Cowboys hot, Knights not: My 2018 NRL predictions

By Adam Bagnall / Roar Guru

I’ll keep the intro short and sweet, nothing about crystal balls, etc. Here is how I see the 2018 NRL ladder at the end of the season.

16th: Newcastle Knights
Sorry Knights fans but I don’t see a climb up the ladder for your team. Yes they have recruited heavily, but have gone for quantity over quality.

Mitchell Pearce is their biggest recruit, but he struggles at times, and still hasn’t stepped up in the rep arena. Kalyn Ponga is raw and could be anything.

They leaked 27 points a game in 2017 and while they will continue to build, they are still a long way from being competitive week in, week out.

15th: Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs
Looked ugly during 2017, and that was when they were in form, which wasn’t too often. New coach Dean Pay will need to get the best out of a struggling side and the Dogs two big recruits Kieran Foran and Aaron Woods have polarised fans over the years.

They tried to offload both Morris twins but got no bites and it’s hard to see where the points are going to come from with a fairly ordinary backline.

14th: South Sydney Rabbitohs
It’s been a big slide from the glory days of 2014, and this will continue in 2018. Sam Burgess is overrated in my opinion, and his brothers, George and Thomas are hit and miss.

Greg Inglis will take time to recapture his best and there are questions surrounding the hooking role. Damian Cook offers more than Farah and could easily play the full 80, but will Farah handle being in reserve grade each week?

13th: New Zealand Warriors
A side laden with talent, but short on mental toughness, being a Warriors fan must be a tough gig. They are inconsistent, lack any ability to close out tight games and the sooner they get rid of Stephen Kearney the better.

They will jag a few wins when everything clicks but will also lose plenty of games they could have won if they played smarter.

12th: Penrith Panthers
They let Matt Moylan go to the Sharks in order to grab two-time premiership winner James Maloney, who struggled in 2017. They are also looking a little thin out wide and will struggle to match it with the better teams with a forward pack that, outside of Regan Campbell-Gillard is modest at best.

Nathan Cleary is the best young half in the game, but he needs a forward pack that will give him room to showcase his talents.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

11th: Wests Tigers
The return of Benji Marshall and a host of new faces should see the Tigers improve from a disastrous 2017 that saw them finish 15th, but I’m not prepared to lock them in for a finals spot.

Marshall’s role will be crucial, and Ivan Cleary needs to take note of how Wayne Bennett used the veteran playmaker; off the bench in limited minutes, with no pressure to run the team. Taane Milne is a great buy and he showed his wares at the World Cup, starring for Fiji, while Josh Reynolds brings plenty of enthusiasm.

10th: Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles
They shipped reliable veteran Blake Green off to the Warriors ahead of the 2018 season, but missed out on Mitchell Pearce and suddenly are desperate for a halves partner for Daly Cherry-Evans.

A quick glance at their 2018 roster reveals only Tom Wright, a former rugby five eighth, and Jackson Hastings. Hard to get too excited there. With the Trobojevic brothers and the addition of Joel Thompson they will trouble teams but won’t be finals bound in 2018.

9th: Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks
They signed Josh Dugan on fullback money, but already have Valentine Holmes on their books and then went and signed Matt Moylan. It’s a confusing situation down in the Shire, and one that needs to be sorted out.

Maloney’s experience is a big loss and they’ve got an overrated utility in Moylan in return. I’m sure Panthers fans would be happy to see the back of their former skipper, while Dragons fans won’t be losing too much sleep over Dugan’s absence.

Lewis and Gallen are a year older and Fifita remains enigmatic while their halves are suddenly looking much less potent.

8th: Canberra Raiders
For too long the difference between the Raiders’ best and worst, has been vast and I don’t see this changing in 2018. The loss of Josh Hodgson to a long-term knee injury is a cruel blow and it’s a big drop in standard to the likes of Savila Havili.

They will score plenty of points and will also leak plenty but I’m backing them to grab the last finals spot.

7th: Parramatta Eels
They’ve taken a massive gamble luring egomaniac Jarryd Hayne back and his attitude could easily derail their season, as could his hot and cold form.

They have the makings of a decent side and Mitch Moses is coming along nicely. Still a year or two away from being a genuine contender but they should sneak in.

(AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

6th: Gold Coast Titans
A new coach and no Jarryd Hayne could only be a positive for the Titans, add to that reliable custodian Michael Gordon, and guys like Mitch Rein and Jack Stockwell who are looking to re-ignite their careers, and things are looking up for the club.

Former Titan Will Matthews has also returned to the area after pulling out of his deal with Wakefield, so look for the club to make a play for the rangy backrower. I like the look of young half Ash Taylor and Konrad Hurrell provides plenty of power out wide.

5th: St George Illawarra Dragons
Yes I’m a Dragons fan and some may see this as bias, but I genuinely believe the Red V are in for a big year. Josh Dugan spends most of his time injured and looking angry, and his loss is easily covered by boom rookie Matt Dufty, while Joel Thompson had little onfield impact, simply running and tackling hard, like most NRL-level backrowers.

Luciano Leilua provides plenty of spark and is set for a big season, while Ben Hunt provides the club with an experienced halfback alongside Gareth Widdop. They have a plethora of backrow talent, and the return of centre Euan Aitken should set the scene for a big year. If they don’t make the finals it’s bye bye Mary.

4th: Brisbane Broncos
Master coach Wayne Bennett will have his troops primed for another assault on the title, and the addition of classy utility Jack Bird makes them even more potent. Bird isn’t a centre, not sure why the Sharks persisted with him there, he’s a back rower with great ball skills.

James Roberts provides the spark out wide and their forward pack remains solid. They are an experienced, professional outfit although their halves is a worry with both Milford and Nikorima capable of lapses.

(AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

3rd: Sydney Roosters
James Tedesco wanted to play finals football and he came to the Roosters, giving them a great shot at their first title since 2013.

Mitchell Pearce is gone, but they have a handy replacement in Cooper Cronk, one of the best halfbacks of all time. Luke Keary continues to improve and they boast an outstanding talent in Latrell Mitchell and an inspirational skipper in Boyd Cordner. Possible GF combatants.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

2nd: Melbourne Storm
The Big 3 is now the Big 2; Cooper Cronk is no longer there but they still boast arguably the greatest fullback of all time in Billy Slater and the greatest hooker of all time in Cameron Smith who pretty much won everything in 2017.

Brodie Croft looks to have the inside running for the halfback spot, but he’s no Cooper Cronk, and that could be the difference in those tight games, but don’t be surprised to see them on GF night yet again.

1st: North Queensland Cowboys
The Cowboys made it all the way to the 2017 decider sans both Johnathan Thurston and Matt Scott. Add those two back in plus the handy recruitment of rising prop Jordan Maclean and I’m backing them to go all the way in 2018.

Jason Taumololo is the best player in the world right now and gives them a go-forward that no other player has, while players like Lachlan Coote, Michael Morgan and Ethan Lowe are ultimate professionals. Ivan Drago, that is, Coen Hess is a potential superstar and the Cowboys will be very hard to beat in 2018. Premiers.

The Crowd Says:

2018-01-15T02:58:05+00:00

The Shafe

Guest


Some brave predictions Adam, but i think you are off with a few. Next year is actually not hard to call. Saving injuries or something outlandish and Cows will be in top 3, likely winners. Storm, Broncs and Roosters all will slide with the loss of their heart and soul number 7 (as will Dogs) - likely out of the top 4 but staying in the 8 (only Broncs in danger of slipping right out). Eels and Sharks too good not to be in the 8 and top 4 and one battling Cows for the GF. Penrith also too good not to miss the 8. Rabbits, Wests, Warriors, Titans, Dogs fighting for the Spoon. Raiders and Manly out of the 8, mid ladder. Leaves Newcastle and Dragons to fight out spot 8 and put pressure on those in the 8. Newcastle may struggle with combinations so possibly mid ladder.

2018-01-10T08:45:24+00:00

TheEroticGamer

Roar Rookie


Penrith 12th? I thought this website required posters to have a certain level of intellect before submitting posts. Good god, absolutely stupidity.

2018-01-07T13:06:06+00:00

Mr Brown

Roar Pro


Raiders will battle to get above 13th. They've recruited no one and have some internal divisions. People are getting carried away with the Cowboys. They will finish 4th at best. Titans will finish in the bottom half of the draw. They will be competitive but lack punch to compete with the top sides. Newcastle certainly won't finish last but they will be lucky to finish higher than 8th. They have bought pretty well across all areas except in the prop department. Their lack of experience and depth up front will hamper their chances. Bulldogs and Souths will battle again this year. Bulldogs hopes are pinned to a fit Foran. If he doesn't fire they are no hope of reaching the 8.

2018-01-05T11:07:52+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Joe Dont forget Tui

2018-01-05T10:52:29+00:00

Jacob

Guest


I feel like this was rated on every team's weaknesses and not their strengths.

2018-01-05T05:06:32+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


To the point and pulling no punches. I don't necessarily agree with some but I like your approach. Exceptional run required for the Titans to get into the 8 and the Morris boys still know how to find the line but more importantly defend it. Tend to agree with the Knights, I would like to see them do well but their buys have either seen better days or yet to achieve them. Hodgkinson was one of the better halves before he went up there, now would could buy him for a cold ctn of beer.

2018-01-05T04:44:33+00:00

rakshop

Roar Rookie


At round 23 (about the same time as the Cowboys looked done) I had the Cowboys locked in as one of two premiership favourites in 2018 and it had nothing do with Thurston and Scott coming back. I wrote a long comment about why the teams should be fearful of the Cowboys in 2018...... long before there run through the finals. http://www.theroar.com.au/2017/08/17/the-cowboys-will-ride-high-in-2018/#comment-5850426 You have to remember that the Cowboys were missing Thurston and Scott, but they also lost Ben Hannant, his backup in Patrick Kafusi, the back ups back up in Ben Spina all due to injury. By the grand final - they literally had one prop forward in their squad and had to start Shaun Fensom as the other starting prop - and they lost him 1 minute into the GF. The reason why teams should fear the Cowboys is because of the 'mid-tier' players of Bolton, Lowe, Hess, Cooper, Fensom, Asiata, Bowen and Jenson who played out of their skin 2017. They play to that level in 2018, adding Scott, Thurston, McClean and Chudleigh into that team - then the likes of Martin, Hampstead, Fensom (injury pending), Bowen and Jenson wont be able to break the starting 17. Thats the real reason why teams should fear the Cowboys - Thurston, Scott and JT13 will win you games - those mid tier players will win your premierships. The Cowboys have an absurd level of quality in those mid-tier players in 2018, thanks in part, to the injury struggles of 2017.

2018-01-05T04:37:13+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Guest


They may have stumbled into the finals but we're good enough to get to the decider without their best player. Not many other clubs could do that. I think their premiership window is open for 2018 but may close after that

2018-01-05T04:34:42+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Guest


No issue there, us Dragons fans need something to hope for and I'm optimistic about the year ahead.

2018-01-05T04:33:11+00:00

Jimmmy

Guest


i know only two things 2018 season. Firstly the best three teams on paper ( by a reasonable margin ) are the Storm, the Cows and the Roosters. Secondly , one or more of these three teams Will disappoint. I just hope it’s not us.

2018-01-05T04:33:08+00:00

Penrith Punter

Roar Guru


Adam, the Titans conceded 497 points in 24 games in 2016. In 2017, they conceded 638. That was the difference. If they defended that poorly because of Hayne, they are a very weak side to crumple like that just because of one player. Hayne did disrupt their season, I definitely agree, but he was not the only reason for their woes.

2018-01-05T04:31:44+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Guest


Plenty of new faces at the Knights but I think they've gone for quantity over quality. Pearce is only ok, Guerra was in decline at the Roosters, Ponga remains an unknown quantity. The Titans biggest problem was Hayne and he is no longer there.

2018-01-05T04:29:00+00:00

Jimmmy

Guest


You really are not so super.

2018-01-05T04:28:30+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Guest


In 2016 they were flying high before Hayne ruined them. I think they'll be a much better team this year.

2018-01-05T03:33:44+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


Tohu and Jordan will be hard to replace but I think Kasiano, Pat Kaufusi and Hoffman were bought for that very purpose. Also Welsh was actually the first choice bench prop and played in the 2016 GF so Kasiano and Pat are not guaranteed a spot as the free bench spots will likely go to Brandon Smith and Welsh. Agree that Nelson has to step up and be a starter with bigger minutes in the mold of Jessie. I think a prop rotation of Jessie, Nelson, Glasby, Kasiano and Welch will be how the Storm go. If Pat Kaufusi turns out like his two older brothers at the Storm he will also be playing a big part in the 2018 campaign.

2018-01-05T03:33:14+00:00

not so super

Guest


THe cowboys fluked their run. Scott is past his best. they wont win

2018-01-05T03:31:25+00:00

Bunney

Roar Rookie


It's in the bag! Probably put them a spot or two too low! ;-)

2018-01-05T02:58:38+00:00

Beastie

Roar Rookie


The Knights to finish 16th because they conceded 27 points a game last season yet the Titans to move up to 6th even though they conceded 26.58 points per game? Considering the forwards and backs the the Knights have purchased and lost and comparing that to the Titans I can't see how you can make an argument as to how the Titans would be above the Knights at the end of 2018, let alone them in the 8.

2018-01-05T02:45:18+00:00

Peter Phelps

Guest


Thanks for the support TB. You have expressed my thoughts most eloquently. At the end of the day, the proof will be in the pudding but that will probably prove everyone wrong anyway. Whatever your views, if we get as much entertainment out of 2018 as we did out of 2017 then we will all do very well. Bring it on.

2018-01-05T02:26:16+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Good on the author for having a punt but the Titans in sixth? Off the back of a 15th placed 2017 and the signings of Matthews, Gordon, Rein and Stockwell...?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar