With their defence and a trade steal firing, the Cats lead the ladder. The next three weeks will tell us if they really deserve to

By Cameron Rose / Expert

Has there ever been a team more “quietly” unbeaten and on top of the ladder, like Geelong this year? The Cats are a game and percentage clear of second spot, but you wouldn’t know it based on the commentary surrounding the AFL over the first seven rounds.

Sydney and GWS have captured the most notices as early premiership favourites, Carlton have made headlines, Port have shown their usual capacity to dazzle and disappoint, while last year’s grand finalists Collingwood and Brisbane have mostly been in the news for the wrong reasons.

Partly, the ridiculous stop-start nature of the season is to blame. Four teams had played two games before half the competition had played one. Sporadic bye rounds have been littered throughout the early part of the year. It’s been hard to get a handle on who sits where.

Also, Geelong have played five of the bottom seven teams, on a ladder that finally shows us all clubs having played an equal amount of games. The six teams the Cats have beaten have won only nine games between them.

The next three weeks will tell us a lot more about where Chris Scott’s men sit, taking on Carlton, Melbourne and Port Adelaide, all expected to be in premiership contention, or at least a threat to be there on preliminary final weekend.

Geelong are no doubt a good side, but they’re not 6-0 good. They are yet to put together a true four quarter performance, even against weaker sides. What they have been able to do is withstand some strong opposition pushes late in games, and still gone onto secure victory. At various times they were challenged by St Kilda, Adelaide, the Western Bulldogs, and even Hawthorn to some extent.

Last year, when finishing 12th, they were losing those games.

As is usually the case, the Cats game is built around defence. They have a great mix of hybrid players that can play tall or small, intercept, mark, play tight when need be, are effective when the ball is on the ground, and can run and rebound. Zach Guthrie really became a player across 2022-23, and he’s gone to another level this year.

The defence needs to be strong, because Geelong are still getting well beaten, and sometimes obliterated, in clearances. Patrick Dangerfield has missed three games, and Cam Guthrie hasn’t played yet, so a lot falls to those two. Tanner Bruhn has been cracking in hard, and it’s worth remembering that he’s still only 21, while Brandon Parfitt has recaptured some form at just the right time after two years in the wilderness where he was often the sub.

Support your AFL team in style – check out The Oodie! They’ve got Adult Oodies for all 18 teams as well as Kids Oodies and even Dog Oodies available in selected teams.  Made from the softest, premium fabrics they are the comfiest memorabilia you’ll ever wear!  #GetYourOodieOn

Bruhn and Parfitt are good pointers to the Cats depth. Tom Atkins finished second in the best and fairest last year, yet has been squeezed out of the midfield due to the emergence of those two. Jack Bowes and teenager Jhye Clark have been getting games. The young ruckman Toby Conway has been given a couple of looks. Other youngsters like Connor O’Sullivan, Shannon Neale and Mitch Knevitt, have had minor gametime.

The forward-line is functioning very well, without anything particularly scintillating from Jeremy Cameron or Tom Hawkins. The latter hasn’t kicked a goal in his last two games, and while the former had a day out against North Melbourne, he’s been pushing further upfield to be that link player.

Ollie Henry will prove to be one of the biggest steals in trade history, it’s completely unforgiveable that Collingwood let him go for pick 28. He’s been good for two goals a game since he arrived last year, and is the perfect emerging young tall as Cameron and Hawkins advance in years.

Oliver Henry of the Cats celebrates with fans during the round nine AFL match between Brisbane Lions and Geelong Cats at The Gabba, on April 20, 2024, in Brisbane, Australia. (Photo by Albert Perez/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Ollie Dempsey has been a revelation, and while a very different player to Gryan Miers, he does have similar attributes in his work rate and good decision making. Tyson Stengle has been looking more like his All Australian form from 2022, rather than the disappointment of last season.

It’s easy enough to look good against minnows like North Melbourne, Hawthorn and St Kilda, or a side that’s badly out-of-form like Adelaide, but the Geelong have used their soft opening to the season to manage their team, get players into form, and get their confidence up.

The next phase of their season starts now – before May is out, they’ll have played Carlton and Melbourne at the MCG, hosted Port and GWS at GMHBA Stadium, and also been diverted up to Darwin against a tricky Gold Coast outfit. We shouldn’t be surprised if they still hold onto top spot by then.

Essendon Bombers
v
North Melbourne Kangaroos
1.05
10.00
AFL : Head To Head
Sun, 19 May 2024, 13:10

Port Adelaide Power
v
Hawthorn Hawks
1.14
5.75
AFL : Head To Head
Sun, 19 May 2024, 15:20

West Coast Eagles
v
Melbourne Demons
5.75
1.14
AFL : Head To Head
Sun, 19 May 2024, 18:20

* Odds Correct At Time Of Posting. Check PlayUp Website For Latest Odds
What are you prepared to lose today?
For free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au

The Crowd Says:

2024-04-27T10:07:53+00:00

Bangkokpussey

Roar Rookie


I remember saying to Peter T.S. when Henry was drafted by Collingwood he would be at Geelong at the end of his draft contract. I think he only play around 5 games in his second season at Collingwood. Of course one of the reasons that Geelong is consistent is it has many players from its local area whereas other teams have little to no players from their immediate area and rely on players from further afield. If my memories serves me correctly two of Carltons best are from the Geelong Falcons. I think Warpol and Parish are two others. You're welcome. Yes Don, sorry I didn't mention Freo.

2024-04-25T22:35:11+00:00

Cinderella's Big Score

Roar Rookie


I've noted that there are different views on this, and that many Collingwood supporters would say that Tom Mitchell was more than adequate compensation for losing Henry. I am on the other side of the argument, even before he left I was saying that Henry could be the next Royce Hart. We will probably never no who got the better of the deal for another ten years. Where I take issue with the author of this piece is his false narrative that Collingwood unforgivably traded Henry to Geelong for Pick 28. His facts about the trade are untrue, and therefore his inference about Collingwood's negligence is equally untrue. It is just a bit of Collingwood-hating strategically inserted into an article aimed at Carlton and Geelong supporters.

2024-04-25T21:39:22+00:00

Dazzler

Roar Rookie


Thank you! At least someone has a clue here! Obviously , Cameron Rose doesn't!

2024-04-25T21:36:29+00:00

Dazzler

Roar Rookie


The Pies got value out of that deal. The Cats had to give up a player that was a higher draft pick to Henry the previous year(which the Pies got Tom Mitchell(and a flag)for), as well as pick28!

2024-04-25T21:33:11+00:00

Dazzler

Roar Rookie


How was it wrong for Pies to get TOM MITCHELL and a flag the following year because of that?

2024-04-25T21:29:16+00:00

Dazzler

Roar Rookie


The Cats gave up more than they should have had to for Ollie Henry! They ALSO traded Cooper Stephens(Pick#16, 2019Draft) to Hawks in a package deal that got Pies TOM MITCHELL! Ollie Henry was pick #17 in the 2020Draft, so Cooper had and extra year of development and was 1 pick higher than Ollie!

2024-04-25T21:19:12+00:00

Dazzler

Roar Rookie


Pick 28 and Cooper Stephens(Pick#16, 2019Draft), who was traded to Hawks which helped the Pies to get TOM MITCHELL(and a flag), was definitely not 'unders'!

2024-04-25T20:56:12+00:00

Dazzler

Roar Rookie


Cameron Rose is no expert if he can't see past the Melbourne mob(or one-eyed Pie supporter) mentality and at least recognise that Ollie Henry was traded for more than just pick 28. The Cats ALSO traded Cooper Stephens(Pick #16, 2019Draft) to Hawks to seal the deal to get Pies TOM MITCHELL, which helped the Pies to win a flag!

2024-04-25T03:14:43+00:00

Cinderella's Big Score

Roar Rookie


And it should be corrected.

2024-04-25T03:13:54+00:00

Cinderella's Big Score

Roar Rookie


Why did you say that Collingwood let Ollie Henry go for pick 28? This is a falsehood.

2024-04-25T01:14:20+00:00

sven

Roar Rookie


yep hes the roars resident fount of wisdom .... just ask him :silly: ....

2024-04-24T23:41:25+00:00

WCE

Roar Rookie


Goes the intellect line in the comments section on a sports website lmfao

2024-04-24T21:50:52+00:00

Cinderella's Big Score

Roar Rookie


No, I've never expressed confidence about the pies this year, you must have me confused with somebody else. I think Geelong, Carlton, maybe Swans, maybe GWS, maybe Melbourne. Collingwood surprised me last year. They could still surprise me this year but I think they are only an outside chance at this stage.

2024-04-24T13:18:04+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Lewis? Huh?

2024-04-24T13:02:32+00:00

deadly demon

Roar Rookie


don hasn't forgotten Freo defeated carlton this year tho nowhere in factual history can I find that. mmmmm

2024-04-24T12:37:49+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


I had some intense words with Pete the Scribe on the matter. I probably think that it was a club effort to retain a talent on the cheap. I agree with what you said below, Cats were always going to bring him home. Maybe TDK, the same. Interesting about your confidence about the Pies this year. April is the month of fools predicting end of season form and finals forms. But, Melbourne, Brisbane and Pies need to improve greatly.

2024-04-24T11:38:47+00:00

sven

Roar Rookie


ah the ol' don freo subterfuge 101 , when shown to be full of it (yet again) claim to be using irony & nuance ... then claim superior intellect ... to match your level of intellect would require frontal lobotomy ...

2024-04-24T11:27:51+00:00

Windrince

Roar Rookie


Both in great form at the moment

2024-04-24T11:24:01+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


If kolonskopy played on him, I would have an heart attack before the final siren.

2024-04-24T11:22:04+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Don’t listen to Lewis’ silliness. It is silly to bring up WA or their few exported players on a discussion about Geelong’s playing style. Some might even say tedious. Lyonesque?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar