Six talking points from Super Rugby Round 17

By Oliver Matthews / Expert

The finals are so close you can practically smell the tension. Excitingly, after 17 rounds there are still several teams who are fighting it out to keep the dream alive and as we head into the final week of the regular season fans and coaches at some clubs will be reaching for a pen, paper and calculator as they try and figure out what has to happen for their team to make the knock-out stages.

In a round that saw some teams’ dreams come true and others’ turn into nightmares, there is plenty to talk about – so let’s get stuck in.

Oh boy are the Reds going to miss Kerevi
Samu Kerevi has played his last home game for the Reds for this season and potentially forever, and this should have every Reds fan very upset.

It’s been a tough season for the Reds but in recent weeks their young team has shown real signs of improvement and there has already been talk of the exciting future that 2020 will bring.

However, with Kerevi leaving the Queensland side, the Reds will find themselves with a huge hole to fill. If we talk purely about his on-field performance, this season has highlighted what a talent Kervei has developed into.

Consider these stats:

First in the carries category with over 40 more than the next best player.
Fourth highest number of clean breaks with 24
First in terms of defenders beaten with 66 so far this season
Second in the comp when it comes to off loads

These are impressive statistics and are no surprise to anyone who has watched him play this year.

When you add to this the incalculable value that he brings in terms of leadership, Brad Thorn must be wondering how on earth can he replace his captain.

Kerevi has led from the front week in and week out and shown his team of youngsters what it really takes to dominate at Super Rugby.

When rugby in Australia is desperately trying to capture the public’s attention and engage with them, losing this guy to an overseas club is a terrible thing and a great loss to the domestic game.

(Photo by Daniel Jayo/Getty Images)

Did the Rebels miss the memo?
So the Rebels must have had an issue with their IT systems or wifi or something? Because none of the players seemed to get the memo about the game against the Crusaders not being a non-contact training session.

While you might be concerned about the Rebels email issues, you can rest peacefully knowing that they are absolute dead certs for the “Best Team Impression of a Bunch of Turnstiles” award and stand a very good chance of getting a medal at the next Olympics in the Just Standing Around event.

Now playing the Crusaders at home the week after they lost is always a tricky situation and the men from Christchurch were on fire on Saturday.

They played some delicious rugby and people checking out YouTube couldn’t be blamed for thinking they were watching a full season highlights reel when they watched the replay of the game.

However, what should be very worrying for the Rebels is the way they got so easily torn to pieces. They had the same amount of possession as the Crusaders and actually slightly dominated the territory and yet they conceded 10 tries and missed 36 per cent of their tackles. That is incredible!

It reached a point where when the Crusaders were given a penalty inside their own 22, they tapped and ran so confident were they of creating a scoring opportunity. You know you’re in trouble when a team does that to you.

Bizarrely the Rebels are still heading for their first finals appearance and as long as they win their final game at home against the Chiefs, then they will likely see this season as a success.

They’ve won just two games from their last eight and even if they do win next week, that’s hardly the form you want to be taking into the finals.

Folau-gate isn’t the reason why the Tahs face a long offseason
Technically the Tahs still have a chance of making the finals but they are going to need a bonus point win when they travel to play the Highlanders and for other results to break in their favour.

So the odds are that the men from NSW will be watching the finals from the sofa and you have to say that’s not really surprising given the way they’ve struggled to find good consistent form.

It would be easy to echo Nick Phipps’ words from the weekend that the fall out from the Folau saga has ruined their season. Understandably it’s made things harder both on and off the field.

But it would be a huge mistake to blame their season on this no matter how strongly Phipps feels it’s messed them around.

There are other key reasons why the Tahs have struggled this season and there’s a growing amount of evidence that indicates that the issues start with the coaching team.

In the lead up to this weekend’s game there was more discussion about how the Tahs hadn’t given their Wallabies the agreed level of rest games this season and were intending to keep playing them in the belief that they could make the difference between finals and no finals.

This just goes to show how the Tahs are not being managed well enough right now. The Brumbies have honoured their commitment to the Wallabies by resting their players and look how they are flying at the moment – they’ve won the Australian conference, secured a home quarter-final and have the best recent form in the whole competition.

Arguably the Brumbies have fewer stars compared to their NSW cousins and yet they blew the Tahs away this weekend, and this season in general.

These “star” players have not improved at Super Rugby level for years now and some are even going backwards (or sideways in Kurtley Beale’s case!)

When the inevitable offseason review takes place at Tahs HQ, let’s hope they are honest with themselves that the problems with their club go far deeper than just missing one player.

(Photo by Anthony Au-Yeung/Getty Images)

Is Super Rugby more even than ever?
Despite criticising two of the Australian sides in the last two points, it’s interesting to note that Australian clubs have had one of their best years for quite a while especially against New Zealand opponents.

Just a couple of years ago not a single Australian side was able to beat a New Zealand side in the entire season. Last year this started to improve and this year there have been some great wins over Kiwi teams.

Over in the South African conference we’ve seen a brilliant race for the finish line with currently four of their teams in the finals and the fifth just one point off a finals spot.

Yes there is plenty of debate about the Jaguares and how their impressive form is not that surprising considering they are basically the Argentinian side – but the fact is that things are much more competitive than they have been for a long time.

Now there could be plenty of reasons behind this and it’s likely that the RA will want to apportion at least some of the cause to the axing of the Western Force. Others might point to some of the Kiwi talent that left New Zealand before this season kicked off.

It’s not true to say that this is now the most even competition ever, and it does still look like the Crusaders will take home the crown for the third time in a row.

But, things are going in the right direction and that is a good thing for everyone. As the competition continues to evolve and change, it’ll be interesting to see whether this trend continues.

Worryingly for others, Kiwi stars coming back at just the right time
So it’s a good news, bad news thing. The good news is the Super Rugby competition is getting some of its best talent back and into form as we head into the finals.

The bad news is that this talent is coming from New Zealand and even more worrying is that most of it is to be found within the Crusaders and the Hurricanes.

On the weekend players who have struggled with injury this year put in impressive performances. Kieran Read looked good against the Rebels and while the opposition played poorly, the Kiwi No.8 had some lovely moments with his hands and played well at the back of the scrum.

Over in South Africa the Canes welcomed back Dane Coles who played the second half and looked full of energy and talent. He scored twice and will be a real handful for any side who comes up against the ‘Canes in the finals.

Obviously this is also frustrating news for the Springboks and Wallabies as we approach the Rugby Championship and World Cup, but in the immediate future, the top two teams in the competition have got two of their best players back and in form.

(Photo by Kai Schwoerer/Getty Images)

Really exciting finals just around the corner
For some teams the season is already over or just 80 minutes away from being over. Obviously it’s going to be disappointing for their fans but if you’re a fan of rugby in general then you should be very excited about the finals series that we’ve got coming in the next few weeks.

Yes there are the same names of the Crusaders and Hurricanes who seemed to book their spots very early on and will be very hard to beat home or away.

But beyond those two there are some great stories evolving. The Jaguares have found their rhythm and style and are not just winning but dominating sides. They’ve only lost once in their last eight games and recently completed a 100 percent successful tour of Australia.

Meanwhile the Brumbies are the only side with better form than the Argentinians and are a club who have developed a genuinely all-round game plan that has seen them charge into the finals.

These four sides alone are going to make the finals fascinating and rugby fans have got some great games ahead of them, and that’s before we even consider whether one of the other four sides could put in a legendary run and challenge these top dogs.

So is it as straightforward to say that the 2019 trophy has the Crusaders name already etched on it? Or will one of the other top three teams steal their thunder come the Grand Final?

The Crowd Says:

2019-06-12T14:48:54+00:00

Realist

Guest


That must be it. RA are a competent body who aren’t controlled by NSW board members pushing their own agendas. Thanks for enlightening us TWAS. I feel like this is a great reason to not sign these blokes even though they are better than any of the incumbents from the Tahs in Hooper and Beale. Nic White is obviously not as good as Phipps and lord only knows Hannigan is world class. Thanks for today’s serving of rugby rhetoric from RA HQ. Will tomorrow’s lesson be that Dean Mumm should have more test caps to his name???

2019-06-12T14:27:56+00:00

Realist

Guest


Well Phipps was ‘player of the series for England’ when they whitewashed the Wallabies 3-0 at home in 2016.

2019-06-12T12:20:51+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Well nothing says owning somebody like having to toot your own horn to say it... But not sure at all what it has to do with David Pocock’s injury history either way...

2019-06-12T12:09:28+00:00

Banjo Kelly

Roar Rookie


Fair enough but they can’t expect to have thei cake and eat it. Both To’omua and White should have backed themselves to make the 23, In my view. Kerevi will leave at the peak of his powers (if he goes) .Let’s hope he re-signs with a super rugby franchise for later on, to allow him to play in 2020 tests.

2019-06-12T12:07:45+00:00

Realist

Guest


Still stinging because I ‘owned’ you in this thread TWAS ? https://www.theroar.com.au/rugby-union/video/youre-damaging-the-game-rod-kafer-blasts-israel-folau-775443/ Get over it.

2019-06-12T07:27:00+00:00

One Eye

Roar Rookie


Crusaders have never, ever, lost a home playoff match and considering this would be title 10 (if they win) that's a lot of matches.

2019-06-12T07:19:23+00:00

One Eye

Roar Rookie


Big on the rumour mill today is Beauden Barrett is signing with the Blues, why for the life of me I cannot understand but apparently he was close in 2016 as well.

2019-06-12T05:31:31+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


He was given the extra year off the back of a good season though. I think locking him in for merely one more year, basically indicating they intend to look beyond him long term is pretty smart.

2019-06-12T05:30:17+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


You never, ever write off a champion and big game specialist Is it writing somebody off to question whether they will be available though?

2019-06-12T05:25:51+00:00

Realist

Guest


johnR - you must have rocks in your head dismissing Pocock so casually when he was the Wallaby’s best player by a country mile in the last two World Cups - literally dragging them into the SF (2011 - remember his effort in the QF) & F (2015). You never, ever write off a champion and big game specialist, especially not in a team hamstrung by Chieka and the NSWRU (RA) As for Locky’s team and I would have the Rebels’ hooker for BPA and as overrated as he is - ‘Beale’ over Hegarty.

2019-06-11T11:48:23+00:00

Peter

Guest


Is this just not very clever rhyming slang or are you referring (incorrectly) to King Richard III of England?

2019-06-11T03:44:50+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


the problem for blues is the 10 - before looking for scrum halves they need an older head at 10. i have been asking this question from the time Perofeta got injured - why did the Blues not get a short term fix. they can get short term players when one player has a long term injury - but they did not get another 10 the 2 guys they have are simply rubbish - sorry to say their planning has been abysmal long time ago i said they shud get hold of Pisi - they did not and he went to Wolves for one year and moved to England. now there is hardly any old 10 around - who can be a mentor and a general on the field. maybe Delany but then he may retire before next season Blues have always put faith in little boys to be their general or some league convert. the silly part is they have been trying this for many years and keep doing it even when it has not worked for so long. i think that is insane.

2019-06-11T03:38:41+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


Crusaders will play Hurricanes in a semi.

2019-06-11T03:14:15+00:00

Jamie

Guest


True Zado, I expect at least 16 Waratahs in the Cheikas RWC 31 squad. It really is not fair how they get a saloon passage into gold every year.I expect him to pick on favourites not form as he has done since 2014.

2019-06-11T01:38:12+00:00

Reedy

Guest


Too many Tahs continually picked have taken the Wallabies from 2nd ranked in 2013 to 6/7 ranked now. No coincidence Chuckles the Clown stacked his Wallaby team with Tahs after the 2014 super win. Look at us now? No more Tahs.Enough is enough !!

2019-06-11T01:33:59+00:00

Markus

Roar Rookie


Honestly it's one of the few times I have actually agreed with Phipps. Folau has given no thought to anyone but himself throughout this whole saga - not to the people his posts were directed at, nor to his teammates who have had to deal with both the public scrutiny as well as internal politics of siding with the player or siding with the team.

2019-06-11T01:20:39+00:00

Markus

Roar Rookie


Repay what dues? Toomua was contracted in Super Rugby for 9 seasons. Injuries played their part, but ultimately coaches including the current one decided he wasn't in their plans. Cheika specifically had RA re-write their eligibility rules so that he could pick Giteau over Toomua for the RWC. White the same, what is his obligation to stick around when the coach explicitly says you are not in his plans?

2019-06-11T01:16:09+00:00

Akari

Roar Rookie


I can't see that by-plenty team doing it for sure. On current form, the Jaguares should be able to do it but they must turn up ready to play for 100 minutes.

2019-06-11T01:09:26+00:00

Bluesfan


Yea - He has quality stamped all over him. When you look at the Crusaders - even there 3rd choice players would walk into a lot of Super teams.

2019-06-11T01:05:10+00:00

Carlos the Argie

Roar Guru


Seconds.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar