The great unofficial preview of the 'unimportant' semi-final

By Harry Jones / Expert

Wales and South Africa play on Sunday to see who will reprise the role of the 2015 Wallabies, losing gallantly to New Zealand.

Several English fans and pundits have talked themselves into a stupor and now believe they are a chance of turning the All Blacks over. We can call the first semi-final the deluded semi, and the second the daylight semi.

Who is the better team in this consolation friendly between number three and four?

Wales has forgotten how to lose lately, according to canny coach Warren Gatland, and has completely forgotten how to lose to the Springboks. Our favourite Roar analyst, the Archbishop of Cardiff, reckons they are too mentally tough for the Boks if it is close down the stretch.

The last time the Welsh exited the World Cup, it was the big slow Springbok No.8 Duane Vermeulen who was toughest and most calm in the big moment, setting dead-legged Fourie du Preez free to run to the corner past the cover defenders as if through quick sand, and send Wales home crying.

But since that time, South Africa have wandered about in the rugby universe, trying to find a coach, a plan, money, proper jerseys, a wing not on the secret sauce, and a rush umbrella defence capable of stopping the big boys.

Wales just kept on winning.

Here we are, in the biggest match of Wales’ rugby history. The boys in red led by a Welsh legend Wings the size of loose forwards, seasoned, hard lads, and a flyhalf who does not miss when it counts. The best No.13 in the world. A halfback who is always onside and the best red-headed backup northern hemisphere No.10 left in the tournament.

How do the teams compare?

Wyn Jones versus Frans Malherbe is not a beauty pageant. Neither has ever passed up a plate of meat. When they burp on the bind, the rest of the scrum has to fight nausea. Their binds are illegal in most countries; Malherbe’s is considered deviant in most of the Middle East. However, both are on the tiebreaker kick-team.

Wyn has a wicket drop goal, apparently; learnt as a bouncer in Swansea. The Boks edge this one-on-three dual, but only because of uber-reserve Vincent Koch on the bench.

On the other side, Tomos Francis is up against a penitent beast playing for his rugby life, and when he and his substitute find themselves weary, no tenderness will be shown: the Ginga Ninja, Stevie Kitshoff, will trot on with his bowlegged canter, and make life even more miserable. Both Saffa props are extremely strong tacklers. Big advantage Boks.

Ken Owens will not be overshadowed by Bongi Mbonambi, but 40-minute Malcolm Marx is the world’s best reserve hooker. South Africa has completed 57 of 57 throw-ins, and their hookers score and snaffle and carry and offload. South Africa 3, Wales 0 thus far.

The second row is a Bok bloodbath. Rassie Erasmus likes 20 per cent of his squad to be locks. Alun Wyn Jones is a bold institution, a sacred totem, a Celtic talisman, a prince of a man, and the single most prolific purchaser of ear bandages in the UK. But the firm of RG Snyman, Eben Etzebeth, Lood de Jager, Franco Mostert and Pieter-Steph du Toit will bankrupt any opponent.

Eleven Bok lineout steals and counting. Very few missed tackles, and a steady diet of crashball to soften up the already brittle Welsh tight forwards. South Africa 6, Wales 1.

The loose trios are even, because Wales lost their best three exponents. Still, the Boks’ loosies are too ponderous at times, Siya Kolisi has a bum knee, du Toi is. in the final analysis. a fast fit lock and, collectively, Bok loose forwards don’t know how to make Jerome Garces happy, so any physical dominance will be negated. South Africa 10, Wales 4.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Extra points for a couple of Bok scrum penalties (Garces usually rewards set piece superiority) and lineout steals, but a Wales point for breakdown literacy. South Africa 12, Wales 6.

Gareth Davies is really fast. He wants to play No.10 for the opposition. His newborn is named Genia. He and Faf de Klerk will bother each other, but Faf is a pocket Hercules who is fond of tackling 10’s before they even have the ball. But he can really be poor – nobody knows who is what here.

Faf can lose his mind, and his box kicks get progressively worse as game wear on. Wales gets one back, and halfback points are doubled: South Africa 12, Wales 8.

Dan Biggar and Handre Pollard are the same person. South Africa 13, Wales 9.

The midfield battle is juicy. Hadleigh Parkes won’t be able to keep Damian de Allende in front of him; but Jon Davies is twice the player Lucky Am is, right now. Probably all four of these guys will just negate each other, and then Frans Steyn will come on and steamroll somebody, perhaps a fellow Bok. South Africa 15, Wales 11.

The Welsh wings are huge, fast, mean, smart and better than the inexperienced Boks wings. Except at running, swerving stepping. But fair play: Wales has the wood. South Africa 15, Wales 13.

Leigh Halfpenny is the Tomas Lavanini of backline scrumcap wearers. He looks angelic without it, sinister with it. He can kick, has good position and is fast. Willie le Roux is hot and cold; when he is hot, he boils over. When he is cold, he has hands of stone, and feet of clay. South Africa 15, Wales 14.

Gatland is more cold-blooded than Erasmus, who smiles even when gutted. One gets the feeling Rassie enjoys life more than Warren. But Gatland figured out how to split a series in New Zealand. South Africa 15, Wales 15.

Card risks: even.

Historic mists of destiny: South Africa by 1.

SA wins by 8-15 points. Alun Wyn Jones delivers a tear-jerker speech. Man of the match goes to Duane Vermeulen, for that fend at the end that bended Ken.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-27T10:59:54+00:00

Daniel King

Guest


"I don't think England have the belief to beat the All Blacks." Next minute.....

2019-10-26T18:16:45+00:00

Ragnar

Roar Rookie


I believe Wales are in with a chance but only because my beloved France were severely stifled by the stupidity of Vahaamahima. Had he not been red carded we would have won easily as we were running Wales ragged. And we French will still have major say on who wins this semi-final because we have Graces as Ref. And that,in a nutshell, sums up why many people get turned off by Rugby Union. The officials have too much impact on the results because of their inconsistency. And that includes the after match citing reviews. Owens had a generally great game but you can't let ''small'' knock ons and marginal off sides go unpunished to keep the game flowing if, on the other hand, you get really very technical in disallowing tries! Its a tough lottery out there. The weather is a major factor too. If it rains then Wales chances improve dramatically.

2019-10-26T16:25:15+00:00

Graeme

Roar Rookie


Unfortunately the deluded semi is over and NZ are the first team into the 3rd place playoff. Hopefully the Boks will ensure that the SH is represented in the final.

AUTHOR

2019-10-26T06:12:33+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Cheers, RT! Good luck to your lot!

2019-10-26T04:22:16+00:00

Oomtas

Guest


If Wales and NZ win the final will be a non event For a final of interest it is essential that SA go through tomorrow. An England - SA or NZ - SA final will be a monumental contest . But NZ - Wales ?. Pfffttt.

2019-10-26T04:19:20+00:00

mzilikazi

Roar Pro


Peter Nelson, played for Canada. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Nelson_(rugby_player)

2019-10-26T03:19:35+00:00

GibbonRib

Roar Rookie


If we could just wind back 2 months, to before Anscombe, Faletau, Foxy, Williams and Navidi got injured, Wales'd be in a pretty good place.

2019-10-26T03:15:30+00:00

GibbonRib

Roar Rookie


I don't think Wales were complacent against France, they couldn't execute or get any control. Combination of fatigue (much shorter turnaround); too many players missing, carrying injuries (Parkes, Liam W) or just on poor form (Biggar, North); France playing very well for much of the game; and struggling with Peyper' s influence. They know they'll need to play much better, but that's a big ask. Not much difference between the XV but the Bok's bench looks much stronger

2019-10-26T02:04:07+00:00

Highander

Guest


Nice Harry, broke the nervousness nicely Perhaps a little generous to your about to be vanquished opponents

2019-10-26T02:00:48+00:00

jaysper

Roar Guru


Really? He seemed like their most potent weapon against the all blacks.

2019-10-26T01:43:27+00:00

Tooly

Roar Rookie


The Bokkies to beat England next week. In the big game here . The Force to prolong the pain on horses this week. There are some good young players coming on, and some forgotten ones . Enever , Samu . Banks and Powell . We must declare all positions vacant and pick a new Wallaby side on next years form. Pick the form side for every match and use the bench for development and speculation. In four years our team will be very different ; thankfully. I hope that Ned Hannigan comes back much bigger.

2019-10-26T01:06:29+00:00

Gilbert

Roar Rookie


Fresh Boks - neutral venue - JG in the middle - Wales by 1.

2019-10-26T01:04:54+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Oops refer post to you before I read this BB

2019-10-26T01:02:37+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Hahaha! ‘Consolation prize indeed’ ... I can see Harry gritting his teeth now!!

2019-10-26T01:00:24+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Biltongbek, nice to see the frequency of your posts lately. Understand your passion for Springbok Rugby, you must be proud of your boys and of Rassie Erasmus, who has chosen a squad “on merit” (though personally I think he missed out the word ‘almost’.) Good luck for tomorrow semi but I think it’ll be just a ‘walk in the park’.

2019-10-26T00:53:59+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Wyn Jones versus Frans Malherbe is not a beauty pageant. Neither has ever passed up a plate of meat. When they burp on the bind, the rest of the scrum has to fight nausea. Brilliant Harry, the commencement of your players comparison for the big match had me spitting out my tea over breakfast! Back to the more serious issues, without playing a second rower as a flanker. I’m pleased that you guys can only play 2 of your locks at one time. Trying to win the covenanted underdog position with me cuts no ice. In spite of what coaches say, I believe there is only one side in this semi final and assuming the losing side will play for pride in the last 20 when they know they have been beaten the margin at the end of the game will be 19+ Do I have to nominate the winner I have projected? Really enjoyed the article Harry, I was going to say ‘put it in your book’ but on reflection this is merely a preview, unless of course you have a chapter heading of “Projects I got right..... or wrong”

2019-10-26T00:31:18+00:00

Bobwire

Guest


Culture vulture

2019-10-26T00:31:06+00:00

Jacko

Guest


I have been disappointed with Kolbe so far....Not sure what game it was but he had a 1 on 1 against a fullback with plenty of space around him and he ran straight into the FB.....I expected to see him put something better on

2019-10-26T00:27:10+00:00

Jacko

Guest


I think last weeks win by Wales will have woken them up to what will be required if they want to proceed to Thursday or get to next Saturday.......They were very average and Gatland spoke of the fact he thought they were very lucky to get past France.....He said they were the 2nd best team in that match.......Will learning all this at the 1/4s be enough for them to beat SA?....I have my doubts but I also believe they will improve dramatically from last weeks display.....Both sides need to start scoring points if they want to continue to the Final and whilst I believe SA has the better defence I also believe that they will show they can score points as well and win by a few...

2019-10-26T00:19:34+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Will Skeen have a bearing on the game or will he be content to just sit in the background.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar