Chook lotto, effort to spare and more NRL Round 22 talking points

By AJ Mithen / Expert

Another NRL round is in the bag. From shortening the season to the top four taking time off, here are my talking points.

Should the NRL season be shortened?
There’s three weeks left in the regular season and the last run of games were announced by the NRL on Sunday. The game stays in Queensland, as if it was ever going to be able to leave.

It’s worth asking though – why play these three rounds? Why not get the finals started after one, maybe two more? Get the season in the bank before something else comes along?

We’re still very much in a live COVID environment where situations are changing daily. It would be horrible if something happened that meant the NRL – and any other sport for that matter – was not able to finish their season or had to defer for a period.

There’s very little drama left in the regular season anyway, with the top three locked away and a bland, uninspiring battle for the lower parts of the finals places. Does it matter who finishes eighth?

The NRL were screaming from the rooftops about wearing the cost of up to $15 million a week to have the teams subbing up north. Why not cut some losses, spare us some rubbish football, save some cash and get to the good stuff?

Should we chop out the final few rounds? (Photo by Mark Evans/Getty Images)

Reminder: Don’t fall for the top four tuning up
Melbourne battled to get past Canberra, Penrith needed some fortune against St George Illawarra but still did enough. Souths and Manly did what they needed to do against vastly inferior opposition.

After Melbourne’s scrappy win the inevitable ‘Storm are gettable’ cries rang out across social media and in commentary boxes like they do every year.

So this is your weekly reminder that teams who are set in the top four have no interest in what happens between Rounds 21 and 25.

They’re nursing players into fitness, doing extra training loading ahead of finals and generally not focusing as much energy into the game at hand. Usually, they’ll still be good enough to win them. Occasionally, they will lose one in the lead in.

Don’t get sucked in. The only thing that matters to Melbourne, Souths and Penrith right now is a week one finals win.

CHN, Matterson and Cleary punishments are all about timing
Corey Harawira-Naera’s shot on Jahrome Hughes was bad, Ryan Matterson’s on Brad Parker was worse. Both players were rightly sent off.

Harawira-Naera doesn’t have any priors, so he can get three with an early plea. Matterson has some bad history but he gets three too. Ironically, the same penalty Storm forward Felise Kafusi got for elbowing Matterson in the head, heavily concussing him in Round 3.

I’ve given up trying to think the NRL cares about the safety of its players. Both of these shots were horrible and caused significant head injury. I understand the loading part of the argument but it’s undeniable if this had happened during the NRL’s fortnight-long ‘crackdown’ on dangerous and high contact, they’d each be gone for at least six.

Panthers halfback Nathan Cleary didn’t even attempt to use his arms when he turned his shoulder into the Dragons’ Jack Bird. It was a shoulder charge to the letter of the law. But he walks away without a charge too. It’s a genuine raffle.

(Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

The decisive Roosters penalty was 100 per cent correct
Staying on the topic of high contact, Thomas Flegler hit Sitili Tupouinua high. That’s a penalty.

And contrary to what commentators and commenter alike might prefer, you don’t hold off on awarding a penalty because of how the game is placed.

It was a penalty all day, even if, like me, you didn’t like the end product of the Roosters getting out of jail.

Victor Radley’s ‘chargedown’ was incredibly dangerous
Speaking of frequent flyers, increasing Roosters liability Victor Radley is going to cop four weeks off for a grade two dangerous contact charge, being he dived at the legs of Broncos halfback Albert Kelly as he kicked.

It looked shocking, because it was. Kelly could have been seriously injured. It brought back memories of the bad old days where props would launch themselves at the legs of a kicker and if damage was done, so be it.

Radley’s extended suspension is because of his shocking prior record, which is also inflated because he was a high tackle ‘crackdown’ victim and got a larger suspension in Round 11.

His dive was unnecessary and put Kelly at serious risk. Sort it out, Victor. There’s many different ways to charge down a kick.

Scoring records are breaking everywhere
To the naked eye, the game under V’landysball rules has been an orgy of pointscoring. For the top teams, anyway. For everyone else it has been a horror show.

Now we’re getting more and more evidence as to how the year is so skewed.

Six weeks ago, Melbourne became the first team in rugby league history to score 40 points ten times in a season. Their 18-game winning streak is a club record, so is their astonishing +485 point differential.

Three of Melbourne’s top-ten individual point-scoring efforts by a player have happened in 2021. The purple machine just keeps rolling.

They’re not on their own, though. During Manly’s 46-point dance on the Eels, Rueben Garrick broke the season point-scoring record for the Sea Eagles. He’s on 268 and moved past Matthew Ridge, Graham Eadie and Jamie Lyon.

To top off the chart topping displays, South Sydney’s belting of the incredibly disappointing Gold Coast was their tenth straight win, the first time they’ve done so since 1989. The Bunnies also became the first team in history to score 30 or more in eight straight games, which had led to their best ever point scoring season with 689, more than their premiership year of 2014.

All fine achievements. But guess what? There’s still three regular season games left. Depending on what happens next with the rules of play, I wager some of these records will never be broken.

We’ll miss you, Sterlo
For decades now the one shining light in Channel Nine’s increasingly horrible rugby league coverage has been Peter Sterling.

The Eels premiership player and Rothmans Medallist (that’s what the game’s best player won before the NRL and the Dally M award, kids) was a beacon during broadcasts with his even handed opinion, shrewd observation bro from innate game knowledge and the fantastic ‘if you freeze it there’ analysis seconds after a big play, where he broke down into simple terms what just happened for the audience.

His knowledge and understanding of the game, its tactics and his ability to translate that for the viewer was unparalleled. When his colleagues worked a game with Sterling, it was obvious they took their job a bit more seriously than the usual bluster and ref baiting.

Peter Sterling (Photo by Mark Nolan/Getty Images)

Rumours abounded as they do in rugby league abut why he was leaving, but he summed it up to the Sydney Morning Herald.

“Turning 61, I guess I felt like I’d have maybe 15 good years physically to direct my energy into other things, mainly family and eventually the opportunity to travel. You know, I’ve never been able to see Europe in their summer because of 30 seasons of working in our winter,” he said.

“It’s just about steering my energy away from watching eight (NRL) games every week. I just want to do those things now while I can. If I want to walk up the steps of Machu Picchu, I don’t think it’s the type of thing I could put off much longer.”

So happy trails, Sterlo. Your influence will be very much missed. God knows Nine needs more rugby league brains like yours.

The Crowd Says:

2021-08-18T03:36:45+00:00

thomas c

Guest


1) The refereeing was a mess. The games i saw had inconsistency with advantage, selective ignoring of high shots and crushers, and it just compounds the inconsistencies from the crackdown (where duty of care and a standard of no such things as an accident seemed to ignore knees to the head in the tackle and mixed messaging on head collisions). 2) The NRL probably needs a couple more rest weeks in the middle. Whatever is going on with rules and covid, there are teams that are absolutely destroyed by injuries. That might feed into all the records being broken. 3) I'd assume the reason for broadcasting matches that don't matter may be built into the contract with the broadcaster.

2021-08-17T05:22:03+00:00

Kilgore Trout

Roar Rookie


1. It feels to me like the regular season should be over . I understand the NRL’s obligation to provide X amount of games because of the agreement in place but at what point do those games actually begin to lose their value . If rusted on fans of the game like The Barry are having trouble getting up for it , this must mean something . I thought it was just me . 2. Who knows . There seems to be such a disconnect with what the game is trying to achieve . One week it’s this , next week it’s that while all the time failing to address a system for the referee’s to fairly and transparently adjudicate on the rules . A card system has been implemented by just about every other sport in order to make it easier for referee’s to compartmentalise offences and rule on them in isolation from each other . Not even considered by the NRL . We would rather spin the chocolate wheel when someone gets smashed around the head or holds someone down too long in a tackle . 3. Radley’s charge down was an text book example of why the rule was introduced . 4. The blowout scorelines are a concern . Are the new rules working ? For every new rule that gets implemented their is some other rise in foul play . Now it’s holding down on the first tackle … because its just a set restart and not a penalty with a touch finder . How do you come up with a new rule that encourages you to break one we already had ? 5. Onya Sterlo . Great player . Great man and I know exactly how you feel . Have fun and enjoy yourself . You will be missed .

2021-08-17T02:53:35+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Of course. the white boots. I had forgotten them. There was also a song released in the week before the grand final. "Chang-alang-alang-alangalands" was an omen for disaster.

2021-08-17T02:46:13+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


St.George beat them twice and the during the year. The reason that people give as proof of how great they were was the 38-0 win in the grand final. This is a game that St.George could have won as they did in the major semi final had they played their reserve grade fullback. The scoring may have started 10 minutes after half time but it was during the half time break that the Saints players threw in the towel. The dressing room during the half time break was in chaos with the officials and the rest of the team trying to persuade Langlands to stand down. I've been admonished before about defaming the great Graeme Laglands but he deserved it. He was a great player but he was in his 13th year with St.George and the reason the doctor's pain killing injection hit the nerve was it was in the wrong place because Chang had had so many leg injuries the nerves were in the wrong place. Do you remember him kicking for touch and missing the ball. Were you at the game?

2021-08-17T00:34:31+00:00

Mark

Guest


You got a few things right, but some wrong. Easts won 19 straight in 1975 - lost 2 of the first 3 games, then won 19 straight up to the finals. The GF was a close contest until about 10 minutes after half time, and Langlands playing on one leg didn't help the Dragons. But to say that Easts were over-rated is nonsense - the team is generally regarded as one of the best ever.

2021-08-16T22:00:54+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Yeah fair, but that’s sorta my point. The Storm and Panthers have been destroying teams all season - even top 4-6 teams but Parra went toe to toe with them but then completely switch off against the Dragons and get dominated As soon as they hit a flat spot it turns into a sinkhole that destroys their season They’ve got a quality roster that regularly plays below its capability. I think a lot of that has to fall at the coaches feet

2021-08-16T21:51:58+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Slater was great at breaking down play when he came in and it was good having a more modern voice in the commentary team but when he’s paired with Smith he’s terrible. They sit around giggling at private jokes and telling each other “this bloke knows more about fullback play…” “You were the best 9 I ever saw…” I suspected Smith would be a great commentator but at the moment as you say it’s a lot of “how good was that? HA HA HAHA!!!”

2021-08-16T21:45:57+00:00

Soda

Roar Rookie


My counter to that is - they legit got beat by the dragons. Bullied on the field by them actually.

2021-08-16T21:20:08+00:00

Kobi

Guest


Most every other rugby league comp in nsw has been canned. Country folk love their footy fixtures and support their local clubs passionately. Have to feel for the players, volunteers, club officials, match officials, supporters & sponsors that are part of the greatest game of all & its been all for nought this yr as was half of last yr. At least the nrl still has a game.

2021-08-16T19:30:49+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


Never knew that about Tatana. That was a cross Langlands had to carry, along with those white boots.

2021-08-16T19:25:06+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


Ingrid Bergman.

2021-08-16T11:06:04+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


look at their squad, thats what happened

2021-08-16T11:03:01+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


They have a poor (or overrated) roster and a poor coach How many of their players would start for Melbourne or Penrith? Their supposed best player - Gutherson - isn't in the top 5 players in his position in the comp. They barely have 13 first graders. They are flattered because most others barely have 10

2021-08-16T10:52:32+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


paid for by the broadcasters. Fox would absolutely love live games over summer

2021-08-16T10:50:53+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


The fact that Annesley comes out and defends every decision the referee's make it just so much more frustrating for the coaches. Sure some of these teams hopes for a final 8 spot is on the line but it seems at the moment according to Annesley the referees can do no wrong. Very frustrating for coaches, fans and player's.

2021-08-16T10:46:26+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Well done Dutski. That's a record number of likes. Well, the most I've ever seen.

2021-08-16T10:34:38+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


I knew a few blokes who gave the game away in the Super League war.

2021-08-16T10:32:54+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Ingrid Pitt who starred in the Vampire Lovers?

2021-08-16T10:29:52+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Ron Coote was a great player but he was a dirty player. In the 1968 GF he king hit Bill Bradstreet, knocking him out. Col Pearce, an old Souths fan, penalised him when a send off was warranted. Billy Wilson got sent off in the 62 grand final for the same thing. Billy was dumped by St.George because of that and he went and played captain-coach for North Sydney.

2021-08-16T10:19:28+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Yes I forgot that. Ken Killer Kearney was a great favourite at St.George and he had Dick Thornett in his team as well. in 1976 Parra had beaten Manly three times but they were jinxed by Manly. Once again I felt sorry for poor Parramatta. They were unlucky to lose to Saints in 1977 with Mick Cronin missing a sideline conversion to give Saints a life with the replay the following week. In the GF replay the next week Rod Reddy was given a free rein on Ray Price's head because he missed Ray Price breaking Mark Shulman's back in the GF. Shulman never played again.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar