Rugby’s back - and what a difference a week makes

By Brett McKay / Expert

Honestly, it’s like we’ve been reading about a different sport over this last week, with the dramatic change in tack around the reporting of rugby in Australia.

Isn’t it funny how quickly perceptions can change?

This is not to say that this sudden outbreak of good news can change the mistakes of the recent and distant past, or that much work is not still required to get rugby in Australia on a significantly healthier footing.

But it was certainly noticeable that over the course of a couple of days, the mood around rugby changed considerably.

Long may that continue.

The week started with the great news that New Zealand was lifting all restrictions apart from the international border, in recognition of reaching the state of a no active cases of COVID-19. The biggest of all the big ticket-items in Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s announcement was that “sporting events, music events can all take place with no restriction of numbers”.

Coming the week Super Rugby Aotearoa was due to kick off, the ticket-purchasing couldn’t begin quick enough, with the result massive crowds in both Dunedin and Auckland across the weekend.

And it was wonderful to see, but we’ll come back this soon.

Wednesday saw the announcement all rugby fans in Australia – and about 150 players and coaches – had been waiting for: that Rugby Australia and Fox Sports had reached an agreement that meant the widely assumed and desperately hoped for Super Rugby AU competition would kick off on July 3.

Sean Wainui crashes through the defence. (Photo by Teaukura Moetaua/Getty Images)

With one simple press of the ‘send’ button on the media release, the new Rugby Australia executive had its first major win. With the deal done to allow the local competition to begin, and with plenty of good will already in the air from the return of the Western Force to the domestic scene, this deal was a clear signal that Hamish McLennan and Rob Clarke were well on the way, and mending a few damaged fences while they were at it.

Their next goal will undoubtedly be to get a Bledisloe Cup series over the line for this year, if not a workable version of the Rugby Championship as well.

The reporting around the new competition was overwhelmingly positive and came from a surprisingly wide suite of outlets across radio, television, print, and online media outlets. Finally, and for what felt like the first time in a long time, rugby fans in Australia could see and hear headlines that weren’t having a crack at the game.

Law variations were being discussed all over the place, among coaches and players alike. Coaches talked among themselves and wanted to do away with the mark inside the 22, instead making all kicks contestable. But Wallabies and Rebels flyhalf Matt Toomua – who has quickly emerged as key figure on a number of topics in recent weeks – had some ideas of his own.

Citing the need for ‘more drama in the attacking quarter’, Toomua’s idea was to remove the mark for kicks inside the attacking 22, as well as a line drop-out for defending teams grounding the ball in-goal, rather than the current 22 restart. He explained during The Australian’s Facebook live video session last Wednesday night that such a tweak could actually sharpen the way Australian players kicked tactically, even at Test level.

Matt To’omua. Ideas man. (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

It’s hard to argue with his reasoning, but moreover, it’s just great to see current players thinking about how to make the game a better spectacle overall.

Sure enough, when on Thursday Rugby Australia confirmed seven law variations for Super Rugby AU, the ‘Toomua Law’, as Wayne Smith dubbed it, was one of them.

The same day, confirmation of rumours emanating out of the West for the last few weeks, that the Force had quietly and cleverly added former Wallabies and Queensland prop Greg Holmes from Exeter in the English Premiership, along with former Force, Brumbies, and Wallabies midfielder Kyle Godwin, coming home after a stint with Connacht in Ireland.

Former Force and Waratahs lock Ollie Atkins will also join them now, also from Exeter, and though former Reds, Waratahs, Force and Worcester flyhalf Jono Lance initially did his best to play down best wishes from Western Force fans on Twitter about his impending return to Perth, the liking of my tweet by him and number of current Force players didn’t exactly scream denial!

The four signings removed any doubt about how serious the Force are taking their return, not to mention any concerns about how competitive they might be. And news of the signings unified Australian fans in another favourite pastime: doomsday predictions for the Waratahs!

Which brings us back to the weekend and New Zealand. Dunedin, to be specific.

What a sight it was, a heaving crowd in under the roof screaming for both sides who either didn’t study the memo hard enough, or underestimated how seriously the breakdown was going to be policed under the new focus in place for both competitions either side of the Tasman.

Bryn Gatland’s late drop goal for a Highlanders win would have made for a slightly awkward reunion with dad and Chiefs coach Warren, but not even the overreaction to the increase in penalties could take away from what was a wonderful moment in rugby this year.

And when the Blues – the Blues, of all teams! – so clinically put the Hurricanes away at a sold out Eden Park, there was no more hiding the contentment. It had been a thoroughly entertaining weekend, with two see-sawing games that only the very astute could have predicted correctly.

The fact those games got the wide coverage they did within Australia tells you there is as much interest in actual rugby as there in rugby politics.

So the challenge for RA over the next few weeks is to leverage this spike in interest into eyeballs particularly, if it’s likely that actual bums on seats might be limited for the Round 1 games over the first weekend in July.

Interest in rugby needs to be maintained so that by the time Queensland and New South Wales out onto Suncorp Stadium on July 3, this competition can be a success from the start.

One starting point would be the excellent Super Rugby AU video released social media last week; easily one of the best competition videos I can recall. It needs to be everywhere.

It has certainly been a great week for rugby fans in our neck of the woods. But the hard work really starts now.

The Crowd Says:

2020-06-17T21:36:05+00:00

Davis

Guest


Good article thanks Brett. Some excellent points there. Toomua's ideas for ditching the mark inside the 22 and line dropout for grounding inside the in-goal area would be fantastic. Particularly removing the 22 mark as that always stops the momentum of the attacking side and more often than not wipes out the scoring chance for the attacking side. Last weekends action in NZ was fantastic. Two great games enjoyed by all regardless of who you're supporting. More than anything I was surprised at how few errors and how fit and sharp the players looked despite not playing a competitive match for at least three months - eight months for some like Beaudy. On the subject of internationals - it seems unlikely we'll be getting the northern tour in November but we'll see. Nov is still a way off so might be ok. I'd love to see an Ashes-style Bledisloe Cup between NZ & Australia if there is no Rugby Championship. A five match series would be excellent for both countries and particularly a big boost for rugby in Australia.

2020-06-17T19:15:49+00:00

Rich1234

Roar Rookie


Here is a rant....’ why on earth do people like TSP come on here’. Seriously, one can only roll one’s eyes. Anyway, onwards and upwards as they say. Brett, I agree with you. Given the dramas that we have been through that are by no means over, it was just nice to get a few green shoots of rugby in the past week. Yes we are by no means out of the woods, and still face serious financial, structural, commercial, issues, but for one week it was nice to see some positivity, some good, coverage, conversation and a bit of hope. I don’t think for one moment that any normal minded person underestimates the mountain that Aussie rugby has to climb, but I will take this for the moment. Thanks for posting Brett, cheers.

2020-06-17T11:15:11+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


Thanks, Brett. Some way to go, but at least Australia is doing far better than most other countries. Keep up the good work and good luck.

AUTHOR

2020-06-17T10:15:28+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Currently NV, I believe the guidance is something like 25% of capacity from mid July - which is going to equate to about 5000-7000 in Perth, Canberra, and Melbourne, and about 13000 in Brisbane. But for the few couple of rounds probably, it'll be much smaller than that, maybe 2000 tops.

2020-06-17T08:52:01+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


Brisbane, coach at a school (mighty 4th's), support the local club and Reds season ticket. Schools rugby probably the most satisfying.

2020-06-17T04:40:55+00:00

Rugby Geek

Roar Rookie


I do like the grounded in try zone restart with a 22. Makes much more sense than a scrum 5

2020-06-17T03:28:19+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


My understanding (and I may wrong) is WR set out a list of approved variations and then told countries they could choose what they wanted to try. I suspect that in Oz's case they took some additional variations back to WR for approval before deciding on their final set. We've got a compromised season so I think it's only a good thing for us to try different things in different countries. We'll all be back onboard with a unified set of laws come the test matches and next year's comps.

2020-06-17T03:16:55+00:00

Jacko

Guest


Where?

2020-06-17T03:15:15+00:00

Jacko

Guest


Yep I 100% agree that we have had constant change over many years now and most of it improves the game to some extent. The reffing we saw in NZ was great for the game so I will wait till we see a few rounds of the Aus comp before judging it too much. Im wondering if WR told NZ and Aus to both trial different laws to make some judgements down the track after seeing how it goes in both country's

2020-06-17T03:03:14+00:00

Jacko

Guest


RG that is why I was disapointed that RA addopted so many experimental laws...I think it would have been better to give the law interpretation change around the breakdown a go before the things like the 50-22 and dropouts under the posts etc. I cant see it benifiting Aus rugby come internationals time

2020-06-17T02:58:57+00:00

Jacko

Guest


And lost damn it!!!!!..LOL I still loved it

2020-06-17T02:58:19+00:00

The Set Peace

Roar Rookie


True we have our problems but at least we address them, not jump back in with a broadcaster that doesn’t want us at the first chance or sitting back while League broadcasts to millions of people.

2020-06-17T01:41:06+00:00

Rugby Geek

Roar Rookie


Jacko Benefiting any Kiwi does grate on me a little or a lot. But they lead the pack and that is never under dispute. Changing the breakdown will mean those who adapt first get an early lead. NZ is still on the horizon compared to us.

2020-06-16T21:35:01+00:00

Richie

Roar Rookie


Thanks Brett. IMO post coronavirus we’ll see a more local/less global attitude to lots of things in life. This includes rugby players. So the future looks like the permanent return of the Force thus continuation of 5 super teams as well as the return (continued return) of Aussie rugby players presently OS. Pipe dream perhaps but for me a possibility to get “eyeballs” seeing and “bums on seats”.

2020-06-16T21:23:15+00:00

JD Kiwi

Roar Rookie


The problem was, the 2015 success wasn't sustainable, the Tahs were soon bottom half. Most years you have all but one team bottom half whereas we have all but one in the knockouts. Having five Aussie teams diluting the strength of a competition would give it the most important basic weaknesses of Super Rugby.

2020-06-16T13:55:47+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


I hadn't considered this but think you guys are right. Would be great to find shots of scrums, mauls, lineouts (uniquely rugby moments) to splice in. I enjoyed the video though in my ignorance

2020-06-16T13:42:56+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


That's the most optimistic take on it. What you need to do though is look at the results of the conference as a group. You could always possibly fluke a squad that went injury free and had lots of good players in form at the right time but it's not reflecting the state of the game properly if the other 4 teams all miss the semis and occupy the bottom half of the ladder. With 5 teams it's our reality. We simply can't deliver 5 decent teams and that's the target

2020-06-16T13:04:23+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


Ohhh didn’t take long ???? but probably only Brett (and Muzzo) on the whole planet got those projections right. More power to them! RT, you better go back re-read the predictions from last week, there were more people who got their predictions right.

2020-06-16T12:48:53+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


At the moment, what is the most optimistic forecast when crowds in a big way (I saw some spread out fans at an AFL game this weekend) can be allowed back in Australia?

2020-06-16T11:53:06+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Would love to see them both have a real crack instead of the narky affairs of late

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar