Australia's unlucky XI from the 2000s golden era

By Jesse Dart / Roar Rookie

Australia were the Test team to beat for the majority of the 2000s.

Iconic names such as Matthew Hayden, Ricky Ponting, Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath decimated all comers, but there were a lot of depth players who had their careers at the international level stunted by the continued dominance.

Here is a team of players that could’ve had much more notable Test careers if it wasn’t for the incredible exploits of the stars.

1. Phil Jaques
Opening our batting is one of the finest domestic cricketers of the noughties, Jaques was brilliant for New South Wales at Sheffield Shield level, even winning the award for best domestic cricketer in Australia for his 2005/06 season.

He managed 11 Tests – no mean feat in an era of Hayden and Justin Langer opening the batting – notching up three centuries. With a Test average of 47.47, you have to wonder just how good he could have been had depth and injury not plagued him.

2. Simon Katich
One of the more experienced members of this squad, having played 56 Tests for Australia, Katich was the perennial next in line for much of his career. He was in and out of the side for much of the decade, being sent to the middle order as well as opening duties.

He would eventually become somewhat of a regular towards the end of the decade, but he was one of the big losers out of Australia’s deep talent pool.

3. Martin Love
With Ricky Ponting occupying the No.3 spot, it would’ve taken the second coming of Don Bradman to dislodge the Aussie captain. The Queensland star made five Test match appearances for his country, but despite his consistent performances at domestic level he could never nail down a permanent place.

4. Darren Lehmann
The former Australian coach could have certainly carved out a more distinguished Test career if it wasn’t for the small matter of Steve Waugh.

A Test average of nearly 45 and five Test centuries are accomplishments not to be sneezed at, however there was potential for much more.

5. Brad Hodge (C)
Possibly the poster child for Test misfortune, Hodge earned himself six Test matches for Australia but even after the exodus that followed the 2006/07 Ashes, he couldn’t force his way into the team.

He crafted two centuries, including a brilliant unbeaten 203 against South Africa. He’s got the captaincy of this team as well, as I can’t think of an unluckier player.

6. Andrew Symonds
Symonds may have been most effective in the shorter forms of the game but was still a handy Test cricketer and deserved more than his 26 appearances.

(Image: Wikimedia/Privatemusings CC BY-SA 4.0)

Despite brilliant centuries against England and India, he will always be remembered for both his disciplinary issues and the vitriol directed at him by Indian spinner Harbhajan Singh during the 2007/08 summer.

7. Brad Haddin
Like Katich, Haddin would eventually get his time in the sun, but the amount of time he was forced to patiently wait his turn validates his spot in the list.

Nobody was going to dislodge Adam Gilchrist, who was not only a top gloveman but a brilliant batter as well. Haddin was forced to wait for years to get his chance, eventually debuting in 2008. He would go on to play 66 Tests, but if not for Gilchrist that number would be a lot higher.

8. Andy Bichel
The record holder for the most 12th man appearances for Australia, being assigned 19 times, Bichel constantly found himself trying to fight past McGrath, Jason Gillespie and Brett Lee to get a game. Taking 58 wickets across his 19 Tests, a shoulder injury would ultimately be his demise, leaving a lot of potential on the table.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

9. Stuart Clark
Always an underrated bowler, Clark’s downfall was being too similar but not as good as Glenn McGrath.

A difficult-to-dispatch seamer, he was a very strong line and length bowler who was more than capable of taking a few scalps. A star of the 2006/07 Ashes whitewash, Clark took 94 wickets across 24 Tests.

10. Stuart MacGill
Managing to take 200 Test wickets despite sporadic selection and competing with Australia’s best ever spinner is an underrated achievement.

MacGill only got his chance on decks that favoured two spinners or when Shane Warne was serving his suspension, but always stepped up to the plate when called upon. Could have easily doubled his wicket total if it wasn’t for Warne.

11. Shaun Tait
This one may be controversial, but despite his erratic nature Tait could have carved out a decent Test career for himself if it wasn’t for Brett Lee.

One of those bowlers who can best be described as expensive but effective, the man they called ‘The Wild Thing’ only earned Test selection three times, taking five wickets.

The Crowd Says:

2019-08-16T07:36:38+00:00

ChrisH

Roar Rookie


MacGill is the unluckiest one there. If it wasn't for Warnie, MacGill would have been the one taking 500+ wickets and being our greatest ever leggie. I do think you should have put a much lower limit on number Tests to qualify for this list. Quite a few of those guys would be more than happy with the Test careers they had.

AUTHOR

2019-08-16T01:56:05+00:00

Jesse Dart

Roar Rookie


Since 2010 though? That's the criteria I'm focusing on and generally all our openers apart from Warner have been unspectacular but Marsh has been lucky to play as much as he has.

2019-08-15T21:51:33+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


Poor old Bic. Almost immediately after he'd set this unwanted record CA allowed the 12th man to go off and play Shield. Guess where the first beneficiary of this change of tradition came from?

2019-08-15T21:44:20+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


Indeedily. At the SCG, traditionally Australia's worst pitch, his average is a lot closer to Bradmanesque than anything SPD Smith has got. Bevo played 82 innings at the SCG and had that same number for his average. Extraordinary. But he *was* hopeless at the higher bouncing ball. F'rinstance, his 82.2 at the SCG is many tads better than his 28.0 (19inn) at the Gabba.

2019-08-15T21:32:19+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


Ahhh. Micheal Slater. Another over-rated NSW player who played far too many Tests. After Slater was dropped he played full Shield season (19 inn) and averaged 37.0. In that same season Cox averaged 60.5. Go figure. Incidentally, Cox averaged over 50 in 3 of his 19 seasons, and none of them were consecutive.

2019-08-15T20:35:02+00:00

Kannga2

Roar Rookie


Sean Marsh isn’t near the top 6 worst batsman I’ve seen for aust Certainly not a great player, but some nice centuries among the failures. There are 6 worse then Sean m

2019-08-15T10:47:49+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Except you’re still cherry picking - go back 12 instead of 10 innings and you take in his back to back 80s against Pakistan in the opening test of those “three series” you mention. As for the Hughes and Warner business, Cowan was opening next summer; so you got an even slower plodder for your trouble. Anyway, I’ve got my ‘hands full’, so I’m outta here, been a real pleasure as always.

AUTHOR

2019-08-15T09:20:29+00:00

Jesse Dart

Roar Rookie


Yeah but appearing as 12th man 19 times is an awkward number to be stuck on, rounding him off with 20 seems too perfect so I'll strand him on 19.

AUTHOR

2019-08-15T09:18:38+00:00

Jesse Dart

Roar Rookie


A strike rate of nearly a run a ball isn't that bad is it? If it was something like 50 fair enough but if 87 is the worst you have in a team on any given day you're doing a pretty good job. Fair enough he's not a rapid scorer but putting that loss on him seems a bit of a reach to me.

2019-08-15T08:48:17+00:00

Crispy Duck

Roar Rookie


um. 67 tests and 13 tons? i do kinda get your point though.... i think.

2019-08-15T07:43:37+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


You take it correctly. Never been a fan of ugly techniques or slow scorers so The Krap was a Twofa. And let's not forget the Kraps' leading role in the infamous 438 odi loss to RSA. Of the six Oz players who batted, Gilchrists 125.0 was the second-lowest SR. Krap used up 90 balls to make 79. A SR of 87.8.

2019-08-15T07:30:52+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


re - "statistical cherry-picking". I picked the most recent innings. That's called 'current form'. Ashley, using a players' last three years figures is "cherry-picking". Last 10 innings is enough. btw, that covered three series, not just the Ashes as you imply. And iirc, Krap was unavailable for the remainder of that Ashes series due to serious injury. So, as I said; old, dubious fitness and no recent runs on the board. Oh and one other thing that you and the OP have missed. It's important in these 'They Were Dropped Too Early' pieces... It's important to look at who they were replaced by. Something else that counted against Krap was that NSW had Hughes & Warner in the runs. re - "shockingly violent" - Take your hand off it.

2019-08-15T04:56:08+00:00

Josh H

Roar Rookie


Surely Bichel would be a better fit for 12th man

AUTHOR

2019-08-15T01:28:53+00:00

Jesse Dart

Roar Rookie


I'm not a huge fan of Watson but if you gave me the choice of him or Mitch Marsh I'd probably rip your arm off in the handshake.

AUTHOR

2019-08-15T01:27:59+00:00

Jesse Dart

Roar Rookie


I knew next to nothing about Herath until he debuted, I really feel for him because he was a gun.

AUTHOR

2019-08-15T01:19:49+00:00

Jesse Dart

Roar Rookie


Not the biggest fan of Katich I take it?

AUTHOR

2019-08-15T01:07:42+00:00

Jesse Dart

Roar Rookie


While I don't think Clarke was our best tactician he wouldn't be our worst, if he was that bad tactically he would've been quickly replaced. He's certainly better or comparable with most 21st century English captains.

2019-08-14T22:27:19+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


A bit like Herath? Get your real shot in your mid '30s after the genius retires?

2019-08-14T22:20:57+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


Why is it that you mock others for "statistical cherry picking", but you love doing it too? Sure he's last few innings, i.e. the Ashes, didn't go well. But he still averaged 46.82 for the 2010 calendar year; has a guy with fifty tests under his belt not earned just a little patience? Are all players who have a bad series "overdue" for a sacking? The highlight of his career (and possibly the cause of it being ended) was grabbing M Clarke by the neck. Well played for that Sime. Bizarre in the extreme that the only thing you liked about him was that he was shockingly violent to a teammate/co-worker and probably should have been dismissed from the team there and then, regardless of form.

2019-08-14T22:16:14+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


An amazing difference of opinion. I would have called him the worst Oz tactical captain I’ve ever seen. Ever? Guess we have different opinions then; lucky it's an opinion site! Interesting though, I would have thought Waugh was the worst you'd seen? Or does your dislike of him extend only to his batting?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar