Was 2021 Bennett's greatest coaching moment?

By Paul Monaro / Roar Rookie

This Penrith side would have beaten Queensland.

You cannot imagine the hunger in a team that has been the best in the competition for two seasons, has fallen short once and made to take the long road the second time.

A team with all the talent, hardness, and desire to be called the best in the toughest contest.

The Panthers just about swept the pools in the Dally Ms. And almost half the team were Origin players.

They have the competition’s most underrated coach and its best playmaker.

And then they came out and played the game of their lives.

Put all of that and hindsight together, and Penrith was never going to lose this game. It shouldn’t have even been a contest. Yet it became one of the great grand finals.

The South Sydney Rabbitohs were the only team in this year’s competition that would have stayed in the contest until the final bell.

In the first half, they absorbed one of the most dominant displays by a grand final opponent and somehow staggered into halftime only two points down. The scoreline for them was flattered by a stroke of luck off the stray forearm of Viliame Kikau, and a piece of classic Cody Walker brilliance.

Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

But when the halftime whistle blew a reprieve to a flagging South Sydney, there had really only been one team in the contest.

What kept them in the game up to that point had them looking like a different side in the second half. Words from the old master, conjuring inspiration in spheres that even Wayne Bennett himself couldn’t fully comprehend.

As often happens in the big games, halftime changed the momentum, and Souths came out ready to seriously test the competition’s best defence.

They were dangerous from the resumption. They found space up the middle and wrestled back possession and field position.

Souths were the better team for long passages of the second half.

Wayne, as he always does, made his players share in a belief that no pragmatist would have. He gave them the formula to defy the odds and a team’s ultimate destiny. And they almost pulled it off.

For us mere mortals, it was a contest for the ages.

So that is credit where it is due to Wayne and his team. But the story isn’t about him. grand finals are ultimately about winners. And sometimes about the dawn of a new era.

Ivan Cleary has been one of the best coaches in the competition for a decade.

Like Wayne in his early coaching years, there has been criticism of his manner and his lack of engagement with the media. It is unfair criticism because he is who he is.

There were claims that statistically he was too old and had coached too many NRL games to win a competition. Like the theory you need to win in Week 1 of the finals, that has been put to bed.

When it comes to instilling belief in your players, where does this rank in Ivan’s coaching performances?

There were a dozen reasons for this team to start to think they were going to be denied once again.

They were busted and seemingly starting the game with only half a tank of gas. Yet, they were the more energetic in the first half, and at their grittiest best in the second.

There were moments that swung the contest, with Stephen Crichton’s intercept the obvious difference. And on both teams, there were individual performances that will be spoken about throughout the off-season.

In such a gruelling and energy-sapping contest, the big men made their mark. Tom Burgess was inspirational for Souths.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

For Penrith, I give the quiet achiever award to Kikau. He seems to have lost his potency in attack, but his defence in this game was colossal. He played more like a lock than a second-rower, chopping down attackers around the ruck.

For such a big man, he must be one of the best ‘boot-lace’ tacklers in the game. Not only did he push himself to the limit in defence, but he also made some crucial tackles that snuffed out building danger from Souths.

Performances like this made the difference. And all the while, Nathan Cleary quietly went about doing what he does. He continually put his team where it needed to be on the field, and this ultimately kept Souths out of the contest.

One thing Wayne Bennett has never done is coach his son to a grand final victory. The pressure on father and son must have been immense.

It would have been all-consuming if not for the psyche that exists in these two unique individuals. The outside noise was deafening for everyone else. But the Cleary’s calmly kept the volume down.

To be a premiership-winning coach was Ivan’s destiny.

It maybe could have come sooner, but this will be all the sweeter. It might be called the pinnacle of his career, yet he is still young enough to achieve so much more.

And his manner won’t change too much. He won’t be paying close attention to what everyone else is saying. He will go on doing just what he does, away from all the criticism and the noise.

Leave the fairytales and the romance to the press and the elder legends of the game. This ending is real. Ivan Cleary is now where he was always destined to be.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2021-10-06T20:23:12+00:00

Paul Monaro

Roar Rookie


Valid points. As you say Souths had the dream run through the finals compared to Penrith. I thought they should have started favorites. But I give credit to the unbelievable toughness and determination of Penrith, which had a lot to do with their coaching. Despite the advantages Souths had, on grand final day they met a team it was going to take an extraordinary performance to beat. And they all but produced that. Put that down to Bennett.

2021-10-06T17:55:23+00:00

Onya.

Guest


How good was Bennett’s coaching for the GF? As was already stated, the Penrith line up was full of injured players. Then South’s had had a weeks rest during the finals & an extra days rest before the GF. That’s after a pretty easily won semi- final. Yet South’s Lost! Not even complaining to the referees could get them home. Glory, Glory hey....

AUTHOR

2021-10-05T23:30:56+00:00

Paul Monaro

Roar Rookie


Can't argue that the winners are the only ones who are remembered. And Penrith thoroughly deserved it. But while it's still fresh in our minds full credit to both sides and both coaches.

2021-10-05T18:44:09+00:00

London Panther

Roar Rookie


I wish I had Wayne’s publicist….

2021-10-05T11:36:47+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


History will show that the Pennies won with a crippled team who came back after losing the first finals game giving themselves a brutal task with a coach many had claimed was a bit of a dud. History is about the winner and Bennetts's efforts in 2021 will just fade away. Rightly or wrongly, the team who gets the silver medal is more likely to be scorned and pitied as time moves on. Bennett himself was quoted many years back saying it's all about winning titles and that's how coaches are judged.

2021-10-05T08:00:19+00:00

Nico

Roar Rookie


Interesting point you make about Bennett’s Newcastle years. I know he cops a lot of criticism but in 2013 he actually got them to the prelims (from 7th), something no other coach has done since ’01, in doing so eliminating both the previous years’ grand finalists along the way. Can’t say I followed it as closely as his Broncos years but that strikes me as another worthy achievement

AUTHOR

2021-10-05T05:18:02+00:00

Paul Monaro

Roar Rookie


You are completely right of course. But it's my highlight

2021-10-05T04:34:48+00:00

Nico

Roar Rookie


Could've easily made the list given he was the first coach to deliver with the Dragons since Harry Bath, however he also had a fairly established squad that were minor premiers the year before to work with. Same reason I didn't include the '92, '97, '98 and '00 Broncos - excellent squads that Bennett didn't need to tinker with as much

2021-10-05T00:04:03+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Maybe the new partner's got something to do with raising his energy levels, Paul. :stoked:

AUTHOR

2021-10-04T23:54:31+00:00

Paul Monaro

Roar Rookie


It was very impressive. You make some good points Paul. I thought he looked disinterested when he was coaching Newcastle - almost like he was half asleep in the coach's box, and that he was close to the end then. But he's been very switched on and at his best at Souths. It will be interesting to see how long he keeps going.

2021-10-04T23:28:21+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I'd argue this was Bennett's best coaching moment, Paul, for 2 reasons. He lost arguably the teams best player (Mitchell) at a critical time, just before the finals. He then brought in a complete unknown to most of us and inspired that young man to plan some outstanding football. He also inspired his team to play terrific finals football, good enough to beat the eventual premiership winners once and so very nearly do it again. And the second reason.... the guy is 71. I've heard people say, these days 70 is the old 60, but putting in 90 & 100 weeks for at least 8 months of the year, dealing with the press and player stupidity at all hours of the day or night, is a young man's caper, yet Bennett managed to get his team within 2 points of a premiership, in the toughest rugby league comp in world and stay enthusiastic - at his age. In the case of Ivan Cleary, this might be his pinnacle, yet you've posed a genuine question about Bennett with many options available. Others have stated some of his outstanding achievements across a long career and what's scary is, any one of these could be a "best of" moment. I guess we won't know till the book comes out.

AUTHOR

2021-10-04T22:40:07+00:00

Paul Monaro

Roar Rookie


No mention of 2010? :happy:

2021-10-04T19:18:24+00:00

The Sporacle

Roar Rookie


I don't think anyone except for Bennett could have put Souths where they ended up, phenomenal effort and I'm not saying it's his best effort because I think he's got more to come. Disclaimer as a Parra fan and I know it would not have been possible due to the draw and it wasn't the refs fault.. if Penrith play a awitched on finals footy Parra I think they push them just as hard :thumbup:

2021-10-04T16:08:52+00:00

Nico

Roar Rookie


For an old bloke Bennett just keeps coming up with the goods. Supposedly having lost his aura in '18, he's since worked his magic with QLD last year and now with Souths. In no particular order I'd put Bennett's top 5 coaching moments as: The '93 finals run with the Broncs winning from 5th and going back to back South Brisbane's '85 BRL grand final win beating a red-hot Wynnum side led by Wally and Gene Miles The '06 finals run culminating in knocking off the salary cap-rorting Storm in the final Origin '01, the year after Queensland's darkest moment, winning the series after blooding 10 rookies and bringing back Alf from the UK Broncos season '99, Brisbane sitting last after 10 rounds and with Alf bowing out mid-season, Bennett masterminded a run of 12 straight wins to get Brisbane into the top 8 and sowed the seeds for the Broncos' dominant 2000 season

Read more at The Roar