Langer's extraordinary prediction in the Adelaide nets may derail the summer

3rd December, 2018

As the Australians prepared for the first of four Tests against India starting Thursday, coach Justin Langer said the final composition of the batting lineup rests between debutant Marcus Harris, and Peter Handscomb on the comeback trail.

That comment means Aaron Finch, and Mitchell Marsh, are definite starters – how many more chances must the younger Marsh get?

Unbelievable.

Of the 14 in the baggy green squad, only veteran paceman Peter Siddle, who is mighty lucky to be there at all, and another debutant in quick Chris Tremain, will definitely miss out.

But how can Harris be under the microscope when he should have been recognised long ago?

In 2010, Harris became the youngest at 18 to crack a Sheffield Shield 150, and five years later was man-of-the-match in the Shield final with 81 and 158.

He moved to Victoria in 2016 with Langer’s parting comment of being a “mediocre” player ringing in his ears, and he’s thrived.

Not only has he scored 501 runs to average 71.57 in this Sheffield Shield season, but his unbeaten 250 against NSW were more runs than the Blues could score in either dig – 159 and 179 – in the innings victory.

Marcus Harris looks set to make his Test debut for Australia. (Photo: Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Harris must open, there’s no conjecture, and Finch should be his opening partner despite the fact he’s having trouble coping with all three formats.

But he’s a big match performer, who also should have been recognised long ago.

That leaves Usman Khawaja at three, followed by Shaun Marsh, Handscomb, Travis Head, the skipper Paine, Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Nathan Lyon and Josh Hazlewood.

That leaves Mitchell Marsh to carry the drinks with a batting average of just 26.01, and bowling average of 42.45 from 30 Tests the justification.

Langer is acknowledged as fiercely supportive of anything Western Australian, but now he’s national coach that must take a back seat when it boils down to what’s best for Australia.

And for good measure Mitchell Marsh has been a party to the pathetic Test record since the ‘Sandpaper-gate’ in Cape Town last March.

Australia lost the last Test in Johannesburg by 492 runs, followed by an honourable draw against Pakistan in Dubai with overall scores of 18-564 compared to 16-663, and lost the second Test at Abu Dhabi by 373 runs.

Serious numbers.

But the Indians haven’t been too crash hot either.

This year the world’s number one Test side has been beaten 2-1 in South Africa, 4-1 in England, and saved some face with a 2-0 win in the Caribbean over a very ordinary side.

Come Thursday they will be facing one of the world’s best attacks in Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood, and Lyon.

Hopefully the long-range weather forecast of a stinking hot summer doesn’t eventuate, as it’s doubtful the pace trio can survive 200-plus overs apiece in the four-Test series if Mother Nature is going to sap them with heat.

But despite the Australians poor record of late, they are still in with a chance if the selected batsmen get the basics right of paying every ball on its merits, and rip into the Indian’s long, and strong, batting lineup.

Importantly, we are in for a fascinating summer that’s important to get the fans back talking and watching cricket, rather than turning away in disgust.

The Crowd Says:

2018-12-06T04:29:16+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru

I just thought I’d add to that. Ravi Ashwin has just come out to bat. The guy has 4 test tons. The same as Watson from many less innings.

2018-12-05T15:59:34+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru

Most of the criticism was his insistence on opening the batting in the long form of the game. If he had been pulling those figures @ 6 then I’d say no one would have criticised. But he continued to open and fail (until a dead rubber) while there was outstanding top order batsmen left out of the side. If David Warner comes back from suspension and averages 35 at the top of the order we can all be sure that he won’t last as long as Watson did. Watson was a fantastic opening bat in white ball cricket. No argument there.

2018-12-05T15:54:01+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru

Dude he was brought in for his bowling-which sucked and he was handed two roads to bat on. The Perth pitch was a s flat as I’ve ever seen and !elbourne was so bad that they were warned over it.

2018-12-05T07:43:53+00:00

Rabbitz

Roar Guru

This. QED

2018-12-04T23:17:54+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru

In part, that's the current climate though, rex. We haven't got the depth to send someone back to the Shield for two years. If they're in reasonable form and have shown that they can succeed in these conditions (both of which apply to M Marsh) then they are odds-on to get picked. I'd be perfectly happy for someone like Burns or Patterson to play instead but I'm not fussed if Marsh starts this series at 6. Even then, of the six players you've named only Katich, Langer and Hayden fit the neat path you're describing. Smith was picked as a spinner then came back as a batsman (and people howled about it until they actually realised he was good), Rogers only played one test initially (as a fill-in) and Khawaja never had a consistent run in the side before eventually becoming a regular in 2015.

2018-12-04T23:00:55+00:00

pakistanstar

Roar Rookie

Imagine how different our side would look if the players below got the same opportunities as either Marsh. Joe Burns Matthew Renshaw Glenn Maxwell Callum Ferguson George Bailey Chad Sayers James Faulkner The Marsh family have been stealing a living from Cricket Australia since the 80's.

2018-12-04T22:38:16+00:00

Hewy

Guest

You know I said first class games for Aus in that sentence. And you know he scored 162 and 1113 for Aus vs India and Pakistan in the last few months. So ignoring it, just makes your rant seem silly.

2018-12-04T13:32:38+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie

David Lord reckons JL set it in concrete. He didn't...but David doesn't really about what was said.

2018-12-04T13:29:22+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie

Argue against it. I suspect you have nothing. All you have is to call on numbers that go back to the last decade.

2018-12-04T13:27:30+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie

You forgot to address the 96.