Revisiting my five fearless predictions before the Test summer

By Patrick Effeney / Editor

Before a ball was bowled in anger this Test match summer, I made a series of bold (read: foolhardy) predictions based on what would happen in the series.

In a tip of the cap to transparency, I thought it worth the time to revisit these predictions and see how I did.

Now considering there were five of them, I’m going to give myself a score out of five. I’m also going to take some serious liberties with my own assessment of my work, and I expect it to be the task of some particularly ravenous Roarers to take those gentle calculations and replace them with much more severe stuff. In fact, I look forward to it.

So let’s get to it.

Prediction 1: The 4-0 streak will continue
I basically said that Australia would whoop India, continuing the fine tradition of these two Test-playing nations of 4-0 results on home soil. If they didn’t do that, I said, they would win 3-0 with a draw in Adelaide.

Well, I was half right.

Australia did whoop India, and had they not been denied twice in Melbourne and Sydney by time and time alone, it would have been a 4-0 result.

But read the scorebook, Effeney – it clearly says 2-0. I’ll take my medicine, try not to place too much blame on placid wickets and award myself half a point.

Prediction 2: Peter Siddle will be dropped before the end of the series
I’ll have to give myself a big tick here. Sidds was largely ineffective at the Gabba, and was sadly dropped.

There were plenty of reasons postured for his disappointment. From a lack of sausage in his diet to his ripe old age of 30, the notable lack of Peter Siddle’s pace escaped nobody, and has led to him being firmly on the outer in the Australian setup, now behind Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood in the stacked fast-bowling pile.

It’s not a place a veteran bowler who plays the role of the honest toiler wants to be.

I want to see that snarl back. That anger, that aggression, that hatred of batsmen.

I tend to agree with Jason Gillespie’s assessment – Sidds needs to bowl fast, hit the deck and possibly hit batsmen. Come on, Pete!

Prediction 3: Everyone will miss DRS
Despite the lack of clangers, with most decisions at least in the realm of understanding of most folks, I’m still going to give myself a tick here. I think we all did miss it.

We would probably all agree that whatever rub of the green there was went firmly against the Indians for much of the series. And still, Aussies protested hard that if we have the technology available, we should use it.

Half of that feeling comes from a desire to see correct decisions made, but a large portion of the emotion also comes from the fact that only one nation defies the use of the system, and that happened to be the nation we were playing.

So I’m going to give myself a tick – 2.5 out of 3 so far, but I have a feeling this is where things start to go downhill…

Prediction 4: Virat Kohli will struggle
You can understand where I was coming from with this one. Sure, we weren’t playing at the WACA, but surely the MCG and SCG would have nice green tinges on Day 1, and the Gabba would be fearsomely quick throughout.

Instead our groundsmen dished up roads that Tony Abbott would be proud to serve up to the good people of Australia who crave infrastructure.

I said at the time, “Kohli is a fine batsman, with the best pedigree of any player on this tour for India. But I still think he’s going to struggle against the pace and bounce of Johnson, and the persistent bounce and seam of Harris.”

All of that remains true, except that Mitchell Johnson and Ryan Harris didn’t terrify anyone except the umpire at the non-striker’s end, who had to constantly duck and weave from the barrage of well-struck boundaries flying in their direction.

I get a big fat 0 for this one.

Prediction 5: Michael Clarke will recapture his best form
Look, I’m going to go easy on myself here. He did capture his best form in Adelaide. He also recaptured a hamstring injury, which ruled him out of the final three Tests, leaving Steve Smith in his place.

Proxy Michael Clarke then went on and scored three more centuries, on top of his own in Adelaide. So it was a great series for Australian skippers, but not necessarily in the way I predicted.

Do I give myself any points here? Probably not… maybe half. Let’s go with half.

So there you have it. I’m scoring myself 3 out of 5.

What do you reckon Roarers? How many liberties am I taking here?

The Crowd Says:

2015-01-15T03:52:48+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


A number of bowlers are in better form this season though. Siddle is averaging something like 13 with the ball.

2015-01-15T02:08:55+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


C'mon mate - I gave you a point for Clarke. Thinking of taking a half point back though for DRS. Comments here indicate not 'everyone' missed it. 1.5.

2015-01-14T13:12:41+00:00

13th Man

Roar Pro


Behrendorff for me cant argue with form. Pattinson is looking good though.

2015-01-14T11:46:16+00:00

Matt

Roar Rookie


Tests were rescheduled so Adelaide was the first test/ I'm guessing when he made the predictions that the Gabba was still the 1st test.

AUTHOR

2015-01-14T06:06:21+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


Where does the other half go?

2015-01-14T05:01:22+00:00

Adsa

Guest


No, no no, half wrong!!

2015-01-14T04:36:20+00:00

spruce moose

Guest


I'll give you 2.5/5 (which is not bad to be honest). I don't believe Clarke recaptured his form. A Clarke century at Adelaide is more predictable than sunrise.

2015-01-14T04:28:35+00:00

Peter

Roar Rookie


Yep not missed at all. However if Billy Bowden were umpiring Australia and India would have recalled their ambassadors by now.

2015-01-14T04:26:51+00:00

Peter

Roar Rookie


Classy player Kohli. If he were Australian he'd have been dropped by now, as happened numerous times with Phil Hughes.

2015-01-14T03:43:41+00:00

Chris

Guest


i did not once miss drs. thought it was brilliant that stuff started and ended with the umpire. and then started again with jingoistic australian and indian commentators and 'journalists' and journalists cause that is just wonderful to read and write about.

2015-01-14T03:11:53+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


I was on holidays. We let the hacks have a turn instead . . .

2015-01-14T02:10:29+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I didn't miss DRS at all. It slows the game down interminably. I can't remember any more or less howlers this season compared to the previous seasons where we did have it. I would love it to stay away for good.

AUTHOR

2015-01-14T02:09:42+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


Correct. I thought they would be juicy, and Mitchell Johnson favoured. Unfortunately it wasn't the case. I still have no idea why.

AUTHOR

2015-01-14T02:08:46+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


I note that you were neither fearless or predictive before this Test summer, O'Connell.

AUTHOR

2015-01-14T02:07:30+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


Tough school The Barry. You always were my harshest marker. The Siddle prediction was made without fear. It mightn't have been controversial, but it was a prediction. He could have killed it in Adelaide, but he didn't. I don't know how you can knock off half a point for the only one I got spot on! I'll still take 2/5. Ryan O'Connell always fares worse.

AUTHOR

2015-01-14T02:04:41+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


Pattinson for mine. I dote on him like Geoff Lemon does a certain Indian batsman ;)

2015-01-14T01:52:33+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I'm with you...not having the game held up for endless replays on decisions that come down to half a millimetre based on technology that can't guarantee that degree of accuracy was a nice change. I think this series showed that good umpiring is way better than DRS. There's a lot to be said for accepting the umpires decision and getting on with it.

2015-01-14T01:48:00+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Way too many liberties Patrick. :-) 4-0 is 4-0. If India won 4-0 would that be half right? 0 points. Siddle prediction was correct but not 'fearless' or 'bold'. 1/2 a point. I didn't miss DRS. 'Everyone' is unquantifiable. 1/2 a point. Kohli killed it regardless of pitches, decisions, etc. 0 points. Clarke did discover his best - even if it was briefly. I think you've dudded yourself here - I'm happy to give you a point. 2 outta 5 ain't bad.

2015-01-14T01:32:21+00:00

slurpy

Roar Rookie


I actually preferred having no DRS. might have to move to india.

2015-01-14T00:11:26+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Superb spin, JB, I've noted this all down for future use.. ;-)

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar