The state of South African rugby pre-Lions 2021 tour

By The masked soup-bone / Roar Rookie

The COVID curveball has cast a long, dark shadow and totally re-shaped the southern hemisphere’s rugby landscape.

The effects have been felt heavily in South Africa.

They say that snow on the mountain brings wisdom and an astute perspective, but being caught directly in my country’s downward spiral over a fiscal cliff, I somehow doubt that.

I’m watching helplessly as our politicos trample the rich 2019 World Cup legacy underfoot as factions squabble around an altar of avarice and self-enrichment versus governance to uplift the downtrodden.

Rassie Erasmus: a blue blood son of our rich soils, prime motivation that our country needs a World Cup win to uplift and unite us has become legend globally and even more visionary than appointing Siya Kolisi as the symbol of a united country – a vision achieved of how a united rugby fraternity becomes stronger together to rise from the Ashes by simply embracing reality and Mandela’s vision of an equal society for all our children to play under the sun and share equally in our countries rich bounty.

Sadly, corruption is thriving, becoming entrenched and destroying the very essence and fabric of our country, while government squabbling has severely delayed the rollout of COVID vaccines – further isolating and delaying our rugby from international competition.

Rugby’s COVID hangover has been good and bad to South Africa. On the one side, there is the Cape’s amateur clubs’ combined power grab decimating the once-vaunted Stormers setup, but also Jake White’s overdue return to the Bulls heartland to mine new talent and retread old talents. There’s the first true commercialisation of our rugby talent kicking off at the Sharks on the shores of the Indian ocean, all against a backdrop of a new frontier beckoning across the equator for our four erstwhile Super rugby franchises into the unchartered waters of a new Pro 16 tournament about to kick off in Europe.

COVID exploded SANZAAR’s slavish pursuit of commercial gain and diminished the once vibrant Super rugby competition down south with only the Nations cup remaining on wobbly ground amid rumblings up north for the Springboks or Pumas to replace the Six Nations whipping boys, Italy, gaining ground daily.

Change is in the air. International rugby is in robust health and itching to open new frontiers to raise the bar ever higher and write new chapters in rugby’s history while the World Cup champion Boks have not laced up a single boot in anger since their heroics in October 2019.

The Lions tour is the last remaining bastion of the original amateur rugby ethos of the four home nations combining to tour their erstwhile southern colonies and test local rugby on their home grounds. The folly of now retreading the 2021 Lions tour by hosting it in the UK goes directly against this ethos and should never happen.

A much better idea is to just postpone it by a year – the short term commercial implications will be recovered in multiples once the tour takes place with guaranteed elevated interest due to the delay.

First choice is not to try and fix something that’s not broken; a Lions series in the UK is not a Lions tour. Besides, our bungling government is finally getting COVID under control and three months hence with normal protocols there isn’t any reason to fiddle with the planned tour itinerary and location. Rugby will be the richer for not tampering with a proven, traditional winning formula. Let’s not throw the baby out with the bath water.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The player resource cupboard as always is still brimming with overflowing talent both established and new. The normal attrition of frontline stars after an epic campaign have now come and passed. The prop resources are aplenty with Steven Kitshoff and Frans Malherbe shoo-ins while Bongi Mbonambi is back and Malcolm Marx is setting stadiums on fire in Japan, warranting his label as the best hooker in rugby.

The lock pairing of Eben Etzebeth and Lood de Jager is building up steam, while RG Snyman is raring to go and Kolisi is going back to basics sans captaincy pressures at pastures new in the Shark camp after his heady journey the last 18 months. Pieter-Steph du Toit and Duane Vermeulen have cleaned up their niggles and are ready to build up new heads of steam.

Faf de Klerk and Cobus Reinach are firing on all cylinders, Handre Pollard is about to return, while Damian de Allende has become a Munster stalwart with oodles of talent. This is keeping Lukhanyo Am honest outside him, while Frans Steyn is now the glue that keeps the Cheetah show in the headlines. The little pocket rocket Cheslin Kolbe astounds every day, with even the flyhalf playmaking berth now in his resume. Rassie will possibly expand his influence by moving him to fullback.

Retreading an international player can be a stroke of genius, like moving Stephen Larkham from fullback to no.10 and du Toit from lock to the side of the scrum. Kolbe’s playmaking skills might just be better utilised from deep. Out wide, the options are legion; Makazole Mapimpi is an evergreen and Rosko Specman could be an apt replacement to fill Kolbe’s twinkle-toes and stepping boots. Defending against Kolbe, Mapimpi and Specman will give many opposition coaches a few sleepless nights!

This is all despite my personal favourite; Aphelele Fassie from the Sharks, who is now bulked up, polished and set to become a new international sensation.

The Lions under Warren Gatland’s guiding hand will be a handful, but Rassie’s troops will be a formidable obstacle for his ambitions to achieve the first ever triple crown as Lions coach.

It will have a hollow ring if he does achieve it on the playing fields of their home countries.

The Crowd Says:

2021-03-24T00:22:16+00:00

Mielie

Roar Rookie


In my humble opinion, le Roux is yet to reach his peak.

2021-03-24T00:16:51+00:00

Mielie

Roar Rookie


Rugby WC is a fair test of ones ability against all others. Wouldn't you agree P2R2? South Africa has won the WC, as have New Zealand, on three occasions. While on two occasions they were excluded from the WC. So all other countries have experienced two W Cs more than what South Africa has. What does "naff" mean? Or do I need to be very, very young to understand it?

2021-03-24T00:16:42+00:00


Haha you reply to my post 20 days after I wrote it and its me who should put it to bed? Did that stone in your shoe remind you to comment?

2021-03-24T00:04:36+00:00

Mielie

Roar Rookie


Hey Jacko, put it to bed mate. South Africans are very aware of their political shortcomings. No assistance is required thank you. You remind me of the fellow who, when getting dressed every morning, puts a stone in one shoe to ensure he remains grumpy all day long

2021-03-23T23:57:11+00:00

Mielie

Roar Rookie


An excellent article. Thank you. It is going to be excellent Rugby. Very much looking forward to it.

2021-03-08T02:38:30+00:00

Blue

Guest


I actually think Willemse's problem is that he is not international class in any position. I have seen nothing.

2021-03-08T02:37:34+00:00

Blue

Guest


There is absolutely no way you experiment at 15 against the Lions (or anywhere else for that matter). Le Roux played a fantastic game in the final. He played the last three games in the WC with a bum shoulder. He could not lift one arm above the horizontal and played on painkillers. Had he not stayed on the park against the Welsh, De Allende would not have scored. It was a classic case of Willie's vision making all the difference. Kitshoff will start. To suggest Nche starts against the Lions is nearly laughable. Perhaps he gets a bench gig but his scrummaging is work in progress. Not at all convincing. Willemse is going to be one of those players who promised but never delivered. Fassi has a much higher ceiling but his turn will come at the end of the year if there is any rugby. Coetzee's experience against the opposition will be invaluable. Mostert might lose out to a player like Orie to play another black player off the bench but you cannot ignore Coetzee. The rest pick themselves. I am genuinely worried about du Toit. Not sure how he will be fit.

2021-03-07T17:41:36+00:00

P2R2

Roar Rookie


SA will NEVER dominate World Rugby forever ... as you say...they are good, but are still yet to prove they are better than all others....and your comment at the end...abit naff really...

2021-03-07T00:50:13+00:00

Kent Dorfman

Roar Rookie


the Lions might be in with a chance cuz the Boks haven't played any games for so long. If the Boks get together 4 weeks before the tour kicks off that'd be like the Lions finally having their first get together as a team after all of their club commitments.

2021-03-06T14:57:21+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


And 1 case of covid and you can kiss the whole tour goodbye.

2021-03-06T12:34:12+00:00

Wayne

Roar Rookie


Thanks mate, we need it. Lions, SA Rugby and broadcasters all rejected the offer. Turns out that hosting the Lions tour in SA with empty stadiums is in fact far more lucrative than holding it in Australia. Accept it or not, the ARU offer was more about a financial boost to the ARU because they desperately need it now after the massive shake up with SA Rugby moving North.

2021-03-06T00:46:51+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


No worries... good luck playing games and making money in SA.

AUTHOR

2021-03-05T11:40:04+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


Viewing you from below your Ivory tower we thank you from the bottom of our hearts for giving us the privilege to play some rugby; we really appreciate it. We will unfortunately have to decline your thoughtful and generous offer though; we will just muudle on by ourselves thank you.

2021-03-05T02:00:51+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Notshe yes

2021-03-04T21:29:18+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


Thanks JN, was the young scrum half Sanele Mohamba? Must admit that after a year since the old SR folded, I'm very rusty when it comes to Saffa domestic rugby talent.

2021-03-04T19:50:41+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


How is hosting it in Aust a money grab? SA and the UK are getting smashed By a virus and a county that managed to control it is open to allowing other teams to come in and play games that will generate millions of dollars for everyone. There are a boat load of Aussies who still cannot get home due to travel restrictions but the Aussie government is open to letting a couple of hundred very well paid athletes and they coaching staff come and ply their trade in a safe covid free environment. Rightly so RA and the Aussie government should be compensated for giving both the lions and the springboks the privilege to play some rugby. And after the disrespect SA showed the RC nations last year they should be thankful the offer is even on the table.

AUTHOR

2021-03-04T17:50:31+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


I respectfully disagree; do it the traditional Lions way or don't do it at all. In the age of rampant commercialism; an unfortunate reality; let's not lose the ethos of rugby. Then let's cancel the tour and write it off to covid's impact allied with idiotic administrators. For me; the Lions and Barbarians ethos keeps the true spirit of rugby vibrant and alive. Maybe I'm just a romantic; pedantic old fart and if so it's fine; it's old farts like me that color the subtle hues to the rich fabric of rugby union Subject closed.

2021-03-04T14:54:59+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Just not the same without “Lions” Fans not travelling

AUTHOR

2021-03-04T13:06:55+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


Willemse has become the victim of country vs club with his constant shuffling between 10 and 15 and his undoubted talent has become very erratic; something we can't afford on the big stage. A much better bet will be to introduce young Curwin Bosch to polish him despite his Currie Cup fumble; he is the junior talent that originally started the Willemse seesaw journey and has all the talent to become an accomplished international.

AUTHOR

2021-03-04T12:59:02+00:00

The masked soup-bone

Roar Rookie


A sad reflection of reality; note the nearly lily-white bench.. Nice pick of Ox Noche to replace the Beast but I will either retread Kolbe to 15 or introduce Fassi; le Roux is very good but so are Fassi/Kolbe and retain Frans Steyn; he's an evergreen and essential insurance policy to back up young blood in the backline. I do expect the bench to have some existing/new black talent to continue the RWC campaign ethos and Marcel Coetzee might be a casualty; he's also seem to have become a bit fragile; he's knee has sidelined him again. Expect a rejuvenated Sukambuso Notshe and young bloods Wandisile Simelane; Stedman Gans (both centres) and a forward wild card.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar