Brisbane vs Collingwood: Friday night forecast

By Marnie Cohen / Expert

It’s not every week that you approach a Friday night game and it is the final game of the round.

Season 2020, you’ve done it again.

It is quite often, however, that Friday night features a mouth-watering match-up and tonight is no exception.

We can expect great things from tonight’s game between Brisbane and Collingwood, as there is a lot on the line for both clubs.

A Brisbane win would push them back in front of Geelong, West Coast and Richmond on the ladder and closer to a top-two finish. A loss draws them further back to the pack and they could risk missing out on a double chance.

A Collingwood victory just about secures them a finals spot (if it hasn’t been solidified already) and keeps them in touch with the top five sides. A loss is risky, but may not be as damaging to them as it would be for the Lions.

Both sides are facing similar issues within their game plan that could not only haunt them this evening, but could really put them at a disadvantage come finals time.

Of course, I’m talking about scoring, with Collingwood and Brisbane each facing their own issues in front of goals.

And their ability to quickly (or not so quickly) rectify this problem could be the difference both this evening and going forward.

For the Lions, they don’t have such a problem getting the ball into their forward 50 and into the hands of their goal scorers.

(Photo by Jono Searle/AFL Photos/via Getty Images )

The issue comes when it’s time to convert. The Lions just don’t take their chances and it’s almost cost them in their past two matches.

They’ve won their previous two games by a combined three points.

In those games against North Melbourne and St Kilda, they scored just 13 goals from a total of 38 scoring shots.

For the season, they’ve booted 124 goals and 159 behinds. Of the other four sides in the top five (Port, Geelong, West Coast and Richmond), only Port Adelaide have scored more behinds than goals for the season but the difference isn’t as large as Brisbane’s is.

And it’s not just players missing in front of goals, but also missing in action.

Livewire Charlie Cameron has kicked just two goals in the Lions’ past four games.

I know he faced an injury scare some weeks ago, but he hasn’t missed a game for the season and I doubt the medical staff would risk him unnecessarily.

Cameron re-finding some confidence would certainly help them get back on track and he is vital should Brisbane wish to be a genuine threat come finals time.

So those are Brisbane’s issues in front of goal.

Collingwood just can’t seem to find them at all. They just don’t score enough.

Against Carlton last weekend, they booted 10.12 (72) in what was their highest score since Round 3.

Coming into Round 15, they have scored a total of 818 points for the season – the lowest of any side sitting in the top eight.

Mason Cox has added some much needed structure to the forward line, more so than Darcy Cameron, who was omitted for this evening’s game, even if that’s all he is useful for.

He’s kicked three goals in his past two games since returning from injury and while it’s not a huge impact, it’s enough to support those around him.

(Photo by Adam Trafford/AFL Media/Getty Images)

He can at least attempt to make a contest and bring the ball to ground, for the likes of Josh Thomas, Brody Mihocek, Tom Phillips, Jaidyn Stephenson, Jamie Elliott and Josh Daicos to create some magic.

There’s plenty of talent in the Pies’ forward line. The difficulty is that most of their forwards aren’t fit enough to play together consistently, and the Pies are still lacking a lethal key forward (sorry, Coxy).

So the big question who wins tonight? It could go either way, really. Couldn’t it?

My gut says Brisbane, but I definitely wouldn’t be writing off Collingwood completely.

On first thought, you wouldn’t look past Brisbane at home. Also, they’re sitting in the top four with a reasonably healthy percentage.

Sure, they’ve had a slippery couple of games, but the good sides find a way to keep delivering.

After all, they’ve only lost two games since the season re-started in June.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

But it will be interesting to see how Collingwood back up their victory against Carlton, particularly if they’re able to register a reasonable score for the second game in a row.

Was that game the fire starter they needed to re-energise themselves towards another finals campaign?

I don’t see why it couldn’t have been.

To give each side an extra boost for tonight’s game, a fresh face is finally getting an opportunity at senior level.

Max Lynch will make his debut for the Pies, while Keidean Coleman will get his chance for Brisbane.

It’s a season-defining game. The Lions have come a long way in the last 12 months. They should be able to get the job done.

That’s my Friday forecast. What’s yours?

The Crowd Says:

2020-09-06T01:35:29+00:00

Lionade

Guest


Was that smart as in “S-M-A-T”?

2020-09-04T12:57:08+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


How come you're not top if you always win?

2020-09-04T09:44:07+00:00

Tassie.

Roar Rookie


I feel that the Lions after a break will out last the Pies. ( If they can kick straight that is)

2020-09-04T09:13:35+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


I've said it...I thought the pies too. But you're such a horrific tip I clearly need to reconsider I find doing the opposite of whatever you think leads to success. So thanks for that. ????????

2020-09-04T06:15:44+00:00

big four sticks

Guest


Don’t you mean peck ‘em alive? Or are you a masochist?

2020-09-04T05:40:26+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


And your prediction, Sprucey?

2020-09-04T05:10:16+00:00

big four sticks

Guest


Yeah but we do win, not by a cricket score, yet we do win.

2020-09-04T05:07:34+00:00

big four sticks

Guest


I am picking the Pies by 24. So many times people have picked against them when, in a normal season, they have to travel interstate and face a team that are seen as certainties, only to come away with the four points. While we all hope they will lose, they rarely do. This reminds me of one of those games. Your mob will cement their spot in the eight.

2020-09-04T05:06:04+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Everyone gets plenty of tips wrong including both of the posters having a crack at Don. Don is very astute in my observation and will occasionally put some mayo on a Freo tip. Big deal. Big Four you would be familiar with mayo, regularly tipping Richmond to win by 100 points.

2020-09-04T05:02:35+00:00

big four sticks

Guest


Yes what happened to that guaranteed victory Don? You said it was a forgone conclusion...in the bag.

2020-09-04T05:00:10+00:00

The Hulk

Guest


We have regained our mojo with big wins over Norf and the tragics ( in fact they are both tragic ). We will not lose another game, storm into the finals, and hold the cup aloft, thus equaling the premiership tally with the salary cap cheats and the drug cheats. It’s Magpie time. Swoop down and peck ‘me alive Pies! The Collingwood super fast train is up and running.

2020-09-04T04:16:11+00:00

Birdman

Roar Rookie


Deduct points this time if you have the stones, AFL.

2020-09-04T03:43:08+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


They did indeed miss out on Riccardi Col, like 16 other clubs. Ruscoe has promise too but both players are still very early on. I wouldn't call Riccardi the messiah just yet.

2020-09-04T03:40:09+00:00

Col from Brissie

Roar Guru


Hey Pete, shame Pies didn’t pick Riccardi in last years draft because he looks like he is going to be a very good forward. They were interested in him & Ruscoe and ended up grabbing Ruscoe. They did a pick swap with GWS which enabled the Giants to grab Riccardi.

2020-09-04T03:32:25+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


It's been a fascinating season so far from a sports medicine & high-performance perspective. Collingwood have been great over the past month under extreme adversity. I've loved watching them along with their management and game style during this period. Geelong have probably managed their list best with regards to injury prevention vs performance — something the Pies can learn from, as both game styles are similarly based on skilful possession & execution. My suspicion is the Lions will come unstuck tonight due to the longer break. We've seen some of the bigger clubs negotiate these short breaks very well over the past 3-months. It's counter-intuitive, but I suspect the high-performance departments of various clubs are utilising their gameday GPS data more affectively than others. With the longer breaks, you have to make the precarious decision of whether to train or not. This is not the case with the shorter breaks for some players, depending on their GPS stats & niggling injuries, etc. We're seeing some unusually high performance from teams coming off the shorter breaks, which does not surprise me given the above. Pies still most likely have a disconnect between medical and high-performance. Something they need to address long term. Pies by 3-4 goals. The Lions have dreadful back-of-centre defence, much like Carlton. That's where Bucks is going to hit with his sledgehammer tonight. I certainly would.

2020-09-04T03:13:11+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Not yet. No club is immune.

2020-09-04T02:45:55+00:00

ScottyJ

Roar Rookie


Im sure youre glad its not your boys this time round.

2020-09-04T02:26:19+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


There it is. Nostradamus here has called a Pies victory. Just like how Freo would beat Richmond... Lions will win by 10 goals now. Possibly more.

2020-09-04T02:22:42+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Smart money is on a Lions loss + Lions having 5-6 more scoring shots.

2020-09-04T02:11:32+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


This game will strike a blow to those who think a game in Qld is an advantage to the Qld sides. The Pies will take this one.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar