You can admit it now - if Stuart Broad was an Aussie, he'd be your favourite player

By Mike Meehall Wood / Editor

It’s been said many times that Stuart Broad is the most Australian of English cricketers. 

His tenacity, his will to win and, yes, his tendency to play a little fast and loose with the spirit of the game would stand him in good stead with some of the best to come from this country over the years, and indeed, make him stand out from plenty of his own countrymen.

What has often been held up as a virtue of Australian cricket – as recently as the Alex Carey stumping in this very series – has similarly been seen as a failure of English cricket, a deficiency in the key areas of ‘wanting it’ and other woolly concepts.

Broad might not have threatened to break anyone’s arm, to get them at the Gabba or indeed, smuggling something from Bunnings down his trousers, but he’s never shied away from being the hate figure for the opposition, or indeed, from smashing the ball to first slip and staying exactly where he was.

There’s always been a competitive edge to him that few of his countrymen – for the record, I am one of them – have shared. It’s what will, over time, end up endearing Broad to Australians over the long run.

History will be kind to him. For the thick end of 15 years, he has dominated the narrative of Ashes contests, whether positively, in producing the devastating spells with the ball that have decided two series, or negatively, by being public enemy number one on most of his visits to Australia.

In terms of English bowlers, he not only has more Ashes wickets than any other player, but also as many moments as any in reasonable living memory.

There’s no ‘Broad’s Ashes’, like there might be with Ian Botham or Andrew Flintoff – or even Ben Stokes – but in terms of bowling longevity, his defining spells across multiple series will be what he is most known for.

James Anderson will always have him as a pure bowler, but he hasn’t run through teams like Broad has, and indeed, hasn’t run through Australia specifically as his younger teammate has. 

He’s had an 11-wicket game, a nine, an eight. He’s taken eight five-fers against Australia, more than anyone else, and five of them were six-fers. Remember, you hate him because he’s good.

In many ways, the best character to compare Broad to is Shane Warne. 

On the field, obviously, Warne still has it and Broad is in that tier just down from the true all-timers, and off the field, too, he’s not quite as colourful a character – though, in fairness, who is? 

But in terms of an ability to create moments, to transcend the game, to be the story of a whole series all on their own, then Broady is as close as any, certainly since Botham’s heyday in the early 1980s and perhaps longer. 

Stuart Broad. (Photo by Phil Walter/Getty Images)

Speaking as a true Warne hater – he was, above all, a scourge of English cricket fans everywhere – there was always a feeling that you couldn’t actually hate the man, because he was that good and also the kind of bloke you know you’d probably get on with.

It was love to hate all the way, as evidenced by the huge outpouring of affection on the spin king’s untimely passing last year.

There’s been plenty of Australians who were hate-to-hate – Justin Langer and David Warner are two that immediately spring to mind – and it might be that Broad inhabits that space for many Aussie fans.

But in a character-off against other occupants of that space, such as Kevin Pietersen, it’s clear that there’s whole other level of depth to Broad’s character that elevates him beyond pure hate figure.

Manage, strategise & dominate. Download Wicket Cricket Manager today!

Remember, the bulk of England fans started off by hating him too. For a long time, Broad was an expensive bowler who got picked for his lower-order batting, which did little to immediately endear him to anyone.

Throw in that he was the son of a former player – the term ‘nepo baby’ hadn’t been coined in 2007, but the feeling existed – who looked like an overgrown private schoolboy.

For fans used to the likes of Flintoff, Steve Harmison and Matthew Hoggard, not to mention Anderson, he seemed like a dilettante who wouldn’t last.

When he was dropped in 2008, however, Broad went away and took seven in county cricket, perhaps the first inkling that there might be a little more backbone than expected.

This became a theme. At times he was most doubted, Broad produced his best. It is, again, the most Australian of qualities for a cricketer to have.

(Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

His willingness, for want of a better phrase, to make the game all about himself, is what has driven him all along.

You can look forward to this, by the way. He’s coming to a media box near you and will be around for the foreseeable. His partner, Mollie King, is a pop star-turned-broadcaster in the UK, and the pathway from the field to the commentary box has been laid for years.

He’ll be top of the list of new recruits for broadcasters in the next Ashes, if not before. He’ll end up in the celebrity jungle, if he wants to, though his partner did the English equivalent of Dancing with the Stars, so perhaps that might be more his vibe.

Vibes is the correct word. He was a vibes cricketer, with a propensity for the dramatic and an unerring ability to claim the moment. 

It’s why fans here hated him so much, but as the on-field fades into the rear view mirror, it’ll be clear that the love was also there.

You’ve not heard the last of him, Australia. In fact, you might enjoy the next bit – even if you don’t want to admit it.

The Crowd Says:

2023-08-02T01:30:46+00:00

mrl

Roar Rookie


I went to the best State High school in country NSW....looking back, I am glad my parents didn't consider a private school....I was never good at rowing, chess and theatre!!! Our cricket team made the State competition NSW schools final, unfortunatley, we had to play Bankstown High. The Waugh brothers had left a couple of years before, but the legacy was there. Wayne Holdsworth cleaned us up the next year when we met East Hills High school. We were the only country public school who made the final two years in a row. Surpisingly, we only had one player who went on to play Sheffield Shield for NSW.

2023-08-01T23:44:03+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


No other city is known more by it’s myths than Adelaide. Funnily enough l went to Adelaide’s best state high school. We played against the Colleges, not the other High Schools.

2023-08-01T05:57:52+00:00

mrl

Roar Rookie


Sydney is where you live...Melbourne is where you shop...and Adelaide is where you went to school. So I am told...I do not get it, but interstate it is an Adelaide "thing".

2023-08-01T05:52:02+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


What is "school tie Adelaide"?

2023-08-01T03:32:09+00:00

Pickett

Roar Rookie


A real antagonist, pain in the butt and the player I loved to hate. But a great player. Well done to him.

AUTHOR

2023-08-01T01:43:18+00:00

Mike Meehall Wood

Editor


No I don't like him for a hundred reasons, that's just my best pithy line on him :laughing:

2023-08-01T01:22:10+00:00

King of Kings

Roar Rookie


He was just hard to follow (similar to Robinson is my perception) and memory of in one WC his 1st over went for 12+ against Sachin from memory and he was mouthing off, while bowling utter sh!te. Probably part also out of his control i thought he didn't warrant selection at times.

2023-08-01T00:22:00+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


You don't like Vaughan because he went to a flash school (I assume) and paid for it?

2023-07-31T23:48:50+00:00

Stylez

Roar Rookie


Stokes is mentally all over Australia :laughing: :laughing:

2023-07-31T23:28:45+00:00

Hutcho

Roar Rookie


Whataboutery doesn't make it untrue though does it?

AUTHOR

2023-07-31T23:24:23+00:00

Mike Meehall Wood

Editor


Oh man, I can't stand Vaughan...him and Root went to the same school, the difference being that Vaughan paid to go there :laughing:

AUTHOR

2023-07-31T23:23:34+00:00

Mike Meehall Wood

Editor


Gonna be some brave revalations when you realise how many Aussie cricketers are privately educated...it's about in line with England these days.

2023-07-31T22:09:22+00:00

humesy

Roar Rookie


Nailed it.

2023-07-31T16:19:15+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


You’re out of your mind

2023-07-31T15:47:58+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


I only admit to things that are true. He’s been a fine bowler, but as with Anderson it’s all overhyped thanks to the sheer number of Tests he’s played. But he’s only played a couple of years longer than Lillee, McGrath, Lindwall and a year LESS than Hadlee who all have much better records. While Broad played 167 Tests over 16 years, Hadlee only played 86. But should we give Broad extra points for stamina and endurance? Definitely not. In those 16 years, Broad played in 498 matches of all kinds, including first class, T20s etc and bowled 9,433 overs, whereas in his last 16 years, Hadlee played 673 matches and bowled 13,276 overs, or 240 more overs annually on average. So Hadlee played a lot more cricket, while Broad has been kept in cotton wool a lot in recent years. Not only is Hadlee’s overall Test average way better, Broad’s isn’t even in the same postcode when it comes to his away average which is a better measure in many ways (less home advantage, based on a greater variety of wickets, on five continents). Hadlee averaged 21.7 away and Broad 31.1. You get similar results if you compare with Lillee or McGrath who aren’t far behind Hadlee. As too often it’s a case of people citing numbers, especially aggregates, without interpreting them critically. Though Broad’s career is more impressive if you just look at his best ten years.

2023-07-31T13:42:28+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Until he bizarrely claimed the Moral Ashes after losing the 2nd test in his post game speech. The Kiwis deserted him in droves after that. :silly: I suspect he has been brainwashed by his skulking coach, Baz. Nah, he's had a few brilliant games in his career but we don't want Stokes as an Aussie with that embarrassing pompous pom high-horse.

2023-07-31T13:33:49+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Well said. Freddie Flintoff was in the same mould. Now there is a rare Englishman we would like as an Aussie!

2023-07-31T09:15:39+00:00

mrl

Roar Rookie


I live in school tie Adelaide these days…I got it wrong. Steve Waugh had already knocked Chris Broads bails off before he smashed the stumps. Now there was a cricketer and a leader…pity he was from NSW. S.Waugh. One of those guys you could imagine being in a war trench thing with. He would have some plan, otherwise just charge out and have a crack!!! Absolute legend.

2023-07-31T09:13:51+00:00

Lord Ted Said

Roar Rookie


I’ve hated Broad but he’s come around for me. Maybe Ive been a bit slow off the mark but now he’s an entertainer! And a good one with a record that has him comfortably on the second shelf, with longevity to throw into the mix as well. Not leaning on his bat either. he’s putting in always. Great career. Memorable.

2023-07-31T09:11:35+00:00

Rossi

Roar Rookie


You ought to give yourself an uppercut with that sort of blasphemy Buster

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar