The only negative is that the season is over

By Nat / Roar Guru

I’m done with the negative. I’ve enjoyed this year and gone out of my way to watch most of the games I can and I’m sure most fans enjoyed where their club was heading at different times during the season.

Preseason we debated about the offseason trades and who got the better end of the deal, only to have last year’s also-rans knock off the top poppies in the opening rounds. The Knights started with enthusiasm and scored an opening round win against a team who made the finals last year, and then Manly put 54 unanswered on a team most tipped to be featuring in the finals.

Some Roarers were quite vocal about the hiding their B-grade Bulldogs gave the Pennies preseason then backed it up in Week 3 with their marquee prop and half at the helm.

There was plenty in the efforts from the Raiders and Titans to predict a season where they would win as many as they lost and all seemed in place in North Queensland with a first up win over the Sharks and a goal post from besting the Broncos in yet another thriller.

Alas, these teams found themselves enjoying some quality time with family this September, but there are some positives to be taken into 2019.

9. Wests Tigers
Ivan Cleary has to be respected for creating a team that, on paper, had no right to be anywhere near the finals. He laid the foundation stone of defence and effort that can be built upon. He gave Luke Brooks the opportunity to shine and in doing so, pushed Nathan Cleary for the Blues jumper. Benji Marshall is a calming influence and Robbie Farah is a pure representation of Leichhardt.

(AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

Again, better teams on paper finished much lower than the Wests Tigers this year, but their table position is a result of a good team playing for each other and their coach.

10. Raiders
Ricky Stuart’s job is a little more difficult. Nick Cotric cannot be wasted on the wing any longer, and I believe Jack Wighton is silky enough and big enough to play as a running five-eighth.

Let Aidan Sezer and Josh Hodgson do general play kicking and have Wighton create for Iosia Soliola, Jarrod Croker and Brad Abbey or Michael Oldfield on the left.

For mine, Josh Papalii was the form no. 13 of the last few months and, if Ricky can get his mongrel pack playing a full 80 minutes, a 2016-esk performance is not far away.

11. Knights
Often described as everyone’s second team, but that may change when they start beating your team. It’s tough to recruit when you’re not winning and tougher to win when your recruits are injured but there’s a mix developing good players and game breakers. Maybe just a dominant prop rounds that mix out.

Mitchell Pearce gets maligned for various reasons but I will suggest that if this team stays fit, Pearce may just pull off a ‘DCE’ and earn his Blues jumper back in the years to come.

What will Brownie do with Kalyn Ponga? At fullback, he’s a star, five-eighth he handled with ease and at lock for Qld he exceeded expectations. I’d say fullback and let him turn up anywhere – and I don’t say that about too many players.

(AAP Image/Brendon Thorne)

12. Bulldogs
Oh the irony when you spend what little cap you have on a world class forward and high quality half, but two rookies steal the show. Those who’ve seen Reece Martin before this year knew he was quality. If you watched him in the PNG world cup team, he was matching it with the rest of the world’s best forwards then kicking the goals from everywhere.

I respect the Dogs have a very high quality pack, but they would be the lesser for not having Martin in that team. “Lewis, Lewis, Lewis is going to score” get used to it Doggies fans, you’re going to be hearing that for a while.

The kid is tough, calm and very few weak points. You know quality when they seem to have time and this young fella moves like Neo.

Special mention to the Morris brothers, they have achieved everything and it will be a shame to see them leave in separate directions. They pulled off plays together that could only be described as telepathic.

13. Cowboys
Ahh the Cowboys. It’s no secret I’m a Broncos man, but home is where the heart is and that’s North Queensland for me. More than most teams at this end of the table, they could’ve and should’ve, but didn’t make an impact on this season. Not only is the team evolving in 2019, but Paul Green will have as well.

Big players leave big holes but a spine of Jake Granville, Michael Morgan, Jake Clifford and Ben Hampton is enough to keep the game’s most dedicated fans making the very long trek for 80 minutes of football.

Last word has to go to Johnathan Thurston. He didn’t come back firing as the JT we know but to suggest he played a year too long is ridiculous.

He lead the stats but they don’t tell the full story – how can we record desire? We remember him for giving his first premiership ring to Steve Price and his last act was to give Gavin Cooper a record that will not be broken for some time.

He has received plenty from the game and has given just as much back. Thank you JT.

14. Titans
Rookie coach Garth Brennan came with credentials, both as a coach and a man manager and, much like most at this end of the table, there is some quality stock at his disposal.

Tell me a pack that includes Ryan James, Shannon Boyd, Jarrod Wallace, Leilani Latu, Kevin Proctor, Keegan Hipgrave, Nathan Peats and Jai Arrow will fear any opposition pack. Out the back, Michael Gordon is a rock, Anthony Don is highly underrated, Phillip Sami pulled an RTS on RTS and an Alex Brimson-Ashley Taylor halves combo could be anything.

Brimson will definitely add spark and starch to that five-eighth role that Bryce Cartwright and Kane Elgey couldn’t this year. In 2019, depth could be an issue but competitiveness will not be.

15. Sea Eagles
Yep, there’s trouble afoot but this team showed they can match anyone. They pumped the Broncos at Suncorp, something the Roosters or Souths could not do. They also outpointed the Sharks.

You’re a hard man if you didn’t feel for Trent Barrett after some of those close losses. Martin Taupau, Jake and Tom Trbojevic, Apisau Koroisau, Dylan Walker and Daly Cherry-Evans. That’s the bones of a very good team. Many judges pointed at lack of a quality five-eighth, but really all they need there is stability.

As Parra showed last year, all you need is consistency from the B+ players and a finals threat you become.

16. Eels
4th to 16th is a bitter pill, but there are positives to take into next year. When Jarrad Hayne came back to the NRL, it was the biggest story of the game’s biggest star on the game’s biggest contract.

His first tackle against the Warriors was a ball-n-all cracker. He then drop kicked a field goal at Campbelltown and declared that “this is my house”.

Maybe that bed was a little too comfy because he didn’t turn up much thereafter. Fifteen months, and a bit of humble pie, later and the prodigal son came home.

While injury interrupted the start of the season, toward the end he was back to carrying the team. Whatever your opinion of him, watching him torment the opposition backlines, position himself like a good winger should and bust tackles with ease is an indication he’s becoming a footballer again and less a celebrity.

Brad Arthur is a good coach, and Parra have the raw talent, but Hayne can be the hero Parra need but not the one they deserve.

Origin
The better team won and dawned a new and exciting era for the pinnacle of our game. Freddie took this chance for a clean NSW slate and picked on form. Other incumbents were unlucky to miss out but the history will show he got the mix right.

James Tedesco, ‘Turbo’, Josh Addo-Carr, and the beast who benefitted most from his selection; Latrell Mitchell. The only mistake I think Freddie made was starting Turbo from the bench. He runs and hits as hard as anyone and the combo with his roving brother is as effective in the 5th minute as the 75th.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

That should be on Kevin Walters’ cheat sheet every year, but that’s what good players do. It would be remiss not to mention Damien Cook here. In a tight series, he was the difference. 80 per cent of the good attacking raids NSW put on came off the back of his lightning quick first steps but also game awareness.

Queensland were far from disgraced and showed their metal against a highly rated forward pack. They won the meters and post contact meters. Cooper played above his club form and Jai Arrow gave no inches in his debut. To quote Gus Gould, “Josh McGuire just doesn’t like humans”. We farewelled Billy with a 100 per cent winning ratio and introduced Ponga.

Talk about potential, this kid has buckets – but how will the Maroons coaching team organise this next generation to support the talent and take it to the current title holders?

I doubt we will see another dynasty but the stars are bright for both sides.

The Crowd Says:

2018-10-07T23:30:36+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Basically Brimson is a footballer, and would do well in any number of positions. It's up to Brennan to work out which is the best one for him and the team. In the short term that's number 6, until Gordon falls away.

2018-10-07T08:07:24+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


'I don’t think too many others in the Tigers squad would be swapped for any starting players at in a top-8 side this year'.. thats probably the beauty of this team,Bunney..when they beat the Roosters back in round 1 the only player missing from last weeks GF was Keary..then that same group of nevilles went on a run knocking over fellow GF's Storm twice,the Rabbitohs,previous years finalists Parra and the infamous Bronco 'tragedy'.. On reflection,was there that much difference between sides 5 - 15 ? Would you rate the Warrior pack or the final 10 rounds of the Dragon three quarters as class? Mattersons a great signing and Josh R.should make interesting viewing especially if Wayne Bennett takes them on..not a fan nor are they my 2nd team by the way..

2018-10-07T06:41:44+00:00

3 R M

Guest


With origin Nat Qlds old guard may have staved off Nsws dominance in the 20s long enough for this generation to come through so there is big positives there in the next couple of years. Truly Bennett did a great job with the Broncos this year as he did in 2015 getting a squad into the finals With injuries and a really young squad I think he's under-rated when you dismiss the hooha.

2018-10-07T06:21:25+00:00

Bunney

Roar Rookie


Not sure I am under-rating them souvalis. They're my fave non-Qld based team (sorry Knights), but they lack class. Yes, Marsters looks good. But of the rest, name the starting players you would you swap out from a finals team for one of the Tigers starting 13. Most people expected them to finish bottom 4, and apart from the breakout of Marsters and the form of Brooks, not much has changed. Packer would make most starting sides, Brooks in for Nikorima and some might suggest Croft, Marsters would displace a couple of right centres, but then...? I don't think too many others in the Tigers squad would be swapped for any starting players at in a top-8 side this year. I'm sure you could argue a few, but I doubt there'll be an avalanche of horror directed my way for saying this. I hope they can prove us mugs wrong and become players we all rate, because they get the job done and win a lot. For me though, the jury is still out.

2018-10-07T05:29:38+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


That’s probably the big takeaway for me from this season. Footy doesn’t start and end at NRL. I’ve always liked Foran and of course hope he comes good but at the same time I don’t really want to waste half a season finding out. I’m not sold on what sort of a combo Foran and Lewis will have. Cleeland is an outstanding player. Apparently the reason he hasn’t had a chance is because of salary cap restraints because he was named outside the Bulldogs top 30 squad. Not sure about Foran at hooker. He’d be up to the defensive workload but I’m not sure about his ability to spot and take the right option from dummy half is like or his ability to pass from the ground.

2018-10-07T03:08:38+00:00

Rob

Guest


I really like AJ Bimson’s potential switching to dummy half. He has displayed the toughness and competitiveness to play the position. He can ball play, is quick of the mark and has the unteachable skill of reading the game. He would definitely be in the picture for 14th man going into SOO next year.

AUTHOR

2018-10-07T01:26:42+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Not even going to try and predict an 8 preseason. A small tweak to any of these teams and an injury to the others and who knows.

AUTHOR

2018-10-07T01:26:10+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Cheers TB, As a footy lover, not everything is about the NRL and I was super impressed with the Dogs ISP win knowing how good Redcliffe were this season up here. I don't know why I'm an optimist about Foran, he's offered nothing in the last few seasons but I still think there's something there. Still, not signing Cleeland is a step backward for depth. Agree with Lichaa though, while he may have been restrained under Des he didn't really take his chance and JMK often showed more in that role. I've offered this before but what are you thoughts on Foran at Hooker?

AUTHOR

2018-10-07T01:08:44+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


I was surprised Green bought Opacic as well due to the depth NQ have running around in the ISP. With hindsight, Green obviously knew he was going to clean out a lot of older players as some of his team selections/positions just seemed odd. He must have been trialing them in different roles. As I said to Rob above, 2019 will be a big trial for Green as it's still a very, very good pack and a bit of youth and speed in the backs, plus Barba now. By rights, they should be playing in September next year.

AUTHOR

2018-10-07T01:00:44+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Yeah I tend to agree with this. I lay huge regard on good defence as very few teams enjoy sustained success on simply outscoring opposition teams. This is what impressed me most about the Tigers and Cleary, they will build better attacking structures then an extra win here/there and they're playing finals.

AUTHOR

2018-10-07T00:54:38+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Thanks Bunney. Brimson does play FB in ISP and good at it, however, what he showed at 5/8 impressed me no end. He can tackle - hard and run with intent. I only prefer to keep Gordon at FB for his experience and goal kicking. Must be frustrating as all get-out to be a Raiders fan. 2nd only to a Panthers fans. They can beat any team on their day or just not show up at all. Like the Panthers, maybe a star half changes their fortunes?

AUTHOR

2018-10-07T00:48:50+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Looking back I think this year showed up Green more than anything. Knowing what JT brings but then what Morgan delivered last year he seemed to go with the 'hit and hope' selection strategy. Every team needs a leader and JT cannot just give that up as it's not in his nature. That said, a lot of good players fell out of form too plus, like you say, the injuries at different times crueled some options. The positive is, these injuries forced Green's hand in blooding new players and the team will be better for it.

AUTHOR

2018-10-07T00:36:44+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Thanks Paul. Yeah I understand where you all are coming from. It definitely wasn't 'sportsman like' but I take it with a grain of salt, mob mentality and all that. To the letter of the law he shouldn't have played and the Easts fans were just enjoying the fact that his team were getting pumped. I view more as the fans having their fun more than absolute disrespect.

2018-10-06T21:29:43+00:00

peeeko

Roar Guru


i can see most of these sides being a good chance of making the 8 next year despite the massive 6 point gap to 9th this year.

2018-10-06T21:28:39+00:00

peeeko

Roar Guru


Paul, they were Easts yobbos not sydney yobbos

2018-10-06T09:16:25+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Absolutely agree about Marsters.

2018-10-06T07:31:03+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Think you’re under rating them there Tigers Bunney..It’s a decent pack..Luke Garner in the back row caught the eye and has expectations,like to see Twal get more quality time,Packer improved and the older heads Robbie,Taylor and particularly Lawrence if he can stay on the paddock bond them well. Ditto the backs,finally Brooks stood up and took out the player of the year..Esan Masters is the next best center in the NRL,behind Latrell,and how good were Fonoa and Thompson..love to see Benny have a shot with them..

2018-10-06T06:08:07+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Great stuff Nat. As a Bulldogs fan it was a pretty grim season but there were a few highlights. The reserve grade team flogging the full strength Panthers in the aforementioned trial at Belmore. The emergence of Rhyse Martin, Lachlan Lewis and Reimis Smith as not only first graders but potential stars. A patch of good form at the end of the season with 36-22 and 38-0 wins against the Broncos and Dragons respectively. The brilliant semi final campaign and double triumph of the Dogs ISP Cup team. Hopefully a few from that crew will get their opportunities in the next couple of seasons. Unfortunately it doesn’t look like being Zac Woolford and Josh Cleeland who are both unsigned. It boggles the mind how we can persist with guys like Lichaa and Foran and these two young guns get 0 NRL games between them. Anyway, sorry to hijack your great article but the positive spin got me in a positive mood.

2018-10-06T05:47:23+00:00

Justin Kearney

Roar Rookie


Absolutely agree with your comments about Slater mate. His treatment was appalling.

2018-10-06T04:27:14+00:00

3 R M

Guest


Hey Nat the Broncos stocks look good. It was great to see so many youngsters get a good shot and really shine . But when the Cowboys bought Opacic I thought they should have waited since you guys had already signed him, and maybe we could have got one of the other great young players in your system. As for the Cowboys I'm optimistic for next year but pretty apprehensive. We got smashed with key injuries before the first game this year and I don't think we had any momentum from there on. And unfortunately this year we looked disorganised a lot of the time . At the start of the year we seemed unfit . The lack of creativity and urgency in general play lasted until late into the season . Bad ball security,missed tackles, poor kicking and a lack of action from coaching staff led to many losses. now that's a list for the off season. The top 8 next year you would think, would be even harder to make than 18, and after this year I'd say no one is garanteed to be there except for Easts so that's something to look forward to if you follow the rooters but we don't ! I'm hoping for a big turn around for the Cowboys and like a lot of clubs they will be need to adapt their game and bring in youth next year .

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar