Asia should have its own Nations League

By Paul Nicholls / Roar Guru

Imagine if every time the Socceroos stepped onto the pitch it was for competition points. No more tiresome friendlies.

It’s happening in Europe already. I’d like to think it could happen in Asia too. Why not across the globe?
 
On June 9 Cristiano Ronaldo held UEFA’s latest trophy aloft at the Estadio do Dragao in Porto.

In defeating the Netherlands 1-0, Portugal became the inaugural UEFA Nations League Champions. It signified a new era in international football.
 
For those unfamiliar with the Nations League concept, a brief explanation is in order. It came about largely to replace the meaningless friendlies that occur during FIFA international windows and as such doesn’t add to the number of international fixtures being played.

The competition is played over a two-year time span.
 
The 55 countries in Europe are separated into four divisions: A, B, C and D. Within each division the teams are split up into groups of three or four teams.
 
The four group winners in Division A play a knockout to determine the overall champion. Group winners in lower divisions are promoted to the next highest division and group losers get relegated.

It’s basically a football pyramid for nations. As teams improve they can rise through the divisions.
 
There has been some debate as to the merits of this new championship. Is it a major trophy or not? I don’t believe you can call it a major trophy yet although time may change that.

England’s Danny Welbeck and Harry Kane applaud supporters. (AP Photo/Matt Dunham)

 
By allowing some countries to qualify for the 2020 European Championships via the UEFA Nations League and the carrot of possible World Cup qualification spots in years to come, there is incentive to perform well.
 
The first version has already thrown up some good stories. North Macedonia and Kosovo were both promoted to Division C for the next tournament.
 
It doesn’t stop there. From September 2019, the 41 teams of CONCACAF (North and Central America) will be conducting their own Nations League with three divisions. With talk of a four division Nations League in Africa also kicking off in 2019 it seems the concept has taken hold.
 
It is a concept the Asian Football Confederation (AFC) should seriously consider. How good would it be for developing football nations such as The Philippines, India and Cambodia to attempt to climb out of their divisions.
 
With 47 member associations, the AFC could be neatly divided into three divisions of around 16 teams each. A three tiered system or two tiers with a geographical split at the lowest tier would both work.

There could be some enticing match-ups at the lower levels: Mongolia playing Maldvies perhaps, or Northern Mariana Islands against Timor L’este. It goes without saying that regular competitive matches will improve these teams.

If the Nations League format could be bedded down at the Confederation level it is not too much of a stretch to think that down the track a world league of two or three divisions could develop. 

It would bring great benefits to teams at the higher end of the weaker confederations: teams such as Australia, Korea, USA, Mexico and many African nations.

A three division 48 team world league based on current FIFA world rankings would have:
–          Five South American teams in Division A.
–          Iran and Japan along with African nations Senegal and Tunisia in Division B
–          Australia and Korea would in Division C

Imagine watching Australia taking on Serbia for a crucial match for promotion to Division B at Suncorp Stadium!

A flight of fancy perhaps but the Nations League concept at the confederation level has gained traction in Europe, the Americas and Africa. It’s high time the Asian Football Confederation got on board.

The Crowd Says:

2019-06-21T01:43:05+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


The whole concept of the European Nations League means there will be virtually no window for Euro nations to play friendlies against nations outside UEFA. The international windows will be either Euro Qualifiers, or Euro Nations League.

2019-06-21T01:33:34+00:00

Tyke

Roar Rookie


It’s a matter of when.

2019-06-20T17:00:15+00:00

Ad-O

Guest


We are better off playing friendlies against European or South American opposition IMHO.

2019-06-20T11:10:25+00:00

Nicholas Belardo

Roar Guru


In Asia? Yes. A FIFA Nations league? There’s no point. What’s the point of the World Cup, and there’s not enough time in international windows for this

2019-06-20T04:21:37+00:00

Midfielder

Roar Guru


great idea

2019-06-20T04:11:46+00:00

Mike Tuckerman

Expert


Watch this space.

2019-06-20T04:03:07+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


Oceania?

2019-06-20T03:13:59+00:00

lesterlike

Roar Rookie


It is needed, especially for the lower end. Pakistan just had their first competitive AFC game in 4 years in the first round of 2022 WCQ's. They lost to Cambodia and are now going to have to wait another 4 years before they get another game. That really isn't good enough and a nations league would help give more regular competitive games across the continent. I'm all for a FIFA nations league as well eventually as it gives opportunities for countries to play competitive games in those famous stadiums outside their confederations, which doesn't exist outside of Intercontinental playoffs (which UEFA teams aren't even eligible for).

2019-06-20T03:04:30+00:00

lesterlike

Roar Rookie


The whole point of it was to replace pointless friendlies in the first place. The players and fans have responded to it well so it's done the job it was designed to do. The bonus is that top teams get to play each other in each others stadiums so it brings big matchups between UEFA outside of European Championships and World Cup's as they are always seeded in different groups.

2019-06-20T02:47:11+00:00

Brian

Guest


Not sure about Qatar but Euro 2020 its a double dip system. There's 10 regular groups with 2 qualifiers each. Then there's another 4 spots for each division of the nations league. Its good because if your in A division it automatically gives you another chance and if your in D division it gives one cheap ticket.

2019-06-20T02:45:28+00:00

Brian

Guest


Agreed, yes they should. 4 divisions of 12 is probably a bit better given the lack of quality at the lower end. They could also double-up as Asian Cup qualifiers in the B and C divisions.

2019-06-20T01:56:58+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


Yes agree it would be a great idea to have our own ‘nations league’ for Asia. Would this then be used as World Cup qualifiers, or would that remain seperate? How’s it work in europe?

2019-06-19T23:41:41+00:00

AJ

Roar Rookie


They're just glorified friendlies in my opinion.

2019-06-19T23:35:12+00:00

Maximus Insight

Guest


Presumably European based players wouldn't be involved in this?

2019-06-19T22:25:49+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


Yes it should.

Read more at The Roar