How the FFA can expand successfully

By Jeremy Arfanis / Roar Rookie

As of the 2019-20 A-League season, there are 11 teams, with one more destined to arrive next season.

Expansion in the A-League is one seriously prominent topic of debate, with seemingly every football fan in Australia having an opinion on this issue. With the 11 existing clubs, the FFA should introduce three new teams for the benefit of football in Australia, in the form of the Wollongong Wolves, Tasmania and Canberra United.

Wollongong Wolves are a club that already exists in the semi-professional football scene in Australia, playing in the National Premier League NSW, which is the second division of football. The South Coast NSW region has a catchment population of over 800,000 people, and their home stadium would be WIN Stadium in Wollongong, which has a capacity of 23,000.

Wollongong would be a perfect addition to the A-League. Wollongong is commonly referred to as the football heartland of regional Australia, and their participation rates support that. Besides Sydney, Wollongong has the highest youth football participation rates. The Wollongong Wolves have gained support from the community, boasting an attendance of over 8000 people for an FFA Cup fixture in 2016.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

In order to engage with this generation’s young football players in that region, the question shouldn’t be whether there should be a South Coast team – it should be when will there be a South Coast team. Playing football has a strong correlation with supporting it, and with uncontested participation numbers, it is a no-brainer to include the Wollongong Wolves in the A-League.

Another club that should be initiated into the A-League is Canberra United. Not only would this team be for the football fans in Canberra, but it would be a clear pathway for players coming through the ranks.

Canberra United are already an established W-League team, plus they already have training facilities and an ideal home ground. The support for an A-League team in the nation’s capital is certainly alive, there just needs to be a team for the community to support. Canberra came in numbers when the Australian nation team last played there, boasting a crowd of 18,500 for a game against Nepal. And it’s not the first time either, producing 19,500 supporters in 2015 and over 20,000 in 2009.

(Tony Feder/Getty Images)

How can you have an Australian league without including its capital city? If we even have the New Zealand capital in our league, why wouldn’t we have our own?

There should also be a team based in Tasmania, playing half of their home games in Hobart and the other half in Launceston, being named Tasmania FC. Tasmania is the only state in Australia to not have a professional football team, resulting in most kids growing up following other sports like AFL. Even with no team, football has the highest participation rate for any sport in the state, which signals that there is a strong need to bring in a team.

There are only 18,000 football participants in Tasmania, which is quite low considering its population. There is no pathway and they don’t even have a suitable rectangular stadium in the whole state. There is potential for a successful team though, with a trial game fetching over 8000 spectators. There needs to be a clear pathway for young Tasmanian kids growing up wanting to play professional football and currently there isn’t. Over time support will come and there will be more participants.

The state of Tasmania needs the beauty of football in their state in order for the sport to grow. There are very few places in the world where football hasn’t connected with the hearts and souls of residents. Tasmania just needs a chance.

An argument brought up frequently is that there should be the A-League then a second division, which is directly underneath. The basic premise is that the best teams from the second division replace the worst teams in the first division. This is the system in most European countries, which is the region with the best leagues in the world.

I don’t agree with this proposal, as Australian football clubs can’t yet survive not being in the first division. Clubs like the Central Coast Mariners, for instance, don’t have the financial backbone and the support to survive in the second division.

The 11 current clubs should all be kept in the A-League, but 2020-21 establishment club Macarthur FC should not be added to the league. This idea by David Gallop has no support from the local residents. For starters, it is too close to the region of Western Sydney. Fans from the Macarthur region still have a local club in the form of the Western Sydney Wanderers. It seems that Gallop found a region with a high enough population and decided to put a football team there with no additional thought.

In order for the FFA to have successful expansion in the A-League, they need to add three clubs: Tasmania, Canberra United and Wollongong Wolves. This would create a perfect 14-team league and would bring the support for football in Australia back.

The Crowd Says:

2020-04-16T07:42:46+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


I missed this reply when it was posted, but I would say that there's a difference between strategising (i.e. examining the likelihood of each eventuality and then working out the best way to deal with it) and the kind of wishful thinking I'm referring to (the people going around and saying "everything is uncertain, so my preferred outcome is the most likely / my preferred strategy is the best").

2020-04-04T03:46:07+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


your entitled to your opinion but calling an entire country people Parasites is not ok

2020-04-04T03:21:03+00:00

Samuel Power

Roar Rookie


Yes please Kevin, would like to see it. Also, hard to see other teams surviving this. Macarthur is looking more and more unlikely every day, Western United are a farce and clubs like CCM don’t have the money.

2020-04-04T00:32:56+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Yes but think about the implications. In a decade you're going to have teams who've had a handful of meetings, building up new rivalries. Old NSL rivalries will be rekindled. Local grudge matches will take on new significance (eg. FFA Cup quarter final: South Melbourne vs Bentleigh Greens!) Plus you'll still have a couple of A League teams in the main FFA Cup draw to provide those mouthwatering "David vs Goliath" battles! All this without breaking the bank Nem! The problem now is it can't flourish the way it could. If all the FFA Cup Quarter Finalists are A League teams...then what's the point?! If I want to watch 4 games featuring all A League teams...I can just watch the A League! :silly:

2020-04-03T23:25:17+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


Do you even understand what the FFA Cup tournament is? It is a KNOCKOUT CUP. Each round 50% of the teams are knocked out. How can that possibly be a proxy 2nd Division? 50% of clubs who enter will play only 1 match each season.

2020-04-03T16:27:04+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


The way to get that back is to reformat the FFA Cup so it acts a proxy second division. You basically get all those old NSL teams having regular annual competition.

2020-04-03T15:51:00+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Melbourne Knights just wanted to extort them. $2 million (or something like that) up front was apparently what MK asked WU for. Naturally they said no. Should've just committed to Whitten Oval from the start, till the new stadium was built!

2020-04-03T15:14:25+00:00

lesterlike

Roar Rookie


That’s not our problem. They are their own country and we are not obliged to provide them with a professional league structure or pathway.

2020-04-03T14:11:22+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


nowhere for a 2nd Brisbane team to play, if SEQ2 is what you want one of the Coasts is a Better but also not great Option

2020-04-03T14:11:22+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


The problem is Brisbane is too big, along with Perth. If you set up both cities with clear geographical teams then the fans will come. I never bother watching Glory, but if you create a Freo/southern suburbs team that's convenient to get to, then I'm keen!

2020-04-03T14:08:07+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


they have there own League but it is Semi Pro and on Par with the NPL's in Australia, NZ is to small a country obsessed with Another Sport in Rugby Union to maintain a pro league but could maintain a couple of pro teams in a Aussie League

2020-04-03T14:06:04+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


if future expansion happens down the line and we have the 11 teams we have right now and MacArthur then Canberra and Auckland are my picks, Wollongong is something i think Football fans want but not necessarily the people of Illawarra want

2020-04-03T14:03:44+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


that team was in Albany which is one of the Most isolated Suburbs in Auckland

2020-04-03T14:01:14+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


Cheaper to travel to New Zealand then it is to Perth from the Major East Coast Cities

2020-04-03T13:44:44+00:00

Beni Iniesta

Guest


LOL! Comedy Gold Jeremy. Do you even "News" bro? Heard of Coronavirus or COVID-19? What makes you think there even will be an A-League next year given the Foxtel TV contract looks set to be ripped up?

2020-04-03T13:04:55+00:00

Kevin

Roar Rookie


I honestly dont think Macarthur will join, while I think Wunited’s license will be revoked.

2020-04-03T12:03:48+00:00

Nick Symonds

Guest


May as well. But Macarthur might be in trouble. - FTBL: CORONAVIRUS THE LAST STRAW FOR MACARTHUR FC? https://www.ftbl.com.au/news/coronavirus-the-last-straw-for-macarthur-fc-546006

2020-04-03T10:25:48+00:00

Nemesis

Guest


That's the sort of strategising & planning people do when they run a business. That's exactly what every business will be doing right now. Planning for different scenarios.

2020-04-03T10:13:27+00:00

Kevin

Roar Rookie


Because I felt like it, I wrote up an entire fixture of the 2019-20 A-League season integrating Canberra, Gold Coast, Hobart, Macarthur and Wollongong into the current fixture. So I basically did a season for a 16 team competition on my notebook. Should I upload the results on the roar once its finished?

2020-04-03T06:59:58+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


Your last paragraph is very true - a lot of people are basically saying "it's all up in the air at the moment, and I'm sure that the cards will fall exactly as I want them to", whether that be the expansion (or contraction) of the current league, the wholesale replacement of the current structure with something resembling the old NSL, or the cessation of professional football entirely, people are going around thinking "this is what I want to happen, therefore it's perfectly logical that it will happen".

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar