Wallabies player ratings from Rugby Championship opener vs Springboks

By Tom English / Roar Guru

The Wallabies went down to a dangerous South Africa team, but how did the individual players stand up in the 35-17 loss?

1. James Slipper
Rating: 5
It was his first Wallabies game for 959 days, but Slipper struggled to find his groove in the first half in a receding front row. He went off with an injury early in the second stanza.

2. Folau Fainga’a
Rating: 5.5
He wasn’t as involved as coach Michael Cheika would’ve liked early on, but he did start to insert himself into the game as it wore on. His lineout throwing was reasonable, and you’d imagine he will hold onto that starting hooker position for next week.

3. Sekope Kepu
6
He conceded a penalty at scrum time but made some hard-hitting tackles. The Wallabies front row was certainly stronger after he, Fainga’a and Slipper went off.

(Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

4. Izack Rodda
Rating: 5
This was a pretty quiet game for him, but he managed to recover a couple of off-target throws for the Aussies before he was subbed off in the 58th minute. The Reds enforcer also tried hard to disrupt the hosts’ lineouts, with only limited success. He recovered an overthrown lineout in the first half and tried hard to disrupt the Bok jumpers.

5. Rory Arnold
Rating: 5.5
He won a lineout against the throw when South Africa were in the Aussie 22, but he didn’t do much else all game.

6. Lukhan Salakaia-Loto
Rating: 6
He would’ve scored the first Wallabies try had Samu Kerevi’s pass to him been legal. He worked hard in defence throughout the game.

7. Michael Hooper (c)
Rating: 7
He didn’t have the usual monster of a game, but he did a fair share of tackling right throughout the match. His decision to not take three points within shadows of half-time came under some scrutiny, however.

(Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

8. Isi Naisarani
Rating: 7
The uncapped No. 8 found himself in the action, making ten runs and gaining 53 metres. While the Wallabies struggled with the gain line at times, he caused some issues for the home team. He was also called on to jump in the lineout, more so early in the game.

9. Nic White
Rating: 9
Knocking Will Genia back to the bench, White pushed his case for Rugby World World Cup selection. He provided good service from halfback and kicked well tactically. One of the better players in the loss, he seems to be much more polished since going to Exeter.

10. Bernard Foley
Rating: 6
He knocked over his three attempts at goal, but the pressure of general play kicking was taken away. South Africa targeted his defensive channel at times and it took his attacking game out of the equation for much of the game. To be fair to Foley, he scored a right place, right time try with nine minutes left.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

11. Reece Hodge
Rating: 6.5
A fair game for the Manly product. He didn’t do a lot of ball-running, but he put in a few good kicks and made a couple of catches.

12. Samu Kerevi
Rating: 7.5
He made a number of runs, amassing 162 metres, and found some holes in the South African defence. However, he threw a forward pass to Salakaia-Loto, causing the Queenslander’s runaway try to be overturned. Almost every time the Wallabies tried to run a set move he was given the ball. He made some tackles when it counted as well.

13. Tevita Kuridrani
Rating: 5
A very quiet game for this particular centre, and he was subbed off for Matt To’omua before the 60-minute mark.

14. Dane Haylett-Petty
Rating: 6
It was a mixed game for DHP. He spun in for a try in the first half before bombing one from a Bernard Foley kick at a crucial point of the game. He made some great catches under the high ball, and his kicking was pretty functional.

His main blunder was committing to a ruck late in the game, where he should’ve stayed back in the defensive line. From this, Herschel Jantjies darted through the newly-found space to score.

15. Tom Banks
Rating: 7.5
Had a solid game for his fourth cap. South Africa kept him on his feet all night, forcing him to go sideline to sideline to recover their kicks, but did his job well in that regard. He also took over kicking duties in general play for Australia after doing this all season for the Brumbies. He made a last-line-of-defence tackle in the first half to stop Elton Jantjies in his tracks, although the Boks did cross the line.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Reserves

16. Jordan Uelese
Rating: 3
His first throw upon coming onto the field wasn’t straight. Only a few minutes later he was taken off the field for a head injury assessment.

17. Harry Johnson-Holmes
6
For a debut, it was a good performance. The scrum improved at the change of the front rowers, and he was a big part of that.

18. Taniela Tupou
Rating: 4
He ran out of the line to make a tackle soon after coming on. Earnt a yellow card by cleaning out a player after the whistle, which cruelled the Wallabies’ chances.

19. Rob Simmons
Rating: 6
Did his job at lineout time, keeping up the good work of the starting second-rowers.

20. Jack Dempsey
Rating: 4
Was substituted on late in the game, but you’d be hard pushed to spot him out there. Didn’t have the impact he was meant to.

21. Will Genia
Rating: 6
Came onto the field for Nic White. Serviceable from halfback, and his few kicks were alright. Could very possibly start against Argentina, and we’ll get a better idea then.

22. Matt To’omua
Rating: 6
He came on for Kuridrani. Looked dangerous in his few touches, but would’ve had a bigger impact playing more minutes. Also made the pop pass to Kurtley Beale which led to Foley’s try.

23. Kurtley Beale
Rating: 8
He was subbed on to inject some X factor into the game and did just that. He ran into a hole after a pass from Genia and threw a great offload to Foley. On another occasion he linked up with Hooper in the wide channel, but it didn’t come to anything.

The Crowd Says:

2019-07-25T06:37:29+00:00

terrence

Roar Rookie


by the way comments are trending come saturday people might just agree that dhp and hodge had awesome games..not..they were both useless..

2019-07-24T13:12:13+00:00

Lano

Roar Guru


In words immortalised elsewhere .."you can't be serious...?"

2019-07-24T10:40:49+00:00

Andres

Guest


Beale.... what a shame about his tackling. His attacking game just blows my mind.

2019-07-24T02:37:13+00:00

Oblonsky‘s Other Pun

Roar Guru


Gotta admit I have been a fan of his play for a long time, but am starting to lose faith. He should also lose points for being a awful captaincy that match.

2019-07-24T01:54:28+00:00

Campbell Watts

Roar Rookie


When you're playing with a 12 who rarely passes to his center partner and a 10 who struggles to throw a cutout pass far enough to reach you its pretty hard to have a big impact on the game!

2019-07-24T00:54:21+00:00

Ben

Guest


On another note i know an 18 point loss is not great but i thought the Wallas were a lot closer than the final score indicates. Loto and DHPs non tries wouldve really set the cat amongst it imo. Any other day those are worth 10-14 so wouldve been interesting to see the Bok reaction. Add the brainfade of Hooper not taking that 3 and Tupous immatuŕity for the card.... Really as a neutral i didnt think Aus were as terrible as the score says, esp when i knew the score prior to watching it. Theyve got an ability to score tries but despite what Cheika says the defence at times was average. At 28-17 if i didnt know the score you got the impression they were back in it. But for both of those non tries.....gee.

2019-07-24T00:35:07+00:00

Ben

Guest


I just rewatched the whole game to concentrate on White since he was given a 9. His passing first half was ok without being outstanding. I can only put it down to fatigue but second half which is where i got my initial impression, his pass definitely became more laboured. I really cannot see where the 9 came from. I would agree with others on here for a 7, but 9? 9 is really outstanding. No way imo was he a 9. You can see the difference in speed of ball in flight between Jantjies and White. It looks like White is concentrating on accuracy above speed, but even then his accuracy isnt always spot on. Jantjies at halfback was imo a 9 but White.....really?

2019-07-23T22:57:46+00:00

The Slow Eater

Roar Rookie


At least we did see the 2 wingers in some action. I might need to watch it again but I struggle to remember where Kuridrani inserted himself all night

2019-07-23T22:56:02+00:00

The Slow Eater

Roar Rookie


Lineout Was good bit in most other facets the forwards were found wanting...

2019-07-23T22:54:16+00:00

The Slow Eater

Roar Rookie


I reckon you’re about right. White had a good game but deserves about a 7. Rodda was MIA and should’ve got a 3. Foley and DHP a 4.

2019-07-23T22:50:34+00:00

Dean

Roar Rookie


Overly generous on most fronts. However, much more balanced than Foxsports.

2019-07-23T22:26:08+00:00

Ben

Guest


I must admit John my first impression upon watching the replay (i didnt watch it live) was that his passing was laboured, often with a sideways skip, further delaying it. The ball didnt seem to follow a hard, quick trajectory and he never seemed to get his feet set first. But then i guess im used to watching Aaron Smiths bullets. Ive been critical of Perenaras passing his whole career and ive been watching him from secondary school level where he and Brynn Hall were in competition their whole careers. Brynn is second to Smith imo re passing but i see similarities in Perenara and Whites passing abilities.

2019-07-23T22:06:49+00:00

Jonesy

Guest


Interesting - I thought his passing off the deck in H1 was quite crisp and quick.

2019-07-23T20:19:08+00:00

Jeff

Guest


Tom,read Nick Bishop's article this morning.You might like to rethink a lot of those ratings then.

2019-07-23T16:43:04+00:00

Zado

Guest


Foley 6? Surely you are joking 3 is more like it.He was a deadset passenger and i was there to see it.Most of the game in defence he was hiding one in from the wing.He is also a pathetic playmaker.He must go.

2019-07-23T12:42:33+00:00

Geno

Guest


There's been a mix up...Hooper wore number 7, not got a 7. If it went that way he'd have been playing tight head.

2019-07-23T11:50:45+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Tom, you twice laid the blame for LSL’s over running of the ball onto Kerevi. Other than that, and the high numbers awarded, all good.

2019-07-23T11:39:52+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


Crap coaching?

2019-07-23T11:38:56+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


Not sure if you’re doing this for a wind up to generate discussion or you really believe them but really? Foley 6 and Hodge 6.5. Not sure what they did to deserve those scores mate

2019-07-23T10:12:22+00:00

Don

Roar Rookie


That. And the author’s review acknowledges the front row performance improved when he left the field! Although, adding up the bench front row scores they total 13 which is 3.5 less than the starting front row. Yet the reserves were better?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar