AFL head of football Laura Kane has indicated Alastair Clarkson’s fine and suspended ban for a homophobic slur won’t be used as a reference point in determining punishment for Jeremy Finlayson.
Port Adelaide forward Finlayson directed a homophobic slur towards an Essendon player in the third quarter of the Power’s 69-point victory over the Bombers at Adelaide Oval on Friday night.
It is understood an umpire’s microphone picked up the f—-t insult, which was heard by multiple players, and at least one Essendon player also called it out. Warriors winger Marcelo Montoya was banned by the NRL for four matches in 2022 for using the same term in abusing an opponent.
The 28-year-old apologised to the target of his slur post-match, and on Sunday made a formal apology, describing his words as “unacceptable”.
A punishment hasn’t been settled, with the AFL still working through options, but chief executive Andrew Dillon confirmed on Monday it would be determined before the next round of games from Thursday.
Essendon coach Brad Scott believed the incident highlighted how far society and the AFL has come in handling homophobia. He insisted none of his players told him about the slur during, or after, the game and the AFL “instigated” the investigation.
“Every now and then there’s a transgression,” Scott said on Tuesday. “These players are human and they make mistakes.
“I think the most important thing is that everyone involved has straight away admitted that there was a mistake and it shouldn’t have happened. Thirty years ago no one would have batted an eyelid, so as an industry, I think the AFL have set the standard in areas like this.”
Last month, North Melbourne coach Clarkson was fined $20,000 and handed a suspended two-match ban for abusing St Kilda defenders Jimmy Webster and Dougal Howard during a pre-season game.
Clarkson was asked to explain his actions to the AFL after allegedly using the homophobic slur “c*******er” during the practice match.
Alastair Clarkson. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)
Kane was asked in a segment on the AFL’s website if it was reasonable to assume Finlayson wouldn’t be suspended, given the precedent that had been set with the Clarkson penalty.
“The really important thing to note here is the consistency with vilification matters is how seriously we take them,” she said.
“They’re incredibly important integrity investigation processes for us because this is not something we want to hear or see on the field, off the field, or in fact in society, and we take all vilification matters incredibly seriously.
“In terms of comparing and contrasting, we investigate all these matters individually and we make sure that any sanction is connected to the incident that we are investigating and that we are dealing with.
Jeremy Finlayson. (Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)
“And that’s what we’ll be doing here in the Jeremy Finlayson matter.”
Earlier on Monday, Dillon was asked how Finlayson’s comment measured up to a racial slur.
In 2021, Adelaide forward Taylor Walker received a six-game ban for uttering a racist remark about a rival reserves player.
“We take them all really seriously and I don’t think you can compare and contrast,” Dillon said.
“But all of them are different, we don’t like them and that’s why we’re looking into it and that’s why there’ll be an accountability.”
Essendon forward Kyle Langford felt the use of a homophobic slur was similar to racist remarks. “It shouldn’t be any different to any kind of racial slur,” Langford told 3AW’s Wide World of Sports on Monday night.
“It’s not acceptable and Jeremy (Finlayson) has owned up to it, so good on him, but the AFL will deal with it.”
Kane and Dillon stressed the AFL did not tolerate homophobic vilification. “I don’t think there’s any place for that anywhere, let alone the league,” Dillon said.
“We take this really seriously and I would prefer to run a proper investigation and a proper process to get to the right outcome.”
Asked whether a punishment for Finlayson should be a “captain’s call” made by him, Dillon indicated that lay with Kane and general counsel Stephen Meade.
Dillon was speaking at a post-Gather Round press conference, where the AFL and the SA government announced the Barossa Valley would host a game in 2025.
Port coaching change on the way
Ken Hinkley is set to hand over the coaching reins to assistant Josh Carr at Port Adelaide with a “handshake agreement” reportedly in place for the transition to happen at the end of next year.
Hinkley managed to avoid the sack last year when he revived the team from a slow start to make the finals.
They are off to a promising 3-1 start this year after Connor Rozee and fellow midfield gun Jason Horne-Francis produced dominant performances to lead their side to a 69-point thrashing of Essendon in the Gather Round.
(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)
The star pair racked up career-high disposal tallies and were the stand-outs in a long list of contributors for the Power in their 17.9 (111) to 6.6 (42) victory at Adelaide Oval on Friday night.
According to reports of Nine’s Footy Classified, Carr did not nominate for the vacant Richmond job last year because he has been assured he will get the Port gig when Hinkley stands aside at the end of 2025.
Club chair David Koch said on the ABC on the weekend that Hinkley was “really supportive of Josh developing into a senior coach”.
“We have extraordinarily high regard for (Carr). You know what sort of bloke he is. He’s got a way, he’s worked at other organisations, he knows the Port Adelaide way, and we put a lot of effort into coaching development,” Koch added.
“We would rather train up from (inside the club) than outside. I’m not sure if a lot of clubs do it, but we have a development coach for coaches.”
with AAP
Frodo
Roar Rookie
You're not real quick, are ya? Zero comprehension skills and the logic of brick!
Law Talking Guy
Roar Rookie
Is that all you've got? Dictatorial behaviour in a clearly functioning liberal democracy? If you don't like it, vote for someone else.
Law Talking Guy
Roar Rookie
not mine, son. Yours. I'm not the one who disagrees with it, and disagrees it with a laughably predictable "control" rubbish. If you don't like it, emigrate. A vast majority of the Australian public support it. How do i know? Neither government is changing the status quo.
Irie
Roar Rookie
As if "society" is either an excuse or an argument to embrace dictatorial behaviour....
Law Talking Guy
Roar Rookie
You agreed with him. You have liked any post defending Finlayson. I'm happy with three weeks. I'm sure you're upset though.
Irie
Roar Rookie
Just because "society" wants to embrace totalitarianism through speech control doesn't mean I have to like or accept it. If you do, that's your grave to dig
Law Talking Guy
Roar Rookie
Says the buffoon who tries to equate gay discrimination to being short. Perhaps you should research on the amount of murders that took place because someone called someone else a f'got. Off you go now, buffoon. Back to the gogo bars for you. I presume that's the only action you get.
Bangkokpussey
Roar Rookie
To say its more offensive to a heterosexual is about as ridiculous as a comment gets.
Law Talking Guy
Roar Rookie
Hahaha. No doubt there is height based discrimination, but you are still coming from this from a genuinely bigoted and dim perspective. It was never been illegal to be too tall or short in Australia. Like I said, some people are beyond education. Read through the posts, I've tolerated and debated contrary views. Just not those from people being deliberately obtuse. Comparing being short to being gay is bigoted and only a fool would try it. I'm not assaulting your character. It's a staggeringly accurate depiction. You suffer from below average intelligence.
Law Talking Guy
Roar Rookie
You're just basically wanting the retain the right to say what you want to say as a POC. Society doesn't work like that anymore.
Law Talking Guy
Roar Rookie
You've just seen in the NRL what you've said is fundamentally false and horrifically outdated. Spencer Leniu thought he could hide behind him being a POC as an excuse to say what he said. His entire defence was built around emphasising that repeatedly. He got 8 weeks for holding that view. Society has gone beyond that now. Whether it's right or wrong is a different story. But an AFL or NRL tribunal is not the place to test it.
Irie
Roar Rookie
Even when a black person says it about themselves, or their friend/s? As a "POC" words are only offensive if you let them be
Bangkokpussey
Roar Rookie
In nearly all research their is evidence of workplace discrimination by height. Your ad hominem comments on my character and your assumption based on nothing but your opinion, that Daniel is not hurt by such comments amazes me you could be connected in any way to a legal profession where critical thinking is a prerequisite, as your "non de plume" suggests. Your obvious inability to tolerate a view that is contrary to your own further shows how opinion is valued more than fact and how the erosion of free speech and truth grows unchecked these days in modern society. Try the link, you might learn something based on research rather than just your own baseless opinion. "Ignorance is bliss, tis foley to be wise". (Thomas Gray) https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20220825-height-discrimination-how-heightism-affects-careers
Irie
Roar Rookie
Being short (and male) in the dating world is discriminated against....
Charlie Keegan
Roar Guru
Yup in amateur leagues it would be a thousand times worse.
Frodo
Roar Rookie
There you go again. Putting words in my mouth that never came out of it. Law Talking Guy? Pffft. Wanna Be Woke Guy more like it. And hey, he got 3 weeks! Does that make you wrong?
Frodo
Roar Rookie
Exactly. Hitting them with the biggest stick you can find may ven be counter productive.
XI
Roar Guru
Yeah it's a eh. Not surprised considering the experiences I had umpiring
dargerovitch
Roar Rookie
Gave you a like for your comment , but please get yourself a diff. screen name. That one you're using is totally off , in fact just as bad as Finlayson's slur.
Barb Dwyer
Roar Rookie
One of the great minds of the twelfth century.