David Warner can still dominate Test cricket

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

To revive his Test career David Warner should skip Australia’s six T20Is in October and November and instead play Sheffield Shield to regain form for the home Tests against Pakistan.

The veteran left-hander is justifiably copping heavy criticism after the worst Test series of his career in the Ashes, during which he averaged just 9 with the bat and was picked apart by English quick Stuart Broad.

Many fans have suggested he should be dropped for Australia’s next Test series, which starts at the Gabba on November 21 against Pakistan.

When anywhere near his best, Warner is far too valuable in home conditions not to be in the Test team.

Granted, he was abysmal in the Ashes. Then again, he has never adapted to English conditions across three tours there, and it must be noted that it is by far the most difficult place in the world for Test openers.

The way the Dukes ball swings and seams extravagantly in the first 15-20 overs of each innings, combined with sometimes juicy pitches, makes opening in England a nightmare.

Warner has always been an entirely different proposition in Australia. The true pace and bounce of Australian pitches and the lack of lateral movement offered by the Kookaburra ball mean he can hit through the line and bully opening bowlers.

Not only does he average 60 on his own patch and have an extraordinary 15 tons from 38 home Tests, but he also scores at a lightning rate of 4.71 runs per over in Australia. His rapid scoring benefits Australia in multiple ways.

Firstly, it sets the opposition back on their heels and forces them to re-arrange their tactics. Secondly, it greatly reduces the pressure on his batting partner. Thirdly, it pushes the match forward, buying Australia extra overs in which to bowl out their opponents twice.

In Warner’s long Test career his worst average in a home series is 39 and that came in 2016 against a rampant South African attack in a three-match series that featured two bowler-friendly pitches. In his two most recent home series he destroyed England and Pakistan.

Australia’s two opponents this summer – Pakistan and New Zealand – would be delighted if he is left out of the home side’s starting XI. In Warner’s eight home Tests against those two sides, he has scored six tons amid a phenomenal 1,101 runs at 85.

Some observers have suggested that, following his 12-month ban from international cricket, Warner has simply lost it, that he will never be the same. The way he dominated the IPL and then the World Cup – finishing as top scorer in the former and second-top scorer in the latter – suggest otherwise to me.

He still has it in him to clatter quality bowlers when the ball isn’t hooping around. That remains a highly valuable skill. I’ve been shocked by the number of cricket followers who in recent weeks have written off Warner’s incredible home record as if it has minimal value.

If hoarding runs as a Test opener in Australia is so elementary then why hasn’t any other Aussie opener matched his feats in the past decade? Last summer’s home series against India gave us an insight into the value of Warner’s dominance at home.

In Warner’s absence, the three openers Australia used together averaged just 27 across that four-match series. Getting the veteran left-hander back to something like his best would be a massive boon for Australia.

Of course, there are no guarantees he can rebound from his horror Ashes. The events of the past 18 months may end up killing off his Test career prematurely.

It’s also worth remembering that fine Australian openers Matt Hayden, Chris Rogers and Justin Langer played Test cricket until they were 37, 37 and 36 years old respectively. Warner is only 32. Some would argue he relies on hand-eye coordination more than that trio, but only time will tell.

Warner’s first step on the road back to Test dominance should be to skip Australia’s six T20I matches against Sri Lanka and Pakistan from late October onwards in favour of playing Shield cricket.

(Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

NSW have four Shield games before the Test series against Pakistan begins. Warner could play in all of those matches or, if he finds top form in the first three, sit out the last to rest up.

If he plays in one or both of Australia’s T20I series it will not only cause him to miss out on red-ball practice but also prevent him from having a steady build-up. Switching back and forth between wildly different formats is not what Warner needs right now.

Granted, Warner is one of Australia’s top three T20 cricketers. But neither of those T20I series are of great importance and Australia have a wealth of other strong opening options including Aaron Finch, D’Arcy Short and Alex Carey.

Sitting out those T20Is would be the best thing for both Warner and the Australian Test team.

The Crowd Says:

2019-09-22T03:32:34+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Laughing at your own jokes?

2019-09-22T03:07:27+00:00

Pom in Oz

Roar Guru


I thought it was the Cockshow Complex... :laughing:

2019-09-22T01:25:49+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


I doubt you know what you're talking about there. Do you mean the licence? The membership? The salary cap? The Cockburn complex?

2019-09-22T00:53:16+00:00

Pom in Oz

Roar Guru


You could buy the Dockers for less...

2019-09-21T23:30:18+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


$274 is not much.

2019-09-21T23:23:44+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


He is better suited batting at 3 than other candidates.

2019-09-21T23:16:26+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Many have thought they have had the wood on Davy, only for him to come out on top. Not many bowlers have the skill to do what Broad did. Remember that Davy hadn't played sustained cricket for over a year. Once he gets a few longer innings under his belt, he'll be pressuring for a spot again.

2019-09-21T06:15:05+00:00

Sandgroper

Roar Rookie


Dave's gone He's been worked out at international level and good bowlers will do what Broad has done It happened to Hayden and he went away and changed his game - I doubt Dave will do that. He doesn't strike me as the sort of person who thinks he could be doing anything wrong If they bowl as well as Broad - Dave is gone. If they bowl badly he may still score. Difficult to believe the Aussie side is picked to include players who can score well only if the opposition bowls badly.......but a Marsh always gets to play sooooo, maybe ..... I

2019-09-21T00:45:53+00:00

Timmuh

Roar Guru


I suspect you're right, Ronan. The length that was getting Warner out so often in England will go over the top in Australia. The movement seemed an issue early in the series and seemed to leave him in doubt with the straight one after that. Being in two minds was evident with the ones wide of off that he left too late, normally he would flashed hard and missed, got an edge for four, or hit the middle middle for four. Warner's biggest problem to me isn't movement, though as above he doesn't always handle it well, it is lack of pace. There is a reason his highest score in England is at The Oval, probably the fastest and bounciest of English pitch squares, and one of his two double figure scores this series was there as well. On the faster, bouncier, decks he may well come good again. But if he should be required to score Shield runs so the selectors can have some faith it was an England thing, and not a sign he has lost it for long form cricket. The opening Shield rounds will see bowlers coming from around the wicket, let's see how he handles it before saying whether he can dominate. I suspect he can at home, but am not confident in making that call.

2019-09-20T00:05:39+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


His Bangladesh centuries were great. But I think with the benefit of hindsight and looking at his collective long term o/s record, they are aberrations rather than innings that can/ would be repeated.

2019-09-20T00:02:58+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Fair point

2019-09-19T23:54:53+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


I agree others now deserve a chance. As I said further down, I’d move on from him personally, with the only potential caveat being whether the tour of Bangladesh actually happens (even then maybe not).

2019-09-19T23:40:05+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


Warner is much like Hayden in the way that their power batting deteriorates fast

2019-09-19T23:38:27+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


He wasn’t batting that well before the ban

2019-09-19T23:37:35+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


He’s nearly 33. His style of batting isn’t aging well as his eye and power deteriorate. I don’t think he will get mountains of runs again

2019-09-19T23:29:29+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Overseas? Absolutely not. I don't think you are appreciative of how ordinary he is overseas. There are 4 batsman who would be picked before him on current form. Khawaja, Bancroft, Burns and I'd give young Puckovski a chance... You know what a chance is yeah? Warner got a million of them. I'd probably look at Renshaw before Warner as well. Were he to bat down the order, then that might change the assessment.

2019-09-19T20:10:32+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


I don't understand how this Warner Must Play is an issue. "If you fail you get dropped" was on the tablets that Moses delivered from the mountain end, so why is it now an issue? Especially when it benefits the player who has the worst behavioral record in Oz cricket history. And people scream like chickens with a fox after them whenever a Marsh gets selected. Go figure.

2019-09-19T17:13:34+00:00

Cari

Roar Rookie


Warner is not my favorite Australian for a number of reasons, but no doubt Broad well shed a tear or two when he retires.

2019-09-19T13:38:18+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Yes, but I would have dropped him after 2. You have conceded you would have kept picking him based on a idea everyone else would still have done worse. Others deserved the million chances he got.

2019-09-19T12:46:23+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


You’ve previously concede you’d have picked him for the first test. That was my only point here. We’ve discussed the rest to death and I even mentioned you to give you an opening to respond to Chris.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar