'Dig our way out': NSW not panicking yet despite clunky loss as Tahs sweat on injured star trio

By Christy Doran / Editor

The Waratahs’ hopes of finishing in the top four are fading by the week. An off-season of promise and hope has been dented by clumsy errors in attack.

The latest setback, a 34-17 defeat in Wellington to the dangerous Hurricanes – the third defeat to Darren Coleman’s side from four matches to start the season.

Forget about the top four aspirations. They’re all but gone.

More pressing for Coleman’s side is somehow finding a win over the fortnight, with the unbeaten Chiefs, who have rested four of their stars including Damian McKenzie and Brodie Retallick for Saturday’s match against the Rebels, and Brumbies looming.

Kini Naholo celebrates his double on debut for the Hurricanes. Photo: Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images

Passes behind players, a dodgy lineout and a lethal Hurricanes side on the counter saw the Waratahs stumble in the New Zealand capital on their first match-up against trans-Tasman opposition this year.

The Waratahs only trailed by five points at half-time, after a fortuitous try to Nemani Nadolo and “remarkable” finish from teen wonder Max Jorgensen saw the visitors go into the sheds behind 17-12.

But three tries in less than 20 minutes to the home side, as halfback Cam Roigard and debutant winger Kini Naholo completed doubles and Dane Coles got on the end of a rolling maul, to put the result beyond doubt.

An intercept to Langi Gleeson, who was once again the Waratahs’ standout, saw the visitors stem the bleeding.

Langi Gleeson was the Waratahs’ best against the Hurricanes. Photo: Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images

Errors from the home side allowed the Waratahs to have a couple of late opportunities to narrow the margin and press for a losing bonus point.

Debutant Mosese Tuipulotu, the brother of former Rebels centre turned Scotland star Sione, was tackled centimetres short of the line with his first touch in Super Rugby and, after some cunning work from Ardie Savea at the breakdown, the visitors were given one final chance after referee Brendon Pickerill deemed the ball unable to come out.

But another turnover at the breakdown meant the Hurricanes won comfortably.

Waratahs captain Jake Gordon lamented his side’s errors.

“It was probably execution a little bit [that hurt us],” Gordon said.

“That falls on the playmakers heads, so nine and 10, but we definitely had a clear plan but just didn’t execute it.

“We need to focus on ourselves here. Individuals, myself included, need to take more ownership especially around the technical side of the game, but we’ve good enough players in this group to turn it around.”

Coleman added: “The attack, it’s not fluent. There’s some glimpses in there and parts, is it our clunkiness, is it the opposition’s quality over our ball, probably a little bit of both.”

Waratahs Head Coach Darren Coleman says he’s excited by the challenge ahead of “digging” their way out of a hole. Photo: Mark Kolbe/Getty Images

Making matters worse for the Waratahs is that they have injury concerns.

Charlie Gamble is likely to miss the next couple of weeks, while Lalakai Foketi has another shoulder injury that will likely see him next week’s home clash against the Chiefs. Max Jorgensen, meanwhile, is under a slight cloud after coming down hard on his shoulder in the process of his brilliant first-half try.

Fortunately the Waratahs have cover in both areas, particularly with Jed Holloway to be available.

Tuipulotu, who is weighing up an offer from Glasgow Warriors to join his brother in Scotland, could start for the first time while Joey Walton and Will Harrison are expected to be available too.

The Waratahs’ scrum held its own for the most part, but elsewhere there were few positives for the visitors.

Gleeson was again phenomenal, hooker Vahe Vailanu, lock Taleni Seu and Jorgensen were the Waratahs’ best.

But the Waratahs will need more if they are to seriously challenge in 2023.

“We don’t want to go into the by one and five, but again that’s my job to get us back up to go again next week,” Coleman said.

“A combination of travel and away games, I probably underestimated the difficult of our first six weeks. But by no means is the season over by any stretch.

“If we can scramble a win over the next two weeks – the Chiefs at home or the next week [against the Brumbies – we’ve got a pretty favourable run home. I think five of our final eight are at home. We’re still in it, but we’ve got to dig our way out of this form slump we’re in at the moment and get some belief and confidence back.”

The home side got on the scoreboard first as Barrett banged over an early penalty.

But their early lead didn’t last long, as former All Blacks World Cup-winner Julian Savea dropped the kick restart and Nemani Nadolo picked the ball up as clean as a whistle to score his first try in Super Rugby since 2016.

The Hurricanes didn’t take long to respond. Roigard, who was excellent all evening at halfback, barged his way through fly-half Ben Donaldson to score.

The frantic opening continued as Jorgensen scored spectacularly after bursting onto a Seu offload to score out wide. Donaldson’s sideline conversion gave the Waratahs a slender lead.

But Naholo’s first try despite the best efforts from Jorgensen to hold the flying winger up gave the Hurricanes a five-point lead at half-time.

Needing a fast start, the Waratahs failed to take their chances early in the second half. Making matters worse, the Hurricanes did what their Australian rivals couldn’t and opened up a huge lead and were chased down.

The Crowd Says:

2023-03-20T21:09:23+00:00

Malotru

Roar Rookie


My mistake Morsie.

2023-03-20T10:38:57+00:00

Chivas

Roar Rookie


Just FYI, Ardie is 29 and he’s a little bit special in his ability to keep his legs pumping in contact. Not much difference in weight. Ardie uses his more effectively, but as stated he is also 29 and consequently is quite a bit stronger, so not really comparable. There are not many number 8’s who people are talking about at 21 years of age, who is able to put on a decent tackle and run like he is. Keiran Read for example in my view was at his peak around 26 and debuted for the AB’s when he was around 23/24 if I remember rightly and he was pretty green when he started.

2023-03-20T01:03:18+00:00

cookie

Roar Guru


May be a little harsh but mate they really don’t look committed and the number of times they either ran into each other or passed to no one makes you wonder where their heads were.. When they did manage to put it together they were ok but all too often they didn’t know whether they were coming or going.

2023-03-20T00:59:43+00:00

cookie

Roar Guru


So all the weights sessions to add an extra 7kg per man was not enough?

2023-03-19T02:55:43+00:00

Rabbitz

Roar Guru


It seems to me that when you find yourself in a hole of your own making, the first thing to do is stop digging. Then you can work out how you got into the hole, why it is so deep and who and how to get out.

2023-03-18T23:13:42+00:00

Big A

Roar Rookie


100% PSTS - even on the Roar all we ever see is let's play this winger at fullback - let's play this 10 at fullback - let's play this centre at winger - let's play this 10 at 9 - how 'bout we just stick with playing everyone in their position - even Noah at the Brumbies - how are we helping his development by subing him on and off at 50 min every game - madness

2023-03-18T22:12:07+00:00

Malotru

Roar Rookie


I don't know Chivas, to me Gleeson is a little like Valetini doesn't often break the line and tends to fall in contact. Unlike Ardie Savea, who though a little lighter, keeps driving on his feet usually taking defenders with him.

2023-03-18T12:47:26+00:00

Spunkmeyer

Roar Rookie


Gleeson underwhelmed agree.

2023-03-18T12:46:24+00:00

Spunkmeyer

Roar Rookie


You forgot Latu.

2023-03-18T11:14:51+00:00

Wolla Wotsa

Roar Rookie


None..

2023-03-18T11:08:35+00:00

Chivas

Roar Rookie


No mate not a fine distinction at all… the distinction between personal attacks against people who post here and negative comments about NSW players and NSW rugby. If you don’t understand that difference I think you have had enough.

2023-03-18T10:22:58+00:00

Objective Observer

Roar Rookie


Mate … Now you’re seeking to make some fine distinction between personal attacks on NSW players and general criticism of NSW playing rugby - a distinction without a difference. Time for another Chivas …

2023-03-18T06:00:01+00:00

JC

Roar Rookie


Intensity is hard to maintain for a young team. The only old heads in the starting team were really Hooper, Gordon, Foketi, Hanigan and HJH, plus Nadolo who’s new to the team. Lots of youth learning on the job, including coach Coleman. Prepared to give them a bit more time to fix selections and execution.

2023-03-18T05:59:56+00:00

WEST

Roar Guru


Waratahs outside backs were one of the only highlights.. imo. The first half was solid by the Tahs, then they almost surrendered and gave up in the second? Unfortunately they now have to face the unbeaten Chiefs, see what happens

2023-03-18T05:55:07+00:00

rusty

Roar Rookie


I do not support the Tahs but was hoping for a good performance from them. They were dreadful. Jorgensen the only one with his rep intact, enhanced. Marky was OK but not the player of last year yet. I cannot cop the Gleeson comments. He was very average. One decent run and a lucky intercept. Looked lost and wandering often and unfit for 80 minutes. Beware Kiwi commentary carrying gifts, I'm sure they've got their eyes on many players they want in the Wallabies to suit their needs.

2023-03-18T05:52:36+00:00

WEST

Roar Guru


Cam Roigard! He’s a tough little bugger, really good around the rucks with sniping runs. Scored a couple of good tries, he’s got a bright future :thumbup: look forward to watching his progress

2023-03-18T05:52:29+00:00

JC

Roar Rookie


:unhappy:

2023-03-18T05:44:59+00:00

WEST

Roar Guru


It’s weird?? Great team on paper.. just can’t click as a unit. A missing ingredient somewhere? A mindset? Poor team culture? Which is odd considering it’s one of Australians more established teams.

2023-03-18T05:33:08+00:00

Rugbytrylover

Roar Rookie


The game plan is terrible. It working.

2023-03-18T05:06:09+00:00

Pete Samu's Tucked Shirt

Roar Rookie


100% pick and stick. Let the combinations grow, and allow the players to play what is in grant of them with an emphasis of situational strategies (exiting plays, 22m attacking line outs etc)

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar