A European Super League is elitist, arrogant and criminal

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

If, like me, you despise the increasingly pointy nature of the pyramid that exists in world club football, news of the proposed European Super League will have you livid.

In essence, a group of the wealthiest and most powerful clubs in Europe have come together with a shared vision to create an elite league, outside current competitions such as the Europa and Champions Leagues.

While there is no doubt that the football played would be of the highest quality and the matches featuring some of the biggest names in the game, the plan, supported by some of the most famous clubs on the planet, is an abomination in light of the already widening chasm between the haves and the have-nots.

English football stands to play a significant role in the competition with the so-called ‘big six’ all in theoretical agreement to establish the league. Liverpool, Arsenal, Tottenham Hotspur, Chelsea and the two Manchester clubs will make up almost a third of what is mooted to begin as a 20-team competition.

Barcelona, Atletico Madrid and Real Madrid are also aligned to the breakaway league, as are Juventus and both Inter and AC Milan. That leaves a hypothetical gap for another eight clubs and whether French and/or German powerhouses choose to join the rebels in the coming days or weeks remains a hot topic of debate.

(Alessandro Di Marco/ANSA via AP)

UEFA’s stance on the proposed league is categorical and clear, describing it as “a cynical project, a project that is founded on the self-interest of a few clubs…the clubs concerned will be banned from playing in any other competition at domestic, European or world level and their players could be denied the opportunity to represent their national teams.”

Before falling for any altruistic rhetoric in regards to the aims and benefits of the league and the upcoming fabrications that its participants will no doubt offer, be sure to understand that the entire exercise is nothing more than the cash grab of all cash grabs.

The numbers circling around potential windfalls for the clubs involved are frightfully scary. Each club had reportedly been offered 3.5 billion euros and with an assured mad scramble over broadcasting rights set to take place in the very near future, figures near three times that amount have been used in some estimates.

Each and every club currently invested in the breakaway league should be utterly ashamed of their behaviour and the cringe-worthy statement offered by Joel Glazer, co-chairman of Manchester United and vice-chairman of the Super League.

“Super League will open a new chapter for European football, ensuring world-class competition and facilities and increased financial support for the wider football pyramid.”

Oh please! Now I have heard it all.

Efforts to further profiteer from football when their presence has already placed immense strain on smaller clubs within their own domestic leagues should alert football fans around the globe to the reality of the depths to which powerhouse clubs appear willing to sink in order to gain financial benefit.

(Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)

Many lower league English clubs are on their knees or dead and buried thanks to the growing power and influence of the EPL’s top end. Clubs right across Europe continue to suffer the financial strains of an ever increasing distance between themselves and the mighty few, who win the league year after year while becoming richer and richer in the process.

Billions are invested in assembling massive squads, further money is made by loaning out players to all corners of the globe and in the end, European football is worse for the entire exercise.

Fans of the powerhouses cheer when silverware is won, unknowingly contributing to the death of what once was the purest and most sincere contest on the planet; the game where a person from the most humble and often poor origins could take on the world and use their skilful control of the sphere to undermine all privilege, class and status.

Sadly, the game has continued to morph down a dangerous road in recent times and the steadfast determination of the European Super League organisers to plough ahead with the most offensive of competitions perhaps explains categorically how little the clubs involved actually care about ethics and their broader responsibilities.

Should the competition come to fruition in time for its slated August kick-off, UEFA had best remain firm on its determination to punish the participants. FIFA would do well to weigh in and offer its full support all the while using the 2022 World Cup as a significant bargaining tool.

(Photo by James Williamson – AMA/Getty Images)

What I find most alarming of all is the fact that the Champions League was not enough for these clubs — an elite competition rebranded in 1992 to provide a platform for the best of the best to compete on a more regular basis.

Now, after the clubs’ financial statements and the players themselves have enjoyed the riches of Champions League football for near 30 years, they want more. More money, more market share and more glory all at the expense of clubs battling away in promotion and relegation fights and participating in the world game in the way we all love.

What the fools fail to see is that more and more of those clubs will continue to die and there are only so many Manchester Derbies and El Clasicos you can play each season.

Football is a game for all, no matter how big or small. However, intentionally squeezing out the small in order to increase profit and revenue at the top end is simply elitist, arrogant and criminal.

The Crowd Says:

2021-04-21T02:31:38+00:00

Punter

Roar Rookie


Not something I need to tell you Buddy, but no other sport apart from Cricket (dodgy pitches) do playing home & away can make such a difference, win 3-0 at home in European cup tie & then lose 4-0 2 weeks later away. As for the A-League, as I have tried to explain to my AFL friends who attend the Football tab, the difference between Football & the A-League. Football is very strong in the this country. The A-League not so much & so many agendas & the organisations. I remember coming home from a Sydney Derby a few years back 64K in attendances & was talking to few English Australians, who said ‘don’t go to a lot of A-League games, but I never miss a Derby, one of my big sporting events of the year’. Unfortunately Gallop & FFA just didn’t back the fans, so with you all the way there. No fans no game.

2021-04-21T02:14:28+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


Couldn’t agree more Punter. I haven’t hardly watched a ball kicked of any game played behind closed doors going right back to last year when the J & K League started up. I liked Simon Hill’s analogy when he stated that the rich owners are only custodians of clubs, but the fans ultimately own them. Unfortunately, here in the A League that has been forgotten by quite a few organisations and the game suffers because of it.

2021-04-20T23:34:35+00:00

Punter

Roar Rookie


Well this comment looks pretty stupid today. No doubting the revenue coming from Asia in ways of TV & buying of merchandise is huge, because this what the Asians do, they watch sport on TV & love shopping. The true fans who support their clubs thru thick or thin, whether they be like the author Stuart Thomas in his love for West Ham or Sydney FC or some scouser in Liverpool or Madridsta from Madrid, even that guy following 3rd or 4th tier football in Bolivia these people live football, they talk football, have passion way beyond watching TV or doing a bit of shopping. You totally misread it, the greedy owners are the only ones looking at Asia only!!!!! And those that don't understand football

2021-04-20T23:03:53+00:00

Punter

Roar Rookie


How has that worked out? Games played without fans, the lack of atmosphere, the 12th man, it wasn't the same for me. It looks like the fan power still has a lot to say, all English clubs pulling out.

2021-04-20T23:03:44+00:00

josh

Roar Rookie


This league seems like the brainchild of corporate types who would see the numbers of Champions League finals and think we could get those numbers each week; if top teams just played each other! It's free money

2021-04-20T22:49:42+00:00

Sam Drew

Roar Guru


I don’t think that would be popular or work either. So much of the backlash has been from the fans, who are used to going to away games within their own country, and back home in under a day. Fans of elite clubs may go on European trips 3 or 4 times, up to 7 if they’re having a really good season, whilst lower-league fans tend to follow England for continental away days. Telling a Newcastle fan that they’re not only going to be in the second or third tier, but would have to travel to Europe 15 or more times is neither practicable or desirable.

2021-04-20T22:39:27+00:00

chris

Guest


You don't really understand how football works do you?

2021-04-20T22:12:57+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


"Another good point in regards to potential criminality." You're using it here in the context of breach of contract issues. Which is clearly not 'informal'. You're engaging in ridiculous hyperbole. Not that you're on your own in that regard of course...

2021-04-20T22:09:35+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


I still maintain it's hysterical hyperbole.

2021-04-20T19:36:50+00:00

Punter

Roar Rookie


Don't me upset little man. If you want to hear nice things about AFL go to AFL tab. If you want to discuss the world game, well no issues. Looks like your little arrogant theory about Asia has gone out the window as clubs start pulling out of the super league.

2021-04-20T16:47:16+00:00

Homer Gain

Guest


This notion that the EPL is beyond the means of the "ordinary fan" is pure myth. In the 19/20 season you could buy a season ticket at West Ham for as little as £320. Even at Billy Big Shot Spurs, whilst you could pay over £2k for a season ticket, you could get one for as little as £790. Given that you pay £5 a pint in many London pubs these days, the price of your ticket for the game is pretty good value, and well within the pocket of the average worker.

2021-04-20T14:47:51+00:00

Pepito

Guest


Waaaahhh, I'm upset, time to throw in a swipe at the AFL.... Child.

2021-04-20T14:44:56+00:00

pepito

Guest


The South East Asian papers (where I live) are unsupportive, but not anywhere near the vitriol of Euro papers and TV. There's a mild sense that this market would get over it faster if this eventuated. What will be telling will be the scheduling of these games... Teams have a strong following here because you can watch most of the weekend league games at reasonable hours (9-10pm) and put in the occasional late night for the CL games. It's a different story if you are asking your fans to stay up until 3-4am every Wednesday though. Also, what will happen once Ronaldo and Messi retire? The fanatical love for them in China is extraordinary. The en masse migration of fans from RM to Juventus was amazing. They've not yet attached themselves to a successor. https://www.bangkokpost.com/sports/1623986/ronaldo-effect-chinese-fans-drop-real-madrid-for-juventus

2021-04-20T13:36:23+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


I didn’t think you really forgot that. They should have beaten Liverpool in the League Cup a year later but for an offside ruling that went against them at Villa Park and without any help from VAR!

2021-04-20T12:37:31+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


So what is the reaction in Asia to this?

AUTHOR

2021-04-20T11:57:50+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Well aware, but was referring to European silverware. Perhaps should have made that clearer. My bad.

AUTHOR

2021-04-20T11:56:55+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I did, and watched that '80 final as an eight year old, half asleep and missed the climax.

AUTHOR

2021-04-20T11:56:02+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I was referring to European silverware. The real stuff. The stuff we are about to claim again.

AUTHOR

2021-04-20T11:54:35+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


You appear to have completely misunderstood the thrust of my argument and are actually in agreeance with what I am saying. Sadly, calling me naive and taking a personal approach might well end our discussion right here. I hope you have a cracking week with your family, a fabulous weekend and know that I would never insult or personally attack valued Roar readers and contributors in the way you have. It's okay to disagree with people, but there is really no need to get personal and attempt to insult; particularly towards people who write for a living like me and have seen and heard it all before.

2021-04-20T11:51:45+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


last time a non top flight club won the FA Cup as well

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar