Cummins under fire for opposition to Alinta Energy deal as Diamonds strike truce over Hancock dispute

By The Roar / Editor

Pat Cummins has confirmed he will not appear in any advertisements for Cricket Australia sponsor Alinta Energy this season, despite authorities insisting his stance on climate change did not prompt the company to cut ties with the sport.

Cummins fronted a press conference in Brisbane on Tuesday regarding his new appointment as ODI skipper, but the focus quickly moved to his reported objections to the soon-to-end sponsorship arrangement with Cricket Australia.

He has already copped plenty of criticism for his views because he has previously appeared in advertisements for Alinta Energy and for driving a “polluting SUV”.

It comes as Netball Australia is fighting a battle with its players over the Diamonds’ objections to wearing a uniform promoting mining giant Hancock Prospecting. 

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch cricket on KAYO

Netball Australia will not be turning its back on its multimillion-dollar sponsorship deal despite opposition from the national squad after Indigenous squad member Donnell Wallam raised her concerns.

(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

The cash-strapped organisation on Tuesday issued a statement reinforcing its support for the partnership, saying the four-year deal with billionaire Gina Rinehart’s company, worth $15 million, underpins the Diamonds program.

Alinta Energy signed a four-year deal to become CA’s principal sponsor in 2018 and subsequently extended the partnership through to June 2023.

With less than a year to run on the contract, Nine Newspapers reported Cummins had expressed concerns to Cricket Australia CEO Nick Hockley about partnering with non-sustainable brands.

According to the Clean Energy Regulator, Alinta Energy’s parent company Pioneer Sail Holdings was responsible for producing 10.7 million tonnes of greenhouse gases in the 2020-21 financial year.

Cummins has long made clear his strong stance on action against climate change, as well as how cricket can better manage its carbon footprint.

The Test captain has previously been in television advertisements for Alinta Energy, but was asked whether it was correct he would not be appearing in them this coming season.

“Yes, 100 per cent,” Cummins said.

While Cummins told reporters he had not put pressure on CA to end the deal, he said players have a role in deciding which organisations they want to be associated with.

“It has always been a balance,” he said. “We have seen certain players make decisions based on religions, or certain foods they eat, where they won’t partner with specific partners.

“Every organisation has a responsibility to do what’s right for the sport and what they think is right for the organisation, and I hope society when it moves forward. 

(Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

“It is a balance when you make decisions about who you are going to welcome into the cricket family.”

Cummins reiterated on several occasions the Australian players had supported CA’s partners and appreciated what they had done for the game.

Hours after Cummins fronted the press, CA said in a statement a “change in brand strategy” – not the skipper’s comments – had prompted the WA-based energy supplier to step away.

The release also noted Alinta’s leadership in transitioning to net-zero emissions through a range of initiatives.

The situation comes days after Saudi Arabian state-owned oil company Aramco was announced as the sponsor of ICC T20 World Cup’s player-of-the-match awards.

Cummins said he had not been consulted on that partnership.

“They are a tournament sponsor. That is obviously far away from the decisions us players make,” he said.

The issue of sporting organisations and who they choose to align with is a topic that is moving front and centre in discussions surrounding sport.

The Australian netball team, which won Commonwealth Games gold this year and will compete in the World Cup in South Africa in 2023, met with Hancock representatives on Tuesday morning.

Diamonds skipper Liz Watson said the playing group supported the sponsorship deal, which was a lifeline after Netball Australia suffered losses of more than $7 million over two COVID-impacted years.

Watson said all parties “wanted to make it work”.

Liz Watson. (Photo by Kieran Galvin/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

“As players we do know that Hancock is such a great investment for our program,” Watson said on Tuesday ahead of the team’s third Test in the Constellation Cup series against New Zealand in Melbourne.

“We are supportive of Hancock and all the players here are as well.”

Wallam is not part of the Constellation Cup playing group and will join the squad for the series against England which starts later this month.

When she makes her debut, the West Australian goal shooter, who plays for the Queensland Firebirds, will become the first Indigenous Test player in more than 20 years.

When the sponsorship was announced, Wallam raised concerns over Hancock Prospecting’s record on Indigenous matters, which date back 40 years to extreme right-wing comments made by Rinehart’s late father Lang Hancock.

Watson said the players wanted to stand by Wallam, who is reluctant to wear the sponsor’s logo.

“She’s part of this program, she knows where we stand, and we’re supporting Donnell with everything that’s going on. I’m confident that we will get a solution on this,” Watson said.

“We’re supporting her cultural sensitivities around the program, around the partnership, and we want her to be herself and feel comfortable and strong. I know that the girls are supportive of that.”

NA said on Tuesday it had been decided it was not in the “best interests” of the players to wear the branded uniform as it could prove a distraction, and this was supported by the sponsor.

Incoming NA chair Wendy Archer, who replaced Marina Go on Monday, said it was a priority to address and resolve player concerns about the partnership as soon as possible.

“Netball Australia has continually attempted to understand, support and work on a long-term solution to this matter which at this time remains unresolved,” Archer said in a statement.

Playing their first home Tests in front of fans since 2019, the Diamonds need two strong wins in sold-out matches Melbourne on Wednesday night and the Gold Coast on Sunday to claim back the trophy.

Watson said she did not believe the sponsorship saga had contributed to the team’s opening losses to the Silver Ferns in New Zealand.

“I don’t think so – we haven’t performed how we wanted to and New Zealand have been great,” she said.

“It’s on us how we’re playing. It’s not got to do with outside noise and New Zealand are playing really well at the moment.”

The Crowd Says:

2023-02-15T02:07:16+00:00

Baggygreen2.1

Roar Rookie


yeah I respect zamps much more than cummins. you have to walk the talk! Doesn't Cummins drive a Range Rover 4WD that was ranked by the America Council for Energy-Efficency Economy vehicles as one of the 12 "meanest" cars for the environment?! should get a tesla

2022-10-30T04:19:30+00:00

Rossi

Roar Rookie


If you truly believed the world will end because of the minor amounts of carbon dioxide humans emit compared to volcanoes etc. you'd be cave-manning it for sure I would've thought

2022-10-28T14:35:47+00:00

Rossi

Roar Rookie


If I believed the sky was falling like these global warmy zealots do I would be living a very simple life, but thankfully I don't fall for it and use electricity guilt free, though the green power is driving up the costs big time

2022-10-28T14:33:44+00:00

Rossi

Roar Rookie


He banged on about facts etc. but went quiet once you asked him for some, typical of the smug left

2022-10-28T14:31:04+00:00

Rossi

Roar Rookie


She doesn't need to. If she does then these lefties will just make more demands- don't feed the trolls! The $300m she has spent on indigenous affairs is more important than apologising for something her dead father said 40 years ago.

2022-10-25T01:28:50+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


"It’s refreshing to have a cricket captain with a strong moral compass." I think it would be more refreshing to have a cricket captain who can bat and bowl well ! Seems the current one is somewhat distracted ? :crying:

2022-10-24T22:40:10+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


What’s that got to do with anything? If I advocated killing your family but slipped you some dollars is that okay? Try and put yourself in her shoes here.

2022-10-24T09:54:17+00:00

Marty

Roar Rookie


Wow, that’s a pretty big assumption. I do own a 4wd actually. I live in the Kimberley so it’s the best way to get out and enjoy what is a beautiful, but pretty rugged, part of the world. In between camping/fishing trips it mostly sits in the garage (because who needs to drive a diesel 4wd around town right?) and we get around in the hybrid we bought last year. It cost more than the petrol model but in the long run we save on fuel and we’re doing our bit for the environment. You’re welcome :thumbup:

2022-10-24T07:10:25+00:00

No9

Roar Rookie


Netball Australia have already made that choice .They said yes to the money and continue to do so . Their legal obligation is to act for the good of the sport not to be moral or ethical judges . Of course they can consider those concerns but it is not their first obligation under their constituion .

2022-10-24T07:01:11+00:00

No9

Roar Rookie


She has the option of walking away. She has free will. She has a choice in that she takes HP money as part of her playing or she decides not to do that . Her choice . The Board must act for the good of the sport . Not pander to individuals who , if my undestanding is correct , has yet to play a game .

2022-10-24T06:53:35+00:00

No9

Roar Rookie


Is she being paid ? I assume some of that comes from HP sponsorship .

2022-10-24T06:51:09+00:00

No9

Roar Rookie


You are right on one point .Plenty of people don't agree . Netball lost $15 million and half Australia . I shouldn't like cricket to end up the same because someone wants to make a political point .

2022-10-24T06:46:45+00:00

No9

Roar Rookie


I know why but apparently you don't . He's a player . He's not on the Board . He's not the CEO either . Players play . The Board administers . Separation of powers .

2022-10-22T22:39:19+00:00

Ball Burster

Roar Rookie


XI: the problem with young Pat's stance is that Alinta is gas and gas is key to the transition to net zero. I wonder how he feels about CA's other sponsors: Bet365, Commonwealth Bank (money laundering), KFC (unhealthy), Qantas (aviation fuel emissions), and Toyota (gas guzzlers)?

2022-10-22T22:12:51+00:00

Ball Burster

Roar Rookie


You need to change your GP Pedro.

2022-10-21T21:16:41+00:00

jammel

Roar Rookie


PeterC - now is a good time if Cummins wants to be an activist. If he wants to be a top cricketer then leave it to when there’s not a World Cup on. Or the ashes eg. Cummins should realise this is a distraction for him and more importantly the team. We’ve all watched the sports docos about focus/concentration/power of the mind etc. I think PattyC will lose more respect from many cricket fans if this continues….

2022-10-21T09:36:10+00:00

PeterCtheThird

Guest


So when would you say is the right time? Probably never, is my guess. I think if Cummins really wants what he said to be noticed, then a World Cup is EXACTLY the right time.

2022-10-20T13:02:25+00:00

liquorbox_

Roar Rookie


Was it a company policy? If so, yes she should comment, if it was his personal opinion then it does not require an apology. The issue with apologies is that people who accept them have already forgiven you, and those who don't accept them never will. Apologies are a waste of time, and this is a prime example, no matter what Gina says or does she will be critisised

2022-10-20T11:40:01+00:00

Notting Pill

Guest


And living ia a first world counrty, where even the "Greener" of us are only that in name only, I bet your're really not doing much either, no mater how much you convince yourself you are or regardless of whatever token enviromental gestures you may perform. So while you doubt that others are aren't doing much to combat climate change, I guarantee that you absolutly aren't. You just expect others, who can't afford high energy prices (was just annouced an expected 30% increase in prices due to the move to renewables) just to suck it up so to make youself feel less guilty. But hey, as least you feel good about yourself.

2022-10-20T05:29:43+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


I don't resent his action or beliefs. And I support a move away from fossils and indeed more sustainable use of resources - I run a sewerage recycling business so his stated position definately aligns with my beliefs and what I do re societal contribution to advancing a more sustainable approach. But I have a problem when people say one thing which aligns with current progressive thinking, but don't really back it up through personal actions. As an authority figure within CA, if making a public statement on a high profile issue, but then doing the antithesis in your personal life of what your statement is a about, I find frustrating. I don't expect Cummins to live The Good Life and use his own waste to fertilise his own domestic food bowl in his backyard, but driving a diesel V8 Range Rover and constantly flying business class, is a bit off when juxtaposed against his statement re his organisation's current sponsor. On a personal action level, he's right at the opposite end of what he is putting forward publicly. That is what I find annoying.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar