'Made to look like clubbies': England media tees off at 'insipid' Aussies in pre-Ashes blow

By Tim Miller / Editor

The English media have predictably had a field day after Australia were humbled by eight wickets in a T20 World Cup thrashing, in an early psychological blow ahead of this summer’s Ashes series.

It might be a much shorter format than the five-day, five-match series that will take place on Australian shores this summer, but the manner in which Australia were dismantled – the victory with 50 balls to spare their heaviest ever by balls remaining in a T20I – bears an eerie resemblance to another limited-overs thrashing inflicted by England before their famous Ashes triumph in 2005.

Back then, the Aussies were thrashed by 100 runs – their heaviest T20I defeat by runs – with Kevin Pietersen, who would go on to etch his name into Ashes folklore with his fifth-Test century, the star of the show.

“The last time England’s T20 team treated Australia with this much contempt, they used the result as a springboard to win the Ashes,” wrote The Mail on Sunday cricket writer Lawrence Booth, voicing the thoughts of many English fans now daring to dream.

“If the leap from Dubai to Brisbane is a big one, then Australian fast bowler Pat Cummins did confess before this game, with the urn in mind, that it would be ‘great to get one on the board’ against the old enemy.

“To the delight, no doubt, of two England captains – not just Eoin Morgan but Test skipper Joe Root, watching from afar – the Australians did not get a look-in.”

>> Australia vs England: as it happened

Such was the dominance of England’s performance that The Times cricket correspondent Simon Wilde felt compelled to very nearly show Australia the rarest of emotions from English cricket supporters towards their biggest rival: pity.

“Don’t ever, ever feel sorry for Australian cricketers, but it was damned hard not to in Dubai this balmy night,” Wilde wrote.

“Eoin Morgan’s breathtakingly efficient team stripped the old enemy of every last vestige of dignity. They blew them away with the ball, and then pummelled them with the bat.

“It was all-out aggression of a sort that Australia specialise in themselves but they did not like being on the other end of it, especially the contempt with which their vaunted fast men were treated.”

Captains Eoin Morgan and Aaron Finch shake hands following England’s big win over Australia at the T20 World Cup. (Photo by Michael Steele-ICC/ICC via Getty Images)

Booth described the Australian batting performance as “strangely insipid”, with Aaron Finch’s men limping to 5/57 after 14 overs… a run rate just over four an over. Early wickets didn’t help, but with Finch content to rotate the strike and bat deep into the innings for a 49-ball 44, it took a late onslaught from bowlers Pat Cummins and Mitchell Starc, and all-rounder Ashton Agar, to see Australia even reach triple figures.

Writing in the Telegraph, chief cricket writer Scyld Berry echoed those thoughts, noting that “such an assertive statement can only do England good” ahead of the Test tour.

“Ever since Sir Ian Botham roared in 1981 and they quaked, Australian cricketers have never liked being bullied… providing Australia do not clobber England in the World T20 knockout stages, England will take some momentum into the Ashes, even if that is a quality which lasts no more than an hour in the heat of battle renewed.”

While Chris Jordan was a shock choice for Player of the Match honours, the twin pillars that dismantled Australia will both be on the plane down under once the World Cup concludes. Jos Buttler’s breathtaking 32-ball 71 with the bat, and Chris Woakes’ superb spell of bowling in the PowerPlay, rent the Aussies asunder, and should see both players head into the Tests chock full of confidence.

“If they [Buttler and Woakes] can bottle their fearless self-belief in Dubai and blend it with discretion in playing themselves in, England will have a core, a hard core, wobbly though their top order may be,” Booth opined.

“With Ben Stokes at five, followed by Bairstow (ahead of Ollie Pope), Buttler and Woakes, England can put challenging totals on Australian scoreboards.”

Having forced his way back into England’s shortest-format setup after years out, Woakes’ success bodes well for his chances of doing likewise to the Test attack. The seamer appeared in just one of England’s summer Tests against New Zealand and India at home, with newcomer Ollie Robinson a standout performer alongside the great James Anderson.

With Stuart Broad also in the mix for the Ashes and Craig Overton another seamer included in the Ashes squad, squeezing in promises to be a challenging task. But Woakes’ Test-match style bowling against Australia, most notably in his dismissal of David Warner for 1, has former England captain turned commentator Nasser Hussain impressed.

“[To hit] top of off, top of off – Woakes is the best in the world at doing that,” Hussain told Sky Sports.

Chris Woakes celebrates the wicket of Glenn Maxwell at the T20 World Cup. (Photo by Francois Nel/Getty Images)

“You’re only allowed to do what the opposition allow you to do. David Warner did try and shimmy down the pitch to Woakes.

“But Woakes bowls that length and it’s very difficult to hit, especially when there’s sideways movement.”

With Warner and Smith, and potentially T20 wicketkeeper Matthew Wade, set to reprise their batting roles in the Ashes, Hussain’s assessment of the Australian top order as “fragile” could prove a portent of things to come. With Warner injured, the batting line-up struggled against India in last summer’s Test series, needing until the third Test to pass 200 in an innings.

“Their batting line-up looks a little bit short of confidence but I think what you’ve got to do is give credit to England’s length and line,” Hussain said.

The former England captain also echoed the thoughts of Australian limited-overs great Shane Watson, who blamed the Aussie struggles on a lack of cohesion in their XI.

“This team, and the combinations, don’t play together consistently at all… and [they] expect to be able to turn things on against world-class teams?” Watson lamented from the commentary box during the match.

“I’ve been asking [why] for the last 10-12 years. It doesn’t make sense. The only way you’re going to play really well as a team is playing together, like England have been doing, like India do.

“When you come up against a team that have got every base covered like England, that’s when teams do get exposed. Australia has been very exposed tonight.”

“They don’t play together very much for some reason, this Australia T20 side, so they’re all a little bit fragile with ‘if I don’t get some runs, who will?’” Hussain said on Sky Sports.

“They left the extra batter (Mitchell Marsh) out today and played the spinning all-rounder (Ashton Agar) and they seemed to be one stage behind with their selection.”

While the batting performance drew much of the ire from critics, the press were equally scathing of the Australian bowlers. Frontline Test quicks Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Pat Cummins – all of whom will likely be in the XI for the first Ashes Test at the Gabba – were treated with disdain by Buttler and Jason Roy, finishing with 0/69 from a combined six overs.

“Their frontline Ashes attack were being made to look like clubbies,” Booth said, while Berry noted the importance of the treatment of Starc in particular, who finished with 0/37 from an expensive three overs.

“It might be a pointer too that England brought down Mitchell Starc, the one member of Australia’s pace triumvirate who has struggled of late, not in white-ball cricket but in Tests,” Berry wrote.

“In his only Test series of the last 18 months, Starc took 11 wickets at 40 runs each in the four Tests against India – and now there is no James Pattinson to serve as a ready-made replacement.”

Despite the thumping result, Berry is still urging caution ahead of the Ashes, noting that the switch to white clothes will likely benefit England’s Test tormentor Steve Smith, who was out to an ugly slog and a marvellous Woakes catch for 1 in Dubai. It will also mean the return of Smith’s partner in crime in the 2019 Ashes, Marnus Labuschagne, who was overlooked from the T20 World Cup squad.

“Steve Smith has reverted to an orthodox stance, which can only benefit him as the years advance, so that he will be scoring runs because of his technique not in spite of it,” Booth said.

Above all, Marnus Labuschagne. After a quiet summer of reconnoitring in English cricket with Glamorgan, Labuschagne – inked in as Australia’s number three – scored 136 and 60* in Queensland’s last Shield game.

“Even though his Test batting average is 60, it would not be a surprise if he lived up to it this winter.”

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Nevertheless, England’s domineering approach to the Australian attack suggests that, just like in their upset 2005 triumph, they hold no fears with bat in hand. With Australia’s chief tormentor Ben Stokes to return to the fold for the Ashes as well, a first Test win on these shores since their 2010-11 series triumph looks well within reach.

>> Check out Australia’s full T20 World Cup and Ashes fixtures as they stand

The Crowd Says:

2021-11-03T23:21:48+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Which ever team the selectors choose for the Brisbane Test, will play in Adelaide - for sure. There's no way they're going to drop a player after only one Test, which makes the First Test selection critical. I'd also hope the selectors are not thinking about anything but the Ashes till January. Once they've chosen the team for the 5th Test, they should then immediately focus on the Asia tours. I agree Warner would likely be a liability, given his age and track record on previous tours to Sri Lanka, etc, but if he has a storming Ashes series and makes a gazillon runs, how do you leave him out? There's lots of time in the New Year to sort out touring squads. Best not to worry about 2022 till then.

2021-11-03T23:09:34+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Last series, the opening cupboard was bare, when Wade opened. Right now, we have Street, Harris, Khawaja and at a pinch, Puckovski, all of whom could be given a chance to open. Throwing the best number 3 bat in world cricket in as an opener sends a signal to England we're panicking, especially when these other guys could probably do a decent job, given the series is in Australia. Completely silly idea from Healy.

2021-11-03T23:03:23+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


It’s a poor idea Pierro, it’s. It necessary to move Labs. It’s like saying Root should have opened for England the last 3 years because they have almost always been 2 down inside 10 overs during that time.

2021-11-03T22:58:28+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


It's good to see Healy coming round to my idea with labs which I've had since last ashes as he's effectively been an opener . Sure it's not ideal but plenty of players can be explored in middle . Maddinson , Carey and inglis all have claims to add huge strength to middle order . This whole let's cling to last few years theory has not worked well losing to India twice and england draw away .

2021-11-03T22:55:41+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


It's true England bowling is weakened but we need to get ready to accept warner won't be going abroad again and really time to get a solid xv in and bolster middle order with talent that works for me . Broad is not the concern . Australia is lucky they are bringing two ageing bowlers that's for sure . Pucovski is out for first test so we have to think about the fact that no other opener has worked . At a push khawaja on current form . Baring in mind I wouldn't be looking at form from a year ago plus now . They have hardly played any cricket for two years and a few are getting on. Shield form has to be assesed as best forn for selection . Labs and khwaja have spanked it. If warner fails in one test for me he has to go . He's not batting well in short form and nz India and england have all got on top of him at times and he's hardly played any red ball cricket in nearly two years .

2021-11-03T22:50:55+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


We did this last ashes faffing about with openers and it cost us .grab Ted we are on home soil so easier but I support healy. Of course it's not ideal but we don't have the luxury of experimenting with openers in an ashes and many have not worked

2021-11-03T22:35:31+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I think Broad will be rested for the Boxing Day game, Jeff. Either that or he won;t bowl a lot of overs in Melbourne and they'll play a spinner to pick up the slack.

2021-11-03T22:15:55+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


I think Healy is panicking. Broad didn’t trouble Warner last tour, in fact don’t think he took his wicket once. It was against the right handed Bancroft he had more success. No need to start sending England negative signals by moving around our successful number 3 to accommodate one bowler who didn’t have an impact last time, is four years older this time and unlikely to hold his place for every Test.

2021-11-03T22:08:16+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Not a fan at all of moving a guy like Labuschgne, who's done so well at first drop, until we've tried all other options. He's settled at 3, knows his role and the numbers show what a success he's made.

2021-11-02T06:06:29+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


Spot on again Paul . Selectors are a mixed bunch and don’t like taking risks . Richardson , abbot (bowled very well last.match ) neser and steketee are there and able to rotate with starc who should bowl pink ball test and possibly Gabba as it’s first test this year where he has done well before instead of late in season . I’d be rotating starc out at mcg and scg for sure and Lyon hasn’t done the job at mcg or scg either against the best teams so they could try swepson . Re the batting there are moves that can be made for openers . With red ball labs and smith are very strong (pink ball can get tricky especially with night sessions ) . warner could go well at the flatter decks but stacking middle order and elevating labs with khawaja (just for this series to start) may not be a bad move at all . Maddinson , Carey could provide stability in middle order . Inglis and head could make decent runs on home pitches but head has his streaky moments . McDermott an outlier . Hard to get these guys on if they stick with Paine warner etc or worse pick a failed opener . Langer is too stubborn and doesn’t like changes and of course bailey may have tasmanian bias

2021-11-02T05:54:09+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


The problem with the selectors is bravery. Right now, the most experienced selector is Langer, even though Bailey's the new head of selections. Will Bailey and Dodemaide have the courage to drop Warner if he makes scores of 4,1, 9 & 11 in the first two Tests? Given this is their first Ashes and in Dodemaide's case, his first series, I very much doubt it. Ditto with the bowling. I agree there's room to get guys like Jhye Richardson in for Perth at least, while I'd be resting Starc for Sydney if he's already played the first 3 Tests and not set the world on fire.

2021-11-02T05:22:58+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


All good thoughts Paul . Not sure the selectors are up to the task . Very good point about the back to back tests . We got found out against india at mcg and scg last year . They need to consider strong rotation . I’m still not averse to some moves at top to stack the middle order as well . Pucovski unpredictable with the head knocks this week apparently . Warner out of form for me but he will get his flat decks at Adelaide and Perth in particular and maybe scg . Could do worse than consider khawaja making centuries in shield to open with Labuschagne who caned a century last week and has opened effectively anyway . This would allow a stacked middle order . I doubt the selectors have that forsight and many will hate tampering with openers but they have let us down alot in recent years

2021-11-02T05:18:51+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


Yep I'd be happy to get the lads back for a shield.match

2021-11-01T22:43:11+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Completely agree. It's one thing to hitting them to all parts in the nets and another to put it all together across a 5 Test series. You're also right, some guys are starting to show some form in the Shield but my concern is how close the Tests are together, especially the first 3. The Brisbane game starts on the 8th of December and the third Test on Boxing Day. I think selectors are loathe to change things when games are not spaced apart and/or if Australia's winning. Hopefully Davey proves us wrong and makes some good scores, but I'm not holding my breath.

2021-11-01T19:22:27+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Maybe we can say we are happy when we go out early? :)

2021-11-01T17:34:12+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


Hes also coming in to ashes with little cricket completely out of form. Wouldn't mind the three bowlers and smith warner getting home for a warm up shield match asap. This is a mediocre smash n Grab tournament

2021-11-01T17:30:40+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


Spot on kalva warner and Paine could be liabilities in ashes yet again

2021-11-01T17:29:12+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


I was calling for Stoinis to open early doors. Warner has always been a big risk for this tournament. I really hope I’m wrong of course

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar