Just one month out, the NSW Origin puzzle is crystal clear

By Tim Gore / Expert

With just three rounds to go until the teams for State of Origin 1 are named, the front-runners for the NSW 17 are standing out.

The Blues have lost 12 of the last 13 series and things have to change.

Under new coach Brad Fittler, there is almost certainly going to be changes – he has said as much.

However, while there have been suggestions of sweeping changes to the side that took the field in 2017, that would be as foolhardy as making no changes at all.

So who from last year won’t feature in 2018?

Firstly, the players who are not available.

Andrew Fifita has declared his allegiance to Tonga and will no longer make himself available for NSW selection. Given his 2018 averages of 18 runs, 132 metres and 3.5 tackle breaks, his absence isn’t ideal. However, absent he will be.

Brett Morris has put his hand down for representative selection, Jarryd Hayne is injured – and would not have been selected anyway – Mitchell Pearce is out for the season, while Nathan Peats is injured and would be unlikely to be picked.

Then there are the players who won’t be selected.

Aaron Woods has had his go. His impact is limited, and while he may get chosen on the basis of experience, I don’t think he should.

Blake Ferguson is unlikely to get a recall following the poor press he garnered last series, mixed with his average form so far this year, while the form of his challengers is very good.

As for Jack Bird, his comeback from injury has been mediocre. He’s played more positions at the Broncos than seen in the Kama Sutra and failed to fire in any of them.

So that is eight of the 17 players who played all three games in 2017 who won’t be there this year.

So who will be?

Forwards

10. Paul Vaughan
The Italian Stallion’s form has been too good for too long for the Dragon not to get his go. The majority of his runs make eight metres or more and he misses less than a single tackle a game.

9. Cameron McInnes
This is the most contested position in the side, with Damien Cook red hot for the Rabbitohs.

They’ll go with Cook if they want an attacking dummy half, but I think they’ll go with McInnes because of the sheer number of Dragons in the side, and because he is the better defender.

He is capable of 70 tackles a game. He is tackling stupid. He’d tackle his grandma into the grandstand concrete. That is what is required in the Origin cauldron.

8. David Klemmer
People have a go at Klemmer because he doesn’t offload much, but when you are a monstrous unit who terrorises defences, do you really need to offload?

I mean, I guess it’s nice, but it’s not essential.

Klemmer has the highest average metres gained in the NRL this year with 169 a game. That’ll do me.

11. Josh Jackson
I know the Bulldogs have been struggling, but this bloke ain’t the problem. He’d be picked in every NRL side – Queensland would pick him if they could.

A superb defender and leader. Made for Origin.

12. Boyd Cordner (c)
Will be captain again and better for the experience of 2017. He’s a superb player.

13. Jake Trbojevic
The best lock forward since Brad Clyde, although he’s not the same sort. He’s mobile, has great hands, hits the line hard and tackles really well. OK, that pretty much describes Clyde, too.

Barring injury, he’ll be in the NSW number 13 for years to come.

Halves

7. Nathan Cleary
He’s the best young halfback prospect since Johnathan Thurston burst onto the scene. If he’s fit he must be the NSW No.7.

6. James Maloney
I know he’s been part of many losing series, but he’s just so good. His form and leadership with the Panthers this season has more than justified the Moylan trade – if young Matt’s indifferent form hadn’t already.

If Cleary is still injured, Jimmy will play 7 and Blake Green will come into the 6 jersey.

Backs

5. Josh Addo-Carr
How can you ignore the form of the Fox? If you want to win an Origin series you must score points. Addo-Carr has shown in the last two years that he is not just a finisher, he’s also a spark. Give him a run.

4. Josh Dugan
I’m not the biggest fan of this bloke as a human and if I could muster a case to leave him out of this side, I would.

I can’t. His rep form is excellent. While his Lennox Head drinking partner won’t be with him, I can’t see Freddie leaving Dugan out.

3. Euan Aitken
We all knew this guy was a talent when he first turned up but this season he has justified the hype.

He’s tough as nails in defence and hits the line hard, with good pace. His Dragons form has been superb.

2. Tom Trbojevic
It’s time for Tommy Turbo to come into the side. He is fast, elusive, good in defence and awesome in attack. At 6’4 he’s pretty good in an aerial contest too.

Let him play.

1. James Tedesco
Yes, I know his Roosters form has been patchy at best. However, this is Origin – he’ll step up.

He is a superb attacking weapon and he’s been in the cauldron before. He must play in the No.1.

Bench

14. Tyson Frizzell
He has been superb in sky blue. He has been superb in the Red V. He can play anywhere in the pack and excel – you could probably play him in the centres at a pinch. Could also be picked at 11, 12 or 13 too.

Must be in the side.

15. Ryan James
I know this selection will be contentious, however this bloke gives 100 per cent, can play 80 minutes and in every pack position but hooker.

Plus, coming from just south of the Tweed, his animosity towards Queenslanders is heightened. He wants to beat the Cane Toads bad. Give him that chance.

16. Jack De Belin
He’s been coming for a while now but something always held him back – and that whale-spout haircut wasn’t great either.

Jack’s ready now.

17. Wade Graham
If he’s fit, the perpetually smiling second rower from the Shire needs to be picked. He hasn’t put a foot wrong at rep level and he’s a real competitor.

If Graham isn’t fit, I’d love to see Jack Wighton get a go. Like Euan Aitken, just harder in defence, Wighton can cover the whole back five and could play in the back row if necessary.

The unlucky ones

Their time will come.

I reckon this side will win the 2018 Origin series.

The Crowd Says:

2018-05-11T20:47:34+00:00

soapit

Guest


definitely, by and large i think we need to put less emphasis on the captaincy in a lot of our teams. you earn the right to long term captaincy, it shouldnt be automatic and creates more problems than it helps if its applied from the get go. change until someone warrants keeping it and then itll happen naturally

2018-05-11T10:28:09+00:00

Paul

Guest


Read it again. They're saying NSW have more players to pick from.

2018-05-11T05:40:45+00:00

steveng

Roar Rookie


I second 3_Hats pick, D. Cook s**ts allover McInnes (who btw, is a former Souths player) who was let go to the Dragons, because of Cook. Cook would be unmanageable for the Qld'ers once he starts going and running from dummy half, McInnes is a good player but, nothing compared to Cook. Cooks versatility and speed, once chimed in with the forwards and Jimi Jet, the Bluezzz will bamboozle the Qld'ers and the Bluezzz will be zipping and memorizing the Maroons in every aspect and SSO games lol Cook has to be picked ahead of McInnes, the only reason McInnes is looking good is, because the Dragons are going good. But wait, that will change, wait folks 'until this Sunday'! Go the Bunnies!

2018-05-11T04:37:22+00:00

Bucks

Guest


Team will be; 1.Tom Trbojevic 2.Blake Ferguson 3.Latrell Mitchell 4.Euan Aitken 5.Josh Addo-Carr 6.James Maloney 7.Luke Brookes / Luke Keary (Maloney would play half-back) 8.David Klemmer 9.Damien Cook 10.Paul Vaughan 11.Tyson Frizell 12.Boyd Cordner 13.Jake Trbojevic 14.Jack de Belin 15.Wade Graham (if fit) 16.Reagan Campbell-Gillard 17.Tariq Sims

2018-05-11T01:12:34+00:00

rl

Guest


I agree Michael - as a Qld fan I reckon James (very good player that he is) is less of a threat than RCG. A front row rotation of Klemmer, Vaughn and RCG - tasty! I also agree with a lot of punters here about Sims - but as Tim says, who do you leave out? On form, it would be Cordner, but I think he's basically untouchable from a selection point of view.

2018-05-11T00:58:05+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It’s also a bit easier to put a bit more sting in your runs when you average 87 metres in 54 minutes like RCG as opposed to Klemmer’s 162 in 55 minutes. For all RCG’s venom he’s made four tackle breaks this season to Klemmer’s 11

2018-05-11T00:54:22+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


I am not saying not pick Klemmer but to me both Klemmer and woods are a little bit predictable and give defence more time to get set. I just think Vaughan and RCG offer a little bit more variety. Sure have Klemmer off the bench. I guess we will have to agree to disagree.

2018-05-11T00:48:28+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I agree on Woods, not on Klemmer. It happens sometimes because it can take 3-4 to bring him down but then you’ve got this evloke setting back in the line.

2018-05-11T00:26:21+00:00

Pomoz

Roar Rookie


When the Panthers played the Bulldogs, the most noticeable thing was how slow Klemmer and Woods were at playing the ball. Lots of post contact metres from Klemmer, he is a big unit to pull down, but he doesn't bend the line. The line just slowly jogs backwards, keeping onside until he is stopped and finally plays the ball. Meanwhile, I have nipped to the fridge for a beer, called my mates and still got back inside to see the next play.

2018-05-11T00:11:06+00:00

Pomoz

Roar Rookie


Same reason to have RCG in. He plays with aggression and will get players fired up. Sim's RCG, Klemmer and James will be a bruising pack that would belt the crap out of anybody. Might be a few penalties and suspensions though.........

2018-05-11T00:02:26+00:00

Ray Paks

Roar Rookie


Woods, Graham and Fifita were the main culprits, you're only MIA because you're KIA. These lot should be banned forever from origin!!!

2018-05-11T00:00:59+00:00

Pomoz

Roar Rookie


Hear, hear and I'm a blue's fan. When we did win it was playing themes dire, dreadful, boring football that was like having root canal, it was so painful to watch.

2018-05-10T23:19:31+00:00

Adam

Guest


Jake is playing well, but JDB has been a big reason Saints are on top. I'd go with JDB at lock and Jake off the bench

2018-05-10T22:20:44+00:00

bear54


Dugan is a very good fullback and that is the only position he should be considered. One of our biggest failings has been playing guys out of their regular week-in-week-out positions and expecting/hoping they will excel. 1. Tedesco (quick but not in form however some experience at Origin is necessary) 2. Addo-Carr (too much speed and good form to ignore) 3. Roberts (too much speed) 4. Mitchell (explosive, creative and can kick) 5. Trbojevic (speed and height) 6. Keary (creative live-wire) 7. Maloney (he's the glue for every team he plays, creative and a great leader) 8. Vaughn (tough, strong, fast) 9. Cook (elusive and quick) 10. Klemmer (see Vaughn description) 11. De Bellin (tough as nails) 12. Sims (hard as nails) 13. Frizell (he is the hammer) 14. Cordner (experienced forward,not skipper) 15. Campbell-Gillard (big man and hard to handle) 16. Jackson (experienced forward) 17. Trbojevic (experienced forward) I don't believe in picking players with injuries in mind. When you're winning players ignore injuries and if you lose a couple the others just have to step up. If you lose a couple of backs then no amount of planning is going to help anyway, it's just bad luck.

2018-05-10T22:18:15+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Darr-ell Darr-ell

2018-05-10T22:16:54+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Who knew...? ?

2018-05-10T22:15:21+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It’s a big issue...I think he’ll be picked but how out of form does he have to get before selectors think of dropping him. When you’ve got a legend you can think about making him long term captain but Cordners not at that stage where his spot in NSWs strongest position should be guaranteed.

2018-05-10T22:01:30+00:00

nerval

Guest


Mushi, why is this colloquialism never used to refer to the likes of Tommy T? I find it odd, even if you don't. Why can't we accept that Mitchell, at the ripe old age of just 20, is not yet a perfect footballer and accept instead his manifest talents?

2018-05-10T21:13:33+00:00

Richard POWELL

Roar Rookie


Lattrell Mitchell must be there even though he's starved of possession at club level. Pity the Roosters don't take a leaf out of Newcastle's playbook, who build their game plan around Ponga.

2018-05-10T20:59:37+00:00

soapit

Guest


he hasnt been captain for long, does he get a spot for life because of it?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar