Right then, what do we need to see from Australian rugby in 2023?

By Brett McKay / Expert

From an Australian rugby standpoint, this shouldn’t be a particularly lengthy list, right?

If only that were remotely true.

Wish lists tend to be overflowing, but remain useful even if just for the purposes of getting goals and ambitions down on paper, if not to use them as a checklist, per se.

So this won’t be an exhaustive list – because they never are – but it’s a decent starting point.

Fringe players to step up
Rugby World Cup years mean two things: the Super Rugby sides prepare themselves for a post-tournament exodus, and a whole lot of contract speculation beforehand.

And the states want to start planning for the next four-year cycle, so what they really need is for the guys who have been solid provincial players for a while, maybe even had some Australia A or Wallabies squad experience, to announce themselves as players a team can be built around.

So the Angus Blyths, the Harry Hooperts, the Isaac Henrys. The Will Harrises, the Harrison Goddards, the Dylan Pietsches. The Billy Pollards, the Tom Hoopers, the Ryan Lonergans.

The Ryan McCauleys, the Tim Anstees, the Isaac Fines-Leleiwasas, the Bailey Kuenzles. The Matt Gibbons, the Jordan Ueleses, the Lachie Andersons.

Some of these guys can even be World Cup bolters. But their CEOs would love nothing more than their signature on the pages of a well-earned contract upgrade and a good start on their 2024 marketing plan.

Young 10s to show the future does not involve the past
Ben Donaldson and Noah Lolesio will get the extra focus, and while I’d love both of them to have absolutely storming years – unignorable years from a selection point of view in fact – I’m actually thinking of the chasing pack behind them.

Tane Edmed and Will Harrison. Reesjan Pasitoa, once he gets back on the field, and Hamish Stewart until he does. Carter Gordon to take the step from promising to quality. And Lawson Creighton to guide his team away from the James O’Connor safety net.

If these guys can step up, then Donaldson and Lolesio will be pushed to new and very welcome levels.

And the sooner they all can, the sooner the Wallabies can move on from Japanese-based players in their mid-30s.

The future needs to be about the future again, not what was the future 15 years ago.

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Lineouts to military accuracy and mauls to set your watch by
Remember the first half of the year when all the Australian sides had pretty decent lineout drives? With England arriving in July, and The Rugby Championship to follow, Wallabies assistant coach Dan McKellar’s ambition to create “the best maul in the world” wasn’t too far-fetched at all.

But it got lost along the way.

Folau Fainga’a scored a maul try in the first England Test in Perth and they didn’t score another one until Fainga’a barged over again in the Wales Test to finish the year.

And it wasn’t all about a misfiring lineout, because that really didn’t take hold until the Spring Tour. There were another eight Tests after Perth and before the Wallabies landed in Europe. So what happened to the maul?

The answer probably doesn’t matter as much as the need for the states to get straight back on the mauling bike next season.

A functioning – and ideally firing – lineout drive is going to crucial come the international season and especially the World Cup, so it’s kind of in the national interest that they do.

Player management and conditioning programs to align
If Wallabies coming off the Spring Tour and destined for France are going to be asked to sit out three Super Rugby games next season, who gets to dictate when those three are? Will national interest override a team needing a win? Or a team needing a win to finish in the top four? Or the top eight?

We can only ask questions because it’s rarely laid out properly how it’s going to work in practice.

And what about state conditioning programs? What can or will be done to ensure no repeats of players having to essentially do a second pre-season once the Test season starts?

Lots of ducks will need to be correctly aligned, but these ones feel pretty important.

February form as a start but not the peak
Everyone knows about the concept of ‘February champions’ (and especially how the Waratahs are destined to always be that). It’s also true that you can’t win a World Cup in February, but you can certainly a start a campaign there.

So a really strong start to Super Rugby Pacific across the board would be great, but even more so if that early form line can increase into the finals and the international season. The increase is the crucial bit here; Australia should be pushing hard to ensure four finals qualifiers, and with that a stronger impetus into The Rugby Championship.

The last thing a strong start in February and March needs is a plateau through April, May and June.

Start well, by all means, but don’t let that be the high point.

(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

Consistency and momentum please
In a World Cup year – and perhaps more than any other, if what coaches say is true – the last thing an international team needs is the kind of existence the Wallabies have adopted in recent years.

That run of five straight wins in 2021 is the only time in the Dave Rennie era the Wallabies have strung consecutive wins together, and even though it came to a disappointing end on the Spring Tour, you could see them improve as a team. There was serious momentum through last season’s Rugby Championship.

In 2022, however, there was nothing like that, and it was hard to measure improvement amid the lose two-win reality they lived this season.

This has to be addressed in 2023 and, as if that’s not challenging enough with upwards of eight starting spots still up in the air, it has to be addressed in less than half a dozen Tests before the World Cup starts.

You’ll never build momentum without consistency. But find consistency and momentum becomes very real very quickly.

A World Cup to enjoy
Wouldn’t it be nice to have the Wallabies land in France and have things click?

If I can only have one thing come through in the 2023 rugby year, this is that one thing.

Merry Christmas and all the best for 2023
After 80-odd columns and 60-odd podcasts for the season, it’s time to put the feet up for a while.

Thanks so much to everyone who’s read and commented, and tuned in and listened along the way. For all the ups and down in Australian rugby in 2022, there is always something to discuss each week, and so for taking the time out to contribute as you all have, it’s a sincere thank you.

It’s been a big year, headlined by the launch and massive growth in The Roar Rugby Podcast, which has been a joy to produce each week, and it continues to blow me away how well it’s done. Thanks to Harry for planting the seed, and to Tony for giving the green light.

It’s been a busy year too, with a lot of rugby, a late-year change of day job, and frankly, it’s just time to sit back and watch some cricket.

See you in February. All the best to you and yours for the break, and please travel safe if you’re on the roads.

The Crowd Says:

2022-12-15T19:38:12+00:00

Rocky's Rules

Roar Rookie


@Brett I agree with all you say but you should have added an additional section called "Discipline, Discipline, Discipline" imo

2022-12-15T11:04:43+00:00

signpost

Roar Rookie


Love your work Brett. Merry Christmas

2022-12-14T20:38:34+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


I don't drink Chablis but even if I did I wouldn't travel 25km to get it. Not when the BOOZATORIUM is 500m down the road.

2022-12-14T20:28:14+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


I always assumed Roar journos wrote Rugby articles with their feet up. :shocked:

2022-12-14T17:43:12+00:00

Passit2me

Roar Rookie


I did it in my 2nd post Brett. Have a wonderful Christmas also :thumbup:

2022-12-14T12:46:57+00:00

brandon

Guest


Red won a comp without NZ. They then got smashed by those missing NZ teams, and that continued into last season.

2022-12-14T11:37:58+00:00

mzilikazi

Roar Pro


Actually have listened to about first 10, so am on the road :happy:

2022-12-14T11:04:50+00:00

Lurk

Guest


Forget about it BMac. Peanut gallery stuff. Why you entertain some of this genuine charity level. Solid yarns this year dude.

AUTHOR

2022-12-14T10:10:40+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


For all this, you still haven't outlined a player being played out of position, nor a coach playing someone out of position, nor have you been able to say what anyone's right position is and which coach is wrong, so I really don't know what more to say. I keep mentioning players and highlighting positions because you can't outline any of this. Anyway, Merry Christmas..

2022-12-14T06:31:28+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


The worst part is this has been going on for years. It was a live thing when Cheika was coach and Johnson DOR. Then SJ was put in charge of contracting when he was not required to supervise the new coach. Then RA let him go when his contract was up. These high powered corporate types keep claiming they are essential because rugby is an entertainment business. Even at 37 players, we are talking about less than 200 employees. Imagine if every business in Australia with 200 employees or more was this hopeless?

2022-12-14T06:15:54+00:00

Muglair

Roar Rookie


I don't know if he could have done much more mz. 50+ players used in each of the last two seasons. We are picking a lot of SR players not ready for test matches. If Jones takes over it could be like McQueen taking over from Smith, a lot of players who have played tests to choose from. The French have a lot of professional teams, a lot of depth, and seemingly a better pathway from junior and U20, which probably boils down to more high quality games played, and more high quality players to play and train with.

2022-12-14T01:50:18+00:00

Biscuit man

Roar Rookie


Right then, what do we need to see from Australian rugby in 2023? No brainer. Getting rid of Mr 34% and his coaching Team unless we are looking into becoming a second-tier rugby nation and continue to fall down the rankings. They have lost the support of most Wallaby fans.. It's embarrassing. No other main Rugby nation would sit on that win ratio from a coach.

2022-12-14T01:01:09+00:00

Geoff

Guest


KCOL, The Reds won the Comp in 2021, what more do you want from them? What did the Tahs do in 2021 and what trophy did the Tahs take home in 2022?

2022-12-14T00:55:35+00:00

Ace

Guest


The Waratahs have two Wallaby test locks, plus The Test hooker. They will dominate. :boxing:

2022-12-14T00:43:43+00:00

Passit2me

Roar Rookie


"That’s just a reality of international rugby. That’s not maintaining the status quo, it’s trying to fit the best players into a side". I would argue it is maintaining the status quo, since it is what we have been doing for a number of years now. With regards to the last part in italics, this is precisely what I don't agree with. trying to make space out of position for a player you want on the field has the potential to disrupt the co-ordination of the team. I believe the AB's and England have both suffered due to doing this. A player such as Tom Wright (or any player) playing 3 different positions, can water down their focus and reduce their effectiveness. I'd prefer a non flashy player who knows the ins and outs of doing their job under pressure, to be on the field. This type of correct decision making under pressure, only comes with repetition and a high level of familiarity with the position. The be honest Brett, the fact you are highlighting the question about which position is right for Tom and which is right for Andrew for example, only highlights the problem I am talking about. There should be no question about their preferred position.

AUTHOR

2022-12-13T23:52:27+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


But again, coaches have different ideas and it may involve players playing in different positions. They can't all fit. There's plenty of argument about Harry Wilson needing to play. But when Rob Valentini is one of the first picked, they can't both play no.8. So 6 becomes an obvious option for one of them, doesn't it? Tom Wright has played three different positions this season, which one is right? What is Andrew Kellaway's right position, and which coach is playing him out of whatever that position is? That's just a reality of international rugby. That's not maintaining the status quo, it's trying to fit the best players into a side..

2022-12-13T23:44:41+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


G’day Muglair. Finally had a chance to read the SMH article. As you called out this quote is the big worry: RA ”will map out a new contracting system for the country’s top 33 to 37 players” In the past the top 40 odd players earned an average of 550K with the rest (around 22m total salaries). Think this 33-37 player group will cost a lot more this time.

2022-12-13T22:50:56+00:00

Passit2me

Roar Rookie


Hi Brett, I am aware there is more sharing of data for conditioning etc. Something I think Cheika looked to initiate when he was coach as he saw it as a priority? With regards to players being willing to play anywhere to get a test jersey, we are frequently reminded of this reality when players are interviewed. However, I don't understand how this makes the players playing out of position, a furphy. Just because players are willing to play out of position to get a jersey, surely that does not mean it is ok to do it. I would have thought the smarter and more productive process of developing players in specialised positions throughout various stages of their career would produce better outcomes. I am all for change through centralised contracts if that is what is needed to get the job done, of producing greater consistency, particularly when I consider maintaining the status quo as the alternative.

AUTHOR

2022-12-13T22:04:43+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Apart from the point of there not being centralised contracts, there's actually never been more communications and coordination between the states and the Wallabies. Training schedules and data, conditioning and recovery programs are all shared, and the Wallabies coaches all get around the states several times a season. But for all that, sometimes coaches just have different ideas. This idea of players being played out of position is mostly a furphy because first and foremost, players will play anywhere to play a Test, and secondly, there remain distinguishing points between all the Australian teams..

2022-12-13T21:28:46+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


No mate. It's XV v XV. If...yes a big if but should we be able to select our best team then of course we can win!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar