'Inappropriate': Eddie puts Laurie in his place over Wallaby criticism, explains Quade battle, gives Hoops, TT update

By Tony Harper / Editor

Wallabies coach Eddie Jones has admonished Australia A assistant Laurie Fisher for “inappropriate” comments on the current coaching set up, while acknowledging he and his team have fallen short of their own expectations so far.

Fisher, who was an assistant coach for the Australia A team beaten in Tonga last week, questioned the credentials of Jones’ defence assistant Brett Hodgson, a former rugby league international, on The Roar Rugby podcast this week.

“From watching the game, I don’t know that they have great clarity themselves at the moment,” Fisher, defence assistant under Dave Rennie last year, said of the Wallabies.

“They have a new defensive coach [Brett Hodgson] who’s never coached rugby union, hasn’t played rugby union.

“He’s obviously working on connection and kick chase and first phase. Is he also talking about what is our contest policy between the 15s, what do you do in our own 22? I saw guys having a crack, but I didn’t see a designated policy of how we’re going to get some pressure on their ball.

“Even close to our line, I saw Jed Holloway pull out of a contest. For goodness sake, you’ve just got to go in and make a mess of it. It’s a non-negotiable. So I don’t know if that’s an area that they’ve addressed with any significance yet. So it’s a huge area for potential improvement.”

Jones was asked about Fisher’s thoughts during a media conference on Saturday.

“Laurie is a member of the Australian A staff so I find those comments inappropriate,” said Jones.

Pressed on if it was a risk to go into high stakes Bledisloe Cup and World Cup tournaments with a defensive coach inexperienced in the XV-man game, Jones said: “Our whole situation is a risk and also an opportunity.

“I’ve got no doubt we’re not as clear about how we want to play as we want to be. The only problem I see with that is we’re not performing as we’d like to perform.

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

“But in a build up to a World Cup these sorts of teething problems are sometimes the best problems to have. And sometimes you find out more about your team in these situations than you do when you think things are going along swimmingly. And they’re not getting along swimmingly.

“And all the comments Laurie’s made … he’s a smart coach and he did a great job with defence for Australia A, so we can take good consolation from that and if we need someone to help us we can use him.”

It was noted that the Wallabies lacked alignment in defence and attack around the breakdown.

“We’re not [aligned] and that’s part of the issues we’ve got at the moment. But in time we will be,” said Jones.

“It’s an understanding issue – understanding what we need, what decisions need to be made by the players. How much is a framework and how much is the decision making of the players and we’re working out the right balance for the team.”

Jones defended the performances of two of his key players – Quade Cooper and Samu Kerevi – while fielding a question about a lack of pace in his halves and at inside centre.

“We’ve got a number of players coming back from long term injuries,” said Jones. “And then we know those players, as much as we like them to be at their best now, they’re not going to be their best until the World Cup.

 (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

“We’ve got a plan in place to get each player back to their best. This is part of the process. So we don’t know where Quade’s going to end up.

“He’s still four games into returning from an Achilles tendon. Samu Kerevi is three or four games back from an ACL and they’re serious injuries. So with better exposure, the quality training and rugby training over the next period of time, they’re gonna get a lot sharper.”

He said he thought it was obvious that fans should be giving those players a break rather than piling on them.

“That would appear to be obvious. I’m happy to talk to those fans face to face if so be it. Let’s have a fan forum. Happy to answer it,” said Jones.

“Anyone who’s coming back from a long term injury needs time. That’s the most obvious and the most sensible way to look at any player and particularly from serious injuries like Achilles tendon and ACL, they need time to train, they need time to get feeling of the game back, their timing of the game back.

“I’ve got no doubt they’ll be at the best for the World Cup.”

The same will apply to Taniela Tupou, who is in the squad for the Bledisloe Cup match in Melbourne next weekend.

He will be cutting it fine though, having returned home from the Australia A tour ill.

“He hasn’t been able to train until today. He came back a little bit crook,” said Jones. “Maybe some of the native Tongan food got to him. I’m not sure. He’s back training today. And if he can get through some some good training early in the week then he may be available for selection.”

Michael Hooper is also racing the clock to be fit.

“He wasn’t able to train today and we’ll  need to make a medical assessment of him over the weekend and see whether he can participate in the game or not,” said Jones.

“We’ve still got a week to go. Calf injuries we tend to be more careful with their rehab than other injuries so medical staff are being pretty careful with him.”

Jones, who dumped out of form fullback Tom Wright for the Bledisloe Cup, said he was weighing up his options for the No.15 jersey, with Jordan Petaia and Andrew Kellaway bothing having spent time in the position during training this week.

“We need to improve the team,” Jones said of what he was looking for in the No.15 role. “We haven’t been good enough for the first two games. I’m still searching for what our best team is.”

Jones goes into the series against the New Zealanders sensing that no one outside his camp gives the Wallabies a chance.

“We’re not too worried about the New Zealanders. We’ve got a lot of things to work out ourselves,” Jones said.

“We’re trying to work out our best game plan. But New Zealand have approached this season a little bit differently than they normally would.

“In a World Cup year, they tend to have a measured build up. And it looks like they’re all guns firing at the moment.

“Our aim is to put them under pressure early in the game and see how they cope with pressure on them, because they haven’t had it as yet.

“It’s a massive game, we’re looking forward to it. There’s nothing better than coaching against New Zealand.

“If you look at Australia at the moment, probably no one outside our immediate squad thinks we’ve got a chance of winning, which sometimes can drive a bit more closeness within the team, a bit more purpose about what we’re doing. We’re looking for the challenge of playing against a very good New Zealand team.”

He said the Wallabies had no choice but to embrace their underdog status.

“Generally speaking, we want to be a team that can cope with any sort of tag that gets put on the team, whether it be favorites or underdogs,” said Jones.

“You just don’t want to be a team that that fronts up when you’re underdogs. In this situation this week, where we’re massive underdogs, that creates an opportunity for us because we know if we can put pressure on a team that’s labelled as red hot favourites, sometimes that pressure can turn into increased pressure on them and stress within their team. And that’s our aim.”

Jones was asked if England’s comeback in the Ashes was something that gave him inspiration.

He dead panned: “I don’t get any inspiration from English cricket.”

The Crowd Says:

2023-07-29T08:56:33+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


I never said Rennie couldn't get them to a semi final. I said getting to a semi is overachieving no matter who is the coach. I also said Rennie didn't show any possibility of getting them to the final. Eddie hasn't either yet, but as there was no way in hell that Rennie was going to, there is no risk in rolling the dice with EJ.

2023-07-29T08:25:42+00:00

Guess

Roar Rookie


But Rennie could get them to semi finals too. If you didn't see it doesn't mean nothing suggested it. They were 6th and rising. Unless Eddie get them in finals it's a fail. Funny thing Eddie still has half the squad that was discovered by Rennie yet you will believe in miracle if he wins wc by chance thinking it's all on him and all the work Rennie's done worth nothing. Miracles don't exist. Real difference is Gordon not Jones. Rennie struggled to make backline working cause he didn't have proper 10 now they do

2023-07-27T20:54:53+00:00

Rugbynutter

Roar Rookie


If you look at brumbies being the only consistent super rugby performer able to match the kiwis over many years I think you might give fisher more credit for that.

2023-07-26T19:04:11+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


No, that isn't what I said at all. I said that a QF would be a solid effort and a semi final would be unlikely but if we achieved it then that is overachieving against our the reality of our world ranking. I am also saying that Australia making the RWC final would be miracle let alone winning the whole thing. These statements apply no matter who is the coach. And then what I am saying is that there was nothing about the last three years under Dave Rennie that would suggest there even a remote possibility of a miracle final or a RWC win happening. Nothing , nada, zilch. Will EJ be able to provide the miracle? I have no idea but given we all know DR wouldn't have, what have we got to lose with EJ?

2023-07-26T18:57:17+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Not at all. However there is a difference between being fit to play and being match fit. You can't assume someone is fully match fit unless they have some games under their belt. It is a balancing act.

2023-07-26T08:19:48+00:00

Guess

Roar Rookie


Huh you saying Rennie wouldn't get them into qf even? You really think he was that bad or just trying to justify Aru f up? Right that's what I'm saying supposedly professional organisation believes in miracles

2023-07-25T20:36:17+00:00

Wig

Roar Rookie


Oh so put unfit and injured on the field for test matches. Insane

2023-07-25T15:18:14+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Good work?

2023-07-25T15:17:23+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Quite the opposite from me. The team has had 2 games under Eddie after 3 years under Dave. My vote is to calm down, stop the rock throwing and let him get on with it. We all know it'll be a solid effort to make the RWC QF and unlikely for us to make the SF and a miracle if we make the final. All RA has said is that they don't believe there would be a miracle under DR and do believe it is possible to have a miracle with EJ.

2023-07-25T15:12:42+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


True, I think we lack the nuance around when it might be ok for the opposition to have the ball (or at least our preferred options) and then how to ensure that they only have it when we want them to and what we are doing to put effective pressure on them when they have it.

2023-07-25T15:11:09+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Agreed. Although I was always taught, if they don't have the ball they can't score a try so don't give them the ball.

2023-07-25T15:05:34+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Well if they don’t play , how do they get match fit? I don’t think there is time to let them play 4 games of club rugby, then 4 games in the Sussie A’s then into the test squad. Plus the issue with letting them play club rugby is that they don’t get the after match care and won’t be on managed minutes with the capacity to have the Aussie team medical staff monitoring them during the game.

2023-07-25T14:59:13+00:00

Guess

Roar Rookie


And Eddie is magic solution? :laughing: That's the problem with many fans and Aru you're looking for quick results

2023-07-24T19:07:16+00:00

gatesy

Roar Guru


"Possession Rugby" is just another newfangled term for what we have always taught- with ball in hand you attack - without ball in hand you attack their possession. Overuse of the word "defend" is rife. It creates a negative mindset. Kicking is just the first building block. Getting the proper number of chasers and players ready to support is the 2nd building block and the 3rd is holding the ball by applying maximum discipline in contact. You then set your structure (pods) and use your well rehearsed "structure" to bend the D-LINE and score tries.

2023-07-24T09:02:55+00:00

Rogue Estate

Roar Rookie


That's actually rather sad - not good for Australian Rugby.

2023-07-24T08:16:38+00:00

Khun Phil

Roar Rookie


Does anyone really take Greg Martin seriously?

2023-07-24T06:29:36+00:00

Guess

Roar Rookie


Dunno to me it simply sounds like him. He was 'brutally' honest last time too. He just speaks his mind. That's his style. I agree tho, seems like treating people like trash is aru style

2023-07-24T06:10:15+00:00

cs

Roar Guru


Does make you wonder about the underlying executive commitment, to be sure.

2023-07-24T06:00:27+00:00

JD Kiwi

Roar Rookie


Fisher had one match, in the past.

2023-07-24T05:26:52+00:00

TPC

Roar Rookie


How? And who thinks Vunivalu (sorry if it's wrong spelling) is a better winger than Wright?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar