At some point, a line has to be drawn in the sand at the Bulldogs.
Quite frankly, it’s grown pretty tiresome, watching the same rollercoaster that never quite marries up to even weekly expectations, and the same divisive reaction that comes from it.
Clearly, there’s a disconnect. Something’s a little off with the players, something’s a little off with the coach, something’s a little off tactically and something’s a little off with the board.
There are Luke Beveridge loyalists, there are Luke Beveridge haters and there are independent observers who are simply befuddled by the tricolour-donning Dogs.
We all know the story, in fact, we’ve been through it multiple times before, and the Bulldogs still find themselves stuck in an almost self-enveloped patch of quicksand.
No one has quite been decisive in recent seasons. Everything just sort of ticks along with silence, almost like a subscription with a forgotten auto-renewal.
The Bulldogs aren’t a bad team, but they aren’t a good team. They tease with the bottom half of the eight. Sometimes they make it, and sometimes they don’t.
A month into 2024, they have two dominating victories, they were smashed once.
Gather Round’s Geelong game was a real chance to secure a third win, which would’ve been huge given they’re not playing fantastic footy. They snatched at chances, while the Cats were able to hold on with exhausted legs. They played in nearly biblical rain five days earlier.
No team relies on its star players quite like the Bulldogs, which is never a recipe for success. Tom Liberatore played one of the greatest inside midfield games of all time against the Cats, Marcus Bontempelli was a dominant figure, Adam Treloar got plenty of the ball, and it nearly got the Bulldogs over the line. Nearly.
Offensively, it’s all driven by brilliant performances, rather than a machine-like level of reliability from a group of players playing their roles well.
Beveridge has made an intentional tactical switch, Aaron Naughton’s playing the traditional centre half-forward role and pushing higher up the ground, while Jamarra Ugle-Hagan’s staying closer to goal.
The development of Sam Darcy was sorely needed as a conduit between the two, and a genuine second ruck option.
Also, Naughton has just four goals in four games, while Ugle-Hagan has just six. Sorely, sorely needed Darcy has been.
The move was meant to unlock space and different avenues to goal with Naughton coming inside 50 from a different angle – but quite simply, 10 goals from the two star key forwards isn’t good.
Cody Weightman has been great in a couple of different ways to start the season but again, his six-goal haul was an out-of-the-box performance that really got the Bulldogs home, not something to bank on constantly.
Defensively, Liam Jones and Ed Richards are the only two reliable cogs. Buku Khamis has been pretty solid, but the moment they can let him play as an interceptor rather than a key defender is where we’ll see him really start to blossom.
There’s been a random rotation of all sorts of players off half-back and precisely none of them have really caught the eye as meaningful contributors.
When you watch the Bulldogs play, it’s almost as if they’re split into three different parts of the ground and coached as such, whereas the best teams in the league have this whole-ground flow, this commitment from a playing group to attack and defend together and reap the rewards, just as they’ll suffer the consequences together.
Marcus Bontempelli competes with Tom Stewart. (Photo by Mark Brake/Getty Images)
Is it the players? Is it the coach? Probably a bit of both, although it’s probably time we stopped criticising Beveridge for failing to extract all he can out of such a talented list – maybe they’re not so talented after all.
The numbers always look nice on paper for the team, they average the second-most disposals, the most marks, the most clearances – if Beveridge was a fantasy coach, he’d win the main prize every season.
They tackled more last year and didn’t focus on uncontested marking as much; increasing free marks indicates a desire to control the game.
In order to control the game, you want to have players with the skills to run into pockets of space and execute difficult, angular kicks.
Two of the players that spring to mind as elite players in that sense are Jack Macrae and Caleb Daniel, perfectly suited to a retentive style that hypothetically, requires targets to be hit and eyes to be lowered.
Now in their limited opportunities this season, they’ve been poor. Whether that’s because they’ve dropped off, or because they’ve been treated poorly by the coach feels like a bit of the chicken and egg scenario. Although as a subscriber to the theory that “form is temporary, class is permanent”, maybe the latter is more applicable.
Maybe the biggest knock-on Beveridge at the moment and indeed in recent seasons, is this apparent obsession with hitching his wagon to unorthodox recruits, whether they be of mature age, delisted by previous clubs, off different rookie lists or simply state league performers.
The very best coaches set up a system and cherry-pick players that can slot in perfectly, even if the outsider doesn’t recognise it at first. That’s what the Richmond dynasty was built on, Melbourne’s success, even the Bulldogs back in 2016 had that going for them.
The 2024 edition of the Bulldogs has no system. It feels at times that Beveridge is just picking players he had previously had a vested interest in recruiting, over established players who seemingly don’t fit his ideals.
Let’s not forget Daniel was one of the smartest and most damaging half-backs in the league in a very different way to most, yet he was the one chosen to fill the clear deficiency on the inside and has played as a forward flanker and sub.
Three-time All-Australian Macrae was hardly failing as a footballer either.
Of course, the loyalists would indicate that you can’t have it both ways – you can’t criticise Beveridge for being stubborn and then criticise when he changes things too.
But the coach has always been one to throw the magnets around to varying levels of success yet nearly a decade into the role, all anyone really wants is consistency.
Naturally, this long into a business relationship, burnout occurs.
That’s why the blame for this average experience overall is shared across all the internal stakeholders at the club.
Beveridge is trying his best, you’d trust that the players are trying their best and the board is trying to support the best they can.
Again though, there’s some sort of disconnect at play here, and the team’s enigmatic charm of Beveridge’s early reign has well and truly worn off.
How will 2024 play out? They’ll come out and obliterate some teams, they’ll fall apart against others, they’ll be around the mark for finals and it’ll be a mystery as to how that’ll go.
At some points though, the line to the rollercoaster isn’t as long, people grow tired of it and there are more innovative, appealing rides to line up for. It’s not the attraction its creators think it is, and it’s not bringing in the success they feel it deserves.
Something’s got to give at the Bulldogs because treading water for years on end isn’t fair to Luke Beveridge, his players and the club’s fans.
Ace
Roar Rookie
PD from an outsider's point of view I have to say I like Buku and O'Donnell What I didn't like was Treloar's soft efforts Or a couple of VFL types ..you may have mentioned one And a truly off night for English. Old Goldy showed him the way on the night The dogs certainly disappoint me as I have a soft spot for them I also like Don Freo's comments about the Bont being CHB and delivering offensively...could extend his career ....if nothing else
Ace
Roar Rookie
Dem, your post yesterday about Dogs stuck in mediocrity could not have been more prophetic They do their best to prove your point of view
Realist
Roar Rookie
Freo always wins in donseyland.
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
They'll need to rebound after last night.
Charlie Keegan
Roar Guru
Yeah that’s fair he’s very athletic, he was able to outpace smaller opponents really well. I think he should watch people of a similar size like Mac Andrew and Nik cox and pick up their behaviours
Virgil
Roar Rookie
The question for me is how did they not have a 5 goal lead at half time? They absolutely dominated the second quarter and had nothing to show for it. The forward structure is not delivering.
Pumping Dougie
Roar Guru
I thought he did a decent job last night - yeah much more suited to the third tall role with O'Donnell providing the physicality. A couple of times Buku was exposed but due to teammates laziness in not running back in defence (e.g. Brambles) and uncertainly trying to cover two at once, so not his fault.
Pumping Dougie
Roar Guru
True but we have plenty in the backline who do that - Richards, Dale, JJ.
Charlie Keegan
Roar Guru
I paid particular attention to him last night and he is very much a third tall you can’t ask him to play directly on an opponent
Charlie Keegan
Roar Guru
He’s on the money
Charlie Keegan
Roar Guru
It’s discipline they gave away three fifty metre penalties last night and that is something they can control.
Macca
Roar Rookie
Yep Don- no excuses
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
No excuses. That game was not won by Carlton.
Macca
Roar Rookie
Yeah Don, I am the one being silly by pointing out the silly things like the score and the ladder. Good teams don’t look for excuses, they look to fix the things they can control
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
You didn't win. It was given to you by an umpire. You are not undefeated. Freo defeated you. The rest is your silly, "But...but.. but..." stuff.
Macca
Roar Rookie
I have acknowledged the blues got lucky on the mark, just not the other 6 you have claimed. I have also said that had Jackson not tapped the ball to exactly the wrong spot, or had Treacy taken an easy mark earlier the mark would never have come to be. It’s easy to blame others instead of looking inward but you never grow
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
As does Alex Stretton's arrangement. You'd have seen Freo in front until the howler acknowledged by all...but you. Denial.
Macca
Roar Rookie
No matter how many times I watch it Don, the final score remains the same
Rowdy
Roar Rookie
It’s good to hear fan’s of other clubs giving their team a bit of a rip.
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
You have enough of them. Get Bevo to give me a call; I can help.