Believe it or not, the run home became even more exciting after a captivating Round 20

By Ryan Buckland / Expert

Let’s just pretend yesterday didn’t happen, ok?

The first five games of Round 20 were decided by less than a goal each – the first time so many games had been within a straight kick margin in the history of the competition.

That is the neatest way to summarise what was a truly captivating weekend of football, the kind that not even the most sappy nostalgist could yell at the clouds about.

Each had its own exciting finish. Geelong’s storming fourth-quarter comeback that fell a Gary Ablett junior miss short against Richmond.

Some last minute end to end stuff in Hawthorn’s win over Essendon.

A clutch set shot followed by the opposite version of that from superstar-in-waiting Cam Rayner in North Melbourne’s win over Brisbane.

A goal-that-wasn’t-but-was by Josh Jenkins in another pulsating Showdown that saw the Crows sneak home this time around.

Lance Franklin strutting across the SCG kicking six goals in a tight contest against Collingwood.

It was a 24-hour treat the likes of which we’d not seen before in the AFL.

(Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)

Those games will have faded from the punditry’s collective memory I’m sure; yesterday bore an injury crisis at the Giants, another awful Gold Coast Suns performance, and a shocking off-ball incident involving Andrew Gaff and Andrew Brayshaw in the round-closing derby.

One word on each for now: unfortunate, predictable, shocking. We will colour in the lines later, because the first and last issues in that list are season-defining.

The events of Sunday certainly took some sheen off what was otherwise sparkling round of football that unfolded about as well as a neutral may have hoped.

Every ladder permutation that was ideal for keeping things alive for longer came to pass, save perhaps Hawthorn’s win over Essendon.

Geelong is this week’s unlucky loser, taking Sydney’s place outside of the eight and falling a win off the finals pace in the process.

It is the first time eighth and ninth have been separated by at least one win all season – yep, since the season started – and it comes with just three games remaining.

Not that Geelong should feel too poorly about the state of things.

They became the latest team to push Richmond right to the brink, a stellar final quarter of bullyball almost putting them over the edge against the best fourth-quarter team in the competition.

Right up until that point the Tigers looked to have the game in hand; Geelong was handballing too much, not marking enough, and turning the ball over at an impressive (for Richmond) clip.

It was a familiar tale, though one the Cats ultimately came within a couple of missed shots for goal from turning into a triumph.

Geelong showed they have the mettle to stand with the Tigers – now they’ve just got to work their way into another chance at doing it.

Fortunately for them, the Cats have a more comfortable ride home than most of those above them on the ladder.

Geelong play Hawthorn this weekend, and finish their home and away season with games against Fremantle and the Gold Coast Suns.

The only other team above them with two more games to come against the bottom six is Richmond, who now as such will almost certainly finish the qualifying rounds with this year’s minor premiership.

Other ladder-positive results that came to pass were Adelaide beating Port Adelaide (I would not be surprised if the Power investigate an avenue to protest the result of this game, Siren-gate style – however it’s still unlikely to happen), Sydney beating Collingwood, and North Melbourne beating Brisbane.

It means eight teams are on 11 or 12 wins with three games to go (GWS, now in third, has a draw), and thus anything is in play.

The “top 12” is still a thing for another week, even if both Essendon (11th) and Adelaide (12th) are mathematical propositions at this point.

At a bare minimum both have to win every game they play, and hope that at least two of the current 11 and 12-win teams don’t go any higher than 12 wins.

That will require some pretty crazy, but certainly plausible, stuff to happen. For example, if Port Adelaide goes 0-3, one of Sydney or Melbourne goes 0-3 (and the other 1-2 with the win coming in their Round 21 game against eachother) and Geelong go 1-2 (which would require a loss to either Gold Coast or Fremantle) then both the Bombers and Crows can squeeze into the eight on 13 wins.

Their situations are remarkably delicate, but all they can do is win and hope for the best.

Similarly, there is a path for every team inside the top ten to finish in the top four. For North Melbourne, at the bottom of the logjam, wins out, and every team above them loses at least one of their games against teams currently below North Melbourne, and North Melbourne puts on some extra percentage, then yes it can finish in fourth spot. That one is… somewhat less likely than one of Essendon or Adelaide making the eight though.

So, what do we watch out for this week? Assuming the top 12 take care of the bottom six (as they have in 67 of 78 opportunities in 2018), then it is another Saturday tripleheader that should command our attention.

Hawthorn face Geelong, before West Coast travel to Port Adelaide, ahead of the Giants hosting the Adelaide Crows in Canberra. No matter the outcome, the top eight will be re-shaped once more.

Melbourne then host Sydney, in what could prove to be an elimination final for the loser if things go badly enough.

For two of these clubs, the events of Round 20 will have a material impact on what’s to come from here.

West Coast will almost certainly be without Andrew Gaff for the rest of the season, following his strike on Andrew Brayshaw.

It might have been out of character, it might have been aimed at Brayshaw’s gut, and Gaff certainly appeared to feel as guilty as a professional footballer has ever felt on the back of an incident like this.

But the facts are Gaff elected to strike Brayshaw with a closed fist, and his strike hit Brayshaw in the face, breaking his jaw and messing up his teeth.

GWS will be without Brett Deledio and Dawson Simpson for at least a fortnight each – probably longer in Deledio’s case – at a time when they need to keep their roll going.

(Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Media/Getty Images)

The Giants have surged to third spot on the ladder, and slayed Carlton despite playing at times with 16 players on the field on account of injuries and player management.

That sort of luxury is rarely afforded in this game, a measure of just how comprehensively the Giants outplayed their opponents.

Still, those injuries will hurt, particularly given the Giants appeared to have figured out their best form of themselves with Rory Lobb playing forward and Simpson in the ruck.

They’ll adjust; hell, that’s how they’ve gotten back into the double chance over the past two months.

How quickly things can change. And there’ll be plenty more where that came from in the final three rounds of this captivating AFL season.

The Crowd Says:

2018-08-06T22:45:00+00:00

Slane

Guest


I think Hawthorn had enough trouble beating Richmond when the Hawks were the number 1 team in the comp and the Tiges were struggling to make the top 8. Hard to see them toppling the Tigers now that the tables have been turned.

2018-08-06T22:33:08+00:00

Tom

Roar Rookie


You won't get fried, every chance of it happening and really I think it is more likely than not. All hinges on you beating the Cats really. I think the only reason you'd get fried is because no one wants it to happen! A Richmond vs Hawthorn final at some stage would be dam intriguing though.

2018-08-06T13:28:04+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


As much as anyone, Dawson is crucial to GWS's chances.

2018-08-06T10:38:52+00:00

Joe

Guest


Worth noting that of those 5 Geelong losses to top 8 sides, two were to Richmond at the MCG (and both were close), two were well in hand until Geelong faded late (which we no longer do), and the other was by a point.

2018-08-06T10:34:15+00:00

Joe

Guest


Every cannonball? Laughable. We played a debutant ruckman and didn't have our best defender. Rain seemed to suit you. Cats will LOVE to meet Tigers in the finals.

2018-08-06T10:15:05+00:00

New York Hawk

Guest


Third gear for the Tigers used to be about one gear higher than their peak performance...

2018-08-06T10:13:29+00:00

New York Hawk

Guest


I’m in the same page as you Andy, for the most part. I don’t think we are necessarily a team that compares favorably with past season top four teams but no teams at the top end of the ladder compare favorably to teams from prior years and as such I have no reason to believe we can’t finish 4th and knock of Richmond in the Qualifying Final.

2018-08-06T08:57:37+00:00

Raimond

Roar Guru


Not enough is being said about McCartin's match-winner on Saturday night. Great awareness for someone playing in their eleventh match. Rayner, on the other hand...

2018-08-06T08:51:26+00:00

Raimond

Roar Guru


Whitfield is a low-key Brownlow chance.

2018-08-06T08:42:20+00:00

Raimond

Roar Guru


a Richmond side they barely moved out of third gear Why does everyone talk about Richmond like this?

2018-08-06T08:23:25+00:00

Col in paradise

Guest


It's like having a bye playing the Sun's .and Freo. another bye...the Tigers will be fresh as daisies, tigers tired and sore is rubbish....

2018-08-06T07:55:36+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Can't help bad luck, Petie. Or maybe some players haven't been managed well. I don't know. So, so sorry the Tigers haven't had many injuries. Maybe the AFL could handicap us in other ways? Injuries in footy are inevitably a fact of life. All teams have had periods of bad luck/poor management. Such is life. Take some panadol and have a good lie down. Why should everyone sympathise?

2018-08-06T07:04:08+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Half our side is missing bilo so only half of them will be exhausted at least.

2018-08-06T07:03:11+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


One reason why the Pies getting close to the Tigers was impressive. I'm sure the Cats, GWS, Swans and Crows could put their own similar side with cross outs below. Realist here are some facts for you to digest. (and thanks to the AFL website for the figures and the best 22 which is pretty close) Games missed since the start of 2017 - Richmond Rance – 0 Astbury – 1 Grimes – 1 Cotchin – 1 Martin – 1 Lambert – 1 Nankervis – 1 Riewoldt – 2 Now, a host of other sides could do below such as Cats, GWS, Crows, Swans, Dogs but I’ll stick with the Pies best 22 which could have been picked against the Swans Sat night. B: Crisp, Dunn, Scharenberg HB: Phillips, Moore, Howe C: Adams, Pendlebury, Wells HF: De Goey, Reid, Stephenson F: Elliott (Jamie), Cox, H-Elliott Foll: Grundy, Treloar, Sidebottom Int: Varcoe, Thomas, Aish, Goldsack

2018-08-06T06:09:19+00:00

bilo

Guest


If I was Richmond I would rather lose now than in September but keep clutching those straws. If the Pies aren't careful they'll be exhausted by the time finals comes around, you know Bucks isn't very experiences at this 'Finals' business.

2018-08-06T05:27:58+00:00

Angela

Guest


Horses for courses - many of us don't find him boring at all. Do we need whinging coaches to liven up the season?? I find that pretty boring

2018-08-06T05:08:55+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


The Cats dominated large parts of the game and when a result is under a kick it's anyone's. Dimma and his charges will know their midfield has been belted twice in a row and that Geelong have also provided a blueprint for other opposition coaches to follow. It's not just Chris talking tough, his players backed it up.

2018-08-06T04:43:06+00:00

Graeme

Guest


The Scott brothers are like Serena Williams, gaceful winners but very poor losers. Both Scotts are sooks and complain and whinge about anything when they loose. Brad Scott almost cried about being booed by Eagles supporters but who doesn't get booed but everyone else just sucks it up. Chris Scott almost cried about Shuey getting "too high frees" yet Selwood is the grandmaster.

2018-08-06T04:34:23+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


I can see the Cats finishing 6th and playing the Hawks. They should win that and that gets them to the semis where anything can happen and usually does.

2018-08-06T04:33:28+00:00

Graeme

Guest


Hawthorn could be worth putting a lazy 10 on. WCE are done despite being stronger at the MCG this year, no Gaff Nic Nat or Kennedy they will struggle to win another game. If the Hawks beat Geelong, they will most likely beat the Saints and Sydney to finish 2nd. The Hawks record at the MCG in finals speaks for itself and they will beat Richmond, Melbourne or Collingwood no risk. GWS are the only team that could possibly beat the Hawks (due to sheer pace) at the MCG in finals provided their injury situation improves.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar