The Freo trio flying under the radar

By Marnie Cohen / Expert

Not that I am keeping tabs, but for those wondering, we have gone nearly two months without Alex Rance in the game.

In the season-opener against Carlton, the Tigers’ star fullback ruptured his ACL – an injury that will almost certainly see him miss the entire 2019 season.

Is it just me or does it feel slightly empty without Rance?

He is a true gentleman and superstar of the game and it feels a little strange not seeing him out there in the yellow and black, week in and week out.

One thing that will certainly feel different without Rancey is the All-Australian side.

For five years, Rance has cemented his spot as the AA fullback and in 2017 he was handed the captaincy.

So this year, things will look a little different – and fellow media and footy fans haven’t taken long to start looking for his replacement.

While it’s probably too soon to be discussing the 2019 AA side, it’s encouraging to see so many different defenders enter the frame of discussion.

I want to discuss one that has somehow flown under the radar.

Fremantle’s Alex Pearce.

Week in, week out he is minimising the effect of some of the league’s biggest names and is barely beaten to the ball.

I saw Pearce play in Round 1 this year, at home against North Melbourne.

Pearce kept Ben Brown to two goals and a behind, rather ordinary by his standards.

Brown also did not take one mark against his opponent and was constantly second to the ball behind Pearce.

For reference, on the weekend Ben Brown took three marks (one contested) and kicked three goals on Carlton’s highly praised Liam Jones before the opening quarter was over.

Pearce is not a player you can typically refer to the stat sheet to find the impact he’s having.

His numbers are modest, which could be one of a number of reasons he’s yet to really capture the attention of those outside WA.

But the key to his game is he winning the hard ball over his opponent.

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

At the end of Round 7, Pearce is averaging 11.4 disposals a game – 8.7 of those intercept possessions and 7.3 of those contested.

So he’s winning the important contests in the back line and rarely coming off second best.

His numbers aren’t big but they do reflect just how hard he is working down back for the Dockers.

Last week, former Hawthorn premiership player Xavier Ellis spoke highly of the 23-year-old’s start to 2019.

“He’s averaging just 0.8 one-on-one losses in defence across the six games, and has an elite rating for ground ball gets as a key defender, according to AFL Stats Pro,” Ellis said on The Hard Ball Gets AFL Show.

“Alex Pearce is the best defender in the competition. He has not been beaten.”

You can gauge an even better understanding of his effectiveness by sitting down and watching him play.

The fact that he has been spoken about so little in 2019 leads me to believe few make an effort to do so.

If you watch Pearce from week to week, it’s the effort and one-percenters – he averaged five a game – that truly highlight his worth.

And he’s not alone.

Pearce has exceptional company in fellow defenders Joel Hamling and Luke Ryan.

Every week Fremantle fans have been writing home about Luke Ryan and it is no surprise why.

His exceptional distribution of the ball has been a factor in Fremantle’s ability to walk their way out of trouble in defence.

He’s averaged 23 disposals at an elite 89 per cent efficiency over seven games.

Ryan has provided trustworthy hands to take the ball out of Fremantle’s defence and shuffle it out to the midfield.

It’s a wonder why few have taken notice.

(Photo by Daniel Carson/AFL Media/Getty Images)

Ryan himself has been crying out for some attention that he’s gone to the extreme lengths of bleaching his hair.

Similarly to Pearce, he’s also averaging just under nine (8.7) intercept disposals a game.

As for Hamling, the start to his AFL career wasn’t quite smooth sailing, but it appears to be third time lucky at Fremantle.

Alongside Pearce and Ryan, he too has enjoyed a great start to his third season back home in WA.

Hamling is like a general down back. His spoils and one-percenters proving the difference in his game.

His desperation to get to the ball and make a contest is what makes him such a valued player in the Fremantle line up.

It’s no coincidence Freo have been so hard to score against in the opening seven rounds of the season.

At the start of Round 7, Fremantle averaged just 67.7 points scored against them per game – the lowest it’s ever been under coach Ross Lyon.

Despite a loss to Adelaide on the weekend, they restricted them to 51 points in a game that was won in the midfield.

The defence is working mighty hard to get the job done and have been rarely beaten.

And this is just the beginning for the Fremantle back line.

The trio have played less than 160 games between them and have a lot more football to go.

If this is a glimpse of Fremantle’s future, then there is plenty to smile about.

So why don’t we talk about it?

If I was to take one guess, it’s that we aren’t paying enough attention to what’s going on in the west.

Supporters may be outraged by the lack of attention and while it is thoroughly deserved, flying under the radar seems to suit this group perfectly.

There are plenty of big talkers around them.

They’re putting their heads down and walking the walk.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2019-05-07T11:05:46+00:00

Downsey

Roar Pro


Yeah, under par forward line exacerbated the low score imo. Just when I think our forwards are getting it together, they give us that effort. Mind, our midfield also failed to deliver to them at times.

2019-05-07T10:56:39+00:00

Downsey

Roar Pro


"...capture the attention of those outside of WA" Freo's back line hasn't been flying under the radar for anyone who actually pays attention to the WA teams. Pearce, Hamling, Ryan et al. are the ultimate defensive wall. You need to be the Night King riding on a forking undead ice dragon to have any chance of getting through them.

2019-05-07T01:49:39+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


Adelaide seemed intent on prioritising defence from the get-go and got that extra man back. Freo started the game with an extended territorial advantage.

2019-05-07T01:45:27+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


They'll sputter for a while yet, kicking into life here and there. A fully cohesive forward line rarely happens overnight, particularly when the new shiny star forward has had no preseason to speak of.

2019-05-06T15:05:37+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


Thanks Marnie, agree he was a fantastic coach. I hope he can prove me wrong but i think his time has passed IMO

2019-05-06T14:21:58+00:00

dontknowmuchaboutfootball

Guest


Just to clarify, with that last question, are you suggesting that, because Freo's forwards have not been provided with adequate coaching, Lyon should be replaced with the current forwards coach, i.e. the one who has presumably been responsible for coaching the forwards?

2019-05-06T09:30:40+00:00

13th Man

Guest


Been saying this for weeks. Darcy Moore is getting a huge amount of press and rightly so but didn't Daniher kick 4 on him the other week? Pearce is absolutely brilliant and is the number one shut down defender in the comp, although a couple of those crows boys would be in with a shout as well. Ryan and Hamling are both also brilliant. Now can we please get that front half working Ross??

2019-05-06T08:58:17+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


Naughton for a 19 year old is banging down doors. There's plenty to be excited about. Pearce & Hamling are 23 & 26 respectively. I think you find why Naughton is getting a fair bit of press at the moment. Both Pearce and Hamling are great players. But they should be, they've been around an AFL list for quite a while now.

AUTHOR

2019-05-06T08:32:06+00:00

Marnie Cohen

Expert


He is a very good coach. You don't accidentally make three (4) grand finals - you are slightly out coached and overall unlucky to lose them. Whether he is a great coach, and will ever win one, I'm not so sure. But I will enjoy his dry humour at press conferences as long as he is in the game.

AUTHOR

2019-05-06T08:29:34+00:00

Marnie Cohen

Expert


He is going to be star. I'm scared for Ben Brown's future encounters w Freo yet cannot wait at the same time

2019-05-06T08:21:10+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


So basically what your saying is Freo, need a coach that can provide a forward structure because the one they have got has been talking about about it for years but cannot provide it, your right. Your description of the game (forward line) on Sunday is not new. Freo need new ideas from a new look coaching staff starting with Ross. How good is Hale ?

2019-05-06T07:51:11+00:00

dontknowmuchaboutfootball

Guest


The thing about Pearce is when he was a kid he used to play midfield. Then he had his growth spurt. So jumping into the groundball contest is second nature to him. He's a man of second and third efforts, and he not only often wins the ball in those situations, but is then very happy to run through the traffic with the aim of getting out a more effective clearance. He's a superb close-checking defender, but it's his contested ball work that makes him so much more than that.

2019-05-06T07:44:52+00:00

dontknowmuchaboutfootball

Guest


Agreed. I thoroughly enjoyed the game (except for the result), and was supremely impressed with Adelaide's defence. For all the blathering about Freo playing an extra behind the ball, the lack of options forward of the ball presented as a problem relatively infrequently. The biggest problems with Freo's attack was the forwards not spreading as the ball moved past centre (so many kicks to packs), leaving the forwards either jumping all over each other, or — worse — not contesting the mark at all. So many times the Adelaide player would step into the space being guarded by three flat-footed Freo forwards and take the mark.

2019-05-06T06:42:06+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


Marnie- your thoughts on Ross Lyon briefly ??

2019-05-06T06:24:18+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


McCarthy was terrible, when he is good he his good, But when he is bad it is really bad. Which is consistency once again, makes way for Blakely, and we need to manage a couple and give North and Giro a run this week.

2019-05-06T06:14:50+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


I know, I wasn’t interpreting it as a dig. I was more commenting because I thought it was funny. Gotta see the funny sides of such an intriguing game. :)

2019-05-06T06:02:22+00:00

User

Roar Rookie


This was to JB and the digs about darling he's been having man, not a dig at Freo.

2019-05-06T06:01:20+00:00

User

Roar Rookie


Ross coached well imo, awful game but it gave Freo a chance considering Adelaide where quite dominant without scoring in the first quarter and have handed Freo multiple spanks at the ADL oval. Pity Hogan, tabener and McCarthy couldn't take advantage of chances they had.

2019-05-06T05:51:20+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


Matti, all teams at some stage have a loose man in defense, but Ross more than most has between 10-16 in defense regularly.

2019-05-06T05:51:09+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


They almost kicked more than Adelaide, too!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar