’s stopped so there’s no real urgency. It lacks a bit of feel for such an important moment in the game.

“It’s a tough one to take.”

Wallaby legend Tim Horan was fuming on Stan Sport.

“I’ve been commentating for over 20 years, I thought it was a disgraceful decision by the referee and I thought he cracked under pressure,” Horan said.

“I reckon you could have another 15 referees, big referees for World Rugby, that would have taken that calmly and wouldn’t have got overawed by the experience. 90 seconds left in the game, and he cracked under pressure in one of the biggest moments, one the biggest games here in Australia, it was a disgraceful decision and World Rugby need to look at it.”

But New Zealand coach Ian Foster said he felt the call was “clear cut.”

Slipper and flanker Rob Leota to calf injuries and endured three yellow cards. New Zealand had issues of their own losing Sam Cane and David Havili to head knocks.

Marika Koroibete  (Photo by Morgan Hancock/Getty Images)

The Wallabies showed their intent before the kick off when their ‘boomerang’ advanced on the All Blacks in face of the haka. The faces of props Slipper and Allan Alaaalatoa showed fierce passion, but a team that has struggled to get started early in games suffered yet another early blow when the game kicked off.

With heavy smoke hanging under the closed roof – what genius ordered that many fireworks in a closed venue? – Jed Holloway mucked up his catch from the Kiwis’ kickoff and Len Ikitau was forced to run the ball out.

The All Blacks received their first in a deluge of early penalties from Raynal and opted to go for the line again after Ethan De Groot was held up.

On three minutes after a relentless rolling maul, boosted by the presence of David Havili and Will Jordan, Samisoni Taukei’aho went over for the opening try.

Richie Mo’unga kicked the conversion and shortly after hoisted a high contestable kick that Bernard Foley, in his first Test for three years, failed to gather it in.

Slipper conceded two quick scrum penalties, pushing him six ahead of the next most penalised player in the competition, and after 11 minutes the All Blacks were up 10-0.

But the Australians fought back with real aggression and desire.

Pete Samu, who had a huge first half, made a break and fed Tom Wright but the All Blacks covered well to stop Marika Koroibete crossing. A penalty advantage gave Foley the first points from in front 16 and on 21 minutes the Wallabies thought they’d scored a special try through Andrew Kellaway.

Holloway produced a cute flick pass at the back of a maul and the ball eventually found Kellaway on the right. He dived for the line late and thought he’d scored but Rieko Ioane’s desperation tackle pushed Kellaway’s hand under the ball and the try was ruled out after TMO review.

The Aussies kept coming and on 27 minutes took a penalty to the sideline and were rewarded for their bravery, with their maul storming the NZ barricades and Rob Valetini driving over the line.

Sam Cane was off injured and his replacement Dalton Papali’I was sin binned moments after coming on.

Samu made another storming break, and then Koroibete smashed through Clarke in a tackle.

“This is where the All Blacks have been struggling, with their backs against the wall,” said Sonny Bill Williams in commentary. And biy did they prove him wrong.

Australia pounded at the door through 15 phases, coming agonisingly close several times before Holloway was isolated and concded a penalty.

It was an incredible defensive effort, a man down, and swung the game the visitors’ way.

From the lineout that followed the penalty, Hoskins Sotutu showed deft hands and sent an inside ball to a raging Clarke, who went on a crazy jagged 60 metre run deep into the heart of Australian territory.

Wright was sin binned in bringing him down and Darcy Swain followed soon after for an ugly tackle that forced Quinn Tupaea from the field with a knee injury.

With a two man advantage the All Blacks went to work but lost the ball over the line through Taukei’aho then butcered an overlap when Rieko Ioane threw the ball behind Beauden Barrett.

Australia reached halftime all level, but the All Blacks were over within a minute of the restart, Taukei’aho making up for his sloppiness before the break with a surging run to the line.

Foley narrowed the margin with a penalty but then Mo’unga added a try. Jake Gordon became the third Australian off to the sin bin and with him out of the action, Beauden Barrett played a delicious chip over the Australian defensive line. Will Jordan gathered the kick and with an impudent step away from Kellaway gave him a clear run to the line.

“You could talk about that try all night, right back with the communication to Beauden Barrett and the little chip kick over. The timing and execution was exquisite,” said Mehrtens.

Australia were drowning but grabbed a lifeline through Kellaway as a flat pass from Foley sent him over to make it 31-20 with 17 to play.

Then the Melbourne Rebels star added another five minutes later – his fifth in four games against the All Blacks.

“People in the stands were thinking about going to grab their car early, they have sat back down,” said Tim Horan on the Stan commentary.

Nic White smashed over his penalty and the Aussies thought they had pulled off one of the sport’s greatest ever comebacks.

But then Raynal stunned everyone.

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-17T20:05:23+00:00

Just saying

Guest


Karma baby! Don't blame Foley. Blame Nic White who has cursed the Wallabies forever.

2022-09-17T11:14:19+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


I would start a Joey with Quade on bench or in the garage. Foley as a back up to both.

2022-09-17T11:04:44+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Actually, I think it's the Aussie media & Aussie Wallaby fans who have cracked under the pressure. Of always losing.....

2022-09-17T10:01:32+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Foley was intending to dropkick through the posts?

2022-09-17T04:20:36+00:00

Virgil

Roar Rookie


Who would you start?

2022-09-16T23:30:46+00:00

humesy

Roar Rookie


so you kick, with no chase with a 3 point lead and 1 minute to go because the ball just goes out automatically while you talk about other things.

2022-09-16T23:16:32+00:00

humesy

Roar Rookie


Going by that logic, Swain's clean out was not so bad. Just yellow card worthy. All the officials said so after seeing the replays.

2022-09-16T22:27:11+00:00

Malotru

Roar Rookie


I believe you Freddo, my mother's side of the family was from the Lot e Garrone region, a little place called Casteljaloux. I lived there as a child for around 3 years.

2022-09-16T12:36:38+00:00

Just call me Campo

Roar Rookie


when are you going home?

2022-09-16T10:42:48+00:00

elvis

Roar Rookie


Yes, as a rusted on Rugby fan for almost 50 years I've never watched an adult match. eye roll. Sigh, watching the Nudgee firsts go round doesn't preclude me watching or having watched or played other Rugby.

2022-09-16T07:52:34+00:00

Freddo

Roar Rookie


Nah, more into volleyball & badminton. The occasional checkers. How bout you, what part of France are you from?

2022-09-16T07:09:19+00:00

adam smith

Roar Rookie


And what exactly are the players supposed to do?! SMH…

2022-09-16T07:07:43+00:00

adam smith

Roar Rookie


@humsey, I noticed a brief moment in the broadcast where the camera was panning around all the players after the game. Sam Whitelock is shaking hands with James Slipper, with Sam saying to James, “Sorry mate!” Not sure of the context of the conversation, but I believe it aligns with your statement & is what Sam is referring too.

2022-09-16T06:11:25+00:00

Mickelondo

Roar Rookie


Foley had been warned twice already about time wasting! Justified call from referee!

2022-09-16T06:00:24+00:00

jammel

Roar Rookie


Australian rugby is in trouble, let's face it. - need free to air super rugby for all the kids. - global rugby referreeing is ordinary. Over-officiated sport never works. - the rules make the game hard to justify/sell to newbies. Player protection is important - but physicality has to remain. Some of the send offs and binnings over the past 3 years or so make this a hard game to watch. - too much pick and stick with the Sydney Tah elite - Hooper Foley Phipps back in the day and Hanigan lol. We need more Brumbies imho!! and Reds too. Foley is not for 2022 - he wasn't even for 2015 IMHO. - one other commenter asked where's Pete Samu been?!?!? Good comment. The answer is - languishing behind Hoops! - can't rub players/talent like Israel F out of the game! Embrace the quality players when you have them. - taking NRL players crosscode is never the answer. - more focus from the Wallabies needs to be on the set piece - and less on response to the haka/learning verses to the national anthem/being a role model/social media/etc. - need a real rugby philosophy too! I'd personally like to see a more conservative game based on strong set pieces, work ethic, strategic kicking for field position, and fewer turnovers. Don't give the ball away unnecessarily! Master that - and then run some more i say. These and some other factors make it hard for people to love the game IMHO. More and more my friends are deserting the sport to NRL and sometimes EPL. I used to adore the Wallabies - thinking back to 91 and 99. Last night's fixture barely made my diary...and the loss barely registered. People will disagree with me I am sure - but a lot of people I know say the above points and I do think they need to be addressed. Rugby is just losing its audience day in day out, it's a shame.

2022-09-16T05:48:52+00:00

jammel

Roar Rookie


I'm with Elvis and Tom G!

2022-09-16T05:33:12+00:00

humesy

Roar Rookie


Forwards were in a huddle not paying attention. He was ready to go but turned back twice to see if the forwards were ready. They weren't and the rest is history. BS decision though.

2022-09-16T05:30:31+00:00

One Eye

Roar Rookie


No, it didn't - at least according to the people who matter in making the judgement which is the ref and TMO who both agreed on penalty only. But if you think they're wrong and you're right then dust off the shorts and boots and get yourself a whistle and show us all how it's done...

2022-09-16T04:47:30+00:00

Peter the Hermit

Roar Rookie


I agree. And if their defence was good enough, they would have staved off the ABs final thrust of the game.

2022-09-16T04:45:55+00:00

Peter the Hermit

Roar Rookie


On the contrary. All Blacks are renowned for trying to speed the game up.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar