Collingwood vs Melbourne: Queen's Birthday Forecast

By Marnie Cohen / Expert

There are many special individuals in this game, but it’s hard to find one having as much of an impact as Neale Daniher.

The former Essendon captain and Melbourne coach fought for many years on field and in the coaches box, but is now battling motor neurone disease and fighting for his life.

Since his diagnosis in 2013 and the launch of the Fight MND foundation in 2014, he has helped raise over $30 million towards research in hope of finding a cure for the incurable.

In recent years, the fundraiser has reached new heights thanks to the Big Freeze slide at the G and its beanies available for sale.

Now, the annual Queens Birthday clash between Melbourne and Collingwood is about more than just footy, as the community unites to support one of its favourite sons and a very important cause.

With the Big Freeze now in its fifth year, Daniher handpicked 14 former Australian sports stars to slide down the most famous slope in the country.

This year’s line up includes former Australian basketballer Lauren Jackson, former Hawthorn legends Sam Mitchell and Cyril Rioli, former Bulldog stars Bob Murphy and Liam Picken and Olympic champion Anna Meares.

The line up also includes Collingwood premiership midfielder Dane Swan, who I am sure they would’ve preferred to be lining up in the side rather than the slide into the ice bath on Monday.

He would be a more than handy replacement for the injured Dayne Beams, who is set to miss up to at least three months with a hip injury.

The Pies, will however be strengthened by the return of Mason Cox who will play his first game since ANZAC day. It has come at the expense of Ben Reid, however, who makes way for the American. Brayden Sier is the other inclusion for Collingwood.

The Pies are sitting pretty inside the top four with eight wins and three losses, however last week proved no match for an on-fire Fremantle outfit, lead by match-winner Michael Walters.

And while most will think another controversial score review was the reason for the Pies’ loss, the stats say otherwise.

Fremantle won the contested possessions, tackle and inside 50 count, appearing hungrier and more determined to win the ball and take the four points back to WA.

It was just a small bump in the road for the Pies, who won their previous seven straight games.

(Photo by Daniel Carson/AFL Media/Getty Images)

The same can’t be said about the Dees, who are struggling on the other end of the ladder and have failed to back up their sensational 2018.

While they have looked better in recent weeks, a last-gasp loss to Adelaide in Darwin last week was their eighth for the year.

One would suggest that 2019 is over for the Dees, but coach Simon Goodwin believes “anything’s possible still in this season” for his team.

And today, as a host of key players return to the Melbourne line up, we are going to find out just how good they are.

Coming into Round 12, the Dees had registered the most points against them of any team this season.

Therefore, the return of prized recruits Steven May and Jake Lever would be music to Melbourne’s ears.

Both defenders will return from injury this week, with May lining up for the first time since Round 2, while Lever will make his first appearance since mid-2018.

And the good news didn’t stop there, with Christian Salem and Marty Hore also returning to the lineup, Oscar McDonald, Jay Kennedy-Harris, Josh Wagner and Billy Stretch making way.

Melbourne will need all the strength down back that they can get as they come up against the competition’s most efficient team inside 50.

Collingwood are travelling at 54 per cent going inside 50, equal with Geelong as the best in the league.

It’s a stark difference to the Dees who are the most inefficient at 40 per cent.

What will determine the outcome of today’s game is which Melbourne outfit comes out to play.

The Pies have been pretty consistent across the board and week in, week out you know what you’re going to get.

But what Melbourne side will we see? One of dee-termination or dee-saster?

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

I suspect that will have an impact on the final result.

So, who wins? Perhaps the side, or individuals, who take ownership of the game.

When Neale Daniher addressed both sides during the week, he spoke of his grandson Cooper and teaching him how to take responsibility in life.

“Take responsibility – no matter what happens, it’s up to you to do something about it,” he told Melbourne players earlier in the week.

“By doing that, what will emerge inside of you is the better side of your character that will allow you to prevail.”

I think it’ll be tight and tough, but I think the Pies have what it takes.

That’s my Monday forecast, what’s yours?

The Crowd Says:

2019-06-10T05:14:54+00:00

User

Roar Rookie


I guess the good thing about wce is they win premierships even when they have multiple 7-8 goals losses in a year. Keep trying.

2019-06-10T05:02:12+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


The good thing still with the Pies is unlike the Eagles, they don’t get 7-8 goal beltings when we lose. Perhaps that starts today but so far we have been in every game.

2019-06-10T04:55:40+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


I don’t think it’s just the new rules. The Cats are on to something else we may not work out until they win the flag.

2019-06-10T02:57:59+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Don’t think the bye will be a problem. Different side, mentally tough. I, we keep setting them hurdles but they just keep doing it. Haven’t set a foot wrong since the arrogant, presumptive performance against GWS.

2019-06-10T02:52:59+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


I have been saying for a while, that the Cats had adapted to the new rules and sides like Richmond where playing under an old paradigm. The Pies are halfway there. GWS are just raw talent. WCE, play so inconsistently that I have no idea.

2019-06-10T02:50:55+00:00

User

Roar Rookie


3 losses on your homeground aswell as a number of close calls to sides like the wb and Essendon does show Melbourne has a better than average chance today. Mental scarring or some other hooplah the talkbackers might say for Collingwood? Who fkn knows, all I know is they haven't impressed at an stage this year besides 1quarter vs port. Any less than a 20 point victory will be alarming.

2019-06-10T02:43:44+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


You had your wake up last week.If it is close, Sidie will get you over the line.

2019-06-10T01:55:09+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


I tipped the demons before the round started. After all the other surprise winners I am not so sure now. Melbourne have been close to winning, just shooting them selves in the foot. Big ins should help them defensively. Pies missing a few. I wonder if losing Beams, as good as he is, will force the Pies to better balance their midfield between inside and outside.

2019-06-10T01:37:13+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Interesting curse on 4th spot. Cats are unique and near full strength. They are trailblazing a new style and none of us have worked it out yet.

2019-06-10T01:35:57+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Yattuzzi, we aren’t playing well and are missing Adams, Beams, Jamie Elliott, Langdon and Scharenberg from our best 22. Melbourne regain Lever and May and a couple more today. Demons would be my tip today.

2019-06-10T01:33:26+00:00

ChrisH

Roar Rookie


Yeah, and incredibly, the Cats seem underrated by a lot of people still. A lot of scribes still say the Pies will win the flag. I can understand that on the “when/ifs” sense, but on current form, there’s daylight after the Cats. The Cats big bogey is the bye, especially the end of season one. I’m not handing the flag to the Cats yet tho. It’s not easy winning from top spot (only 1 of the last 8 flags). Also, last year WCE lost three straight mid-season, and the year before the Tiges lost four straight, so September’s all that counts. On a semi-side note and a warning to the other sides battling for a spot in the top 4, historically, it’s impossible to win the flag from fourth spot in the current final 8 system (started 2000), with only 2 teams even making the grand final from fourth spot out of a total 38 (19 GFs).

2019-06-10T01:24:59+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


3rd vs 15, should be a walk in the park. The win will put you up into second by a game and maybe even percentage.

2019-06-09T22:00:22+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


If the Demons win today the real story is the Cats sitting three games clear on top by round 12. Extraordinary. Challengers are dropping off left, right and centre. Eagles the latest to stumble with yet another 8 goal belting perhaps showing they have dropped away.

2019-06-09T21:35:50+00:00

Grints

Roar Rookie


The inclusions for Melbourne quell my anxiety a bit - all quality. However it will take a bit for May and Lever to get back into top form and make an impact i think. Cant see them getting over a strong Collingwood.

Read more at The Roar