Round 17 Pies review: Who dares wins

By Sports Bloke / Roar Pro

You wouldn’t bloody believe it, Pies fans.

Robert Harvey decided he wasn’t Nathan Buckley, we opened our game up and we bloody won and, even if we didn’t get the result it wasn’t torture to watch.

How refreshing was that?

The Tigers led for more than 80 minutes of the match and yet there was not one threat of violence against the television.

It was clear early that the instruction out of the coaching box was to play with freedom. The Pies were relentlessly looking for the kick into the corridor, to play on and kick to a lead.

On occasion, this led to a turn over and a goal from the Tigers, but fortune favours the bold, who dares wins!

If greatly we dare, then greatly, we may fail, but I would rather us fail greatly than fail meekly.

While we are on an onslaught of quotes, “Without commitment you will start, but more importantly, without consistently you will never finish”.

So what are we looking for now? Consistency.

Consistently dare, Robert Harvey, and we may consistently win.

For an entire match, we dared, and we were an inch off here or an inch off there, and the Tigers capitalised. The signs were there, though our midfield was on fire.

Taylor Adams was an absolute raging bull (he went over 60 per cent by foot this week).

Jordan de Goey is finding his groove in the middle, showing – dare I say it? – Dusty-like ability and The Old Rolls Royce, Scott Pendlebury, yet again had an unheralded performance (90 per cent by foot in the contest is something else). His ability to slow time is something to behold.

Jack Crisp continues his push for a first best and fairest at Pie Land and Calllum Brown was fantastic through the middle, benefiting from the the absence of Josh Daicos with some legitimate midfield minutes.

(Photo by Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

I’m big on Callum as a pure mid, but I’m afraid he’s going to have to find a way to be more of a threat in another position on the ground as the line for midfield minutes may not get shorter for a couple more years.

The dominance at stoppage is not without contribution from the Tigers; Maribor Chol and Marlion Pickett were lambs to the Brodie Grundy slaughter.

In defence, although predictably scored on more freely, we still had some serious winners.

Braydon Maynard has been our most important player since Darcy Moore went down. His work on tall forwards has been nothing short of incredible.

Bruzzy, as he is affectionately known, has up until this year spent the vast majority of his playing time as a small-to-medium rebounding defender and has taken the chocolates against one of the best key forwards of the last five years in Jack Reiwoldt.

He held Jack to four marks, two of which and his lone goal were when Bruzzy was off the ground with what looked like a serious collarbone injury after he laid a patented bone crunching tackle. He came back on to finish the game.

Another winner in defence and winner of the freedom play was John Noble. There was a play a minute from halftime kicked off by Noble that could have been our best for the day.

He played on from a mark deep in a defensive pocket with a dart straight into the corridor. This led to a chain of hand balls, a kick and a Darcy Cameron mark in the goal square, taking the ball coast to coast in 15 seconds. You could feel the confidence and dare build.

At the start of the third quarter, we had a similar hand ball chain through the middle kicked off by young Isaac Quaynor that threatened to set the Pies ablaze, but alas, Jack Crisp was just off target.

Quaynor continues to mature greatly and you feel has taken on more medium defensive responsibility as Maynard looks after a tall.

Jordan Roughead was his ever reliable best and our Wings in Will, Will Hoskin-Elliott and Chris Mayne, worked hard all day.

I will take a moment here and its something I have already spoken about this year, but I was hard on Will Hoskin-Elliott at the start of the year. Real hard.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

I may have called for a retirement, but good golly that bloke has turned his year around with his move onto a wing. He looks like a new man and I take my hat off to him. Well done.

Up forward, without the human roadblock in Mason Cox, our boys were free to move and lead. It looked far less congested and as stated, Billy Elliot prospered from the baby giraffe’s absence, kicking three straight, with 21 touches and five tackles.

He is an absolute star, our best forward by a mile and he does not deserve the ball and chain that is Coxzilla weighing him down.

Darcy Cameron played well, kicking two and grabbing seven marks, working up the ground well at times. Brody Mihocek played with desperation all day and I feel a big one coming for him soon.

The kids: Browny was probably our best along with IQ, with decent performances from Trent Bianco, Oliver Henry and Trey Ruscoe as the medi-sub.

Now, we will wrap it up with the last quarter. Twenty minutes of football bliss for Pies fans.

If I had it my way, the article would stop here and I would insert a replay of the last quarter.

In lieu of that, I will leave as I came.

Who dares wins.

We dared and we won.

The Crowd Says:

2021-07-18T07:47:52+00:00

John


Well don't spruke the Pies too much. The second half against Carlton is totally lacklustre. Robert Harvey has ruled himself out as next coach on this performance.

2021-07-17T02:34:05+00:00

fabian gulino

Roar Rookie


gold coast.lol

2021-07-17T01:15:12+00:00

djdart

Roar Rookie


Love the passion and excitement Bloke, great read !! That’s the one I’ve been looking for all year, we played with dare and flare and to see us gut running up the middle in the last was brilliant. I was lucky enough to be at the game and the boys created a little bit of spirit that night, the self belief will be gold !! We really play our best footy when we take it on and I’m very grateful to Harvey for releasing the shackles and playing the kids. When someone is banging the door down in the magoos, he picks them and gives them a run, like hopefully young Ginnivan does in the coming weeks. I’ve been very fortunate to have been to most of our games this season and when we bring real effort, we look so much better. Hopefully this and the Melbourne win not only proves to the group but to prospective coaches as well, that we have something very positive to work with for the future, Go Pies !!

2021-07-16T23:24:41+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Noble gives us pace and run in the back half IMO Bell. I like that he will take the game on. Madgen is good back up but is only there in the absence of Moore and Howe.

2021-07-16T20:29:54+00:00

Bell31

Roar Rookie


What makes you sold on Noble (he makes a lot of clangers)? My main issue with Magden is that his decision making, and kicking efficiency leave a lot to be desired.

2021-07-16T09:04:39+00:00

Col from Brissie

Roar Guru


Can only think Kennedy will play more midfield than he has this season.

2021-07-16T08:39:58+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


I’m sold on Noble, jury out on Madgen Bell. Maybe as back up only.

2021-07-16T08:38:27+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Yes Cox, Sier, Mayne, Madgen all out of contract among others.

2021-07-16T08:37:24+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Blimey Col, I can’t recall Cripps missing any games. A big out. Who does the inside mid work now?

2021-07-16T08:12:48+00:00

Aransan

Roar Rookie


Is he out of contract, and if he isn’t what is it? Wouldn’t suit at the Bombers but I think he would still have something to offer elsewhere given the right role.

2021-07-16T08:00:45+00:00

Bell31

Roar Rookie


Loved the article and the game too of course! Really positive about Darcy Cameron's development and Maynard is becoming the heart of the team. Great to see Adams back - big fan of his. The only thing that surprised me is you really rating Noble - he makes me 'groan' at least once (if not a few times per match) with the clangers he makes --- his speed is what keeps me thinking he's worth another year on the list, but his kicking efficiency needs to improve out of sight. Jack Magden is the other one that makes me wince a few times per game, even though he gives a good solid effort - I'm not sold on these two at all.

2021-07-16T07:58:12+00:00

Andrew

Guest


Well I think that makes the list like 15 players missing. Almost got enough injured to make an injured 22 team.

2021-07-16T07:50:17+00:00

Col from Brissie

Roar Guru


Cripps out Pete.

2021-07-16T05:19:06+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Mason Cox appears finished at the Pies. Which club would take him? Hawks?

2021-07-16T03:08:27+00:00

fabian gulino

Roar Rookie


collingwood vs carlton this is the game to play for win lose.for carlton it means a slight chance to make 8th postion.lose say good bye.for Collingwood it will mean a late charge towards the 8.lose its 2021 finished. The magpies are starting to play down corridoor footy which is the only way not sideways.Mason cox looks like to stay in the VFL for the rest of 2021.He looks slow and awkward,dropping very easy marks.

2021-07-16T03:00:42+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


I really hope they could organise a scratch match or something, they wouldn't be the only team wanting to get a game into players this close to finals.

2021-07-16T02:39:34+00:00

FabPhil

Roar Rookie


Really enjoyed the game purely for that last quarter burst, and I don't think I would have even minded us going down by a kick after that. The highlight for me was our loveable whipping boy of late, Callum Brown. He always had plenty of rhythm, and it's great to see him find some poise which apparently can work wonders.

2021-07-16T02:34:53+00:00

Andrew

Guest


With no VFL on this weekend, C. Curnow won't get his 1st hit out this week. Big shame as this kid needs to get back out there.

2021-07-16T01:49:40+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


I would much prefer to finally have a game where I can relax and enjoy the second half (very few and far between for a Blues supporter) but I have a feeling you are correct. A lot will come down to who the Blues select.

2021-07-16T01:43:46+00:00

Chris Lewis

Roar Guru


Me think Collingwood has a great chance, but what do I know. Last week three winners and now struggling to hold off Roar's experts.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar