Five talking points from Melbourne Storm vs Brisbane Broncos NRL preliminary final

By Scott Pryde / Expert

The Melbourne Storm have cruised through to the NRL grand final on the back of a 30-0 victory over the Brisbane Broncos in the first preliminary final. Here are my talking points from the match.

Score points or the Storm will strangle you
If there was ever a better example of a team failing to score points and being punished for it, I’d like to hear about it.

The Broncos bombed so many scoring opportunities in the first half. Full credit to Melbourne, because their defence was restrictive, scrambled well and covered a lot of ground, but the Broncos shouldn’t have gone into halftime down 8-0.

They should have had at least one try on the board, and in all probability more. Corey Oates bombed an almost certain one on the wing, Tautau Moga died with the ball twice when it looked like they had an overlap on the left, and they could have had others.

Of course, it wasn’t just their terrible execution. Melbourne’s defence made them panic, and feel like every opportunity had to be taken – which frankly, it does against Craig Bellamy’s side.

But the Broncos played like they were under pressure from the opening minutes, and it was evident in their execution when they had the ball.

The Storm then went into halftime on the back of Josh Addo-Carr’s long-range try and dominated the second 40 minutes.

Put simply, score points and make the most of your opportunities or the Storm will make you pay – big time.

Melbourne showed vulnerability for the second straight match – will it strike them in the grand final?
After trailing at halftime against the Eels, it was important for the Storm to make a statement in the first half of their preliminary final and be dominant during the first half, living up to the mantra that they are indeed the best team in the competition.

They were anything but though. Errors marred their first half as the Broncos dominated territory and possession, despite not being able to score.

If you were to only look at the scoreboard, you’d put a big tick next to the Storm and tell them there was nothing to work on.

Uncharacteristic would be the word you’d use to describe the first half from Melbourne, but even worse than that, it resembled times of last year’s finals series when they simply didn’t look themselves – and history will tell us how that one played out.

From Billy Slater dropping the ball twice, to Josh Addo-Carr making a simple error, their forwards dropping it and Cameron Smith putting the ball over the dead ball line from kicks a couple of times – in total, the Broncos had four seven-tackle sets in the first 40 – it’s things that will concern coach Craig Bellamy.

There is plenty to work on for the Storm, but surely it won’t strike again next week? They were a lot better in the second half, and some will say it could be put down to a week off and a bit of rust – but it’s concerning.

Three seasons of heartbreak for the Broncos
When Wayne Bennett returned to the Broncos in 2015, there was a three-year timeline set as the benchmark for the Broncos to win a premiership.

Well, here we are three years later and it’s been three years of oh so close, yet oh so far. Of course, 2015 saw the Broncos exceed anyone’s expectations as they made the grand final and looked to have it won before, you know, Johnathan Thurston happened.

2016 wasn’t sensational for the Broncos as they finished fifth, beat the Titans in a controversy-marred game, then bombed out at the hands of the Cowboys (again).

Unfortunately, it’s been more of the same this year. As much as the Broncos finished third position and that deserves credit, they were never truly setting the world on fire. Their attack was brilliant, defence good in patches, but they didn’t string together 80 minutes of high-quality footy all that often.

It showed during the finals as they lost to the Roosters, battled past the Panthers and were ultimately brought down by the Storm.

With the losses of Adam Blair, Ben Hunt Herman Ese’ese and Tautau Moga at the end of this season, it gives Wayne Bennett a chance to reshape the roster. Three trips to the finals isn’t a bad run in anyone’s book, but for a side who promised to be premiership-worthy in three years, the clock is now ticking in overtime.

Craig Bellamy is the best coach in rugby league
Seven finals trips in 12 years. That stat is insane in a 16-team competition with a salary cap to enforce a ‘level playing field’ – and yeah, quotation marks because it’s obviously not.

But, whichever way you look at it, the Storm are the ultimate professionals, and who knows where they would be without Bellamy at the helm.

He is emotional in the coaches box, but brilliant. He showed it again last night as he turned the Storm out of a first half slump and into a second half rampage. He did it against the Eels as well a fortnight ago.

Bellamy managed to constantly turn players who were fringe first graders at other clubs into great players at his own, and while Cronk, Slater and Smith have a lot to do with it, if the Storm get over the line next Sunday, they can turn and thank Bellamy as one.

Billy Slater will make all the difference next Sunday
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again – the Storm would have won the 2016 grand final if Billy Slater had of been on the field.

He is the best fullback in the game bar none. There is no one that’s even close to the veteran Storm, Queensland and Australian fullback. From defensive organisation to match-winning plays in attack and acceleration that he has held strong on, even this far into his career, he has it all.

While Cameron Smith and Cooper Cronk are legends in their own right, Slater is a match-winner. He is a guy who can pop up from nowhere and make something happen. He is always there to latch onto offloads, up in support – and that’s why he scored a double.

The difference between the Storm with Slater and without Slater is that they can win coming from behind with Slater. Cronk and Smith are great at controlling the game, but it’s an instinct they tended to lose in 2016 – coming from behind to win.

Sure, he made a couple of defensive errors in the first half, but even then, he was close to the best on ground. If you’re a young fullback and not closely studying the game of Slater, then I don’t understand what you’re doing.

Slater is the best fullback in the game, and you just watch as he does something miraculous next Sunday to ensure the Storm force their way over the line.

Roarers, what did you make of the game?

The Crowd Says:

2017-09-25T09:56:42+00:00

Eddie Otto

Roar Guru


The fact they led 8-0 at halftime shows what a good side the Storm are. They made a number of fundamental errors and conceded 60% of possession but still managed to go into halftime up 8-0. To be honest I think Wayne Bennett did about all he could with that roster at Brisbane this year to get them a Top 4 finish and a Prelim Final berth. They are a superstar short of a Premiership side and I'm not convinced they will be bette next season. Jack bird is a good player but it all be interesting to see how it works out with Milford alongside him. Brisbane need a real general in the halves to put it all together for mine, and I don't think Bird is the answer.

2017-09-23T12:28:08+00:00

doogs

Guest


all good Rellum. You are saying he could pass more. That's fair enough

2017-09-23T09:48:50+00:00

Nico

Guest


No question Bellamy is one of the best coaches but that stat that he's coached Melbourne to 7 gf s in 12 years needs to be qualified with the fact that 4 of them came when Melbourne were over the salary cap. That leaves 3 legitimate gf appearances for 1 win. To put things in perspective Hasler and Bennett have both won 2 in that time, with Hasler managing an additional 2 losing appearances

2017-09-23T09:23:06+00:00

Kurt S

Roar Pro


Melbourne showed they are vunerable. Brisbane could well have been well ahead at half time but they bombed every opportunity, took terrible options on the 5th tackle after the first 15 minutes and gave Melbourne a leg up on as they scored their initial points off Broncos errors. All credit to Melbourne to get it together in the second half and run away with it. What was Brisbane thinking by continuously running down the left corridor? Robert James must be peeved. Melbourne can b beaten, does the winner of the Roosters- Cowboys have the discipline to take the game to them?

2017-09-23T08:53:16+00:00

muzzamite

Roar Rookie


Great game, fast, plenty of footy, best team won. It is time however for drug, alcohol testing before commentry. Andrew John's just ridiculous for 80 minutes

2017-09-23T08:53:14+00:00

muzzamite

Roar Rookie


Great game, fast, plenty of footy, best team won. It is time however for drug, alcohol testing before commentry. Andrew John's just ridiculous for 80 minutes

2017-09-23T08:53:10+00:00

muzzamite

Roar Rookie


Great game, fast, plenty of footy, best team won. It is time however for drug, alcohol testing before commentry. Andrew John's just ridiculous for 80 minutes

2017-09-23T08:26:47+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


Can't be on the field after the 4th tackle. Consistently breaks that

2017-09-23T08:01:59+00:00

Dean

Guest


The scoreline flattered the Broncos. Id go as far as to say that Smith was prepared to gamble on his kicks going over the dead ball line. Probably knew the Storm could defend against that happening. I didnt see him looking overly concerned with that happening even once. Come half time, the Storm had spent that whole half defending their try line, but it was the Broncos who went into the sheds both physically and mentally drained. Tired players make lazy decisions in defence and it showed itself to be true in regards to the Broncos in the second half. Personally, I was surprised the Storm didnt put 50 on the Broncos after the half time break. As for Blairs thuggery on Cronk, he does it in nearly every game he plays. Can always be relied on to give cheap penalties away. The better team won on the night. I was just surprised how easily they did it.

2017-09-23T07:49:45+00:00

Zedman

Roar Rookie


As i said Langer is the best and has been doing it the longest, i was barracking for the Broncs last night and am disappointed they didn't go better. To label someone a hater because they don't agree with you is a lost argument. Check the rules, you may learn something.

2017-09-23T07:36:16+00:00

thomas c

Guest


Boyd was a problem and they brought benji once they'd lost all the momentum. A couple of the tries were probably due to lacking boyd's positional play and organisation (and broke the camel's back). It's the result you should expect when you field inexperienced 6,7,9 and an injured 1 against the best spine ever assembled. Melbourne are great, but if the broncs hadn't butchered a couple tries, they could have at least applied a little pressure.

2017-09-23T06:54:56+00:00

Greg Ambrose

Guest


All players need to be trained to set up their supports. I saw Moga play some great games this year but it is crucial to be able to put your winger over for a try. I had a read of an article on google from the SMH in around 2012 I think where someone had done a thorough analysis of the top coaches. Back then he concluded that the top coaches were Bellamy and Warren Ryan. He claimed that Bennett was good but over rated and put him on par with Fulton. I wonder how he stacks up now? Three average years at the Knights and one great and two good years at the Broncos. Personally I reckon his effort to almost win against the Cows in the GF was his best ever effort.

2017-09-23T06:49:48+00:00

Wayne Turner

Guest


On another point:- With Cronk leaving.I suggest the Storm try to get Matt Moylan,if he can leave Penrith. Munster can play in the centres,then fullback whenever Slater goes.Moylan at 6,Croft at 7. Away from the Sydney media spotlight could help Moylan.Plus Bellamy could help take his game to another level...

2017-09-23T06:45:40+00:00

Wayne Turner

Guest


Great points. Brisbane are thugs,especially Adam Blair.

2017-09-23T06:44:19+00:00

Wayne Turner

Guest


It is the point.You had ignored who was missing in that GF.It mattered.Just like it mattered last year no Slater.While this year they have the big 3.

2017-09-23T05:55:00+00:00

Mike from tari

Guest


Agree with you Boyd should never have played & Oates was off his game, so Bennett is to blame, no criticism of Bennetts selection of his mate in the Courier Mail, he should not have changed his team from their Penrith game, anyway Boyd should have been replaced at half time by Benji then they might have had a chance.

2017-09-23T04:57:56+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Many thought Maguire was poor last night in attack near their line. I happen to be one of them. He is a decent metre eater and good in defense but I do think he is limited in attack. My opinion, you don't have to agree, depends what sort of football you want the Broncs to play.

2017-09-23T04:41:50+00:00

doogs

Guest


I felt Maguire has had a terrific year. Many experts and commentators have said so as well. Yes I know you are not hating on him, but I feel your criticism is a bit harsh.

2017-09-23T04:40:08+00:00

doogs

Guest


I think Hunt will be sorely missed in general games but not the big ones. I counted him turning over the ball in Melbourne's twenty about six times. Awful kicks, dropped ball, forward passes. He is a great player but not in the big ones. In that way I don't think he will be missed overall. Adam Blair can go as far away as he likes

2017-09-23T04:38:16+00:00

doogs

Guest


lol so true

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar