The XI Australia should select for the first Ashes Test

By Zac Standish / Roar Guru

It was mostly a summer to forget for the Australian cricket team.

From numerous shortcomings on the limited overs stage to a first-ever Test series loss on home soil against India, the turmoil from the events of sandpapergate some eight months prior were without a doubt surfacing for all to see.

A complete domination of Sri Lanka to finish the summer would offer some sort of reprieve for Tim Paine and his men, as the likes of Shaun and Mitchell Marsh, Aaron Finch and Peter Handscomb all became casualties of a selection overhaul in mid-January.

This would see Marnus Labuschagne, Kurtis Patterson, Joe Burns and Jhye Richardson given opportunities in a new-look Australian side that, although facing sub-standard opposition, seemed to gel on the field and performed well as a result.

So, with the much-anticipated return of former captain and vice-captain Steve Smith and David Warner just under two months away, what will the Australian Test side look like when it next takes the field for the first Ashes Test at Edgbaston on the August 1?

1. David Warner
A potentially controversial pick that in reality should be a no brainer, the successful return of David Warner to the top of the batting order will be pivotal if the Australians are any chance of retaining the urn away from home.

At his best Warner is a match winner, plain and simple.

Aggressive in his approaching to batting and the game in general, Warner is a top-class player that can swing the game in your favour in a matter of overs and put pressure on the opposition from the outset.

If he is able to reintegrate himself back into the system with no hiccups and accept his role within the side, he will without a doubt have a big say in the success of the side in this incredibly important Ashes series.

2. Marcus Harris
Entering the Australian summer as a relatively unknown shield prospect, Harris has shown himself to be a player for the future after some admirable performances at the top of the order.

Relatively positive in the way he goes about his cricket, Harris’ technique has stood up at Test level from his very first innings as you got the immediate sense that he belonged in a baggy green.

Despite his reasonable success this summer, Harris did struggle to turn starts into genuine scores on numerous occasions, with no hundreds to absolutely lock his place in the side long term.

This inability to convert starts into big scores has been the source of much frustration for Australian fans throughout the summer, however, Harris has shown in his short Test career a technique and game plan suitable for long term success.

The Ashes will be a critical learning curve for the 26-year-old, who has earned his place for the first Test and will continue to get better with experience.

3. Usman Khawaja
If you had asked me the after play on day one in Canberra last week this selection could well have been different as the out-of-form Usman Khawaja had again failed with a horrendously mistimed drive ending his innings three balls after it began.

(AP Photo/Kamran Jebreili)

In a summer to forget, Khawaja would average just 28.8 in the India series, only passing 50 on one occasion throughout the four Test matches.

However, a ton full of character, class and charisma by the elegant number three in the second innings secured his spot for this Test match as he again enters a Test series with plenty to prove.

Clearly talented enough to hold down a spot in this Australian side, Khawaja sneaks into his usual position at number three as he looks to really cement himself as a top-quality Test cricketer.

4. Steve Smith
Thank the lord, he is back.

After 12 months of agonizing waiting, the Australian team will finally get its superstar back for one of the most important series of his career.

It is needless to say that Smith is the most important player in this team, with his ability to consistently chalk out runs something that makes opposition sides instantly sweat.

A smooth transition back into the team will be perhaps the most important aspect to his upcoming Ashes campaign, as the former skipper looks to reclaim his throne atop of the world batting rankings.

Despite the overall class of the man, Smith has tended to slightly struggle with the moving ball in the past, making this series all the more important as he announces himself back onto the international cricketing stage.

5. Travis Head
Perhaps the biggest positive to come out of the period since the ball-tampering saga, young South Australian Travis Head has emerged as a class middle order batsman.

Beginning with a gutsy 72 in the second innings of his first Test against Pakistan to see his side to a thrilling draw, Head has played a number of outstanding knocks under pressure in his short test career.

A brilliant player of spin that uses his feet well and possesses a solid technique, it seems as if Head will adapt well to the swinging English conditions and play a key role at number five for his country.

Already promoted to the position of vice-captain, the sky is the limit for Head, who after finally breaking through with a maiden century against Sri Lanka will be looking to make his mark on cricket’s greatest rivalry.

6. Kurtis Patterson
By far the hardest position in the side to choose, I’ve gone with late summer bloomer Kurtis Patterson to fill the void at number six for the Australians in England this winter.

A widely unknown prospect, Patterson jumped into the spotlight with two centuries against Sri Lanka in an Australia A tour match to be a late inclusion into the Test side.

Since his inclusion, Patterson has shown the temperament and class of a Test cricketer, adapting to the highest level in extremely impressive fashion.

The hundred he scored in just his second innings, in particular, showed the talent of the man, as he took an inexperienced Sri Lankan bowling attack to the cleaners in an incredible display of Test match batting.

Now, it is obvious that the task becomes a lot more challenging for this series facing Jimmy Anderson and co in their own backyard, however, having battled his way through first-class cricket for a number of years all signs point to a determined young man ready to take his game to another level.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

7. Tim Paine © (wk)
Thrust into the toughest position in Australian sport in dramatic fashion ten months ago, Tim Paine has not put a foot wrong leading this inexperienced group of cricketers.

Along with his work as captain, Paine has also been fantastic behind the stumps throughout the summer, pulling off some extraordinary catches and keeping things tidy and under control.

The one major worry surrounding Paine’s game, however, is his batting, which has been very sub-standard for such a crucial cog in the Australian order.

Over the six Test matches played by Australia this summer, Paine would fail to pass 50 with a score of 41 in the first Test against India the skipper’s best result with bat in hand.

However, his importance to the team with the gloves and in a leadership capacity will without a doubt see him take part in this crucial Ashes series, as he looks to lead Australia to its first series win in England since 2001.

8. Pat Cummins
After a successful return to the Test side last summer, Pat Cummins took his game to another level in this past season with outstanding performances seeing him become the world’s top-ranked bowler and the poster boy of Australian cricket.

Renowned for his raw pace and bounce, Cummins is the bowler every captain dreams of having at his disposal as he always runs in hard and makes the batsman sweat whether they are new to the crease or 150*.

Now the newly crowned best bowler in the world will take his talents to the birthplace of the game for his first Ashes series on British soil.

Spearheading the three ponged Australian pace attack of himself, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc, Cummins will be arguably Australia’s most important player in this series as they look to take advantage of a weaker English batting line-up.

Along with his prodigious ability with the ball, Cummins is also more than capable with the bat with the attacking number eight currently sporting an admirable average of 20 and two half-centuries.

9. Mitchell Starc
If you had to pick the Australian bowler under the most pressure coming into this series it is without a doubt Mitchell Starc, who after a string of subpar performances this summer lost his position as the spearhead of the Australian attack.

At his best, it is very clear that Starc is one of the best bowlers on the planet.

Blessed with incredible speed and an ability to generate large amounts of swings to go along with a toe-crushing yorker, Starc is a major weapon which used correctly will garner a lot of success in any conditions.

However, this past summer Starc has struggled for rhythm, consistency and even pace on several occasions as he only managed to take 13 wickets against India while also being picked off easily by the likes of Cheteshwar Pujara, Majinka Agarwal and Virat Kohli.

With the English conditions famous for rewarding consistent bowling, this is something Starc must improve on in the coming months, as a bowler that leaks runs will only cause disaster for this Aussie side.

(AP Photo/Rick Rycroft)

As Jhye Richardson waits in the wings, I still keep faith in Starc to begin this series, but a couple of bad performances could easily see the big quick on the sidelines by the third Test.

10. Josh Hazlewood
The most consistent of the Aussie quicks, Josh Hazlewood will be a man on a mission come August as he looks to remedy a poor series on British soil in 2015 and prove he can adapt to the swinging conditions.

A tall fast bowler that consistently puts the ball in good areas and troubles the opposition batsman, last time it seemed Hazlewood looked to do much with the swinging ball as he often overpitched to the English batsmen.

Now with four more years of experience under his belt, Hazlewood will look to show that these troubles are behind him and just bowl a consistent line and length, which brought legendary Australian quick Glenn McGrath great amounts of success in the English conditions.

With two strike weapons in Starc and Cummins by his side, Hazlewood has a big role to play in building up pressure on the opposition batsman and toiling away on that good line and length to make life difficult for the English.

At his best, Hazlewood complements this Australian attack perfectly, and as vice-captain of the side will be a massive presence for this team as they look to retain the urn.

11. Nathan Lyon
Among the premier spin bowlers in world cricket, Nathan Lyon will gear up for his third Ashes tour of the British Isles as a crucial clog to the Australian team.

Renowned for his ability to hold up an end and attack through his constant pressurizing line and length, Nathan Lyon will be an invaluable member to this bowling as his consistency will allow Tim Paine to effectively rotate his quicks at the other hand.

Having never truly dominated an Ashes series away from Australian soil, this will be a defining period in the career of Lyon as he looks to cement his legacy one of the best bowlers in Australian history.

Among the more experienced players in the squad, Lyon will also serve as a crucial locker room presence throughout this series as he looks to guide this side through perhaps its biggest challenge.

The Crowd Says:

2019-04-08T09:56:21+00:00

Gaz

Guest


As a pomm, I wholeheartedly welcome Khawaja. Your batting doesn't concern me, think it's about as bad as ours on the whole. Your bowling does though. Just hope we pick Jack Leach, if Steve Smith has a weakness, it's to the ball that goes away from him.

2019-03-13T23:42:06+00:00

Spanner

Roar Rookie


Exactly Gee - too wasteful with a hard, shiny ball !

2019-03-13T23:40:33+00:00

Spanner

Roar Rookie


You'll see it in England Viv - line and length with a bit of movement off the deck) with the Duke. I'd be more worried about Starc, if I were you !

2019-03-08T03:31:33+00:00

Gee

Roar Rookie


Burns for Harris and Richardson for Starc. Burns and Khawaja deserve first go at it I think and Starc strikes me as a bowler unsuited to pommie conditions like Lee and Johnson were.

2019-03-06T23:26:03+00:00

Mario Lia

Guest


Warner Harris and Burns should be the top 3 in the first ashes test. Khawaja is the one whom should be left out. Harris was leading run scorer against India and is the currently the leading shield run scorer. He is also making plenty of runs facing the dukes ball lately.

2019-03-06T12:23:47+00:00

John

Guest


Burns to open thanks.

2019-03-06T11:59:34+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


Like I said, two 50s in 11 digs (with an average of 32) isn't enough to displace one of the best batsmen in the world. It's okay, but it doesn't lock him in. Besides, the guys who came into the side after the bans knew they had limited time to make a case. Warner and Smith will get good hitouts before the Ashes. If they look out of form then fine, hold them back. But my guess is they'll slot back in without too much difficulty. They've been playing and training plenty so it's not as if they'll be blowing out cobwebs.

2019-03-06T09:08:25+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Absolutely. Not trying to exclude them, just have them back under the best circumstances where they have some form backing them and it's all done fairly. :)

2019-03-06T06:56:12+00:00

Joshua Kerr

Roar Guru


If Warner/Smith played in the practice games against the counties and performed well, would you then be happy to include them in the test squad? I know Bancroft is playing for Durham this year so he will be able to get some red-ball experience in English conditions; he's also had good innings in the Sheffield Shield - maybe put him back in at the top order?

2019-03-06T04:20:18+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I think they're one in the same, DP. Ever since Smith & Warner were outed, the selectors have been experimenting with the lineup and finally came up with a team that worked against Sri Lanka. Much of that experimentation would probably not have happened if those 2 guys had been in the team over the past summer. We'll never know for sure of course, but I doubt greatly Finch would have opened the Test batting and Labushagne would probably not have scored a baggy green.

2019-03-06T04:16:40+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


I would have thought Harris had done enough against India to be fairly safe if it wasn't Warner - so he would be dumped on reputation? Labuschagne - yeah, agreed and I wouldn't have had him there. But you can't keep tossing guys in on a whim and then tossing them out. How is Warner and Smith's red ball form like lately?? Marnus hasn't cemented a spot in my book, but have Smith or Warner made a compelling case for immediate inclusion by weight of runs over the past year?? Let them get some form or runs before we all expect them to magically transform our fortunes.

2019-03-06T04:12:00+00:00

VivGilchrist

Roar Rookie


What does Hazlewood bring to the side? Because whatever it is, I haven’t seen it in a while.

2019-03-06T04:05:31+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Am I suggesting experimenting? Or sticking with the last winning test team?

2019-03-06T03:45:33+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


I just say two words.... Joe Burns

2019-03-06T02:57:52+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


If Harris (on the basis that Burns should really be ahead of him in the pecking order) and Labuschagne had cemented spots in the side then it would be fair to question whether Smith and Warner should just waltz back in. But they haven't. Harris only reached 50 twice in 11 digs (albeit one was washed out) while Labuschagne only has one 50 from his first eight innings. You can also mount a strong argument that Labuschagne hadn't made a compelling case for selection in the first place. Throw in the fact that Warner and Smith are the best two red ball batsmen in the country, with daylight in third place, and they simply can't be omitted based purely on not being the incumbents. I'd happily have Harris and Labuschagne in the squad but they haven't earned the right to keep better players out of the side.

2019-03-05T22:35:52+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


DP I agree with your sentiments about Warner in particular, but I don't think the First Test of any series, let alone an Ashes in England is a place to be experimenting with the batting lineup, which is essentially what you're suggesting. By all means, play the current squad in practice matches and see how they go and even play them in the First Test IF Warner and/or Smith is not fully fit, but both have to play if available as they are still our two best Test batsmen by a country mile.

2019-03-05T22:32:28+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Zac, Burns would have to be injured not to walk out with Warner to open in the First Test in England. He's shown he can make big Test scores and is in some pretty good form. I agree with your other selections, though Smith & Warner need to get some good centre wicket practice in, sooner rather than later, and show the rest of the guys exactly what they can do. If Hazlewoods not 100% right, I'd love to see Jhye Richardson get a game. He looked very comfortable in the baggy green against Sri Lanka

2019-03-05T22:18:01+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


And a good response - touche :). I think you got my point - I want these guys back too so definitely in the squad - but just imagine how it might be, if this current group, buoyed by the trust and faith the selectors had in keeping them, rose to the occasion and actually made it difficult for Smith and Warner to walk back in? Imagine us winning the first test without these two, how strong would our cricket be then? And if we lost (there's no guarantee these two would have made it a win) nobody could claim they were stiffed by the selectors if replaced. Plus then whoever is in the best form gets the best chance to keep their job. What's Harris done to be cast aside for Warner just on reputation? Maybe Khawaja is still struggling so they tweak #3?

2019-03-05T20:12:39+00:00

ForwardsWinMatches

Guest


Agree with the sentiment DP, even if for slightly different reasons. I don’t want Warner back in the team at all - I think he’s a bad influence and overall a bad look. I think Smith should earn his way back and if he can, drop Khawaja and shuffle them up one with Maxwell in at 6. Burns and Harris to open.

2019-03-05T16:17:39+00:00

Joshua Kerr

Roar Guru


A really good point made here. The Australian players who have replaced Smith/Warner/Bancroft have worked hard in the test squad this year to try and compensate for the loss of the trio. However, saying that, if they aren't included in the squad, Australia may find it a struggle to retain the Ashes without the class batting of Warner and Smith. I think it's time to forgive and forget - all three have done the time for their crime. Mohammad Amir's doing well for himself after his 5 year ban for match fixing.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar