FLEM’S VERDICT: Aussie bats will be too strong for fired-up Proteas pacemen but watch out for Rabada

By Bowlologist / Expert

This South African bowling attack has the firepower to rattle the local batters but I can’t see Aussies losing a Test because of the advantages they have when it comes to scoring runs.

South Africa have an imposing bowling line-up that has the ability to get 20 wickets in all three matches but that’s mixed in with can they score enough runs against the Australian attack?

And the answer to that is I don’t think so. There’s no genuine star batter in this team. Their captain, Dean Elgar, has got a vast career and hundreds against Australia. He’s just a classical opener, a nudger of the ball. 

Temba Bavuma we’ve seen out here before but after 87 Test innings and only one hundred, he doesn’t pose as much of a threat as some of the star batters they’ve brought out here in the past like Jacques Kallis, Graeme Smith, AB de Villiers and Faf du Plessis. 

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch cricket on KAYO

He’s got a tight technique, hasn’t got a bad cover drive but like Elgar, he’s not going to tear an opposition bowling attack apart. 

(Photo by Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

Rabada’s wicket-taking ability is their main hope, he’s arguably the best fast bowler in the world. To have 257 wickets in 55 matches at 22.46 is nuts. It underlines his class and he’s taken over from Dale Steyn as their pace spearhead in the past few years. 

He’s also got Steyn’s elite ability to break through regularly. His strike rate is one of the best of all time at 40.2 and I really rate that. The aim of the game is to get 20 wickets every Test so to have someone who not only strikes regularly but doesn’t go for many runs either is a real luxury for the Proteas.

Rabada’s got everything – aggression, he attacks the batter, his line and lengthy deliveries challenge both the outside and inside edges, he can bowl genuine outswingers. I put him up there with Pat Cummins on the top shelf of the best quicks on the planet. 

He’s already fast but his effort ball is lightning quick. His yorker is a cracker, he got Usman Khawaja last time they were out here in Perth with a beauty, and his bouncer puts batters on the back foot when he needs to. 

And he’s a fine reverse-swing bowler as well and that could come into play in the third Test at the SCG. It’s a very dry centre wicket square there at the moment, spinners have been getting wickets in Shield cricket so that could suit Rabada to a tee.

Dean Elgar. (Photo by Albert Perez/Getty Images)

Lungi Ngidi will share the new ball with him and he’s not quite as quick as Rabada but he has a better release that can produce a late outswinger. He’ll relish playing in the Australian conditions with a bit of pace and bounce in the wickets as well. 

He’s only 15 Tests into his career but has 49 wickets at 21.61 and also doesn’t muck about, striking at once every 43.4 deliveries, which is world class.

Anrich Nortje is an interesting one. He’s been up into the mid 150km/h ballpark so he’s express pace. His action is a bit more front-on and he uses his height well and brings a lot of energy to the attack, often as the change bowler. 

He normally bangs the ball in just short of a length to hit splice high on the bat but he can also go “nose and toes” to push batters back before slipping in the yorker.

Again, the stats indicate how much of an impact he’s made in a short space of time – 57 wickets from 15 Tests at 27.52 with a strike rate of 43.8. 

Rabada’s taken over from Steyn as the pace spearhead but Nortje’s copied his chainsaw celebration so we’ll be seeing that a bit over the next few weeks. 

And if you think we’ve got some tall bowlers in the Australian attack, wait until you see Marco Jansen – he’s 2.06m, a left-armer and although he’s not as fast as the other three, he’s another consistent swinger of the ball.

For the Aussie right-handers, he’ll be a constant threat to trap them in front and for the lefties he will be taking the ball away from them towards the slips. 

Another relative newcomer to Test cricket at 22, he’s bagged 37 wickets from just seven Tests and his average and strike rate are better than the others – 18.59 and 34. They’re some seriously good numbers. 

As an all-rounder it gives them a nice balanced attack by playing him as well but if you have him batting at No.7, that means their keeper, Kyle Verreynne, goes up to six and it could leave them a little skinny when their batting depth isn’t great as it is.

Keshav Maharaj is a really experienced spin bowler who will be able to dot players up and they haven’t had many quality tweakers over the years but his record of 154 victims at 30 in 45 Tests is excellent. 

He might have a chance to really shine in that Sydney Test. 

They’ve talked it up already how they want to make the Aussie batters uncomfortable by bowling short and it’ll be interesting to see how they respond.

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Usman Khawaja is very strong on the pull and hook, David Warner prefers to cut through the off side, Marnus Labuschagne was almost compulsively playing shots when the West Indies bounced him so is he going to duck under a few with two fielders out in the deep?

Steve Smith, with the changes to his stance, feels like he’s in a better position to take on the short ball but he’s still very selective about when he does. Travis Head can tend to keep his hands up when he’s playing the short ball so he could be a chance to glove one if he’s not careful and for Cameron Green, his height should be an advantage to combat that sort of bowling pretty well. 

Warner’s been given another show of faith by the selectors and I agree that you’ve just got to back him and we’ll worry about his spot later on if he still doesn’t get a big score. 

South Africa have had some good attacks over the years – guys like Allan Donald, Steyn, Morne Morkel and Shaun Pollock – so this attack could be as imposing as some of those sides but I can’t remember them having a left-armer to throw into the mix like Jansen and a spinner as skilled as Maharaj.

This group would be up there with the best attacks they’ve brought out here. 

The series will come down to which batting unit can weather the early storm when the ball is new to put up a decent total and if you compare the records of the two teams then Australia should come out well on top in that regard. 

I think it’s going to be an engrossing Test series, I’d say the MCG in the second Test would be South Africa’s best chance to steal a win off the Aussies. All three Tests will be close and if a few of their gritty batters are able to dig in, particularly if it’s a low-scoring series, that gives them a chance with the bowling attack they’ve got. 

The Crowd Says:

2022-12-17T06:01:34+00:00

Marty

Roar Rookie


Told ya!

2022-12-17T02:37:41+00:00

Takeadeepbreath

Roar Rookie


Dropped....terrible last tour against England. Flatters only to deceive. Given the start SA have had...probably wouldn't have made any difference. LOL

2022-12-16T23:22:36+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Dropped? Or injured?

2022-12-16T20:14:04+00:00

Takeadeepbreath

Roar Rookie


Agree with everything here, except .....Markram not part of the squad, and thank goodness for that. When he arrived on the scene, he was widely regarded as being the "next Kallis" for SA....proof is in the pudding as they say.....probably the most overrated player to walk the planet. So, happy he doesn't feature here, because his single figure scores ain't going to help much.

2022-12-16T16:03:07+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Yes, a while ago. Less likely as he turns 37yo and 38.

2022-12-16T15:54:51+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Not sure I agree right now but we're splitting hairs. You may be right about his age but he churned out big tons less than a year ago.

2022-12-16T15:36:14+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Ussie is less consistent and older than Davy. No problem if they both went now. Ussie's age could be a factor in his innings not going on to the 90s and 100s.

2022-12-16T10:17:12+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


I worry about both openers going together. And I think it's a real concern. I'd be looking at a new partner for Ussie if Warner doesn't get some runs in the next 3 tests

2022-12-16T09:57:34+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


I don't think that's a problem. Cricket is not like footy where you need to build a synergy within the team. Cricket just needs players to play their role. It's the role, well-executed that builds the synergy. We just pick the form role player. If we were to try to rebuild for the future, we don't pick a 33yo Boland or Neser, we pick Morris or Richardson. We don't bother with Carey, we go to Philippe. If Warner and Khawaja go tomorrow, any of Bancroft, Whiteman, Renshaw, Harris, Ward, Jewell, Hunt are ready. Even a vintage Daniel Hughes could do an Adam Voges, a Chris Rogers or a Mike Hussey.

2022-12-16T09:00:55+00:00

Simoc

Roar Rookie


The SA guys have the opportunity to prove themselves against currently the worlds number one test team. That is often when these SA guys come good. We shall see. SA have never produced a weak team (like WI did) so competition is guaranteed. We haven't won a home series vs SA since 2006 so this is our chance to right the record.

2022-12-16T08:51:16+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


"we're only dancing on this Earth for a short while" sang the Cat.

2022-12-16T08:49:10+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


If we have one chink in the armour of our understanding about SA they'll find it.

2022-12-16T08:45:30+00:00

Simoc

Roar Rookie


We'll finally see Boland bowl to competent batsman while though not among the worlds best won't gift wickets as the Poms and Windies have done so recently. The SA attack looks stronger than ours but their batting is weaker. The spine free selectors failed to give Morris a run in Adelaide and he may never get another look in. So much for stuffing current form which can be critical. Bailey is a really weak Chair of selectors. Anyway it should be a competitive series. They normally beat us so winning will be different!

2022-12-16T08:33:54+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Good call but we need to move one of him or Khawaja on in the next year, so we don't replace both simultaneously. And it's not going to be Ussie right now.

2022-12-16T08:29:23+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


That sounds like Cam Green's innings in Adelaide. Where everybody else made it look like playing A graders on a road, he couldn't find the middle, ran out his partner and then got himself out. His form is a real worry ahead of a series where we can guarantee at least one collapse. From really solid and confident last summer to a nervous wreck this season.

2022-12-16T07:41:32+00:00

Shire

Roar Rookie


Even Steve Waugh managed a century in Sharjah during his nadir.

2022-12-16T07:00:45+00:00

Shire

Roar Rookie


Yes, I have always thought that economy rate it way underrated as a measure of a bowler's efficacy, but ultimately it doesn't matter because the two are intrinsically tied together and result in a bowler's average. Strike rate is more result oriented, and therefore more exciting, but the trade off usually ends up being that the strike bowlers bowl less overs.

2022-12-16T07:00:23+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


It's a Keith Stackpole, Ian Redpath, Bob Simpson, Steve Waugh, Matt Renshaw run of form. He has been terrific. Your 3 year bit seems to have overlooked an innings or ten.

2022-12-16T05:49:47+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Strike rate is overrated. Doesn’t matter too much the difference between 40 and 50, say. If your four bowlers average 25 with a strike rate of 50 it means you get the opposition out on overage for 250 in about 83 overs. If they average 30 with a strike rate of 40, the oppo gets out for 300, in 65 overs. Maybe a fraction more time to win the Test and your bowlers are a bit more rested, but doesn’t make up for the deficit.

2022-12-16T05:44:56+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Rabada is arguably the best fast bowler in the world because 257 wickets in 55 matches at 22.46 is nuts. Cummins’ average of 21.50 with home matches on generally higher scoring pitches is even nutsier. Batting is indeed the likely difference with not one of the SA top 6 averaging over 40 - probably the weakest SA lineup since 1960. But Markram and v d Dussen could easily come good, and Verreyne has an FC average over 50.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar