The run home: Who'll be in the eight when it matters?

By Stirling Coates / Editor

With this weekend seeing another ‘festival of footy’ get underway, it’ll be hard to do this kind of article later as the information will be out-of-date in a day.

So, with five rounds to go, I’ll be looking at every club’s run home to see how things will look when the finals get underway. At the bottom, I’ll have my predicted ladder for the end of the season.

The staggered byes this season add the fun layer of games in hand to this year’s equation, so there’s more to it than just looking at the ladder.

1st – Port Adelaide

10-3, 126.6%

Remaining fixture: Swans (Adelaide), Kangaroos (Metricon), Bombers (Adelaide), Magpies (TBA)

The fact those three losses were ‘uppercuts’ against Brisbane, St Kilda and Geelong will be a worry until the finals get underway, but Port have done the hard yards and have one hand on the minor premiership. Neither Sydney, North Melbourne nor Essendon should have any business troubling the Power over the last month, although Collingwood could be tricky in the final round if they’re battling for a spot and/or the match is away from Adelaide.

Depending on how other results go, however, they’re almost certainly going to be up against Geelong, Richmond or West Coast in a qualifying final – I suspect they’d much prefer the Lions. The Eagles do have a game in hand and similar percentage, however, so a good run from them could see Port still go 4-0 and fall to second, which I don’t reckon they’d mind at all.

(Photo by Daniel Carson/AFL Media/Getty Images)

2nd – Brisbane Lions

10-3, 117.4%

Remaining fixture: Magpies (Gabba), Suns (Gabba), Swans (Cairns), Blues (TBA)

The minor premiership is still in reach but, as above, it’d be a surprise to see Port Adelaide drop a match over their last four. Playing at The Gabba swings the pendulum hugely in their favour against Collingwood, while they should have the class to see off Gold Coast, Sydney and Carlton after that.

Very hard to see them dropping out of the top four, but West Coast’s last five matches could see them lose a home final. Given it’s likely to be Port and West Coast above them in that scenario, they won’t get the luxury of an away game at The Gabba or Metricon.

(Photo by Jono Searle/AFL Photos/via Getty Images )

3rd – Geelong Cats

9-4, 140.6%

Remaining fixture: Bulldogs (Metricon), Bombers (Gabba), Tigers (Metricon), Swans (TBA)

Geelong’s league-best percentage works in their favour for an assault on top spot, but a tricky final month also puts them at risk of falling out of the top four. Pencil in wins over the Bombers and Swans and they’ll start favourites against the Bulldogs, but Round 17’s date with Richmond will prove pivotal.

If the Tigers beat West Coast this week and then knock off the Cats, likely results elsewhere will see Chris Scott’s side dumped to fifth. Geelong’s best shot at a ‘home’ final (whatever it’s worth) is for Richmond to end West Coast’s winning streak, but then to knock them off themselves later in September.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

4th – West Coast Eagles

9-3, 121.3%

Remaining fixture: Tigers (Metricon), Bombers (Gabba), Bulldogs (Metricon), Saints (Gabba), Kangaroos (TBA)

They still need to prove they’ll handle Queensland hub life better the second time around (which they most likely will), but West Coast’s game in hand on the rest of the top four is a big wildcard here.

Richmond and the Bulldogs (on their day) will push them all the way, but another five Eagles wins will put them level with the Power and Lions on points. They’re ahead of Brisbane on percentage and within striking distance of the Power too, making them a team to watch very closely over the home stretch.

(Photo by Daniel Carson/AFL Photos via Getty Images via Getty Images)

5th – Richmond

8-4-1, 119%

Remaining fixture: Eagles (Metricon), Dockers (Metricon), Cats (Metricon), Crows (TBA)

Two straightforward wins and two genuine blockbusters to finish things off for Richmond. Needless to say, they won’t secure the double chance without knocking off both the Eagles and Cats above them – barring upsets.

The two points they earned from their draw against Collingwood means percentage likely won’t come into it; going 4-0 will be enough for them to unseat Geelong. That said, they’d need serious boilovers to finish any higher than fourth – meaning they’ll be hoping for a Brisbane minor premiership, or at least a qualifying final at The Gabba.

(Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

6th – St Kilda

8-5, 114.5%

Remaining fixture: Demons (Alice), Hawks (Metricon), Eagles (Gabba), Giants (TBA)

St Kilda’s percentage is far from bad, but it’s too far back of their rivals for them to sneak into the top four – a feat that would require them upsetting West Coast anyway. It’s very hard to see them falling to Melbourne, Hawthorn or GWS on current form – so a top eight spot is all but assured – but they’d need to win all four of their remaining matches by ten goals to score a double chance – ain’t gonna happen.

Dan Butler of the Saints celebrates a goal. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

7th – Collingwood

7-5-1, 109.1%

Remaining fixture: Blues (Gabba), Lions (Gabba), Suns (Gabba), Power (TBA)

Did themselves an almighty favour last night in downing the Roos and now control their own destiny. The ladder says they have a six-point lead on the chasing pack but, having played 13 games to Melbourne, Carlton and GWS’ 12, it’s really only two – and their run home is tough.

That makes their next clash against the Blues the most important match in this rivalry since Carlton killed off Collingwood’s top four chances in 1994. On current form, I can’t back the Pies against Brisbane or Port so, if they fall to the Blues, even going 1-3 with a win against the Suns would leave them at 8-8-1 – highly unlikely to make the eight.

Knocking off Carlton puts their arch-rivals well behind the eight ball and, even if they lose to the Lions and Power, gives them enough on the board to see off the others. If they lose? Game on.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

8th – Western Bulldogs

7-6, 101.4%

Remaining fixture: Cats (Metricon), Eagles (Metricon), Hawks (Adelaide), Dockers (TBA)

Like the Magpies, did themselves a world of good in that third quarter against Melbourne on the weekend. Turning their woeful percentage around has been a huge help too – the problem is they’ve only got four games left (versus five for the three teams in pursuit) and their next fortnight sees them play Geelong and West Coast. Despite leading the pack, they’re hardly in control.

Notching an upset in either game would almost certainly see them through but if, as is more likely, they go 2-2, they really need to hope the others take points off one another. The silver lining is that they don’t play Melbourne, Carlton or GWS in the run home, so they don’t give them a leg up if they lose, but they’ll be watching that trio very closely.

Carlton beating GWS – even if they lose to Collingwood beforehand – looks to be the most dangerous result for Doggies fans over the home stretch, so they may need to do the unthinkable and get behind the big, big sound when that match rolls around.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

9th – Melbourne

6-6, 112.1%

Remaining fixture: Saints (Alice), Swans (Cairns), Dockers (Cairns), Giants (Gabba), Bombers (TBA)

The Demons shouldn’t need too much help from the outside to get back into the eight, although they need either the Dogs or Magpies to lose games against the top four. Their significantly easier run home than the Bulldogs’ puts them at an advantage but, of course, they need to bank the points – something they can’t necessarily be trusted to do.

They can afford going down to St Kilda this weekend, but would then need to go 4-0 against Sydney, Fremantle, GWS and Essendon – very achievable. If all goes to script, their Round 17 clash with the Giants could be a virtual elimination final – if only Tom Scully was still in orange.

(Photo by Matt Turner/AFL Photos)

10th – Carlton

6-6, 100%

Remaining fixture: Magpies (Gabba), Giants (Metricon), Swans (Metricon), Crows (Metricon), Lions (TBA)

As I’ve alluded to already, the next fortnight will be season-defining for Carlton. Presuming they take care of Sydney and Adelaide, knocking off Collingwood and GWS almost certainly gets them into the eight, even if they lose to Brisbane in their final home-and-away game.

Even strong finishes to the year for Melbourne and GWS wouldn’t be enough to knock them out in that scenario.

They can’t afford both the Western Bulldogs and Collingwood winning out, even if one those sides finish unbeaten, a 4-1 finish to the year should be enough to see the Blues through.

Losses over the next fortnight obviously make things a lot harder – they’d need the others to go to water to sneak in.

(Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

11th – GWS Giants

6-6, 96.8%

Remaining fixture: Dockers (Optus), Blues (Metricon), Crows (Adelaide), Demons (Gabba), Saints (TBA)

Unfortunately, for GWS fans, they may have already made their bed in 2020. A loss to Fremantle this round would just about be curtains – they’d need to knock off Carlton, Adelaide, Melbourne and St Kilda from there to do it and, right now, I’d only back them in one of those games.

They’ve got the talent to flick the switch and go 5-0 to finish as high as sixth, but their percentage works against them here too.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

12th – Essendon

5-6-1, 85.9%

Remaining fixture: Hawks (Adelaide), Eagles (Gabba), Cats (Gabba), Power (Adelaide), Demons (TBA)

A much-improved effort against Richmond on the weekend after last week’s shocker against St Kilda (which, in fairness, is their only truly bad game of the last month). The real obstacle here is the brutal run home and their awful percentage. If they’re to stage a miracle, Hawthorn isn’t a must-win, it’s a must-belt – but I can’t see them going 3-0 against West Coast, Geelong and Port Adelaide.

I would say even the most one-eyed Bombers fan would agree but, let’s face it, they’ll lose to the Cats by 86 points and their supporters will be flooding Twitter with clips of offline ball-ups all week, claiming that was what cost them.

(Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

13th – Fremantle

5-7, 93.5%

Remaining fixture: Giants (Optus), Tigers (Metricon), Demons (Cairns), Kangaroos (Metricon), Bulldogs (TBA)

With a game in hand and reasonable (for their position) percentage, Freo aren’t out of it just yet – but they’ll almost certainly need to run the table. I’d back them in against GWS and North on current form, but they probably start just behind the Dees and Dogs and are obviously huge underdogs against Richmond. They’ve looked much better under Justin Longmuir this year, but are a few pieces short of the full puzzle.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

14th – Gold Coast Suns

4-8-1, 94.1%

Remaining fixture: Kangaroos (Metricon), Lions (Gabba), Magpies (Gabba), Hawks (TBA)

Despite the lengthy winless run, it’s been a superb leap forward for Gold Coast in 2020 – but you’d hope how flat they looked against Carlton was just a blip. They’ve probably earned a pass mark for this season as it is, but I’d really want a good win against North and a final-round triumph over Hawthorn if I was a Suns fan. Finishing 4-12-1 would be an injustice to themselves.

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

15th – Hawthorn

4-8, 82.7%

Remaining fixture: Bombers (Adelaide), Crows (Adelaide), Saints (Metricon), Bulldogs (Adelaide), Suns (TBA)

Hawthorn’s form since the start of July, for a side that’s clearly been trading to win for some time, simply hasn’t been good enough. Alastair Clarkson has earned the right to end his time at the Hawks on his terms, but a poor showing over the last five matches would raise even more questions. They looked good against the Power and should net one or two wins – Round 23’s Gold Coast clash looks like a bottom four decider.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/AFL Photos/via Getty Images)

16th – Sydney Swans

4-8, 81.7%

Remaining fixture: Power (Adelaide), Demons (Cairns), Blues (Metricon), Lions (Cairns), Cats (TBA)

Haven’t seen a side do such a dramatic about-face as Sydney did against the Giants and Freo over the last fortnight in some time. Sadly, for Swans fans, they finish the season off against Charlie Dixon, Tom McDonald/Sam Weideman/Luke Jackson, Levi Casboult/Harry McKay, Eric Hipwood and Tom Hawkins without the services of Dane Rampe. Look away – 17th place very possible.

(Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

17th – North Melbourne

3-10, 81%

Remaining fixture: Suns (Metricon), Power (Metricon), Dockers (Metricon), Eagles (TBA)

The Kangaroos were in it last night for as long as Collingwood allowed and once the Pies got their act together, they weren’t getting close. Will look to give Gold Coast and Fremantle a good run over the last month, but this season can’t finish quickly enough for North fans.

(Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

18th – Adelaide Crows

0-13, 54.9%

Remaining fixture: Hawks (Adelaide), Giants (Adelaide), Blues (Metricon), Tigers (TBA)

Well… Adelaide’s best chance of avoiding the first winless VFL/AFL season since 1964 will come in the next fortnight. Home games against the struggling Hawks and free-falling Giants are the ones to circle – if they can’t nab the four points in either of those then you can stick a fork in them.

(Photo by Daniel Kalisz/Getty Images)

My predicted ladder

1st – Port Adelaide (14-3)
2nd – Brisbane Lions (14-3)
3rd – Geelong Cats (13-4)
4th – West Coast Eagles (13-4)
5th – Richmond (11-5-1)
6th – St Kilda (11-6)
7th – Melbourne (10-7)
8th – Collingwood (9-7-1)

9th – Carlton (9-8)
10th – Western Bulldogs (9-8)
11th – GWS Giants (7-10)
12th – Fremantle (7-10)
13th – Gold Coast Suns (6-10-1)
14th – Essendon (6-10-1)
15th – Hawthorn (5-12)
16th – Sydney Swans (4-13)
17th – North Melbourne (3-14)
18th – Adelaide Crows (0-17)

The Crowd Says:

2020-08-26T10:22:26+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Guest


Imagine the day when your only skill. that of taking cheap shots at Eagles players.deserts you. Imagine the Bulldogs having a forward who will kick 40 goals a year , every year. Imagine the Eagles not having Darling in the 3rd quarter of the 2018 GF. Darling wins games. Ask the Tigers.

2020-08-26T07:46:24+00:00

Klompy

Guest


I know you were WASS. I was too.

2020-08-26T05:39:20+00:00

pablocruz

Roar Rookie


A goose on the loose?

2020-08-26T05:10:17+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Just remember, Scott, Carlton had lots of chances to put Freo to bed...but were unable to do it. Freo stood firm. Outside agents were needed for them to prevail. This idea that Freo had chances seems to be one that is only used to condemn Freo. Freo was in front for the game. I think they are a better side than Richmond and we now have only 7 of our best 22 out...6 if they play Hogan. If Blakely played more than 55% game time against Carlton, we'd have that game under our belt too.

2020-08-26T05:00:30+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


Alex who? :silly:

2020-08-26T04:57:22+00:00

ScottD

Roar Guru


I'm loving your optimism Don and I'll be at the stadium cheering my purple team on but I've got to say that we had plenty of chances to put Carlton to bed and didn't so we have to just suck that loss up. I like you, also fancy our chances against the Tigers but I wouldn't say it's "unlikely" that the Tiges will beat Freo. More likely that we are in with a red hot chance. Freo can and should beat GWS, Doggies & Dees but they have proved that although they are an up and coming team that they still have the capacity to lose from anywhere :) Go Freo !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2020-08-26T02:26:41+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


I'm just teasing Klompy. It's good to see you branch your opinion out beyond your team. There's a big wide world of footy out there and it's great to be amongst it.

2020-08-26T02:18:31+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


Imagine watching bug Jack Darling drop a sitter at Optus Stadium on grand final day, 20m out directly in front, with the game in the balance in the last quarter...poor old Jack. Is there another player in the AFL who seeming just loses the ability to do basic things out of nowhere?

2020-08-25T22:29:55+00:00

Mark

Roar Rookie


I see your point but this is quite different. The home games we sold were a part of the AFL development of the Gold Coast market. Results wise, they were not advantageous at all to Richmond (except financially) in fact, quite the opposite after famously losing the “unloseable” game at the hands of Karmichael Hunt. :unhappy: They were arranged and put in place prior to the commencement of the season as part of normal fixturing. Now, I know fixturing this year has been anything but normal, but I stand by my comment above. This would create a dangerous precedent on the eve of the finals and give WCE an unfair advantage over other Finals contenders.

2020-08-25T21:27:24+00:00

Birdman

Roar Rookie


Cheers Rowdy :thumbup:

2020-08-25T19:43:27+00:00

2dogs

Roar Rookie


Good talk Pete good talk

2020-08-25T19:43:06+00:00

2dogs

Roar Rookie


I shot the Sheriff

2020-08-25T13:30:28+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Luke McPharlin did.

2020-08-25T13:13:51+00:00

Blitz

Guest


Money - that’s all that the Tigers played for 10 years ago! https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/reluctant-tigers-to-keep-selling-games-20110530-1fcri.html

2020-08-25T13:12:43+00:00

Blitz

Guest


Richmond was selling home games a decade ago so please don’t bring up the “setting precedents argument now” that Richmond cannot and does not want to create one in 2020. Precedents were established many years ago when clubs sold their homes games to eg Tassie, NT and other teams and grounds! https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/reluctant-tigers-to-keep-selling-games-20110530-1fcri.html

2020-08-25T12:55:04+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Nah. I am always optimistic. Good luck finding anything negative like the comments of those you refer to. If folk want me to lose heart over Freo...there's no chance. Who knows why they try?

2020-08-25T12:36:58+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


See how fair I am? I can drool over a Victorian. Truly amazing.

2020-08-25T12:24:46+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Saw PTS drool over him. Ayers retired him 2 years too soon. Sorry, I think I just drooled too.

2020-08-25T12:21:59+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


He was having a go at you sounding like the more obnoxious Tiges supporters. Which, l must admit, you did do a good impression.

2020-08-25T12:20:15+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Au contraire. No-one owned the 'air' like GA Sr

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar